Long-term impacts of Argentine ant invasion of urban parks in Hiroshima, Japan
Long-term impacts of Argentine ant invasion of urban parks in Hiroshima, Japan
Journal of Ecology and Environment. 2014. Aug, 37(3): 123-129
Copyright © 2014, The Ecological Society of Korea
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial Licens ( which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
  • Received : May 18, 2014
  • Accepted : May 26, 2014
  • Published : August 28, 2014
Export by style
Cited by
About the Authors
Sang-Hyun, Park
Shingo, Hosoishi
Kazuo, Ogata

Ant communities are well suited for monitoring changes in ecosystems. Although numerous studies have examined the responses of ant communities to environmental disturbance, relatively few long-term studies on ant communities have been undertaken in urban environments. We examined species richness in nine urban parks in Hiroshima, Japan, and compared the survey results with data collected at the same sites by using the same methods in 1999. In both surveys, total of 25 species was recorded: 23 species in 1999 and 20 species in 2012. Non-metric multidimensional scaling analysis revealed that the ant communities consisted of two distinct groups, which could in turn be characterized by three patterns of ant community changes in between the two groups. The first of these community change patterns was characterized by a shift within group 1, but the number of species remained constant (approx. 10 species). The second pattern was characterized by a shift within group 2, but the number of species remained low (approx. 4 species). The third pattern was characterized by a shift from group 1 to group 2 as the abundance of Linepithema humile (Mayr) increased over time. Unlike the first and second patterns, the number of ant species in communities of the third type decreased significantly. These findings suggest that L. humile has a marked effect on the species diversity of indigenous ant communities in urban environments.
Ant communities are well suited for monitoring ecosystems because the distribution patterns of individual species are relatively stable ( Alonso and Agosti 2000 ). In addition, the stability, sedentary nature, and sensitivity to environmental perturbation also make ant communities suitable for assessing the general state of an environment ( Alonso and Agosti 2000 , Yamaguchi 2005 , Ribas et al. 2012 ). Consequently, numerous studies have examined ant responses to a variety of environmental disturbances ( Human and Gordon 1996 , Thompson and Mclachlan 2007 , Menke et al. 2011 ).
Most of the studies conducted to date on ants in urban environments have concentrated on the negative effect of the urbanization on ant biodiversity ( Holway and Suarez 2006 , Sanford et al. 2009 ) or the relationship between invasive and native species ( Miyake et al. 2002 , Touyama et al. 2003 , Sunamura et al. 2007 ). However, given the difficulties associated with conducting long-term observations in urban environments, the amount of ecological data collected in urban environments is typically limited ( Buczkowski and Richmond 2012 ). Consequently, most of the studies on ants in urban environments have been performed at a single point in time along a gradient of urbanization (e.g., urban vs. rural areas, urban periphery vs. inner city, and urban green spaces vs. residential areas), or surveys have been conducted in several sites that have similar environmental condition ( Yamaguchi 2004 , 2005 , Stringer et al. 2009 ). While these approaches have allowed us to simplify the complicated effects of urbanization ( Antonova 2005 ) and increased our understanding of the impact of invasive species on native communities ( Touyama et al. 2003 , Stringer et al. 2009 ), these approaches also have shown several associated problems. To date, numerous studies have been undertaken at different sites for better understanding of the effect of urbanization on ant diversity in urban. However, it is difficult to assess the effect of urbanization on ant diversity in urban environments in isolation because different sites have subtle differences as microhabitat characteristics ( Buczkowski and Richmond 2012 ). According to Porter and Savignano (1990) , invasion of the fire ant Solenopsis invicta in the southeastern USA had a negative impact on the populations of other insects, particularly native ants, in the region. However, for 12 years after the fire ants had invaded an area, the diversity of local populations of native ants and other insects had returned to pre-invasion levels ( Morrison 2002 ). Consequently, although one-off experiments conducted to assess the effects of urbanization or invasive species on native populations may be technically sound, the overall value of data that these studies generate is somewhat limited as they reflect conditions at a single point in time.
In order to better understand the ecology of urban environments, we examined changes in the community structure of ants in urban parks over a decade. We also clarified the impacts of invasion by the Argentine ant Linepithema humile (Mayr) on species diversity of indigenous ants by using long-term data. In conjunction with the field data collected in this study, we reanalyzed the data of Touyama et al. (2003) to assess the effects of urbanization and L. humile abundance on indigenous ant communities. The findings of the study are considered useful for the conservation and management of urban biodiversity.
- Study area
We resampled the nine urban parks among 12 urban parks ( Touyama et al. 2003 ) in Hatsukaichi and neighboring Hiroshima ( Fig. 1 ) to compare changes in ant assemblages over time because the three urban parks have been changed and trimmed for the construction of high-way road and apartment.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Location of the nine urban parks in Hiroshima and Hatsukaichi surveyed in this study. Black dots (●) denote the sites have been invaded by L. humile and white dots (○) denote the sites that have not been uninfested. St. 1, Ougien Dai-ichi Kouen; St. 2, Ougien Dai-ni Kouen; St. 4, Minori Kouen; St. 6, Ujina Kaigan Dai-ichi Kouen; St. 7, Ujina Dai-ni Kouen; St. 8, Ujina Dai-san Kouen; St. 9, Ujina Dai-yon Kouen; St. 10, Ujina Higashi Dai-ni Kouen; St. 11, Tan-na Nishi Kouen.
All of the urban parks surveyed were small (less than 0.5 ha) with a centrally situated playground consisting of bare soil, playing equipment, and occasionally wisteria trellises. Organic matter in the topmost soil layer (e.g., leaf litter and humus) was limited to areas under shrubs, as fallen leaves and weeds were usually removed during routine park maintenance. The environmental conditions in the surveyed parks were thus considered to be very stable over time.
Ants were collected using the same time-unit sampling method as that employed in 1999. The method consisted in collecting as many species as possible within a specified time period (10 min, repeated 10 times at each park in this study) by conducting visual and manual searches for ants on the ground surface, under stones and bark, and around the bases of trees ( Touyama 2000 , Ogata 2001 ). Ant specimens were then sorted and identified to species by using taxonomic keys provided by the Japanese Ant Database Group (2003) .
- Data analysis
Using the frequency data for each species, we performed a non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS) analysis to examine the similarities between all parks over time. This ordination technique represents samples as points in a two-dimensional space, such that the relative distances of all points are in the same rank order as the relative similarities of the samples ( Van der Gucht et al. 2005 ). We used the Bray-Curtis index as a similarity measure for different parks. The Bray-Curtis index is considered to be well suited for multivariate statistics because it is less affected by the numbers of rare species in the samples ( Krebs 1989 ). The NMDS goodness of fit was estimated using a stress function which ranged from 0 to 1, with values approaching zero indicating a good fit. An analysis of similarity (two-way crossed ANOSIM) with 999 permutations was used to test for significant differences between groups. In addition, the similarity percentage tests (SIMPER) were conducted to identify which species contributed the most to the average measure of dissimilarity between groups ( Clarke 1993 ). All analyses were performed using Primer ver. 5 ( Clarke and Gorley 2001 ).
Finally, to assess temporal species turnover, we computed Jaccard’s index (JI) from the presence-absence data in the ant data matrix; JI = a /( a + b + c ), where a is the number of species observed in both years, b is the number of species observed only in 1999, and c is the number of species only observed in 2012 ( Radomski and Goeman 1995 , Stuart et al. 2012 ).
- Changes in the number of ant species over time
Table 1 shows a list of the species identified in each park together with their abundance. A total of 25 species are shown; 23 species were recorded in the 1999 survey, and 20 species were recorded in the present survey. The differences between the two datasets are due to the inclusion of two previously unobserved species, Temnothorax koreanus (Teranishi) and Hypoponera nubatama Terayama & Hashimoto, and the apparent disappearance of five previously observed species, Nylanderia flavipes (F. Smith), Pachycondyla chinensis (Emery), Pheidole noda F. Smith, Crematogaster osakensis Forel, and Lasius hayashi Yamauchi & Hayashida.
Relative frequency (0 to 1,n= 10) of ant species in the urban parks surveyed by time-unit sampling* in 1999 and 2012
PPT Slide
Lager Image
*Time-unit sampling: 10 replications of 10-min sampling in each park. The site numbers correspond to Fig. 1.
The number of ant species exhibited several different inclinations among the examined parks. First, in parks where L. humile was dominant (e.g., St. 8 and St. 9 in Table 1 ), the number of the indigenous species remained relatively low in both 1999 and 2012. Second, in parks where the incidence of L. humile increased over time (e.g., St. 1, St. 2, and St. 4 in Table 1 ), the incidence of the indigenous ant species decreased significantly over time (Mann-Whitney U test, P < 0.05). Third, in all of the parks except St. 10, the number of indigenous species decreased, but these differences were not statistically significant (Mann-Whitney U test, P > 0.05).
- Changes in occurrence patterns of each ant species over time
Fig. 2 shows the relative frequency of three ant species that were common to all of the parks surveyed in both 1999 and 2012. Interestingly, L. humile maintained either high (e.g., St. 8 and St. 9) or increasing (e.g., St. 1, St. 2, and St. 4) frequencies of occurrence over time. For example, the incidence of Tetramorium tsushimae Emery was high in those parks where L. humile was absent and was markedly lower in those parks where L. humile had increased over time.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Changes in relative abundance of three common ant species in each park over time.
Spearman’s rank correlation coefficient analysis revealed a significantly negative correlation between the incidence of L. humile and other ant species, such as T. tsushimae ( rs = −0.67, P = 0.002), Pristomyrmex punctatus F. Smith ( rs = −0.68, P = 0.002), Formica japonica Motschoulsky ( rs = −0.61, P = 0.007), Crematogaster matsumurai Forel ( rs = −0.54, P = 0.020), Lasius japonicus Santschi ( rs = −0.76, P = 0.000), Pheidole indica Mayr ( rs = −0.55, P = 0.019), and Nylanderia amia (Forel) ( rs = −0.63, P = 0.006). However, no correlation was observed between the incidence of P. noda, C. osakensis , and L. hayashi and invasion by L. humile . The incidence of Nylanderia sakurae (Ito) remained constant over time irrespective of invasion by L. humile ( Table 1 ).
- Changes in ant community composition over time
The NMDS analysis separated ant communities into two groups ( Fig. 3 ); stress was low (0.08), indicating a good degree of fit. A two-way crossed ANOSIM showed that the species composition of the ant communities at the sites did not change over time ( R = 0.157, P = 0.119), except when L. humile abundance increased, as this caused a significant change of the ant communities ( R = 0.478, P = 0.004).
PPT Slide
Lager Image
The non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS) ordination to show community composition and tracking patterns of ant community composition over time.
Additionally, SIMPER analysis revealed that five species were the main contributors to the differences between two groups (overall dissimilarity = 77.38%, see Fig. 3 ). The representative species of group 1 were F. japonica and T. tsushimae , whilst L. humile was the most representative of group 2 ( Table 2 ).
Results of the similarity percentage (SIMPER) analysis for five ant species representing more than 50% of the cumulative contribution to average dissimilarity between two groups
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Results of the similarity percentage (SIMPER) analysis for five ant species representing more than 50% of the cumulative contribution to average dissimilarity between two groups
In addition, we identified three general patterns of change in ant community structure between groups 1 and 2 in response to changes in L. humile incidence over time ( Fig. 3 ). Although the first and second patterns both shifted within their respective groups, the third pattern shifted from group 1 to group 2, in response to an increase in L. humile abundance over the 13 years between surveys. The index values of the estimated mean of species turnover in the first and second patterns were 0.52 and 0.55, respectively, while that associated with the third pattern was higher, at 0.72.
In this study, we clarified the effect of urbanization and invasion by L. humile on the following three ant community characteristics in urban parks over a ten-year period: 1) changes in the number of ant species over time, 2) changes in occurrence patterns of each ant species over time, and 3) changes in ant community composition over time.
First, the number of ant species decreased significantly after an invasion or increase in L. humile abundance. Further, the number of ant species in parks where were either not invaded by L. humile or had post-high intensities of L. humile did not change significantly, suggesting that the presence of L. humile had a negative impact on the number of indigenous ant species ( Miyake et al. 2002 , Sunamura et al. 2007 ).
Second, both urbanization and high numbers of L. humile had a marked effect on indigenous ant species over time. In case of P. noda , C. osakensis , and L. hayashi , they were not observed over time, implying that their absence in invaded parks was due to urbanization and not due to invasion by L. humile . However, high frequencies of L. humile had a negative impact on the incidence of several indigenous ant species in urban parks, including T. tsushimae and P. punctatus . Thus, the obtained results implied that ant species surveyed in this study, except for N. sakurae , have been affected by continuous urbanization or L. humile invasion.
Third, NMDS analysis showed that the ant communities of the surveyed parks could be divided into two groups, and that the compositions of the ant communities in each of these groups were significantly different. Three patterns of change in ant community structure were identified in both groups; only the third pattern exhibited a shift from group 1 to group 2. This shift was caused by an increase in L. humile abundance over time. Furthermore, the species turnover rate in groups exhibiting the third pattern was higher than the species turnover rate in groups exhibiting the other two patterns. Therefore, the ant community composition may be simplified under the influence of new invasions or increases in L. humile abundance.
In conclusion, because most urban parks are maintained regularly for the benefit of visitors and are located in developed areas, these habitats are considered to be very difficult for ant species to invade. However, in the event that colonization by an invasive species does occur, the impact on any existing indigenous ant assemblages is expected to be negative. The findings of this study demonstrated that invasion by L. humile decreased the species richness, and that species turnover accelerated the abundance of L. humile increased over time, simplifying the indigenous ant community structure in urban parks ( Oliveras et al. 2005 ). Consequently, a continuous monitoring and ecological study of L. humile is considered necessary in order to preserve ant biodiversity in urban environments.
We thank Dr. Touyama Yoshifumi about his previous result and valuable information. We also thank review of Dr. Javadi Firouzeh and Dr. Jusup Marko (Faculty of Science, Kyushu University) for improving the paper. This work was supported in part by Global COE Program (Center of excellence for Asian conservation ecology as a basis of human-nature mutualism), MEXT, Japan.
Alonso LE , Agosti D. , Agosti D , Majer JD , Alonso LE , Schultz TR 2000 Biodiversity studies, monitoring and ants: an overview; Smithsonian Institution Press Washington, DC Ants Standard Methods for Measuring and Monitoring Biodiversity 1 - 8
Antonova V. , Chipev N , Bogoev V 2005 Species diversity and distribution of ants in different habitats in the parks of the city of Sofia Petekston Press Sofia Biodiversity, Ecosystems, Global changes. I-st National Scientific Conference in Ecology 231 - 236
Buczkowski G , Richmond DS 2012 The effects of urbanization on ant abundance and diversity: a temporal examination of factors affecting biodiversity PLoS ONE    DOI : 10.1371/journal.pone.0041729
Clarke KR 1993 Nonparametric multivariate analyses of changes in community structure Aust J Ecol 18 117 - 143    DOI : 10.1111/j.1442-9993.1993.tb00438.x
Clarke KR , Gorley RN 2001 PRIMER v. 5: User Manual/Tutorial Primer-E Plymouth
Holway DA , Suarez AV 2006 Homogenization of ant communities in the mediterranean California: the effects of urbanization and invasion Biol Conserv 127 319 - 326    DOI : 10.1016/j.biocon.2005.05.016
Human KG , Gordon DM 1996 Exploitation and interference competition between the invasive Argentine ant, Linepithema humile, and native ant species Oecologia 105 405 - 412    DOI : 10.1007/BF00328744
2003 Japanese Ant Image Database Japanese Ant Database Group
Krebs CJ. 1989 Ecological Methodology Harper Collins New York, NY.
Menke SB , Guenard B , Sexton JO , Weiser MD , Dunn RR , Silverman J 2011 Urban areas may serve as habitat and corridors for dry-adapted, heat tolerant species; an example from ants Urban Ecosyst 14 135 - 163    DOI : 10.1007/s11252-010-0150-7
Miyake K , Kameyama T , Sugiyama T , Ito F 2002 Effect of Argentine ant invasions on Japanese ant fauna in Hiroshima prefecture, western Japan: a preliminary report (Hymenoptera: Formicidae) Sociobiology 39 465 - 474
Morrison LW 2002 Long term impacts of an arthropod community invasion by the imported fire ant, Solenopsis invicta Ecology[2337:LTIOAA]2.0.CO;2 83 2337 - 2345    DOI : 10.1890/0012-9658(2002)083[2337:LTIOAA]2.0.CO;2
Ogata K 2001 Time unit sampling: a protocol ANeT Newsletter 3 18 - 19
Oliveras J , Bas JM , Gomez C 2005 Reduction of the ant mandible gap range after biotic homogenization caused by an ant invasion (Hymenoptera: Formicidae) Sociobiology 45 1 - 10
Porter SD , Savignano DA 1990 Invasion of polygyne fire ants decimates native ants and disrupts arthropod community Ecology 71 2095 - 2106    DOI : 10.2307/1938623
Radomski PJ , Goeman TJ 1995 The homogenizing of Minnesota lake fish assemblages Fisheries 20 20 - 23
Ribas CR , Campos RBF , Schmidt FA , Solar RRC 2012 Ants as indicators in Brazil: a review with suggestions to improve the use of ants in environmental monitoring programs Psyche    DOI : 10.1155/2012/636749
Sanford MP , Manley PN , Murphy DD 2009 Effects of urban development on ant communities: implications for ecosystem services and management Conserv Biol 23 131 - 141    DOI : 10.1111/j.1523-1739.2008.01040.x
Stringer LD , Stephens AEA , Suckling DM , Charles JG 2009 Ant dominance in urban areas Urban Ecosyst 12 503 - 514
Stuart YE , Losos JB , Algar AC 2012 The island-mainland species turnover relationship Proc R Soc B 279 4071 - 4077    DOI : 10.1098/rspb.2012.0816
Sunamura E , Nishisue K , Terayama M , Tatsuki S 2007 Invasion of four Argentine ant supercolonies into Kobe Port, Japan: their contributions and effects on indigenous ants (Hymenoptera: Formicidae) Sociobiology 50 659 - 674
Thompson B , Mclachlan S 2007 The effects of urbanization on ant communities and myrmecochory in Manitoba, Canada Urban Ecosyst 10 43 - 52    DOI : 10.1007/s11252-006-0013-4
Touyama Y 2000 Estimating species richness: an application of time unit sampling method to a myrmecofaunal survey Jpn J Environ Entomol Zool 11 51 - 60
Touyama Y , Ogata K , Sugiyama T 2003 The Argentine ant, Linepithema humile, in Japan: assessment of impact on species diversity of ant communities in urban environments Entomol Sci 6 57 - 62    DOI : 10.1046/j.1343-8786.2003.00008.x
Van der Gucht K , Vandekerckhove T , Vloemans N , Cousin S , Muylaert K , Sabbe K , Gillis M , Declerk S , De Meester L , Vyverman W 2005 Characterization of bacterial communities in four freshwater lakes differing in nutrient load and food web structure FEMS Microbiol Ecol 53 205 - 220    DOI : 10.1016/j.femsec.2004.12.006
Yamaguchi T. 2004 Influence of urbanization on ant distribution in parks of Tokyo and Chiba City, Japan I. Analysis of ant species richness Ecol Res 19 209 - 216    DOI : 10.1111/j.1440-1703.2003.00625.x
Yamaguchi T. 2005 Influence of urbanization on ant distribution in parks of Tokyo and Chiba City, Japan II. Analysis of species Ecol Res 8 17 - 25