Broadband Piezoelectric Vibration Energy Harvester Using Pole-Zero Cancellation Technique
Broadband Piezoelectric Vibration Energy Harvester Using Pole-Zero Cancellation Technique
Transactions of the Korean Society for Noise and Vibration Engineering. 2014. Feb, 24(2): 87-92
Copyright © 2014, The Korean Society for Noise and Vibration Engineering
  • Received : November 26, 2013
  • Accepted : January 09, 2014
  • Published : February 20, 2014
Export by style
Cited by
About the Authors
기 우 김
Corresponding Author ; Member, School of Automotive Engineering, Kyungpook National University E-mail : +82-54-530-1407, Fax : +82-54-530-1409

This paper presents a new design for a piezoelectric energy harvester with the potential to harvest vibration energy over a wide range of excitation frequencies, particularly beyond the resonance frequency. The piezoelectric vibration energy harvester employs the concept of pole-zero cancellation occurring in a lever type anti-resonant system. The experimental results show that the proposed energy harvester can provide the potential possibility of a broadband piezoelectric vibration energy harvester.
1. Introduction
Although vibration-based energy harvesting based on piezoelectric materials is one of the most promising technologies as a potential replacement for primary battery sources in long-term, low-power autonomous sensory systems, there are only a few examples of commercial product available for energy harvesting because the power output of existing piezoelectric vibration energy harvesters (PVEHs) is not sufficient (1) .
In addition, conventional vibration energy harvesters using only cantilever beam structure generally become inefficient when exposed to off-resonance or low frequencies because they are designed to tune to their resonant frequency. The power output degrades significantly when the ex-citation frequency of the ambient vibration deviates from the resonant frequency. Therefore, extending the feasible operating range for piezoelectric vibration energy harvesting is a major research issue (2) .
Recent attempts to enable broadband PVEH have included active resonance frequency tuning for varying vibration frequency spectra (3) , the design of multi-modal structure consisting of multiple beam arrays (4,5) , and the use of a nonlinear vibration oscillator (e.g. the Duffing oscillator) (6~9) . In particular, many studies have examined nonlinear bistable (buckling or snap-through) systems to address the aforementioned limitations of conventional beam structures (10~12) , and true wide bandwidth vibration energy harvester based on piezoelectric transduction is examined (13) . In addition, two flexible piezoelectric elements arranged in a bucked structure have been designed for harvesting over a broad range of ambient frequencies (14) . Although previous studies have produced some promising findings, most broadband prototypes require better performance, simpler structures, and new operational principle.
This study proposes a new broadband piezoelectric vibration energy harvester that can generate electric power over a wide frequency range by simply including a geometric configuration such as a lever mechanism(Section 2). The new concept of a broadband PVEH is experimentally validated through laboratory tests(Section 3).
2. Broadband Piezoelectric Vibration Energy Harvester
The schematic diagram of the proposed broadband PVEH inspired by anti-resonant vibration isolator (15) is illustrated in Fig. 1(a) . This configuration can be approximated by a linear lumped single-degree-of-freedom(1-DOF) mass-spring system by connecting a of negligible to the primary proof (tip) mass through a simple lever mechanism and by assuming that the cantilever beam dominantly vibrates only with the fundamental vibration mode because of the proof mass( Fig. 1 (b) ). Then the constraint equation for z with respect to x and y and the Lagrangian function can be defined as follows:
PPT Slide
Lager Image
(a) A schematic diagram of a broadband piezoelectric vibration energy harvester and, (b) An equivalent lumped spring-mass system (1-DOF) with a lever mechanism
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Where z = αy − ( α −1) x , and α = 1 / 2 . Here Hamilton’s principle yields the following equation of motion (15) :
PPT Slide
Lager Image
PPT Slide
Lager Image
, and μ = ms/m .
The ratio of Laplace transform of input ( y ) to the Laplace function of output ( x ) yields following transfer function
PPT Slide
Lager Image
where s is the complex variable. The roots of the numerator and denominator of the transfer function yield two resonant frequencies
PPT Slide
Lager Image
where ωP is the resonant frequency associated with poles, and ωZ is the anti-resonant frequency associated with zeros of the given system, respectively.
Note that the zero associated with the anti-resonant frequency is added to the system because of the lever. In addition, if μ = 1 ( α − 1) , then ωP/ ωZ =1 , which implies that pole-zero cancellation can occur under certain excitation conditions. The frequency response function (FRFs, i. e., the transfer function) is uniform across all excitation frequencies, which allows for a new effective means for a broadband vibration energy harvester. To illustrate the pole-zero cancellation technique, the frequency response function for Eq. (2) is simulated (see Fig. 2 ). The viscous damping constant( c=0.01 N·s/m) was included to show the damped response. The auxiliary mass ( mS ) is tuned to change the parameter μ , remaining constant α (=0.01 m/0.005 m), because the ratio of the primary mass to the tuning mass ( μ ) is a more sensitive parameter, and easier to change. With the removal of the tuning mass, the system becomes a conventional 1-DOF mass-spring system with a base excitation foundation, introducing a single peak (the resonant frequency of 16 Hz shown as a solid line in Fig. 2 ). The spring constant ( k ) is approximately estimated to be 100 N/m based on the bending stiffness of beams (0.095( L )×0.0173( W ) ×0.0005( t) m). In addition to a resonant frequency, an additional peak (an anti- resonant frequency of 19 Hz) is observed because of the zeros when the tuning mass is set to 0.0035 kg (the dotted line in Fig. 2 ). In general, this lever-type 1 DOF mass-spring-damper system can significantly reduce the amplitude of the transmitted vibration within the anti-resonant frequency range (i.e. a vibration isolator acting as a band-pass filter). On the other hand, the frequency response function flattens over a wide range of excitation frequencies (above 12 Hz in Fig. 2 ) because the poles and zeros cancel out as a result of the sufficient inertial forcing term when the tuning mass increases to 0.015 kg ( μ ≅ 1 , the phantom line in Fig. 2 ). Unlike in the case of the conventional 1-DOF system, the frequency response function shows no decrease beyond the resonant frequency.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Simulation results for the frequency response functions(m=0.01 kg, α =2)
3. Experimental Validation
An experiment is conducted to validate the proposed design for broadband piezoelectric vibration energy harvesting. A prototype is fabricated based on a lever-type anti-resonant system ( Fig. 1 ) and validated through a laboratory test, as shown in Fig. 3 . A cantilever beam type piezoelectric harvester is first constructed using the macro fiber composite (MFC) from Smart Material Corporation ® (Model: M8528P2, 0.09( L ) × 0.0173( W ) m), and the glass-fiber reinforced plastic (GFRP) substrate plate ( t =0.5 mm) from Composite Structure Technology ® . Then MFC and GFRP are bonded using an Epoxy (model: 3M ® DP460). To minimize the mass effect of the lever, it is made simply of lightweight wood, and pivoted at a fixed hinge connected to the base foundation, as well as to the proof mass. Accordingly, the rigid lever amplifies the input vibration force to provide a greater output force, which is frequently referred to as the leverage effect. The proposed harvester is excited harmonically using an electromagnetic shaker (model: Modal Shop 2007E). A generated sinusoidal signal is applied to the shaker through a linear amplifier. To measure the maximum output voltage, the open-circuit DC voltage without a resistive load from the harvester is measured by using a full-wave rectifying circuit with a bridge diode (model: Analog Device ® DB105, voltage drop Vf =1.1 Volt), as shown in Fig. 4(b) . The capacitive element of 1 μF is chosen for a smooth transient response.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
(a) The broadband piezoelectric vibration energy harvester and, (b) overall experimental set-up
PPT Slide
Lager Image
(a) Full-wave rectifying circuit (b) implementation of full-wave rectifying circuit
To measure the frequency response function (FRF), the base acceleration is also measured using an ICP-type accelerometer (model: 355B02; PCB Piezotronics, Inc.) mounted on top of the shake. The voltages from the harvester and the voltage from the accelerometer are sampled with a sampling frequency of 400 Hz, and analyzed using a dynamic signal analyzer (model: HP35670A). While the proof mass of 0.01 kg is fixed to the end tip of the harvester, the tuned mass is adjusted manually by using small metal weights.
4. Results and Discussion
Multi-mode voltage frequency response functions are estimated using the AC output voltage (before rectifying) and the applied acceleration (an approximated root mean square (RMS) value of 1 m/s 2 ), as shown in Fig. 5 . Although the sampling frequency is chosen to be sufficient for capturing some of the natural frequencies, only the fundamental vibration mode of interest is plotted for comparison with respect to the simulation results. The experimental result is generally consistent with the simulation results. The slight attenuation above 30 Hz in Fig. 5 is due to the exclusion of the higher modes. The voltage FRF for anti-resonant ( ms =0.0035 kg) and pole-zero cancellation ( ms =0.015 kg) slightly becomes reduced because of the reduced excitation force resulting from the attachment of tuned mass and lever. However, the voltage FRF for pole-zero cancellation (the phantom line in Fig. 5 ) shows no significant decrease beyond the resonant frequency, which is consistent with the simulation results. In the case of pole-zero cancellation, the anti-resonant frequency disappeared, and the voltage FRFs can be more uniformly distributed, ranging from 15 Hz to 40 Hz, at the expense of peak value at the resonant frequency.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Experimental results for the frequency response functions (m=0.01 kg, α =2)
To demonstrate the wide bandwidth of the proposed harvester using pole-zero cancellation, the output AC voltage is rectified to a DC voltage with the rectifying circuit. When vibration is on around 3 second, the open-circuit DC voltages with respect to different excitation frequencies are illustrated, as shown in Fig. 6 . The measured DC voltages reach their steady-state values of 2.8 V at 17 Hz (resonant frequency), 2.2 V at 23 Hz, and 2.1 V at 22 Hz, respectively. These steady-state values as a function of the excitation frequencies are averaged by using 5 measured data, as shown in Fig. 7 . The trend of the frequency response curves is nearly consistent with the multi-mode voltage frequency response functions (the phantom line in Fig. 5 ). The average power output capability of the proposed broadband harvesters can be measured using the following equation (10) .
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Steady-state open-circuit DC voltages with respect to different excitation frequencies: PVEH using pole-zero cancellation (ms=0.015 kg)
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Broadband vibration energy harvesting performance of the proposed PVEH
PPT Slide
Lager Image
where C is the capacitance (1 μF in this study), Vp is the peak-to-peak open-circuit voltage of the piezoelectric harvester, and Δt is the time interval required to reach the steady-state open-circuit voltage. The average output power is approximately estimated to be 13~15 μW over excitation frequency between 18 Hz and 24 Hz, which can suggest that the proposed PVEH using pole-zero cancellation possesses wide operating range.
5. Conclusion
This paper proposes new broadband PVEH based on the pole-zero cancellation technique to extend the operating frequency range. Pole-zero cancellation is successfully produced using a lever type anti-resonant configuration with the tuning mass. In comparison to the conventional cantilever beam-type harvesters, the proposed PVEH offers a simple but effective way to generate electric power over a wide range of frequencies (i. e., between the fundamental and second natural frequencies). The results suggest that the proposed harvester can potentially provide a simple means to overcome the limitation of conventional PVEHs (narrow operating range).
Gi-Woo Kim received his Ph.D. degree in Mechanical Engineering Department from the Pennsylvania State University in 2009. He had worked for the Hyundai Motor Company Powertrain R&D Center from 1996 to 2004, and Mechanical Engineering Department at University of Michigan from 2009 to 2011, respectively. He has been working for the Kyungpook National University as an assistant professor since 2011. His research area of expertise includes a smart material-based sensor and actuator, automotive electronic control, torsional vibration control, vibration based energy harvesting etc.
Erturk A. , Inman D. J. 2011 Piezoelectric Energy Harvesting Wiley & Sons New York
Elvin N. , Erturk A. 2013 Advances in Energy Harvesting Methods; Chapter 2 Broadband Vibration Energy Harvesting Techniques Springer New York
Zho Y. , Zu J. , Su W. 2013 Broadband Energy Harvesting Through a Piezoelectric Beam Subjected to Dynamic Compressive Loading Smart Mater. Struct. 22 045007 -    DOI : 10.1088/0964-1726/22/4/045007
Ferrari M. , Ferrari V. , Guizzetti M. , Marioli D. , Taroni A. 2008 Piezoelectric Multifrequency Energy Converter for Power Harvesting in Autonomous Microsystems Sens Actuators A 142 (1) 329 - 335    DOI : 10.1016/j.sna.2007.07.004
Lee S. W. , Kim Y. Y. , Kim J. E. 2013 Mathematical Model for a Mode-sequence Reversed Two-degrees-of-freedom Piezoelectric Vibration Energy Harvester Transactions of the Korean Society for Noise and Vibration Engineering 23 (6) 546 - 552    DOI : 10.5050/KSNVE.2013.23.6.546
Barton A. W. , Burrow S. G. , Clare L. R. 2010 Energy Harvesting from With a Nonlinear Oscillator J. Vibr. Acoust. 132 021009 - 1    DOI : 10.1115/1.4000809
Arrieta A. F , Hagedorn P , Erturk A. , Inman D. J. 2010 A Piezoelectric Bistable Plate for Nonlinear Broadband Energy Harvesting Appl. Phys. Lett. 97 104102 -    DOI : 10.1063/1.3487780
Erturk A. , Hoffmann J. , Inman D. J. 0000 20A Piezomagnetoelastic Structure for Broadband Vibration Energy Harvesting Appl. Phys. Lett. 94 254102 -
Soliman M. S. M. , Abdel-Rahman E. M. , EI-Saadany E. F. , Mansour R. R. 2008 A Wideband Vibration-based Energy Harvester J. Micromech. Microeng. 18 115021 -    DOI : 10.1088/0960-1317/18/11/115021
Kim G.-W. , Kim J. 2013 Compliant Bistable Mechanism for Low Frequency Vibration Energy Harvester Inspired by Auditory Hair Bundle Structures Smart Mater. Struct. 22 014005 -    DOI : 10.1088/0964-1726/22/1/014005
Harne R. L. , Wang K. W. 2013 A Review of the Recent Research on Vibration Energy Harvesting Via Bistable Systems Smart Mater. Struct. 22 023001 -    DOI : 10.1088/0964-1726/22/2/023001
Liu W. Q. , Badel A. , Formosa F. , Wu Y. P. , Agbossou A. 2013 Novel Piezoelectric Bistable Oscillator Architecture for Wideband Vibration Energy Harvesting Smart Mater. Struct. 22 035013 -    DOI : 10.1088/0964-1726/22/3/035013
Marinkovic B. , Koser H. 2012 Demonstration of Wide Bandwidth Energy Harvesting from Vibrations Smart Mater. Struct. 21 065006 -    DOI : 10.1088/0964-1726/21/6/065006
Blarigan L. V. , Danzl P. , Moehlis Jeff 2012 A Broadband Vibrational Energy Harvester Appl. Phys. Lett. 100 253904 -    DOI : 10.1063/1.4729875
Yilmaz C. , Kikuchi N. 2006 Analysis and Design of Passive Band-stop Filter-type Vibration Isolators for Low-frequency Applications J. Sound Vib. 291 1004 - 1028    DOI : 10.1016/j.jsv.2005.07.019