Taxonomical Study of Chrysosplenium L. (Saxifragaceae) in Korea Based on Chemical Composition
Taxonomical Study of Chrysosplenium L. (Saxifragaceae) in Korea Based on Chemical Composition
Korean Journal of Plant Resources. 2013. Dec, 26(6): 718-725
Copyright © 2013, The Plant Resources Society of Korea
This is an Open-Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License ( which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
  • Received : November 20, 2013
  • Accepted : December 12, 2013
  • Published : December 31, 2013
Export by style
Cited by
About the Authors
Hyun-Jun, Kim
Hea-Seok, Jeong
Department of Natural Medicine Resources, Semyung University, Jecheon 390-711, Korea
Shin-Ho, Kang
Department of Natural Medicine Resources, Semyung University, Jecheon 390-711, Korea

Components extracted from 7 species and 18 populations of Chrysosplenium in Korea were compared and analyzed using GC-MS analysis. 57 components (≥80% quality) were identified, of which neophytadiene, palmitic acid and phytol were found at all the taxa. Percentage composition of isolated extracts showed a clear difference in components type and GC-MS profile. On the basis of that result, da ta matrix was made and cluster analysis using UPGMA was conducted. From the result of cluster analysis, two grou ps were recombined; one with alternate leaves comprised C. japonicum in Ser. Alternifolia and C. flagelliferum in Ser. Flagellifera and the other with opposite leaves gradationally comprised C. psuedofauriei in Ser. Sinica, C. ramosum in Ser. Oppositifolia and C. sphaerospermum, C. valdepilosum , C. flaviflorum in Ser. Pilosa . These chemotaxonomic results agreed in general with those of existing studies on external morphology and molecular. In conclusion, chemical compositio n can be an useful characters in understanding the relation analysis among interspecific and intraspecific complex with the he lp of cluster analysis of 7 species and 18 populations of Chrysosplenium in Korea.
About 57~65 species of Chrysosplenium L. in Saxifragaceae have been known to be distributed throughout the world ( Hara, 1957 ; Pan, 2001 ). This genus except for 2 species distributed in South America is restrictively distributed at the northern hemisphere; 2 species in Northeastern America, 4 species in Northwestern America, 2 species in Europe and most of the remaining taxa in eastern Asia (35 species in China, 18 species in Japan) ( Spongberg, 1972 ; Pan, 2001 ; Iwatsuki ., 2001 ). This genus was established as taxon by Linne (1753) for the frist time, classified as 2 subgenus ( Gamosplenium, Dialyspelium ), according to arrangement type of sepals by Maximowicz (1877) and divided as 2 sections ( Gamosplenium, Dialyspelium ), according to arrangement type of leaves by Franchet (1890) . On the other hand, Hara (1957) reclassified this genus 17 series, maintaining that the classification of Franchet wasn’t nature classification. As the studies on Chrysosplenium L. in Korea, Forbes and Hemsley (1887) reported for the first time, and then Palibin (1898) , Nakai (1909) , Chung (1937 , 1965) , Park (1949 , 1974) , Lee (1976) , Lee (1996a) , Lee (1996b) reported in the plant checklist and illustrated book of flora. Additionally, Chung and Kim (1988) recorded this genus as 7 species and 1 variety, and Kim (2007) as 5 species and 3 varieties C. flagelliferum F. Shmidt, C. alternifolium var. sibiricum Seringe ex DC., C. japonicum (Maxim.) Makino, C. ramosum Maxim., C. pseudofauriei H. Lév., C. flaviflorum Ohwi, C. pilosum var. fulvum (Terracc.) Hara, C. pilosum var. valdepilosum Ohwi. Recently, Han . (2011) raised C. pilosum var. fulvum and C. pilosum var. valdepilosum to the status of species, C. sphaerospermum and C. valdepilosum , on the basis of taxonomic treatments such as ITS sequences and seed characteristics of C. pilosum complex faced with the different taxonomic views.
As the studies on the chemical compounds of Chrysosplenium , 77 components comprising Eicoane, Palmitic Acid ethyl ester, Dibutyl phthate, (z,z,z)-9,12,15-Octadecatrienoic acid, ethyl ester, 2,6-Butylated hydroxytoluene and 5,6,7,7α-Tetrahydro 4,4,7α-trimethyl-2 (4H)-benzofuranone were identified and isolated in C. nudicaule ( Yang . , 2004 ), and 4 components chrysosplenol B, chrysosplenol D, chrysosplenoside B and chrysosplenoside D in C. alternifolium ( Gudej and Czapski, 2009 ). As chemotaxonomic studies, Bohm and Collins (1979) reported that the arrangement of leaves was divided into alternate and opposite according to the containing degree of O-methylated flavones and supported the opinion of Franchet (1890) that Chrysosplenium should be classied into 2 sections, Oppositifolia and Alternifolia . But, studies on the components composition of Chrysosplenium in Korea are difficult to find and chemotaxonomic studies aren’t carried out until now.
So, this study was conducted to determine the chemical components of Chrysosplenium in Korea and the interspecific chemical differences of it, and compare our findings with those of morphological and phylogenetic classification.
Materials and Methods
- Plant Samples
18 populations representing C. sphaerospermum, C. valdepilosum, C. flaviflorum, C. psuedofauriei, C. ramosum, C. japonicum and C. flagelliferum were sampled in Korea from April to May, 2011. Information of taxa and sources used in this experiment was as Table 1 . Voucher specimens were dried an kept at Herbarium of Semyung University (NMR).
Collected materials used in this study
PPT Slide
Lager Image
CB: Chungcheongbuk-do, GB: Gyeongsangbuk-do, GG: Gyeonggi-do, GW: Gangwon-do, JN: Jeollanam-do, JJ: Jeju-do
- Extraction and purification
The whole plants of collected samples were used as specimens for extraction after washing with distilled water, air-drying under shade for a week and then grinding. 200 mg of grinded specimens dissolved in 5 mL of 99.9% MeOH was extracted 3 times for 1 hour with the use of ultrasonic extraction. MeOH extracts from ultrasonic extraction were filtered with 0.45 μm nylon syringe filter and then used in GC-MS analysis.
- GC-MS analysis
GC-MS analysis for the compositions of extracts was performed using same GC/MSD (HP6890GC/5973MSD, USA), equipped with Ultra 2 (Agilent 19091B-102, 315Max). The injection volume was 2 μL. The carrier gas used was helium, at a constant flow rate of 0.4 mL/min. The oven temperature was initially held at 120 ℃ for 5 minutes, then raised to 300 ℃, 5 ℃/min. Components of the extracts were identified with the aid of the database (Wiley7N).
- Cluster analysis
The phenogram was prepared using 7 species comprising 18 populations in Chrysosplenium in Korea. Every analyzed components ( ≥ 80% quality) were treated as OTU (Operational Taxonomic Unit) and each OTU marked as value of “1”, when founded, or “0”, when not founded. After the above procedure, data matrix was prepared. The phenogram was prepared using average linkage cluster analysis according to average distance. UPGMA (unweighted pair group method with arithmetic average) of PAUP 4.02b (Swoffrd, 1998) was used for statistical analysis.
Results and Discussion
- Components composition
On the basis of results from this study of 7 species comprising 18 populations in Chrysosplenium in Korea using GC-MS analysis, 57 components ( ≥ 80% quality) were identified as Table 2 . Percentage composition of extracts identified from Chrysosplenium in Korea was listed in Table 3 .
The list of identified componunds
PPT Slide
Lager Image
The list of identified componunds
Percentage composition of extracts identified fromChrysospleniumin Korea
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Percentage composition of extracts identified from Chrysosplenium in Korea
There was some difference among 7 taxa in components composition; 21 Kinds of components in C. sphaerospermum , 15 in C. valdepilosum , 19 in C. flaviflorum , 22 in C. psuedofauriei , 14 in C. ramosum , 24 in C. japonicum , 21 in C. flagelliferum were identified. Number of components specie in each taxa was 6 (compound 8, 12, 15, 18, 21, 57) in C. sphaerospermum , 1 (compound 33) in C. valdepilosum , 6 (compound 5, 10, 19, 36, 41, 43) in C. flaviflorum , 5 (compound 1, 6, 22, 40, 47) in C. psuedofauriei , 1 (compound 30) in C. ramosum , 5 (compound 7, 11, 38, 48, 49) in C. japonicum and 3 (compound 4, 34, 42) in C. flagelliferum . Neophytadiene (0.93~11.08%), Palmitic acid (0.63~3.34%), Phytol (0.97~9.45%) were detected in all the taxa experimented. There was a definite difference in components types and GC-MS profile among the taxa.
In addition, it was showed that C. japonicum population from Mt. Palgong contained 20 kinds of components, the most, and C. sphaerospermum population from Isl. Naro 6 kinds, the least. In the meanwhile, it was judged that geographical variation of C. sphaerospermum. C. flaviflorum occurred to some extent in chemical components composition of them. The chemical composition of C. sphaerospermum populations from Isl. Jeju and Isl. Naro was generally similar to that from the inland areas, but, compound 2, 8, 12, 18, 21, 23, 45, 56 identified from the interior population weren’t identified in C. sphaerospermum populations from island areas and compound 3, 29, 53, 57 were specific in populations from Isl. Jeju and Isl. Naro. Collected populations of C. sphaerospermum were usually distributed at the margins of moist valleys. Light condition of their habitats was good because the flowering season, early spring, of them didn’t overlap with the actual growing period of other plants. Above chemical composition difference might be an indication of local differnetiation between inland populations and island populations rather than different environmental conditions of their habitats. In C. flaviflorum , compound 13, 14, 20, 25, 26, 39 were identified in populations from Mt. Myeongji, Mt. Cheongyang and Mt. Samdobong but compound 36, 37, 53 were specific in population from Mt. Samdobong. Populations from Mt. Myeongji and Mt. Cheongyang were usually distributed at an altitude of about 100~200 m and populations from Mt. Samdobong were restricted to highland over 1,000 m. Water condition was judged to be similar in that all the populations of C. flaviflorum were distributed at the margins of moist valleys. Light condition of their habitats was also similar because their flowering season, early spring, didn’t overlap with the actual growing period of other plants. So, it was estimated that these components differences might be caused by those of altitude of their habitats.
From this study, differences of components among taxa and populations were identified. These differences were assumed to be caused by those of geographical or inhabiting environments. So, it was suggested that additional studies on environmental characteristics, morphological variations and genetic diversity according to their natural habitats should be conducted.
- Cluster analysis
For conducting cluster analysis, data matrix was made on the basis of components composition of 7 species and 18 populations in Chrysosplenium cluster analysis was carried out using UPGMA of data matrix drawn and phenogram was accomplished ( Fig. 1 .).
PPT Slide
Lager Image
UPGMA tree of the genus Chrysosplenium.
Chrysosplenium in Korea comprises 5 series; Alternifolia , Flagellifera, Oppositifolia , Sinica, Pilosa . Ser. Alternifolia and Ser. Flagellifera have alternate leaves, and Ser. Oppositifolia , Ser. Sinica and Ser. Pilosa have opposite leaves ( Hara, 1957 ; Chung and Kim, 1988 ). From this study, Chrysosplenium in Korea was divided into two groups on the basis of component analysis using GC-MS. That was agreed to system of morphological classification and view of Bohm and Collins (1979) that the arrangements of leaves were divided into alternate and opposite according to the containing degree of O-methylated flavones.
C. japonicum in Ser. Alternifolia and C. flagelliferum in Ser. Flagellifera were recombined to Group 1. C. japonicum and C. flagelliferum with altermate leaves can be classified according to the presence and absence of rossetted leaves and the number of bracteal leaves ( Kim, 2007 ). The recent molecular phylogenetic study ( Han 2011 ) supported that C. japonicum and C. flagelliferum are allied species because of their close relationship.
Group 2 with opposite leaves was redivided into two subgroups. One subgroup comprised C. psuedofauriei in Ser. Sinica and C. ramosum in Ser. Oppositifolia . The number of common components in C. psuedofauriei, C. ramosum was 11 and similarity was found in chemical composition. But, compound 1, 6, 13, 22, 27, 28, 29, 40, 47, 54, 56 found in C. psuedofauriei weren’t found in C. ramosum and compound 30, 46, 51 found in C. ramosum weren’t found in C. psuedofauriei . These two taxa have a same important characteristic such as oppsite leaves, but have definite differences in features (spreading or erect) and colors of sepals, features of carpels (spreading or erect) and shapes of capsules. According to the recent boundary diagram using ITS analysis by Han (2011) , C. psuedofauriei was firstly branched from outgroup (bootstrap, 98%), and then C. ramosum formed close relationship with Ser. Pilosa (bootstrap, 95%). The study of Han . (2011) showed somewhat different results from this study. So, it was estimated that additional close studies should be needed to determine the accurate systematic relationships. The other subgroup gradationally comprised C. flaviflorum, C. valdepilosum, C. sphaerospermum in Ser. Pilosa . Type of leaf, flower, fruit, seed and frequency of hair were key characters in the morphological taxonomy in Ser. Pilosa ( Hara, 1957 ; Chung and Kim, 1988 ). According to features of seed surface ridges, C. flaviflorum didn’t have ridges, C. valdepilosum had them slightly and C. sphaerospermum had them definitely ( Han ., 2010 ). According to the colors of bracteal leaves, C. valdepilosum was bright yellow, C. sphaerospermum was greenish or greenish yellow ( Kim, 2007 ). Han . (2010) reported that C. flaviflorum was definitely identified from other taxa in that it had subhypogaeus stolon. According to the phylogenetic study using nrDNA of ITS sequence ( Han , 2011 ), taxa of Ser. Pilosa formed close relationships. According to the results of this study, Ser. Pilosa was divided into 3 taxa; compound 3, 13, 14, 20, 26 were found commonly, but compound 5, 10, 19, 36, 41, 43 were restricted to C. flaviflorum , compound 33 was restricted to C. valdepilosum and compound 8, 12, 15, 18, 21, 57 were restricted to C. sphaerospermum . So, these findings could be an evidence to support those of existing morphological and molecular studies.
The results of this study were generally agreed to taxonomy according to morphological characteristics and systematics using nrDNA of ITS sequence. In conclusion, chemical composition using GC-MS analysis of 7 species and 18 populations of Chrysosplenium in Korea can be useful characters in understanding the relationship among interspecific and intraspecific complex. More comprehensive taxonomic studies introducing various chemotypes should be conducted and, consequently, these studies can make it possible to identify Chrysosplenium more accurately.
This paper was supported by the Semyung University Research Grant of 2012.
Bohm B.A , Collins. F.W 1979 Flavonoid of some species of Chrysosplenium Biochem. Syst. Ecol. 7 195 - 201    DOI : 10.1016/0305-1978(79)90050-4
Chung T.H. 1965 Illustrated Encyclopedia of Fauna & Flora of Korea. Tracheophyta. Genus Chrysosplenium Ministry of Education Seoul, Korea 497 - 483
Chung T.H. , To B.S , Lee D.B , Lee. H.J 1937 Nomina Plantarum Koreanum Chosen Nat. Hist. Inst. Seoul, Korea Genus Chrysosplenium 80 - 81
Chung Y.H , Kim Y.D 1988 Monographic Study of Endemic Plants in Korea X. Taxonomy and Interspecific Relationship of the Genus Chrysosplenium Korean J. Environ. Biol. 6 (2) 33 - 63
Cudej J , Czapski. P 2009 Components of the petroleum ether and chloroform extracts of Chrysosplenium alternifolium Chem. Nat. Comp. 45 (5) 717 - 719    DOI : 10.1007/s10600-009-9422-y
Forbes F.B , Hemsley W.B 1887 An enumeration of all the plants known from China proper, Formosa, Heinan, Corea, the Luchu Archipelago and Island of Hong Kong J. Linn. Sco. Bot. 23 271 -
Franchet A.R. 1890 Monographie du genere Chrysosplenium Tournfort Nouv. Arch. Mus. Hist. Nat. Paris III 2 87 - 114
Han J.W. , Yang S.G , Kim H.J , Jang C.G , Kang S.H 2010 Morphological chaeacteristics and distribution of Korean endemic Chrysosplenium flaviflorum Ohwi Korean J. Plant Res. 23 (5) 480 - 485
Han Jong-Won , Yang Sun-Gyu , Kim Hyun-Jun , Jang Chang-Gee , Park Jeong-Mi , Kang Shin-Ho 2011 Phylogenetic study of Korean Chrysosplenium based on nrDNA ITS sequences Korean J. Plant Res. 24 (4) 358 - 369    DOI : 10.7732/kjpr.2011.24.4.358
Hara H. 1957 Synopsis of Genus Chrysosplenium L Jour. Fac. Sci. Univ. Tokyo, Bot. 7 1 - 90
Iwatsuki K. , Boufford D , Ohba H 2001 Flora of Japan, Vol. IIb Kodansha LTD. Tokyo, Japan Chrysosplenium L 58 - 70
Kim Y.D. 2007 The Genera of Vascular Plants of Korea Academy Publishing Co. Seoul, Korea Saxifragaceae
Lee T.B. 1976 Vascular plants and their uses in Korea Bull. Kwanak Arb. 1 1 - 137
Lee W.T. 1996 Standard Illustration of Korean Plants Academy Press Seoul, Korea
Lee Y.N. 1996 Flora of Korea Kyohak Publishing Co Seoul, Korea
Linneus C. 1753 Species Plantarum 398 -
Maximowicz C.J. 1877 Diagnosis Plantarum Novarum Asiaticarum Scripsit Bull. Acad. Sci. St. Petersb. 23 340 - 350
Nakai T. 1909 Flora Koreana J. Coll. Sci. Univ. Tokyo, Japan. 26 220 -
Palibin J. 1898 Conspectus florae Koreae. Pars Prima. Acta. Horti. Petropol. 90 -
Pan J. , Wu Z.Y. , Raven P.H. 2001 Flora of China, 8 Science Press;Missouri Botanical Garden Press Beijing;St. Louis 346 - 358
Park M.K. 1949 An enumeration of Korean plants Ministry of Education Seoul, Korea Genus Chrysosplenium 83 - 85
Park M.K. 1974 Keys to the Herbaceous plants in Korea (Dicotyledoneae) Chungeumsa Seoul, Korea Genus Chrysosplenium 208 - 210
Sponberg G.L. 1972 The genera of Saxifragaceae in the South- eastern United States Jour. Arnold Arb. 53 409 - 494
Yang Y.S. , Shi G.F , LU. R.H 2004 Study on the volatile constituents of Tibetan medicine Chrysosplenium nudicaule Chin. NPRD 16 38 - 40