Feasibility of seed bank for restoration of salt marsh: a case study around the Gwangyang Bay, southern Korea
Feasibility of seed bank for restoration of salt marsh: a case study around the Gwangyang Bay, southern Korea
Journal of Ecology and Environment. 2012. Jun, 35(2): 123-129
Copyright ©2012, The Ecological Society of Korea
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License ( which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
  • Received : January 07, 2012
  • Accepted : April 03, 2012
  • Published : June 01, 2012
Export by style
Cited by
About the Authors
Seonmi, Lee
Department of Biology, Graduate School of Seoul Women’s University, Seoul 139-774, Korea
Yong-Chan, Cho
Department of Forest Resource Conservation, Korea National Arboretum, Pocheon 487-821, Korea

Salt marsh is an important transitional zone among terrestrial, riverine, and marine ecosystems and is a productive habi-tat that interacts extensively with adjacent landscape elements of estuarine and coastal ecosystems. Nowadays, in addi-tion to various human activities, a variety of natural processes induce changes in salt marshes. This study aims to provide background information to restore disturbed salt marshes and to propose their ecological restoration using seed banks. The study area is a prepared area for the Gwangyang Container Port located in the southern Korea. This area was formed by accumulating mud soils dredged from the bottom of the forward sea. This land was created in a serial process of pre-paring the Gwangyang container port and the salt marsh was passively restored by seeds buried in mud soil dredged from seabed. As a result of stand ordination based on vegetation data collected from the land, stands were arranged according to tolerance to salinity in the order of Suaeda maritima, Salicornia europaea , and Phragmites communis communities on the Axis 1. Landscape structure of the projected area was analyzed as well. Edges of the projected area were divided from the marginal waterway by the dike. Four types of vegetation appeared on the dike: Alnus firma plantation, Robinia pseu-doacacia plantation, Lespedeza cyrtobotrya plantation, and grassland. In the more internal areas, two types of vegetation sequences appeared: Aster tripolium community- Suaeda glauca community- Salicornia europaea community sequence and Aster tripolium community- Suaeda maritima community- S. europaea community sequence. Mixed community showed the highest species diversity (H′ = 0.86) and S. europaea community showed the lowest (H′ = 0.0). Evenness is the highest in Mixed community (J′ = 2.26) and the lowest in S. maritime - S. europaea community (J′ = 0.0). Several plant communities were successfully established on the land created by mud soil dredged from the bottom of Gwangyang Bay. Moreover, community diversity in this area approached a similar level with those from other studies involving natural salt marshes. Therefore, restoration effect based on community diversity obtained in our study can be evaluated as a success-ful achievement. In this respect, although most salt marshes in Korea and other places worldwide have been destroyed or disturbed by excessive land use, feasibility of seed bank as a restoration tool is greatly expected.
Salt marshes appear along the edges of shallow seas with soft sediment (Eisma et al. 1998) and are important transitional zones among terrestrial, riverine, and marine ecosystems. Salt marshes include distinctive natural re-sources and maintain key ecosystem processes (Wall et al. 2001). They develop on coastal shores where they are sufficiently protected from wave and tidal energy to al-low sediment suspended in the water column to settle out and accumulate (Chung et al. 2004, Hughes and Paramor 2004, Nottage and Robertson 2005).
Salt marshes develop well in the western and south-ern coasts of Korea because of the big difference between the flow and ebb tides thereby occupying 2.7% of total national area (Han 2008). Salt marshes are ecologically important and productive habitats that interact exten-sively with adjacent landscape elements of estuarine and coastal ecosystems. The most obvious biological charac-teristic is the unique plant communities including many species, which are found only in tidally influenced areas (Nottage and Robertson 2005). Nowadays, however, salt marshes are changing by a variety of natural processes and threatened by human activities (Doody 2001, Nottage and Robertson 2005). In most areas of Korea, salt marshes experience human exploitation such as salterns, farms, reclamations, and so on. A lot of salt marshes have dis-appeared already but the damage is in progress because of the high land use intensity (Ministry of Environment 2006).
Ecological restoration is the process of assisting re-covery of degraded, damaged or destroyed ecosystems (Society for Ecological Restoration International Science & Policy Working Group 2004) and the return to a similar approximation of their original state (National Research Council 1992). The goal of this is to reestablish a complete functional ecosystem (Stanturf et al. 2001).
Seed banks are a group of non-germinated but viable seeds stored in the soil. They can remain dormant for many years to decades until surrounding environments are appropriate for germination (Grime 1989, Simpson et al. 1989). These dormant seed banks can have ecologi-cal and evolutionary influences on actual plants above ground (Kalisz 1990). Therefore, they are recognized as a critical element in management plans of a given ecosys-tem (Cox and Allen 2008). In addition, after destruction or disturbance of an ecosystem, they play an important role in natural regeneration (Grime 1981, Roberts 1981). The value of the seed banks for restoration is different ac-cording to the type and length of disturbance of the site (Middleton 1999).
To date in Korea, most studies on salt marshes have fo-cused on the environmental factors affecting vegetation (Lee and Kim 1988, Lee et al. 2009) such as characteristics and distribution of halophyte (Ihm 1989, Lee 1989, Ihm et al. 1995a, 1995b, 1998a, 1998b, Kim et al. 2005, Han 2008). Therefore, many studies haven’t been done regarding salt marsh restoration, particularly through the use of seed
Lager Image
A map showing the study area.
This study aims to diagnose feasibility of ecological restoration of artificially disturbed coastal areas. Further, this study aims to evaluate restoration effects based on naturally established species composition and diversity of vegetation in a salt marsh created by seeds buried in the mud soil dredged from the seabed.
- Study area
The study area is located around the Gwangyang Con-tainer Port, Southern Korea (latitude N 34°54′-N 35°10′ and longitude E 127°31′-E 127°38′). The land of this study area was created by accumulating mud soil dredged from the seabed to ensure water depth in the Gwangyang con-tainer port ( Fig. 1 ). This land was the bare flat in the early days, but it didn’t remain for a long time because of the abundant seeds that were buried in the dredged soil. This study was carried out in the seventh year since the flat was created. The study area at the time of the survey was covered with salt marsh vegetation and thus resembled a typical salt marsh.
This area is surrounded by Gwangyang-si, Suncheon-si, Yeosu-si, Namhae-county, and Hadong-county and belongs to the warm-temperate forest region (Yim and Kira 1975). Plant communities dominating in this region are Pinus thunbergii community, P. densiflora community, Quercus variabilis community, Q. acutissima community, Q. serrata community, and so on (Ministry of Environ-
Lager Image
A physiognomic vegetation map showing the projected area for the Gwangyang Container Port.
ment 2006). Mean annual precipitation and temperature at Suncheon weather station, which is the closest weath-er station to the study area, were 1,487 mm and 12.5℃, respectively.
- Methods
- Creation of salt marsh
The land of salt marsh of our interest was created by accumulating mud soil dredged from the bottom of the Gwangyang Bay to ensure water depth in the Gwangyang container port. Salt marsh vegetation was restored pas-sively by seeds buried in the mud soil dredged from the seabed.
- Vegetation sampling and data analysis
Vegetation survey was carried out in the salt marsh re-stored passively by seeds buried in the mud soil dredged from the seabed. Vegetation map was prepared by in-terpretation of IKONOS satellite image and color aerial photograph, and field check. The vegetation map was constructed with ArcView GIS (Environmental System Research Institute 1996).
Vegetation sampling was conducted from May to Sep-tember, 2007 on 65 plots. Vegetation survey was carried out by recording the cover class of plant species that ap-peared in randomly installed 1 m × 1 m quadrats. Cover data were transformed from the ordinal scale of Braun-Blanquet (1964), and subjected to ordination. Differences in species composition were analyzed with detrended correspondence analysis (Hill 1979) by using PC-Ord 4 program (McCune and Mefford 1999). Species diversity was compared by Shannon-Wiener (Magurran 2004) and evenness (Pielou 1966) indices.
- Landscape analysis
Landscape structure of the projected area and its sur-rounding areas are depicted in Fig. 2 . The edges of the projected area were divided from the marginal water-way by the dike. Vegetation was introduced on the dike and formed a hedgerow. This hedgerow was constructed around the projected area except the southern road side. Four types of vegetation appeared on the dike: Alnus firma plantation, Robinia pseudoacacia plantation, Les-pedeza cyrtobotrya plantation, and grassland. Dominat-ed vegetation was established bordering the hedgerow. Phragmites communis community occupied the adja-cent areas of the living hedgerow in a gentle slope. In the more internal areas, the following two types of vegeta-tion sequences appeared from the marginal toward the central parts: Aster tripolium community- Suaeda glauca community- Salicornia europaea community sequence
Lager Image
Detrended correspondence analysis ordination based on the vegetation data collected in the 65 stands. A, Salicornia europaea community; B, Salicornia europaea-Aster tripolium community; C, Salicornia europaea-Suaeda glauca community; D, Aster tripolium-Salicornia europaea community; E, mixed community; F, Phragmites communis community; G, Phragmites communis-Suaeda glauca community; H, Salicornia europaea-Suaeda maritima community; I, Suaeda maritima-Salicornia europaea community; J, Aster tripolium-Suaeda maritima community; and K, Suaeda maritima-Phragmites communis community.
Lager Image
Shannon-Wiener (H′) and evenness (J′) indices of the salt marshes vegetation. Se, Salicornia europaea community; SeAt, S. europaea-Aster tripolium community; SeSg, S. europaea-Suaeda glauca community; AtSe, Aster tripolium-S. europaea community; Mx, mixed community; Pc, Phragmites communis community; PcSg, P. communis-S. glauca community; SeSm, S. europaea-Suaeda maritima community; SmSe, S. maritima-S. europaea community; AtSm, A. tripolium-S. maritima community; SmPc, S. maritima-P. communis community.
and Aster tripolium community- Suaeda maritima com-munity- Salicornia europaea community sequence. The former appeared in the west of the projected area, which was a little dry and the latter appeared in the east of that, which was relatively wet. On the other hand, Triglochin maritimum is growing in the pool remaining in a part of the study area but was not expressed in a vegetation map because the area is too small.
P. thunbergii community, P. densiflora community, and P. rigida plantation appeared in the surrounding forested area. In addition, cultivated land, orchard, and residential area existed in the lower forests and plains.
- Species composition
Stand ordination based on vegetation data was car-ried out in order to compare species composition among plant communities established in artificially constructed salt marshes around the Gwangyang Container Port ( Fig. 3 ). The eigen values of axes 1 and 2 were 0.813 and 0.386, respectively. According to tolerance to salinity, stands were arranged in the order of Suaeda maritima, Salicor-nia europaea , and Phragmites communis communities on the Axis 1. Significant relations were not found with the Axis 2.
- Species diversity and evenness
Shannon-Wiener and evenness indices were com-pared among plant communities ( Fig. 4 ). Mixed commu-nity showed the highest species diversity (H′ = 0.86) and S. europaea community showed the lowest (H′ = 0.0). The Shannon-Wiener index of all communities was below 1.0 because each community was composed of only a few species adapted to the characteristic environment of salt marshes. Evenness was the highest in Mixed community (J′ = 2.26) and the lowest in S. maritima - S. europaea com-munity (J′ = 0.0).
- Comparison of vegetation types
In the previous studies on salt marshes in Korea, Ihm (1989), Lee (1989), Ihm et al. (1998a), and Han (2008) clas-sified fourteen, eight, nine, and six halophyte communi-ties, respectively. Plant communities that they reported were S. europaea community, Suaeda japonica communi-ty, S. maritima community, S. glauca community, Zoysia Arsinica community, Artemisia scoparia community, Limo-nium tetragonum community, A. tripolium community, Atriplex gmelinii community, T. maritimum community, Carex scabrifolia community, P. communis community, Phacelurus latifolius community, Scirpus maritimus community, Typha orientalis community, Conyza bonar-iensis community, and Artemisia fukudo community. These plant communities were usually expressed as pure stands. In our study area, five kinds of halophytes formed communities and those communities were usually mixed types rather than pure ones. A short period of seven years of restoration created several communities, which corresponded to 29.4% of total halophyte communities classified at salt marshes in Korea. Comparing the result with each study area mentioned above, community di-versity in this area approached a similar level except for Ihm’s (1989) result. However, it should be noted that Ihm’s (1989) result was obtained from salt marshes throughout the entire South Korea. Considering the facts, restoration effect obtained in our study can be evaluated as a success-ful achievement.
- Restoration of salt marshes using seed banks
Bradshaw (1984) suggested three methods for eco-system restoration. First is a passive restoration such as natural recovery. Second is implementing minimum in-tervention to accelerate succession and third is active in-tervention such as sowing seeds, planting trees and using seed banks. In general, the success of salt marshes resto-ration depends on the three factors (Wolters and Bakker 2002), namely the seed banks (Willems and Bik 1998), the presence of species pool (Morton and Law 1997, Zobel 1997, Zobel et al. 1998), and the ability of species to dis-perse (Willson and Traveset 2000, White et al. 2004). It is believed that even if halophytes have disappeared, their seeds may be buried in the soil seed bank. Consequently, they can germinate when the surrounding environment becomes appropriate for growth (Fenner 1985). Recently, studies on active restoration using seed banks and the potential contribution of seed banks for restoration have been gradually increasing (Augusto et al. 2001, Richter and Stromberg 2005, Roovers et al. 2006, Koh 2007, Lee 2007, Zhan et al. 2007, Lee et al. 2008).
Salt marshes are one of the most disturbed places ex-periencing both natural and anthropogenic disturbances (Wang et al. 2009). Seed banks are very useful for recovery of annual plants after disturbances (Baskin and Baskin 1980, Lee et al. 2008) and for the design of restoration projects (Richter and Stromberg 2005). Dormant seeds have significant ecological and evolutionary influences on plant population and community dynamics (Kalisz 1990). A few studies have mentioned that most seeds in salt marshes are transient and short longevity (Thomp-son et al. 1997, Wolters and Bakker 2002). However, sever-al plant communities were established successfully from soils dredged from the bottom of Gwangyang Bay even though the original purpose of this work was not restora-tion. Moreover, community diversity is similar to the re-sults of other studies. Since there is a great number of salt marshes in Korea and other places worldwide which have been destroyed or disturbed by excessive land use, the use of seed banks as a restoration tool is expected to increase. In addition, it would be applicable to restore landfill front in the reclaimed area such as Saemangeum. In fact, case studies executed in the United States and Netherlands showed that soil seed banks contributed significantly to re-establishment of salt-marsh communities (Turner et al. 1988, Toth 1996, Bakker et al. 2002).
Augusto L , Dupouey JL , Picard JF , Ranger J 2001 Potential contribution of the seed bank in coniferous plantations to the restoration of native deciduous forest vegetaion. Acta Oecol 22 87 - 98
Bakker JP , Esselink P , Dojkema KS , van Duin WE , de Jong DJ 2002 Restoration of salt marshes in the Netherlands. Hydrobiologia 478 29 - 51
Baskin JM , Baskin CC 1980 Role of seed reserves in the per-sistence of a local population of Sedum pulchellum: a di-rect field observation. Bull Torrey Bot Club 107 429 - 430
Bradshaw AD 1984 Ecological principles and land reclama-tion practice. Landsc Plann 11 35 - 48
Braun-Blanquet J 1964 Pflanzensoziologie. 3rd ed. Spring-er Wien.
Chung CH , Zhuo RZ , Xu GW 2004 Creation of Spartina plantations for reclaiming Dongtai, China, tidal flats and offshore sands. Ecol Eng 23 135 - 150
Cox RD , Allen EB 2008 Composition of soil seed banks in southern California coastal sage scrub and adjacent ex-otic grassland. Plant Ecol 198 37 - 46
Doody JP 2001 Coastal Conservation and Management: An Ecological Perspective. Kluwer Academic Publishers Boston, MA.
Eisma D , de Boer PL , Cadėe GC 1998 Intertidal Deposit: Riv-er Mouths, Tidal Flats, and Coastal Lagoons. CRC Press Boca Raton, FL.
Environmental System Research Institute (ESRI). 1996 Ar-cView GIS. Environmental System Research Institute, Inc. New York.
Fenner M 1985 Seed Ecology. Champman & Hall London.
Grime JP 1981 The role of seed dormancy in vegetation dy-namics. Ann Appl Biol 98 555 - 558
Grime JP 1989 Seed banks in ecological perspective. In: Ecology of Soil Seed Banks (Leck MA, Parker VT, Simp-son RL, eds). Academic Press London 15 - 22
Han YU 2008 The characteristics of halophyte vegetation of salt marshes in the southern and western coasts of Korea. Mokpo National University Muan, Korea. Ms Thesis.
Hill MO 1979 DECORANA: A FORTRAN Program for De-trended Correspondence Analysis and Reciprocal Aver-aging. Cornell University Ithaca, NY.
Hughes RG , Paramor OAL 2004 On the loss of saltmarshes in south-east England and methods for their restora-tion. J Appl Ecol 41 440 - 448
Ihm BS 1989 Distribution of coastal plant communities in response to soil water potential and plant osmotic ad-justment. Seoul National University Seoul, Korea. PhD Dissertation.
Ihm BS , Lee JS , Kim HS , Kwak AK , Ihm HB 1995a Adjust-ment of three halophyte to changes of NaCl concentra-tions. Bull Inst Litt Environ Mokpo Natil Univ 12 1 - 10
Ihm BS , Lee JS , Kim HS , Kwak AK , Ihm HB 1995b Distribu-tion of coastal plant communities at the salt marshes of Mankyung and Donjin River estuary. Bull Inst Litt Envi-ron Mokpo Natl Univ 12 11 - 28
Ihm BS , Lee JS , Kim JW , Kim HS , Ihm HB 1998a Studies on the vegetation at the wetland of Suncheon-Man. Bull Inst Litt Environ Mokpo Natl Univ 15 1 - 8
Ihm BS , Lee JS , Kim JW , Kim HS , Ihm HB 1998b Studies on the vegetation distribution and biomass at the wetland of Hampyung-Man. Bull Ins Litt Environ Mokpo Natl Univ 15 9 - 20
Kalisz S 1990 Soil seed banks. Ecology 71 1226 - 1227
Kim CH , Lee KB , Kim JD , Cho TD , Lim MS 2005 The study on the flora and vegetation of salt marshes of Dongjin-river estuary in Jeonbuk. J Environ Sci 14 817 - 825
Koh JH 2007 A study on the potential contribution of soil seed bank to the revegetation. J Korean Environ Res Reveg Technol 10 99 - 109
Lee JS 1989 On establishment of halophytes along tidal level gradient at salt marshes of Mankyong and Donjin river estuaries. Seoul National University Seoul, Korea. PhD Dissertation.
Lee JS , Ihm BS , Myeong HH , Park JW , Kim HS 2009 Soil en-vironment analysis and habitat of halophyte for restora-tion in the salt marshes of southern and western coasts of Korea. Korean J Plant Res 22 102 - 110
Lee JS , Kim JK 1988 Factors affecting plant distribution in salt marsh of Mankyong river and Donjin river estuaries. Nat Sci Res Kunsan Natl Univ 3 45 - 59
Lee SM 2007 Secondary succession and seed bank structure of abandoned rice paddy field, and its restoration. Seoul Women’s University Seoul, Korea. Ms Thesis.
Lee SM , Cho YC , Shin HC , Oh WS , Seol ES , Park SA , Lee CS 2008 Successional changes in seed banks in abandoned rice fields im Gwangneung, central Korea. J Ecol Field Biol. 31 269 - 276
Magurran AE 2004 Measuring Biological Diversity. Black-well New York.
McCune B , Mefford MJ 1999 PC-ORD Multivariate Analy-sis of Ecological Data. Version 4. MjM Software Design Glenden Beach, OR.
Middleton B 1999 Wetland Restoration, Flood Pulsing, and Disturbance Dynamics. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. New York.
Ministry of Environment. 2006 Development of Ecological Conservation and Management Techniques of Halo-phyte Communities on Salt Marshes of Southwestern Coasts in Korea. Korea Institute of Environmental Sci-ence and Technology Seoul.
Morton RD , Law R 1997 Regional species pools and the as-sembly of local ecological communities. J Theor Biol 187 321 - 331
National Research Council. 1992 Restoration of Aquatic Ecosystems: Science, Technology, and Public Policy. National Academy Press Washington, DC.
Nottage A , Robertson P 2005 The Saltmarsh Creation Hand-book: A Project Manager’s Guide to the Creation of Salt-marsh and Intertidal Mudflat. The Royal Society for the Protection of Birds Sandy, Bedfordshire.
Pielou EC 1966 The measurement of diversity in different types of biological collections. J Theor Biol 13 131 - 144
Richter R , Stromberg JC 2005 Soil seed banks of two mon-tane riparian areas: implications for restoration. Biodiv-ers Conserv 14 993 - 1016
Roberts HA 1981 Seed banks in soils. Adv Appl Biol 6 1 - 55
Roovers P , Bossuyt B , Igodt B , Hermy M 2006 May seed banks contribute to vegetation restoration on paths in temperate deciduous forest? Plant Ecol 187 25 - 38
Simpson RL , Leck MA , Parker VT 1989 Seed banks: general concepts and methodological issues. In: Ecology of Soil Seed Banks (Leck MA, Parker VT, Simpson RL, eds). Aca-demic Press London 1 - 8
Society for Ecological Restoration International Science & Policy Working Group. 2004 The SER International Primer on Ecological Restoration. Society for Ecological Restoration International Tucson, AZ.
Stanturf JA , Schoenholtz SH , Schweitzer CJ , Shepard JP 2001 Achieving restoration success: myths in bottom-land hardwood forests. Restor Ecol 9 189 - 200
Thompson K , Bakker JP , Bekker RM 1997 The Soil Seed Banks of North West Europe: Methodology, Density and Longevity. Cambridge University Press Cambridge.
Toth LA 1996 Restoring the hydrogeomorphology of the channelized Kissimmee River. In: River Channel Res-toration: Guiding Principles for Sustainable Projects (Brookes A, Shields FD Jr, eds). John Wiley & Sons Chichester 369 - 383
Turner RE , Mendelssohn IA , McKee KL , Costanza R , Neill C , Sikora JP , Sikora WB , Swenson E 1988 Wetlands hydrol-ogy and vegetation dynamics. Association of State Wetland Managers Berne New York Proceedings of the Na-tional Wetland Symposium: mitigation of impacts and losses New Orleans, LA. 1986 Oct 8-10 135 - 141
Wall DH , Palmer MA , Snelgrove PVR 2001 Biodiversity in critical transition zones between terrestrial, freshwater, and marine soils sediments: processes, linkages, and management implications. Ecosystems 4 418 - 420
Wang CH , Tang L , Fei SF , Wang JQ , Gao Y , Wang Q , Chen JK , Li B 2009 Determinants of seed bank dynamics of two dominant helophytes in a tidal salt marsh. Ecol Eng 35 800 - 809
White E , Tucker N , Meyers NM , Wilson J 2004 Seed disper-sal to revegetated isolated rainforest patches in North Queensland. For Ecol Manage 192 409 - 426
Willems JH , Bik LPM 1998 Restoration of high species den-sity in calcareous grassland: the role of seed rain and soil seed bank. Appl Veg Sci 1 91 - 100
Willson MF , Traveset A 2000 The ecology of seed dispersal. In: Seeds: The Ecology of Regeneration in Plant Com-munities (Fenner M, ed). 2nd ed. CABI Publishing Wall-ingford 85 - 110
Wolters M , Bakker JP 2002 Soil seed bank and driftline com-position along a successional gradient on a temperate salt marsh. Appl Veg Sci 5 55 - 62
Yim YJ , Kira T 1975 Distribution of forest vegetation and climate in the Korean Peninsula I. Distribution of some indices of thermal climate. Jpn J Ecol 25 77 - 88
Zhan X , Li L , Cheng W 2007 Restoration of Stipa krylovi-isteppes in inner Mongolia of China: assessment of seed banks and vegetation composition. J Arid Environ 68 298 - 307
Zobel M 1997 The relative role of species pools in determin-ing plant species richness: an alternarive explanation of species coexistence? Trends Ecol Evol 12 266 - 269
Zobel M , van der Maarel E , Dupré C 1998 Species pool: the concept its determination and significance for commu-nity restoration. Appl Veg Sci 1 55 - 66