Twenty apple germplasm accessions from the Korean Genebank were successfully cryopreserved using two-step freezing to back up genetic resources maintained by field collections. This study examined the morphological and genetic stability of cryopreserved dormant apple buds that were stored in liquid nitrogen, and then rewarmed and regrown. Whole plants were regenerated directly from dormant buds through budding without an intermediary callus phase. The cryopreserved buds produced high levels of shoot formation (76.2-100%), similar to those of noncryopreserved buds (91.3-100%), with no observed differences between cryopreserved and noncryopreserved materials. Three of the twenty cryopreserved apple germplasm accessions were used to assess morphological and genetic stability. No differences in morphological characteristics including shoot length, leaf shape, leaf width/length ratio, and root length were observed between controls (fresh control and noncryopreserved) and cryopreserved plantlets. The genetic stability of regenerants (before and after cryopreservation) was investigated using inter simple sequence repeat (ISSR) markers. The ISSR markers produced 253 bands using four primers, ISSR 810, SSR 835, ISSR 864, and ISSR 899. These markers showed monomorphic banding patterns and revealed no polymorphism between the mother plant and regenerants before and after cryopreservation, suggesting that cryopreservation using two-step freezing does not affect the genetic stability of apple germplasm. These results show that two-step freezing cryopreservation is a practical method for long-term storage of apple germplasms.
Apple is a fruit tree found in orchards throughout the world. In general, the conservation of apple genetic resources involves field planting (field gene banks) for vegetative propagation of plants, but this approach typically requires large amounts of space and extensive maintenance. Tissue culture has distinct advantages, and it is used for short-term preservation (
Withers and Engelmann, 1997
), but it does not provide for long-term preservation. The occurrence of genetic variation in plant material produced from tissue culture has been described for many species such as horseradish, alfalfa, and pecan trees (
Rostiana , 1999
Vendrame , 1999
Piccioni , 1997
). Cryopreservation is an alternative approach for the long-term storage of plant germplasm and is the preferred option for the long-term preservation of clonally propagated germplasm. Under cryopreservation, plant materials are stored at ultra-low temperatures (-196℃) in liquid nitrogen (LN). At this temperature, cell division and metabolic activity are suspended, and the material remains unchanged for a long period, thereby conferring genetic stability to clonal germplasm, including materials produced from apple. Somaclonal variation in cryopreserved plant material has been assessed in potato, Scots pine, cassava, and sugarcane, and no genetic differences were found in regenerated plantlets following LN immersion (
Harding and Benson, 2000
Haggman , 1998
Gonzalez-Amao , 1999
). Studies of genetic alteration in apple have been limited (
Wu , 1999
), and no studies on simultaneous changes in phenotype and genotype have been published.
Cryopreservation of dormant vegetative apple buds was first described by
Sakai and Nishiyama (1978)
. Protocols based on endogenous production of cryoprotectants in dormant apple buds were refined by
Tyler and Stushnoff (1988)
with recovery by grafting. Subsequently, an effective protocol for cryopreservation of dormant winter apple buds was developed at the National Center for Genetic Resources Preservation (NCGRP) in Fort Collins, CO, USA, using material grown in the continental climate (
Forsline , 1998
Forsline , 1999
Towill and Ellis, 2008
Towill , 2004
). Previous studies have detailed the improvement of a standard ‘two-step freezing’ method to induce a higher rate of shoot formation from cryopreserved vegetative apple buds and to implement long-term conservation of apple germplasm in the Korean Genebank (
Yi , 2013
). In this study, we cryopreserved 20 accessions of apple genotypes using a two-step freezing method adapted for Korean genotypes. Subsequently, we observed morphological characteristics and examined genetic variation at the molecular level using inter-simple sequence repeat (ISSR) markers to assess the genetic stability of plantlets recovered from three cryopreserved apple germplasms.
Materials and Methods
- Plant materials
Stems containing the current season of growth from 20 apple cultivars were collected in early January 2013 when the buds were quiescent in a field at the National Institute of Horticultural and Herbal Science (NIHH), Daegu, Republic of Korea. The stems were collected after the temperature had been below approximately 0℃ for at least 72 h. The sampled scions were wrapped and stored at -5℃ for cold acclimation for 3 weeks.
- Cryopreservation procedures using two-step freezing
The stems were cut into 35 ㎜ long, single-node sections with the bud in the central position, and then spread on trays and kept unsealed in a freezer at -5℃ to dehydrate. When the stem sections reached the target moisture content of 35%, they were double wrapped in moisture-proof plastic to eliminate further desiccation and maintained at -5℃ until treatment with liquid nitrogen (LN). The sections were packaged in polyolefin tubes (
) and cooled to -35℃ at a rate of 1℃/h and maintained for 24 h using a programmable refrigerator (Dasol Scientific, Hwaseong, South Korea). The tubes were then moved quickly from the cooling unit and placed in liquid nitrogen vapor for at least 24 h (
). Warming was accomplished by transferring the tubes to a 4℃ room in containers with moist peat, where they were kept for 7 d.
Procedure of ‘two-step freezing’ for Malus domestica A: Single bud segments in polyolefin tubes desiccated to 35% water content. B: Second freezing of frozen single bud segments from -35℃ to -196℃ (liquid nitrogen). C: Shoot formation from a grafted bud obtained from a section that was cooled at 1℃/h to -35℃, held for 24 hrs, transferred to liquid nitrogen, and thawed at 4℃. a: fresh control (30 days after grafting), b: noncryopreserved (30 days after grafting), c: cryopreserved (55 days after grafting).
- Viability test
Stem viability was tested by grafting buds to seedling rootstock. Grafting was performed using a chip budding technique with 1 year old apple seedling rootstock. Rootstocks for grafting used in this study were standard seedlings (Dongbu Nursery, Kyungsan). The budded rootstocks were kept in a greenhouse and examined over a 2-month period for growth of the bud. We defined viability as the formation of a shoot from the grafted bud. For evaluating viability, each accession was repeated in three replicated experiments with 10 plants. The data are presented as mean ± standard error (Mean ± SE).
- Observation of morphological characteristics
Because the shoot tips surviving after cryopreservation exhibited a lag phase of 25 d after budding, we used control shoots 30 d after grafting and surviving cryopreserved shoots 55 d after grafting to observe morphological characteristics including shoot length, leaf shape, leaf width/length ratio, and root length. Morphological analysis was performed on 10 plants with three replicates of each treatment.
- DNA extraction and inter simple sequence repeat (ISSR)-PCR analysis
Total genomic DNA was isolated from young leaves using a Gentra Puregene Cell Kit for plants (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany). The isolated DNA quality and concentration were determined using a spectrometer (ND-1000, NanoDrop Technologies, Wilmington, DE, USA), and the DNA was diluted to a working concentration of 20 ng/μl. Of 99 ISSR primers from a UBC primer set (University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada), four primers revealed reproducible and clear amplicons, and these primers were used for further study. The sequences of these four primers were shown in
. PCR amplification was carried out in a 25 μl reaction volume containing 10 mM Tris HCl (pH 8.3), 50 mM KCl, 1.5 mM MgCl
, 0.1 mM dNTPs, 1.0 U
DNA polymerase (Inclone Biotech, Republic of Korea), 0.3 μM primer, and 20 ng genomic DNA. The amplification was performed in a PTC-200 thermocycler (MJ Research, MA, USA) with reaction conditions programmed for an initial predenaturation at 94℃ for 5 min followed by 45 cycles of denaturation at 94℃ for 1 min, annealing at 50℃ for 45 s, and extension at 72℃ for 2 min, with a final extension at 72℃ for 5 min. Amplification products were separated by electrophoresis in 1.5% agarose gel stained with non-toxic LoadingSTAR (Dynebio, Republic of Korea) and visualized with ultraviolet (UV) light.
Details of ISSR primers, locus, sequence, annealing temperature, and cycles used in analysis of apple germplasms
zTa: annealing temperature.
Results and Discussion
- Survival of cryopreserved dormant buds and shoot formation
In preliminary experiments to determine optimal conditions, the two-step freezing procedure proved to be effective for the cryopreservation of apple dormant buds. We previously developed a protocol adapted for Korean winter dormant apple buds, which promotes the preservation of valuable germplasms for successful apple breeding (
Yi , 2013
). In this study, 20 apple germplasm accessions were preserved using this protocol. As shown in
, the cryopreserved buds produced high levels of shoot formation (76.2-100%, mean 87.29%) similar those of the noncryopreserved buds (91.3-100%, mean 97.79%), with no differences observed between the cryopreserved and noncryopreserved materials. Most of the cryopreserved stems regrew and produced new leaves by 55 d after grafting, in contrast to the noncryopreserved stems, which required only 30 d. The lag phase in the cryopreserved stems may have been caused by damage from the ultra-low temperature of the LN during cryopreservation.
Comparison of shoot formation rates between noncryopreserved and cryopreserved stems using grafting
- Morphological stability
The shoots surviving after cryopreservation grew well and developed normal plantlets and roots (
). The morphological markers observed in this study included shoot length, leaf shape, leaf width/length ratio, and root length. Compared with the unfrozen controls (fresh control and noncryopreserved), no significant morphological differences were observed in the cryopreserved shoots (
Comparison of morphological characteristic of control shoots 30 days after grafting and of cryopreserved shoots 55 days after grafting
zW/V represents width/length of leaves, ten shoot or leaves with three replicate tests.yMean separation within columns by Duncan’s multiple range test at 5% level by R project (R version 3.0.1) for statistical computing.
The aim of conserving plant genetic resources is not only to store germplasm but also to limit the introduction of variation at the lowest level possible during the procedures being used. Thus, any conservation method should preserve the genetic stability of the plant material. In this study, both the unfrozen controls (fresh control and noncryopreserved) and the cryopreserved shoots exhibited the same regrowth patterns, indicating normal growth and development in the cryopreserved shoots.
- Assessment of genetic stability using ISSR markers
The genetic fidelity of the apple material after freezing in LN appeared to be maintained based on the lack of morphological differences in the materials. However, morphological evaluation is an indirect test method that can provide only a partial assessment of genetic stability. Molecular markers provide a more direct method by examining genetic variation at the DNA level. In this study, we used four selected ISSR primers to analyze genetic stability during the cryopreservation procedure based on the amplification of PCR fragments ranging in length from 200 to 2000 bp (
). A total of 253 DNA fragments were produced equally in the fresh control, noncryopreserved, and cryopreserved groups. Three cultivars exhibited distinct genotypes using the ISSR 835, 864, and 899 primers, whereas the band pattern acquired using the ISSR 810 primer did not differ by cultivar (
). No differences in bands were detected between control (fresh control and noncryopreserved) and cryopreserved shoots using the four ISSR primers, whereas two bands were detected specifically in the noncryopreserved group (
). Although cryopreservation of apple dormant buds does not appear to cause genetic variation, there is the possibility of point mutations outside of priming sites investigated that may go undetected. According to
, the variation detected in long cultured
germplasms was no longer observed after one year of growth in the field, it is believed that the variation was transient. In a similar research,
De Verno (1999)
reported that somaclonal variation after cryopreservation appeared during spruce embryogenic cultures, but the variations were no longer detected in the regrown trees.
ISSR profiles of fresh control, noncryopreserved, and cryopreserved plants with four primers (ISSR 810, ISSR 835, ISSR 864, and ISSR 899). Lanes 1, 4, and 7, fresh control; Lanes 2, 5, and 8, noncryopreserved; Lanes 3, 6, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, and 19, cryopreserved; M, DNA marker; *, detected specific bands.
The total number of amplified bands produced by four ISSR markers in three cultivars
The total number of amplified bands produced by four ISSR markers in three cultivars
For cryogenically derived material, most studies have identified no differences at the chromosome or DNA levels following cryopreservation.
tested plantlets regenerated from
shoot tips cryopreserved by vitrification and found no DNA alteration using random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers. In another study, adventitious buds of rice haploids were successfully cryopreserved, and subsequent analysis of surviving regenerated shoots using RAPD markers showed no genetic variation (
Zhang and Hu, 2000
). Moreover, studies on potato by
Harding and Benson (2000)
found no differences between cryopreserved materials and controls. Maintenance of the genetic stability of cryopreserved germplasm has been also reported in
Scocchi , 2004
Dixit , 2003
), and in grape and kiwi (
Zhai , 2003
). Similarly, in our study, plants regenerated from cryopreserved dormant buds using two-step freezing were 100% genetically similar, suggesting that no DNA polymorphisms induced by cryopreservation accumulated (
The goal of the conservation of plant genetic resources is not only to store germplasm but to also minimize genetic variation to the maximum extent possible during conservation. Maintenance of true-to-type clonal fidelity is an important factor to be monitored during conservation of vegetatively propagated species. In conclusion, we did not find genetic changes in the cryopreserved shoots as assessed using several morphological and molecular markers, thereby demonstrating that cryopreservation using two-step freezing of dormant buds is a practical method for the long-term storage of apple germplasm. To overcome the limitations of this study, a larger population is needed for further investigation of cryopreserved shoots.
This study was carried out with the support of ‘Research Program for Agricultural Science&Technology Development (Project No. PJ009369)’, National Academy of Agricultural Science, Rural Development Administration, Republic of Korea.
Developmental competence and ploidy stability in plants regenerated from cryopreserved potato shoot tips
Genetic stability of cryopreserved shoot tips Rubus germplasm
In vitro Cell. Dev. Biol.-Plant.
De Verno L.L.
Somaclonal variation in cryopreserved embryogenic clones of white spruce
Plant Cell Rep.
Genetic stability assessment of plants regenerated from cryopreserved embryogenic tissue of Dioscorea bulbifera L. using RAPD, biochemical and morphological analysis
Development of base and active collections of Malus germplasm with cryopreserved dormant buds
Recovery and longevity of cryopreserved apple buds
J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci.
de la Fe C.
Cryopreservation of encapsulated sugarcane apices: effects of storage temperature and storage duration
Cryopreservation of embryogenic cultures of Scots pine
Plant Cell Tiss. Organ Cult.
Analysis of nuclear and chloroplast DNA in plants regenerated from cryopreserved shoot-tips of potato
Molecular stability of the ribosomal RNA genes in Solanum tuberosum plants recovered from slow growth and cryopreservation
Genetic integrity of cryopreserved plant cells; A review
Estimating alfalfa somaclonal variation in axillary branching propagation and indirect somatic embryogenesis by rapid fingerprinting
Int. J. Plant Sci.
Efficiency of inter-simple sequence repeat PCR for detecting somaclonal variation among leaf-culture-regenerated plants of horseradish
Cryopreservation of winter vegetative buds of hardy fruit trees in liquid nitrogen
Plant recovery of cryopreserved apical meristem-tips of Melia azedarach L. using encapsulation-dehydration and assessment of their genetic stability
Cryopreservation of apple genetic resources
Can. J. Plant Sci.
Plant Cryopreservation―A Practical Guide
New York, USA
Cryopreservation of dormant buds
Cryopreservation of Malus germplasm using a winter vegetative bud method: results from 1915 accessions
Dehydration of dormant apple buds at different stages of cold acclimation to induce cryopreservability in different cultivars
Can. J. Plant Sci.
Freezing of water in dormant vegetative apple buds in relation to cryopreservation
AFLP analysis of variation in pecan somatic embryos
Plant Cell Rep.
Flow-cytometric assessments of ploidy stability in cryopreserved dihaploid Solanum tuberosum and wild Solanum species
Biotechnology in Agriculture
New York, USA
In vitro conservation of plant genetic resources
Cryopreservation of apple shoot tips: importance of cryopreservation technique and of conditioning of donor plants
Cryopreservation of dormant apple winter buds using ‘two-step freezing.’ Plant Breed
Genetic stability assessment of plantlets regenerated from cryopreserved in vitro cultured grape and kiwi shoot tips using RAPD
Cryopreservation of in vitro-grown shoot tips of Amorphophallus by vitrification
Acta Agronom. Sin.
Regenerating plants from cryopreserved adventitious buds of haploids and their genetic stability in rice
L. Wuhan Bot. Res.