Biological control using the plant growth-promoting Rhizobacterium (PGPR) has received significant attention in recent years. PGPR has been linked with promoting growth in economically important crops, such as potatoes, tomatoes, and rice.
Bacillus mojavensis
KJS-3 (Moja-3), isolated from food waste, possesses antifungal properties against
Aspergillus terreus, A. fumagatus, A. flavus
, and
Fusarium redolense
, and it may have potential in the development of products for industrial applications. The main purpose of this study was to determine the effects of spraying the PGPR
Bacillus mojavensis
KJS-3 on the growth of altari radish (leaf number, leaf length, leaf weight, root length, and rhizome length, adjacent portion diameter, and weight) and lettuce (leaf number, length, width, and weight). Three different concentrations of the foliar spray treatment of
B. mojavensis
KJS-3 were applied to the altari radish and lettuce: the recommended standard concentration of 1×10
9
cfu/g, half the standard concentration of 0.5×10
9
cfu/g, and double the standard concentration of 2×10
9
cfu/g). The
B. mojavensis strain
foliar spray treatment increased the growth of the leaves and roots of the altari radish and increased the growth of the lettuce leaves. For both plants, the recommended concentration of
B. mojavensis
KJS-3 produced better growth than half the standard concentration, and the growth was similar with the double dose. This study demonstrates positive effects of Moja-3, suggesting it may be a potential new bio-fertilizer for improving the growth of altari radish and lettuce.
Introduction
In modern agriculture field, increase in use of chemical pesticides and chemical fertilizers has resulted in deterioration of soil fertility and manifestation of pesticide-resistant mutants of insects and plant pathogens, ultimately causing harm to human body. To overcome these problems, biological control using PGPR has gained increased attention and much research works have been carried out in recent years. PGPR is a specific group of (bacterial and fungal) microorganisms that can be found located inside wide varieties of plant tissue types: fruit
[30]
, seeds and ovules
[23]
, stems
[22]
, roots
[13
,
16]
and tubers
[15
,
33]
. Most of these PGPRs are members of common soil bacterial genera such as
Bacillus, Pseudomonas
and
Burkholderia
[21]
. The PGPR has been found promoting growth in several essential crops such as wheat, soybean, lettuce, bean, maize, barley
[19]
, potatoes
[6
,
12
,
24
,
33]
, tomato
[20
,
28]
, and tomato and cucumber
[9]
.
Bacillus subtilis
(Ehrenberg), the oldest gram-positive spore-forming bacterium, has proven to be safe as a non-pathogenic species and have been used enormously in various human food preparations for many years. The bacterium isolated from several botanical environments, mainly from the soil, has displayed properties similar to that of antibiotics with biological control potential. A strain of
B. subtilis
(RRC101) initially identified as
Enterobacter cloacae
and recently reported as a corn endophytic
[14]
is intercellular, nonpathogenic and growth enhancer, protecting the plants against fungi. Also, the report suggests that this strain can colonize plants from the seed application. This strain has been patented (Patent No. 5,994,117; ATCC 55732) as a biological control for treating the fungal infections in maize
[4]
. Subsequently, this isolate was found closely related
B. subtilis
like phenotype that was recently described as
Bacillus mojavensis
[27]
. The
mojavensis
strain is a relatively new member of the genus
Bacillus
, and is known to be a PGPR of plants that can be distinguished from its closest relative
Bacillus subtilis
, with divergence only in their DNA sequences and fatty acid compositions
[27]
. The study of
B. mojavensis
appears to be profoundly valuable due to its effect on plant diseases and mycotoxins, possessing antifungal activity against pathogenic fungi in plants. Antifungal agent as a cyclic lipopeptide produced in
Bacillus mojavensis
was recently identified by Dr. Bacon
[31]
.
Bacillus mojavensis
presents additional qualities of being competitive with some fungi, mostly those that are also PGPR by the production of isomers of the surfactins, a biosurfactant that is described as being the most potent familiar of lipopeptide group. The surfactins are very active, readily degradable thus becoming more attractive for use in biocontrol
[3]
. On the other hand,
Bacillus mojavensis
KJS-3 (
B. mojavensis
KJS-3) was identified by Prof. Jae Seon Kang from the food wastes, and its antimicrobial activity was examined against some harmful fungi such as
Aspergillus terreus, A. fumagatus, A. flavus
and
Fusarium redolense
, adopting the spot-on-lawn method
[17]
. This strain has been patented as a biological control for diseases in human caused by fungi, MRSAs, and
vancomycin-resistant Enterococci
[18]
. The aim of this study was to determine the biological control for the growth of altari radish and lettuce, by using PGPR
Bacillus mojavensis
KJS-3.
Materials and methods
- Materials to study effects on growth of altari radish and lettuce
Bacterial strains, culture condition, media
The bacterial strain,
B. mojavensis
KJS-3 KCCM10961P was produced in Tryptic Soy Broth (TSB, Bacto) media and propagations generated in TSB on a rotating shaker (200 rpm/min) at 42℃. The formation of spores of
B. mojavensis
KJS-3 was done in medium containing corn starch 15 g/l, yeast extract 5 g/l, K
2
HPO
4
2.5 g/l, KH
2
PO
4
2.5 g/l, KCl 0.5 g/l, NaCl 0.3 g/l, MgSO
4
·7H
2
O 0.5 g/l, MnSO
4
·H
2
O 0.03 g/l and CaCl
2
·2H
2
O 0.2 g/l. Then, all the spores were cultivated under experimental conditions for 5-6 days at 42℃. All of the media utilized in this study were autoclaved at 121℃ for 15 minutes.
- Plant site for cultivation
The cultivation of altari radish and lettuce were done in the farm of Dong-A University, Gimhea, South Korea and the effect of
B. mojavensis
KJS-3 was studied by comparing the growth of altari radish and lettuce.
- B. mojavensis KJS-3treatment method
Foliar spray treatment
100 g, 50 g and 200 g of
B. mojavensis
KJS-3 each were suspended separately in 20 liter water to prepare the three samples in the concentration of 1×10
9
CFU/g, 0.5×10
9
CFU/g and 2×10
9
CFU/g respectively. The standard concentration sample of 1×10
9
CFU/ g bacterial suspension was sprayed on day 7 for three times, when 3-4 leaves of altari radish were developed.
Treatment area
As shown in
Table 1
, twelve different plots (with total area of 60 m
2
) were allocated for altari radish as well as lettuce, separately. These plots were randomly treated with three different samples of Moja-3, for three times.
Treatment area and test methods for altari radish and lettuce
Treatment area and test methods for altari radish and lettuce
Area layout for Moja-3 test in altari radish and lettuce
To evaluate Moja-3 effects, 12 testing areas were divided to control, half dose, standard dose and double dose treatment. The areas are shown in
Fig. 1
.
Test area layout for cultivation of altari radish and lettuce. 12 testing areas are divided to 4 sections for cultivation of altari radish and another 12 areas were tested for lettuce. Control, half dose, standard dose and double dose treatments were applied to each section and the divided areas are shown in Fig. 1.
Cultivation methods
For the cultivation of altari radish and lettuce, their seed were taken from Heungnong province and their specifications have been shown in
Table 2
.
Overview of altari radish and lettuce
Overview of altari radish and lettuce
Planting, cultivation and harvesting of altari radish
We cultivated altari radish following to the timeline shown in
Table 3.1
.
Timeline for altari radish cultivation and harvesting
Timeline for altari radish cultivation and harvesting
Planting, cultivation, and harvesting of lettuce
Timeline for the lettuce cultivation is shown in
Table 3.2
.
Timeline for altari radish cultivation and harvesting
Timeline for altari radish cultivation and harvesting
Results and Discussion
- Effect of Moja-3 foliar treatment on altari radish
Effect of Moja-3 foliar treatment on the characteristics of altari radish leaves
The results of Moja-3 foliar treatment (up to three weeks, once each week) on leaves of altari radish have been summarized in
Table 4.1a
below. After harvesting, the growth characteristics of three different groups of altari radish treated with half, standard and double concentration of Moja-3 were tested by comparing the number, length and weight of the leaves with untreated control group. The number of leaves of control group was 15.21, and those treated with half dose, standard dose and double dose were 16.84, 18.22 and 18.21 respectively. While, the length of leaves of control group was 57.17 cm, those treated with half dose, standard dose and double dose of Moja-3 foliar spray were 61.28 cm, 63.78 cm and 63.74 cm respectively. The weight of leaves of control group was 191.14 g and those treated with half dose, standard dose and double dose were 202.14 g, 225.28 g and 222.04 g. These results suggest that, compared to untreated control group, the Moja-3 foliar spray group showed an increase in growth of altari radish leaves. As there were no significant differences in the growth characteristics (number, length and weight) of altari radish leaves when treated with the recommended standard and double concentration of Moja-3, the standard dose of foliar spray treatment was the preferred one over half dose test sample.
Characterization of Altari radish leaves afterBacillus mojavensisKJS-3 treatment
* Means in a column followed by same letter are not significantly different according to Duncan’s multiple range test at the 1% level (p≤0.01).
Characterization of altari radish root afterBacillus mojavensisKJS-3 treatment (Foliar spray)
* Means in a column followed by same letter are not significantly different according to Duncan’s multiple range test at the 1% level (p≤0.01).
Effect of Moja-3 foliar treatment on the characteristics of altari radish roots
After harvesting the altari radish, roots of altari radish were compared between the untreated control group and 3 different foliar spray Moja 3 treatment groups. Length of the root of control group was found to be 13.35 cm whereas the length of altari radish treated with half concentration, standard concentration and double concentration of Moja-3 foliar spray group were 14.27 cm, 14.51 cm and 14.48 cm respectively. Rhizomes of the control group was 6.54 cm and the altari radish treated with half dose, standard dose and double dose of Moja-3 foliar spray group were 7.61 cm, 7.75 cm and 7.70 cm respectively. Similarly, the diameter of adjacent portion of control group of altari radish was compared with Moja 3 treated group and found higher (4.85 cm) in case of standard dose of Moja-3 treated group. Weight of the root of control group altari radish was 201.21 g, while those of half dose, standard dose and double dose were 226.85 g, 235.08 g and 233.18 g. The growth in weight of the altari radish roots due to standard dose was more acceptable; it was higher than the growth in weight of the roots due to half dose (226.85 g) and even similar to double dose (233.18 g). In the present work, the use of 1×10
9
CFU/g concentration of Moja-3 treatment group showed the higher impact on the growth of root of altari radish.
Bacillus mojavensis KJS-3 foliar spray treatment for the growth of altari radish
Result of Moja-3 foliar spray in the altari radish, for three weeks once each week, did not showed any inhibitory effect on the growth of altari radish, and the results observed have been shown in
Fig. 2
below.
Altari radish during and/or after Bacillus mojavensis KJS-3 treatment.Cultivation procedure and altari radish growth appearance after Bacillus mojavenis KJS-3 treatment (Foliar Spray) : 2.1-day 1 of Moja-3 treatment, 2.2-devastating, 2.3-growing, 2.4-before harvesting, 2.5-after harvesting, 2.6-comparison of study groups.
Effects of Moja-3 foliar treatment on the characteristics of the lettuce leaves
Result of Moja-3 foliar treatment on the lettuce leaves have been summarized in
Table 4.2
below. After harvesting three different groups of lettuce treated with half, standard and double doses of Moja-3, growth characteristics were examined by comparing the quantity, length and weight of the leaves with the control group. The number of leaves of control group was 20.15, while those treated with half dose, standard dose and double dose were 22.14, 23.84 and 23.71 respectively. The length of control group leaves was 22.17 cm, while the length of the leaves treated with half dose, standard dose and double dose were 24.18 cm, 26.29 cm and 26.07 cm respectively. The width of the control group leaves was 13.51 cm while those treated with Moja-3 foliar spray half dose, standard dose and double dose were 15.02 cm, 16.14 cm and 16.08 cm respectively. The weight of control group leaves was 157.58 g and those treated with half dose, standard dose and double dose were 170.10 g, 174.86 and 170.44 g. The growth in weight of the lettuce leaves due to standard dose (174.86 g) was more acceptable; it gained higher growth compared to the growth from half dose (170.10 g) and double dose (170.44 g). These results suggest that, compared with untreated control group the Moja-3 foliar spray group showed an increase in growth of the leaves of lettuce, and among there different group standard foliar spray treatments group showed the good result.
Growth effects afterBacillus mojavensisKJS-3 treatment (Foliar spray) on lettuce leaves
* Means in a column followed by same letter are not significantly different according to Duncan’s multiple range test at the 1% level (p≤0.01).
Bacillus mojavensis KJS-3 foliar spray treatment for the growth of lettuce
Result of Moja-3 foliar spray in the lettuce, for three weeks once each week, did not showed any inhibitory effect on the growth of lettuce, and the results observed have been shown in
figure 3
below.
Lettuce during and/or after Bacillus mojavensis KJS-3 treatment. Cultivation procedure and lettuce growth appearance after Bacillus mojavenis KJS-3 treatment (Foliar Spray) : 3.1-day 1 of Moja-3 treatment, 3.2-devastating, 3.3-growing 3.4-before harvesting, 3.5-after harvesting, 3.6-comparison of study groups.
This is the very first study on growth promoting effects of bacterial application in the growth parameters of plants such as altari radish and lettuce. Though, similar investigations were conducted in different plant species, their studies suggested that, bacterial applications including
Pseudomonas
and
Bacillus
strains can stimulate growth and increase the yield in pepper and tomato
[20
,
28]
, in beans
[32]
, in sugar beet
[5]
, in spring barley
[29]
, in sweet cherry
[10]
, apricot
[1]
, in raspberry
[25]
in apple
[2]
, in rocket
[8]
and in tomato and cucumber
[9]
. The key reason for the growth promoting effect of bacterial applications on plant growth is that they affect on fixation capacity of Nitrogen
[7
,
26
,
34]
and is one of the most prominent mechanism of action with high probability of affecting plant growth
[10]
.
In modern agriculture field, increase in use of chemical pesticides and chemical fertilizers has resulted in deterioration of soil fertility and manifestation of pesticide-resistant mutants of insects and plant pathogens damaging human body. To overcome these problems, biological control using endophyte is becoming more and more attentive and much research has been carried out in recent years. The species mojavensis is a relatively new member of the genus Bacillus and is known to be a PGPR of plants.
Bacillus mojavensis
KJS-3 discovered from food waste has been investigated as potential for developing the product in the industrial applications and found to possess antifungal property against
Aspergillus terreus, A. fumagatus, A. flavus
and
Fusarium redolense
. The effects produced by three different
B. mojavensis strain
foliar spray treatment method resulted increase in the growth of both altari radish and lettuce. The standard recommended dose of
B. mojavensis
KJS-3 (1X10
9
CFU/g) was found to be more effective than half of the dose and similar to the double dose, for the growth of both altari radish and lettuce. The present study demonstrates a significant positive effect of
B. mojavensis
KJS-3 as a potential agent of new bio-fertilizer for growth of altari radish and lettuce cultivation.
Acknowledgements
This research was supported by Kyungsung University Research Grants in 2014.
Altindag M.
,
Sahin M.
,
Esitken A.
,
Ercisli S.
,
Guleryuz M.
,
Donmez M. F.
,
Sahin F.
2006
Biological control of brown root (Moniliana laxa) on apricot (Prunus armeniaca L.) by Bacillus, Burkholdria and Pseudomonas application under in vitro and in vivo conditions
Bio Control
38
369 -
372
DOI : 10.1016/j.biocontrol.2006.04.015
Aslantas R.
,
Cakmakci R.
,
Sahin F.
2007
Effect of plant growth promoting rhizobacteria on young apple tree growth and fruit yield under orchard conditions
Sci Hortic
111
371 -
377
DOI : 10.1016/j.scienta.2006.12.016
Bacon C. W.
,
Hinton D. M.
,
Mitchell T. R.
,
Snook M. E.
,
Olubajo B.
2012
Characterization of endophytic strains of Bacillus mojavensis and their production of surfactin isomers
J Biocontrol
62
1 -
9
Bacon C. W.
,
Yates I. E.
,
Hinton D. M.
,
Meredlth F.
2001
Biological control of Fusarium moniliforme in maize
Environ Health Perspect
109
((Suppl 2))
325 -
332
Conn K. L.
,
Nowak J.
,
Lazarovits G.
1997
A gnotobiotic bioassay for studying interactions between potatoes and plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria
Can J Microbiol
43
801 -
808
DOI : 10.1139/m97-117
Dursun A.
,
Ekinci M.
,
Donmez M. F.
2008
Effects of inoculation bacteria on chemical content, yield and growth in Rocket (Eruca vesicaria subsp. sativa)
Asian J Chemistry
20
3197 -
3202
Dursun A.
,
Ekinci M.
,
Donmez M. F.
2010
Effects of foliar application of plant growth promoting bacterium on chemical contents, yield and growth of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) and cucumber (Cucumis sativus)
Pak J Bot
42
3349 -
3356
Esitken A.
,
Karlidag H.
,
Ercisli S.
,
Turan M.
,
Sahin F.
2003
The effect of spraying a growth promoting bacterium on the yield, growth and nutrient element composition of leaves of apricot (Prunus armeniaca L. cv. Hacihaliloglu)
Aust J Agric Res
54
377 -
380
DOI : 10.1071/AR02098
Esitken A.
,
Pirlak L.
,
Turan M.
,
Sahin F.
2006
Effects of oral and foliar application of plant growth promoting rhizobacteria (PGPR) on yield, growth and nutrition of sweet cherry
Sci Hortic
110
324 -
327
DOI : 10.1016/j.scienta.2006.07.023
Frommel M. I.
,
Nowak J.
,
Lazarovits G.
1991
Growth enhancement and developmental modifications of in vitro grown potato (Solanum tuberosum ssp. tuberosum) as affected by a non-fluorescent Pseudomonas sp
Plant Physiol
96
926 -
938
Germida J. J.
,
Siciliano S. D.
,
de Freitas R.
,
Seib A. M.
1998
Diversity of root-associated bacteria associated with field-grown canola (Brassica napus L.) and wheat (Triticum aestivum L.)
FEMS Microbiol Ecol
26
43 -
50
DOI : 10.1111/j.1574-6941.1998.tb01560.x
Hinton D. M.
,
Bacon C. W.
1995
Enterobacter cloacae is an endophytic symbiont of corn
Mycopathologia
129
117 -
125
DOI : 10.1007/BF01103471
Hollis J. P.
1951
Bacteria in healthy potato tissue
Phytopathology
41
350 -
366
Jacobs M. J.
,
Bugbee W. M.
,
Gabrielson D. A.
1985
Enumeration, location, and characterization of endophytic bacteria within sugar beet roots
Can J Bot
63
1262 -
1265
DOI : 10.1139/b85-174
Kim D. H.
,
Kim H. K.
,
Kim K. M.
,
Kim C. K.
,
Jeong M. H.
,
Ko C. Y.
,
Moon K. H.
,
Kang J. S.
2011
Antibacterial activities of macrolactin a and 7-O-succinyl macrolactin a from Bacillus polyfermenticus KJS-2 against vancomycin-resistant enterococci and methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus
Arch Pharm Res
34
147 -
152
DOI : 10.1007/s12272-011-0117-0
Kim K. M.
,
Choi S. M.
,
Kim D. U.
,
Yoon S. J.
,
Lee D. K.
,
Kang J. S.
2009
Acute oral toxicity and identification of antimicrobial and antifungal effects of Bacillus mojavensis KJS-3 as novel strain isolated from food wastes
Mol Cell Toxicol
5
54 -
Kloepper J. W.
,
Zablotowicz R. M.
,
Tipping E. M.
,
Lifshitz R.
,
Keister D. L.
,
Cregow P. B.
1991
The Rhizosphere and Plant Growth
Kluwer Academic Publishers
Dordrecht
Plant growth promotion mediated by bacterial rhizosphere colonizers
315 -
326
Kotan R.
,
Sahin F.
,
Demirci E.
,
O¨zbek A.
,
Eken C.
,
Miller S.A.
1999
Evaluation of antagonistic bacteria for biological control of Fusarium dry rot of potato
Phytopathology
89
41 -
Lodewyckx C.
,
Vangronsveld J.
,
Porteous F.
,
Moore E. R. B.
,
Taghavi S.
,
Mezgeay M.
,
van der Lelie D.
2002
Endophytic bacteria and their potential applications
Crit Rev Plant Sci
21
583 -
606
DOI : 10.1080/0735-260291044377
Misaghi I. J.
,
Donndelinger C. R.
1990
Endophytic bacteria in symptom-free cotton plants
Phytopathology
80
808 -
811
DOI : 10.1094/Phyto-80-808
Mundt J. O.
,
Hinkle N. F.
1976
Bacteria within ovules and seeds
Appl Environ Microbiol
32
694 -
698
Nowak J.
,
Asiedu S. K.
,
Bensalim S.
,
Richards J.
,
Stewart A.
,
Smith C.
,
Stevens D.
,
Sturz A. V.
1998
From laboratory to applications: challenges and progress with in vitro dual cultures of potato and beneficial bacteria
Plant Cell Tissue Organ Culture
52
97 -
103
DOI : 10.1023/A:1005965822698
Orhan E.
,
Esitken A.
,
Ercisli S.
,
Turan M.
,
Sahin F.
2006
Effects of Plant Growth Promoting Rhizobacteria (PGPR) on yield, growth and nutrient contents in organically growing raspberry
Sci Hortic
111
38 -
43
DOI : 10.1016/j.scienta.2006.09.002
Reis V. M.
,
Olivares F. L.
,
Döbereiner J.
1994
Improved methodology for isolation of Acetobacter diazotrophicus and confirmation of its endophytic habitat
World J Microbiol Biotechnol
10
401 -
405
DOI : 10.1007/BF00144460
Roberts M. S.
,
Nakamura L. K.
,
Cohan F. M.
1994
Bacillus mojavensis sp. nov., distinguishable from Bacillus subtilis by sexual isolation, divergence in DNA sequence, and differences in fatty acid composition
Int J Syst Bacteriol
44
256 -
264
DOI : 10.1099/00207713-44-2-256
Sahin F.
,
Kotan R.
,
Demirci E.
,
Miller S. A.
2000
Domates ve biber bakteriyel leke hastaligiile biyolojik savasta actigard ve bazi antagonistlerin etkinligi
Ataturk Universitesi Ziraat Fakultesi Dergisi
31
11 -
16
Salantur A.
,
Ozturk A.
,
Akten S.
,
Sahin F.
,
Donmez F.
2005
Effect of inoculation with nonindigenous and indigenous rhizobacteria of Erzurum (Turkey) origin on growth and yield of spring barley
Plant Soil
275
147 -
156
DOI : 10.1007/s11104-005-8094-z
Samish Z.
,
Etinger-Tulczynska R.
,
Bick M.
1961
Microflora within healthy tomatoes
Appl Microbiol
9
20 -
25
Snook M. E.
,
Mitchell T.
,
Hinton D. M.
,
Bacon C. W.
2009
Isolation and characterization of Leu7-surfactin from the endophytic bacterium Bacillus mojavensis RRC 101, a biocontrol agent for Fusarium verticillioides
Agric Food Chem
57
4287 -
4292
DOI : 10.1021/jf900164h
Stajkovic O.
,
Delic D.
,
Josic D.
,
Kuzmanovic Ð.
,
Rasulic N.
,
Knezevic-Vukcevic J.
2011
Improvement of common bean growth by co-inoculation with Rhizobium and plant growth-promoting bacteria
Roman Biotechnol Lett
16
5919 -
5926
Sturz A. V.
,
Christie B. R.
,
Matheson B. G.
1998
Associations of bacterial endophyte populations from red clover and potato crops with potential for beneficial allelopathy
Can J Microbiol
44
162 -
167
DOI : 10.1139/w97-146
Vance C. P.
,
Dennis D. T.
,
Turpin D. H.
,
Lefebvre D. D.
,
Layzell D. B.
1997
Plant Metabolism
Longman Scientific
Essex, UK
The molecular biology of nitrogen metabolism
449 -
476