Methods for sampling and analysis of marine microalgae in ship ballast tanks: a case study from Tampa Bay, Florida, USA
Methods for sampling and analysis of marine microalgae in ship ballast tanks: a case study from Tampa Bay, Florida, USA
ALGAE. 2011. Jun, 26(2): 181-192
Copyright ©2011, The Korean Society of Phycology
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of theCreative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License( permits unrestrictednon-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium,provided the original work is properly cited.
  • Received : February 02, 2011
  • Accepted : April 04, 2011
  • Published : June 30, 2011
Export by style
Cited by
About the Authors
Matthew J. Garrett
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, Fish and Wildlife Research Institute, 100 8th Avenue SE, St. Petersburg, FL 33701, USA
Jennifer L. Wolny
Florida Institute of Oceanography, University of South Florida, 830 1st Street S, St. Petersburg, FL 33701, USA
B. James Williams
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, Fish and Wildlife Research Institute, 100 8th Avenue SE, St. Petersburg, FL 33701, USA
Michael D. Dirks
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, Fish and Wildlife Research Institute, 100 8th Avenue SE, St. Petersburg, FL 33701, USA
Julie A. Brame
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, Fish and Wildlife Research Institute, 100 8th Avenue SE, St. Petersburg, FL 33701, USA
R. William Richardso
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, Fish and Wildlife Research Institute, 100 8th Avenue SE, St. Petersburg, FL 33701, USA
Ballasting and deballasting of shipping vessels in foreign ports have been reported worldwide as a vector of introduction of non-native aquatic plants and animals. Recently, attention has turned to ballast water as a factor in the global increase of harmful algal blooms (HABs). Many species of microalgae, including harmful dinoflagellate species, can remain viable for months in dormant benthic stages (cysts) in ballast sediments. Over a period of four years, we surveyed ballast water and sediment of ships docked in two ports of Tampa Bay, Florida, USA. Sampling conditions encountered while sampling ballast water and sediments were vastly different between vessels. Since no single sample collection protocol could be applied, existing methods for sampling ballast were modified and new methods created to reduce time and labor necessary for the collection of high-quality, qualitative samples. Five methods were refined or developed,including one that allowed for a directed intake of water and sediments. From 63 samples, 1,633 dinoflagellate cysts and cyst-like cells were recovered. A native, cyst-forming, harmful dinoflagellate, Alexandrium balechii (Steidinger) F. J. R.Taylor, was collected, isolated, and cultured from the same vessel six months apart, indicating that ships exchanging ballast water in Tampa Bay have the potential to transport HAB species to other ports with similar ecologies, exposing them to non-native, potentially toxic blooms.
In the past 20-30 years, ballast water has been linked to introductions of non-native plant and animal species to areas throughout the United States (Carlton et al. 1995,Ruiz et al. 1997). Extensive work has been conducted to document ballast-water exchanges and their effects in major shipping hubs, including the Great Lakes (Mills et al. 1993), San Francisco Bay (Cohen and Carlton 1998), the estuarine reaches of the Hudson River (Strayer 2006), and the Chesapeake Bay (Duggan et al. 2006). In 1997, the International Maritime Organization adopted a measure that included voluntary open-ocean exchange of ballast water to reduce introductions of non-native species (International Maritime Organization 1997). Despite this plan, thousands of phytoplankton species may be in transit in ballast tanks of tens of thousands ships worldwide at any given time (McCarthy and Crowder 2000).
Only in recent years has ballast water been identified as a vector for non-native harmful introductions of microalgae for numerous high traffic, international ports including Tacoma and Angeles, Washington (Kelly 1993), the Laurentian Great Lakes and the Upper St. Lawrence River (Subba Rao et al. 1994); Oakland, California (Zhang and Dickman 1999); Willapa Bay/South Puget Sound, Washington (Christy 2003), multiple ports in Australia (Hallegraeff and Bolch 1992) and New Zealand (Dodgshun and Handley 1997) and the ports of Busan and Incheon in Korea (Yoo et al. 2006). There are well documented cases of introductions of harmful algal bloom species (HABs) via ballast water from Australia, where increased incidences of ‘red tides’ caused by Gymnodinium catenatum Graham and Alexandrium catenella (Whedon & Kofoid) Balech were correlated with ship traffic from Japan (Hallegraeff and Bolch 1992, Hallegraeff 1998).
In the United States, Florida is second only to Hawaii in the number of established non-native species, and it has more species of harmful algae than any other state (Steidinger et al. 2000). Sixty-five non-native plant and animal species have successfully been inoculated or become established in Florida’s Tampa Bay ecosystem (Baker et al. 2004). Ballast water and ship fouling are considered possible routes of introduction for several of these invasive species. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) estimates that the total volume of ballast water released into the Port of Tampa in 1996 was 2.1 million metric tons, the equivalent of approximately 3.91 L min -1 (United States Environmental Protection Agency Gulf of Mexico Program 2004). Microalgae present a particular concern because they can survive in ballast water for weeks. Many species, including harmful and toxin producing dinoflagellates, produce resting stages called cysts that can remain viable for long periods and be discharged from ballast-tank waters and sediments while a ship is in port (Hallegraeff and Bolch 1992). To date, the only non-native microalga reported for Tampa Bay is the diatom Odontella sinensis (Greville) Grunow (Baker et al. 2004). However, ballast water and sediments in vessels arriving from ports in South America and the Caribbean pose the greatest threat for introductions of non-native HAB species into Tampa Bay because of climatic similarities and geographic proximity.
Tampa Bay, a shallow, vertically mixed estuary, has an average depth of approximately 4 m and is the largest open-water estuary in Florida (Bendis 1999). The upper reaches of the estuary often act as a nutrient or particulate sink, providing conditions that can support massive algal blooms. The Port of Tampa and Port Manatee were selected as sites for this study for that reason and because of their high volume of ship traffic coming from the Ca
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Map of Tampa Bay Florida USA showing the Port of Tampa and Port Manatee.
ribbean. Over four years we surveyed and grew non-native marine microalgae, with emphasis on HAB species, collected from waters and sediments of ships’ ballast tanks and from waters and sediments of these two commercial shipping ports in Tampa Bay. Qualitative sampling strategies and methods for collecting samples from ballast tanks were developed or refined with the expectation that invasive marine microalgae species would be few and present predominantly as cysts associated with sediments and materials deposited at the bottom of the tanks.
- Field sampling
Ship selection and sampling strategy. An informal interagency cooperative agreement between the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) Ballast Water Research Program and the U. S. Coast Guard (USCG) Marine Safety Office / Tampa Prevention Department/ Port State Control Branch was established to provide access to commercial ships at Port of Tampa (lat. 27°55′ N, long. 82°26′ W) and Port Manatee (lat. 27°38′ N, long. 82°33′ W), USA ( Fig. 1 ). Access to ships was granted only when FWC staff accompanied USCG personnel on annual safety inspections of foreign vessels. A ship’s most recently submitted USCG ballast water reporting form and a list of its 5-10 most recent ports of call were used to guide tank selection for water and sediment sampling. Ships with ballast originating at locations in subtropical climates similar to that of Tampa Bay and known to harbor HAB species were given sampling priority. Likewise, ballast water with a salinity of 25-35‰, the average salinity range for Tampa Bay (Bendis 1999), was also given sampling priority. Collection efforts focused on sampling tank bottoms and areas in which material was likely to collect and on sampling as many tanks as possible on each vessel.
Sounding pipe sampling. Sampling via sounding pipes was adapted from methods used by Dodgshun and Handley (1997). Soundings were made using an aluminum measuring tape and Kolor Kut ® Water-Finding Paste (Kolor Kut Products Co. Ltd., Houston, TX, USA). Water depth and tank depth were used to calculate the distance from the ship’s deck to the surface of the ballast water. One of two pumps was used, depending on distance to the ballast and their respected lift capabilities. For distances less than 8 m, a Flotec FP5112 impeller pump (Flotec, Delavan, WI, USA) was used ( Fig. 2A ). For distances greater than 8 m, a Waterra Hydrolift II inertia pump (Waterra USA Inc., Bellingham, WA, USA) was used ( Fig. 2B ). When access to an electrical outlet was unavailable, a portable gas generator was used to supply power.
With each pump, 1.5-cm diameter tubing, equipped with a foot valve covered with aluminum screening to prevent large particles from entering the pump, was lowered to the bottom of the tank and primed by manually raising and lowering the tubing repeatedly. Water was pumped through a 20-㎛-mesh screen sieve into 19-L buckets until a layer of material was visible on the screen. Sediment slurry retained on the screen was washed into 250-mL jars and placed in the dark. One liter of unsieved, unpreserved water was collected from each tank for species composition analysis. All sieved ballast waters were returned to their original tank.
Hatch sampling. New procedures were developed for sampling ballast waters through ballast hatches because the opportunity to open the hatches arose midway through the project. Water depth and tank depth were used to calculate the distance from the tank opening to the water surface. Sampling equipment was of one of three designs, selected as a function based on distance to the water and pump capabilities. 1) For distances less than 8 m, the Flotec FP5112 impeller pump was used. The tubing was fed through an extendable (243-270 cm) aluminum pole and secured at the intake end of the pole which was inserted into the tank and connected to the pump at the other end. The pipe was used to direct the intake of the tubing to various areas of the tank bottom ( Fig. 2C ). 2) If a tank was deeper than the length of the fully extended aluminum pipe and water depth was at least 1.5 m deep, a 1/12-hp, 120 V AC submersible pump (model 3E-12N; Little Giant Pump Co., Oklahoma City, OK, USA) was used. The pump was moved along the bottom of the tank by raising the pump, swinging it, and lowering it in small increments using a rope ( Fig. 2D ). 3) If the water at the bottom of the tank was visibly shallow (less than 1.5 m), a 12 V DC submersible pump (model WSP-12V-2; Waterra USA Inc.) was used and continually repositioned on the tank bottom ( Fig. 2E ). This pump, powered by a 12 V rechargeable battery, was also used when a gas-powered generator was prohibited.
In all hatch sampling situations using pumps, regardless of the type of pump used, water was directed into a 30-cm diameter 20-㎛-mesh plankton net (Sea Gear Corp., Melbourne, FL, USA) suspended over the open hatch such that sieved water drained back into the tank ( Fig. 2C , D & E). Water was directed into the net until a layer of material was visible within the net. Sediment slurry retained in the plankton net was washed into 250-mL jars and placed in the dark.
When the distance from the deck surface to the water surface was greater than 8 m, none of the established pump methods had the required lift potential to collect water, and therefore a pump-free approach was required. A bucket fixed with a 1.5-kg weight was repeatedly lowered to the bottom of the tank so as to disturb as much sediment as possible, then the bucket was retrieved and its contents removed. When very little or no water was visible, and personnel safety was not an issue, staff entered the tank and sediment was manually collected with a scoop or cooking baster and placed into 250-mL jars.
One liter of unsieved, unpreserved water was collected from each tank for species composition analysis. When a plankton net could not be used due to tank structure, water was sieved into a series of 19-L buckets as described for sounding pipe sampling. If water could not be sieved aboard the vessel due to time constraints, deck operations,etc., it was pumped directly into 20-L carboys and transported to the laboratory, where it was sieved and discarded after being sterilized with chlorine bleach.
Port sampling. To ensure that no presumed non-native marine microalgae species had been introduced into Tampa Bay, we monitored phytoplankton populations at nine stations at Port of Tampa and five stations at Port Manatee semi-annually ( Fig. 1 ). Surface water was sampled using a bucket; bottom water was sampled using an 8.2-L Van Dorn bottle (Wildlife Supply Co., Yulee, FL, USA). Sediment was sampled using a Petite Ponar ™ grab (Wildlife Supply Co.). In addition to the port surveys, water and sediment samples were taken opportunistically
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Schematic drawings of ballast sampling methods. (A) Impeller. (B) Inertia. (C) Directed intake. (D) AC submersible. (E) DC submersible.
next to moored ships that were also being boarded for ballast water sampling. Water samples were collected at these times with the 20-㎛-mesh plankton net.
- Laboratory studies
Species composition and analysis. Unsieved, unpreserved whole-water, and unacidified Lugol’s-preserved plankton net and sieve samples collected from the ballast tanks or during port surveys were examined using a Zeiss Axiovert 25 inverted light microscope (Carl Zeiss Inc., Thornwood, NY, USA) and Lab-Tek TM glass-bottom chambers (model 155380; Nalgene Nunc International, Rochester, NY, USA). Organisms were identified to the lowest taxon possible after Schiller (1937), Steidinger and Williams (1970) and Tomas (1997).
Cyst concentration and isolation. Upon returning to the laboratory, all samples were sealed, wrapped in aluminum foil, and kept in the dark at approximately 22°C until processed. Cysts were concentrated using a modification of the density-gradient method described by Bolch (1997). Approximately 60 cm 3 of the floc layer of the sediment slurry was sonicated with a membrane dismembrator (model 100; Fisher Scientific, Pittsburgh, PA, USA) for 7 min at 10 W. Sonicated samples were sequentially filtered through 250-㎛ and 90-㎛ mesh sieves and collected on a 20-㎛-mesh sieve. The 20-㎛-fraction was rinsed into a 150-mL beaker with sterile-filtered seawater adjusted to the approximate salinity of the water at the sample site. An aqueous solution of Trizma-buffered sodium polytungstate (SPT) was prepared with a density of 1.37-1.39 g mL -1 . Ten mL of the 20-㎛-fraction sample was layered over 4 mL of SPT in a 15-mL centrifuge tube and spun at 2,126 ×g for 10 min in an Eppendorf 5810 centrifuge (Eppendorf International, Hauppauge, NY, USA). The material lying between the SPT and water was removed from the centrifuge tube with a disposable pipette, placed in a 15-mL centrifuge tube, and centrifuged at 1,329 ×g for 3 min to pellet the cysts. The top nine ml of material was discarded. Waste SPT solution was frequently examined by light microscopy at ×100 to confirm that no cysts or cyst-like cells were lost from the sample. The pellet was resuspended in the remaining one mL. Purified cyst samples were placed in a six-well tissue-culture plate and viable cysts and cyst-like cells were isolated following the micropipette technique described by Andersen and Kawachi (2005) using sterile-filtered seawater at a salinity of 25‰. Single viable cysts and cyst-like cells were placed in individual wells of 96-well tissue-culture plates containing approximately 150 μL of port water sterile-filtered using a 0.2-㎛-pore filter and at a salinity of 25‰.
The Bolch (1997) method was further modified to efficiently process volumes of sediment greater than 1,000 cm 3 . Sediment slurry samples (50 cm 3 ) were placed in a 1,000-mL beaker with sterile-filtered seawater added, then agitated on an Innova 2000 shaker table (Eppendorf International) for 15 min at 140 rpm. The sample was allowed to settle for at least eight hours to create a floc layer. The floc layer was removed from the top of the sediment sample, placed into a 250-mL beaker, and was purified and concentrated as described above.
The efficiency of the cyst concentration method using the shaker table versus not using the shaker table was tested using port sediments. Cysts were enumerated from ten 100-g samples processed by each method. Enumeration data was analyzed with a two-sample t-test on the means of each method using the R software package (R Development Core Team 2010).
Cyst incubation. The 96-well tissue-culture plates containing individual cysts and cyst-like cells were fitted with lids, and the parts taped together on all sides; each plate was placed in a clear, sealable plastic bag and incubated at 40 μE m -2 s -1 using full-spectrum fluorescent lights. Cysts were incubated under a 12 : 12 light : dark cycle in a temperature-controlled room at 22-24°C or in a growth chamber at 24°C. The conditions used for excystment studies were consistent with the salinity and temperature conditions routinely found in Tampa Bay (Bendis 1999). Plates were examined for excystment twice weekly during the first two weeks, weekly during the third and fourth weeks, and occasionally during the following two to six months using an Olympus CK30 inverted light microscope (Olympus Corp., Center Valley, PA, USA) at ×40-100 magnification.
Photomicrography and identification. Each cyst and cyst-like cell was photographed at ×640 magnification using a Zeiss Axiovert 25 inverted light microscope equipped with an Olympus Microfire digital camera. When images of greater resolution were desired, photographs were taken at ×640 and ×960 magnification using an Olympus IX71 inverted light microscope equipped with a water-immersible condenser and an Olympus DP70 digital camera. Cysts photographed using the Olympus IX71 microscope were individually transferred by micropipette into coverslip-bottom petri dishes (model P35G-0-10-C; Mat-Tek Corp., Ashland, MA, USA). Following excystment, single motile vegetative cells were left undisturbed to grow and divide. After multiple cellular divisions, several cells were removed for examination and identification using the Olympus IX71 microscope. Fluorescent microscopy using Calcofluor White M2R following the methods of Fritz and Triemer (1985) was used to determine the shape and arrangement of armored dinoflagellate thecal plates. When a culture had grown to a sufficient density, cells were fixed for examination with a Cambridge Stereoscan 240 scanning electron microscope (Carl Zeiss Inc.), following the methods of Truby (1997). Using microscopic observations and micrographs (see examples in Fig. 3 ) vegetative cells and cysts were identified to the lowest possible taxonomic group after Lewis (1991); Marret and Zonneveld (2003); Matsuoka and Fukuyo(2000, 2003); Montresor et al. (1997, 2003); Schiller (1937); Steidinger and Williams (1970); Tomas (1997); and Barrie Dale, University of Oslo (personal communication).Landsberg (2002) was used to determine if species had been noted as producing toxins or other harmful effects. Head (1996) was used to verify geologic cyst-based names.
- Field
A total of 82 vessels visiting the Port of Tampa (58 vessels)and Port Manatee (24 vessels) were boarded from 2003 to 2006. Sixty-three samples were collected from various types of ships, including 60 bulk carriers, 2 liquid (petroleum) bulk carriers, and 1 container-cargo vessel. Two different ships were sampled repeatedly on separate dates, and one ballast tank was sampled repeatedly from the same vessel on different dates. Sampling methods ( Table 1 , Fig. 2 ) were dependent upon accessibility to ballast tanks, ballast water depth, and distance to water. Each method described was applied when acceptable, although some were applied more often than others. Although volume of water sieved from ballast tanks varied between methods and ships, the selected method was performed until material was visible on the collection device.For the purposes of this study, cyst yield is defined as the ratio of the total number of cysts and cyst-like cells recovered to the total number of times each method was implemented. Cyst yields were greater when sampling through open hatches than when sampling through sounding pipes. The directed-intake method produced the greatest cyst yield, 80.0 ( Table 2 ).
Analysis of surface and bottom water samples collected during port sampling did not note any vegetative non-native microalgae cells that had not already been
Methodologies for sampling through a sounding pipe or hatch with associated criteria and equipmentSeeFig. 2for equipment set-up.N/A, not applicable
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Methodologies for sampling through a sounding pipe or hatch with associated criteria and equipment See Fig. 2 for equipment set-up.N/A, not applicable
identified in local waters prior to the study. Of the cysts collected from the benthos during the port sampling and allowed to excyst in the lab, none were of a species that had not already been documented in local waters prior to this study.
- Laboratory
Microscopic examination of ballast-tank water samples revealed that 36% of ships and 42% of ballast tanks sampled contained live microalgae. Species composition analysis of 63 ballast-tank water samples recorded a total of 73 species of marine microalgae, dominated by dinoflagellates and diatoms ( Table 3 ). Diatom species were consistently found in more tanks than were dinoflagellate species; the two most common diatoms were Melosira moniliformis (O. F. Mueller) C. Agardh and species of Coscinodiscus (Ehrenberg) Hasle & Sims.
In the cyst collection and concentration procedure for ballast sediment samples, most of the material in the resulting cyst pellet was overwhelmingly dominated by small, unidentifiable debris, and the remainder consisted of cysts, cyst-like cells, and pollen grains. Microscopic analysis of the waste material, including the 20-㎛ filtrate, SPT, and pellet, after primary centrifugation revealed little to no loss of cysts or cyst-like cells. From 63 ballast samples a total of 1,633 cysts and cyst-like cells were recovered, of which 187 were viable cysts that excysted under laboratory conditions set up to replicate environmental condition found in Tampa Bay. Cysts and cyst-like cells were found in 46% of the ballast water samples,representing 39% of the ships sampled. The number of cysts and cyst-like cells recovered per sample ranged from 0 to 418.
Cyst recovery by methodology including number of times implemented number of cysts and cyst-like cells recovered and average cyst yield
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Cyst recovery by methodology including number of times implemented number of cysts and cyst-like cells recovered and average cyst yield
Marine microalgae taxa identified from unsieved unpreserved samples of ballast-tank water
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Marine microalgae taxa identified from unsieved unpreserved samples of ballast-tank water
Excystment success rate, i.e., the ratio of the number of cysts that excysted to the number of cysts and cyst-like cells that were isolated, varied widely with sample, ranging from 0 to 50%, with an average rate of 21%. Although cysts were typically concentrated and isolated within a few days of sampling, cysts were also successfully recovered from samples after three to six months in storage. Only three dinoflagellate species, Alexandrium balechii (Steidinger) F. J. R. Taylor, Calciodinellum levantinum Meier, Janofske & Willems, and a peridinoid dinoflagellate morphologically and genetically similar to those described by Rhodes et al. (2010) and Nézan and Chomérat (2011) (Wolny and Puchulutegui unpublished data), were successfully established as laboratory cultures from single cysts collected from ballast water sediments. Eleven species of cysts isolated from ballast sediment samples were identified to the species level, including five po-
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Examples of light micrographs used to identify cysts and vegetative cells for this study. (A) Alexandrium balechii cyst. (B) Hypotheca of A. balechii showing the diagnostic sulcal plates. (C) Cyst cluster of a peridinoid dinoflagellate. (D) Vegetative cell of the peridinoid dinoflagellate with characteristic apical pore complex. Scale bar represent: 40 ㎛.
tentially harmful species, using established taxonomic methods that relied both on the morphology of the cyst and on the morphology of vegetative cells following excystment( Table 4 , Fig. 3 ).
The two versions of the cyst isolation method (shaker table vs. no shaker table) were compared using 100 g of ten samples processed by each method. The total number of cysts was enumerated for each sample, and data were analyzed with a two-sample t-test using the R software package (R Development Core Team 2010). The numbers of cysts recovered in the two methods were not statistically different (t = -1.3691, df = 18, p = 0.19, α= 0.05).
Transport of organisms in ballast tanks has been well documented, for example the introduction of zebra mussels to the Great Lakes (Griffiths et al. 1991) and increases of red tides in Australian waters (Hallegraeff 1993). Both Grosholz (2005) and Ruiz et al. (1997) note that introductions of non-native species into coastal systems can have major ecological effects and that they are increasing both at temporal and spatial scales. Hallegraeff (1998) cautions that the introductions of toxin-producing HABs could have deleterious effects on human health. Despite Florida being second only to Hawaii in the total number of invasive species and being home to more than 60 HAB species (Steidinger et al. 2000), studies have not been done to monitor ballast waters of ships moving in and out of local ports. This study represents the first of its kind for Florida waters.
This study focused on collecting high-quality samples of water and sediment from ballast tanks. Sampling methods were tested and modified with the objective of adapting a sampling protocol to dynamic, challenging sampling conditions, and to obtain qualitative samples. We had limited opportunities to board ships docked in Tampa Bay. Numerous types of sampling environments were encountered, and time was often a limiting factor when attempting to collect ballast samples. Tank structures were rarely similar, even between ships of a comparable size or type, and transport of sampling equipment onto a vessel was time consuming and labor intensive. Thus, methods requiring limited amounts of adaptable equipment were preferable.
Rigby and Hallegraeff (1993) found that many organisms transported in ballast tanks were associated with bottom waters and sediments. Bottom sampling through sounding pipes, as recommended by Dodgshun and Handley (1997), collects water only in and around the pipe opening and therefore from a limited area of the ballast tank. We learned early in our study that planktonic organisms were in low concentrations in the tanks’ water column, existed predominantly as cysts associated with sediments on tank bottoms, and thus were insufficiently sampled through sounding pipes. Thus we modified our protocols for sampling sounding pipes to sampling an expanded area of ballast tank bottoms by sampling through hatches when available. Although each method was adaptable to reach the bottom of the tanks, the directed-intake method seemed to be the most efficient with respect to sampling time and sample quality, or cell yield. The major advantage of the directed-intake method was the use of an extendible aluminum pole, which allowed the sampler to manipulate and direct intake tubing to areas around the inside of the tank where material was more likely to collect (tank bottom, cross beams, etc.) and to areas where concentrations of material could be seen. The directed-intake method allowed a more comprehensive exploration and collection of tank-bottom materials and permitted sampling from areas of the tank that pumps and intakes used in other methods could not reach.
During this study, the direct-intake method was not used as often as other methods. The method was not fully refined and implemented until midway through the project. A drawback of the directed-intake method was the lack of lift potential of the pump compared with those produced by pumps in the other methods. Due to the shallow nature of the bay, vessels visiting Tampa Bay ports often partially deballast before entering the bay. Because of this, the distance from the deck to the
Dinoflagellate species identified from excystment studies done on ballast water sedimentsCells were identified using light and scanning electron microscopy.aDenotes species that can be harmful.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Dinoflagellate species identified from excystment studies done on ballast water sediments Cells were identified using light and scanning electron microscopy. aDenotes species that can be harmful.
water in the tanks we studied was often greater than the lift capabilities of the pump used in the directed-intake method. While the inertia pump provided greater lift capabilities,it needed the structure of the sounding pipe to work effectively. Despite this limitation, the direct-intake method consistently produced a greater cyst yield than other methods ( Table 2 ) and thus became the preferred sampling method when conditions allowed. Sieving water through a suspended 20-㎛-mesh net, as was done in the direct-intake method, improved sampling efficiency further by returning water directly back into the tank, reducing labor and time compared with the on-deck bucket sieving.
The presence of nine live, non-native taxa, including one HAB species ( Dictyocha fibula Ehrenberg) in the ballast water suggests that live non-native species can survive the voyage from a foreign port and be introduced to different regions through the transportation and release of ballast water. The harmful dinoflagellate (Zingone et al. 2006), Alexandrium balechii , was found both in the ballast water of one ship and in the port water where it was berthed. This species was collected from both locations in the vegetative and cyst stages and successfully cultured from both stages. Six months later the same vessel was boarded and the same ballast tank was sampled. A. balechii cysts were recovered again from the ballast tank, excysted, and successfully cultured. This suggests that this native species and possibly other cyst-forming dinoflagellates have the potential to be drawn into ballast tanks of a vessel berthed at Port of Tampa or Port Manatee,encyst, be expelled into a foreign port with similar environmental conditions, then excyst and reproduce as suggested by Hallegraeff and Bolch (1992) as a route of introduction. Although only one non-native HAB species was found in the ballast water samples, 15 other native harmful, toxic or species closely related to toxic species or species associated with fish kills were found in ballast water samples ( Table 3 ).
For the purposes of processing sediment samples collected from ballast tanks or from the ports several no hyphen for this word were made to the Bolch (1997) method of cyst purification. Bolch (1997) sonicated samples at 150-200 W for 2 min. The sonic dismembrator used in our study had a maximum output of only 20 W, so we extended sonication time to 7 min at 10 W. There was concern that the increase in sonication time may have destroyed the cysts. However, the presence of viable, sensitive cysts (i.e., polykrikoid spp., A. balechii ), as defined by Zonneveld et al. (2001), in our samples after sonication, suggested the prolonged, reduced wattage sonication did not destroy cysts. In the original method, the first and second centrifugations were performed at 1,600 ×g and 1,000 ×g, respectively. In the modified method, the centrifugations were performed at 2,126 ×g and 1,329 ×g. The third centrifugation in the Bolch (1997) method seemed unnecessary and was dropped from our method.Finally, addition of the shaker table step added the potential for greater efficiency when processing larger volumes of sediment. Although processing sediment in this manner takes longer than the Bolch (1997) method, most of the additional time is spent allowing sediments to settle. By concentrating and using only the portion of sediment of flocculent fraction, more material can be sieved without clogging by sand or other materials of a large grain size. This modification allows for larger volumes of sediment to be processed with the same active time investment that smaller volumes would require; this is beneficial when harvesting cysts for culture, toxin, or genetic studies.
We thank the United States Coast Guard Marine Safety Office (Tampa) and the captains and crews of foreign vessels for the opportunity and invaluable assistance given to us while on board. We are grateful to Tom Corbin and Ryan Pigg for assistance with sampling, Llyn French, David Crewz, and Frank Courtney for aid with this manuscript,and Karen Steidinger for advice throughout the project. We also offer thanks to two anonymous reviewers of this manuscript for their comments. Support for this project was provided to the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission by the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation (Grant #2002-0005-010) under funding to the Foundation from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP Grant #CZ616). The FDEP grant agreement was funded under the Florida Coastal Management Program from the Office of Ocean and Coastal Resource Management under the Coastal Zone Management Act of 1972, as amended, NOAA Award No. NA05NOS4191074. The views, statements,findings, conclusions and recommendations expressed herein are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the State of Florida, NOAA or any of its subagencies.
Andersen R. A , Kawachi M , Andersen R. A 2005 Traditional microalgae isolation techniques.In Algal Culturing Techniques Elsevier Academic Press San Diego CA 83 - 101
Baker P , Baker S. M , Fajans J 2004 Nonindigenous marine species in the greater Tampa Bay ecosystem. Technical publication No. 02-04 Tampa Bay Estuary Program St. Petersburg FL 131 -
Bendis B University of South Florida 1999 Water quality trends in Tampa Bay Florida University of South Florida St. Petersburg FL USA 84 -
Bolch C. J. S 1997 The use of sodium polytungstate for the separation and concentration of living dinoflagellate cysts from marine sediments Phycologia 36 472 - 478
Carlton J , Reid D , van Leeuwen H 1995 The role of shipping in the introduction of non-indigenous aquatic organisms to the coastal waters of the United States (other than the Great Lakes) and an analysis of controlled options.The National Sea Grant College Program/Connecticut Sea Grant Project R/ES-6 Groton CT 213 -
Christy A. E 2003 2002 monitoring of harmful algae in South Puget Sound and Wilapa Bay: species of concern and future considerations J. Shellfish Res 22 601 - 602
Cohen A. N , Carlton J. T 1998 Accelerating invasion rate in a highly invaded estuary Science 279 555 - 558
Dodgshun T , Handley S 1997 Sampling ships’ ballast water: a practical manual. Cawthron Report N 417 Ballast Water Programme Nelson 60 -
Duggan I. C , Bailey S. A , van Overdijk C. D. A , MacIsaac H. J 2006 Invasion risk of active and diapausing invertebrates from residual ballast water in ships entering Chesapeake Bay Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser 324 57 - 66
Fritz L , Triemer R. E 1985 A rapid simple technique utilizing Calcofluor White M2R for the visualization of dinoflagellate thecal plates J. Phycol 21 662 - 664
Griffiths R. W , Schloesser D. W , Leach J. H , Kovalak W. P 1991 Distribution and dispersal of the zebra mussel (Dreissena polymorpha) in the Great Lakes region Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci 48 1381 - 1388
Grosholz E. D 2005 Recent biological invasion may hasten invasional meltdown by accelerating historical introductions Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 102 1088 - 1091
Hallegraeff G. M 1993 A review of harmful algal blooms and their apparent global increase Phycologia 32 79 - 99
Hallegraeff G. M 1998 Transport of toxic dinoflagellates via ships’ ballast water: bioeconomic risk assessment and efficacy of possible ballast water management strategies Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser 168 297 - 309
Hallegraeff G. M , Bolch C. J 1992 Transport of diatom and dinoflagellate resting spores in ships’ ballast water: implications for plankton biogeography and aquaculture J. Plankton Res 14 1067 - 1084
Head M. J , Jansonius J , McGregor D. C 1996 Modern dinoflagellate cysts and their biological affinities.In Palynology: Principles and Applications Vol. 3 AmericanAssociation of Stratigraphic Palynologists Foundation Salt Lake City UT 1197 - 1248
International Maritime Organization 1997 Ballast Water Guidelines A. 868 (20) Available from:
Kelly J. M 1993 Ballast water and sediments as mechanisms for unwanted species introductions into Washington State J. Shellfish Res 12 405 - 410
Landsberg J. H 2002 The effects of harmful algal blooms on aquatic organisms Rev. Fish. Sci 10 113 - 390
Lewis J 1991 Cyst-theca relationships in Scrippsiella (Dinophyceae) and related orthoperidinoid genera Bot. Mar. 34 91 - 106
Marret F , Zonneveld K. A. F 2003 Atlas of modern organic-walled dinoflagellate cyst distribution Rev. Palaeobot.Palynol 125 1 - 200
Matsuoka K , Fukuyo Y Japan Society of the Promotion of Science WESTPAC-HAB/WESTPAC/IOC 2000 Technical guide for modern dinoflagellate cyst study Japan Society of the Promotion of Science WESTPAC-HAB/WESTPAC/IOC Tokyo 29 -
Matsuoka K , Fukuyo Y , Hallegraeff G. M , Anderson D. M , Cembella A. D UNESCO 2003 Taxonomy of cysts.In Manual on Harmful Marine Microalgae UNESCO Paris 563 - 592
McCarthy H. P , Crowder L. B 2000 An overlooked scale of global transport: phytoplankton species richness in ships’ ballast water Biol. Invasions 2 321 - 322
Mills E. L , Leach J. H , Carlton J. T , Secor C. L 1993 Exotic species in the Great Lakes: a history of biotic crises and anthropogenic introductions J. Great Lakes Res 19 1 - 54
Montresor M , Janofske D , Wallems H 1997 The cyst-theca relationship inCalciodinellum operosumemend (Peridiniales Dinophyceae) and a new approach for the study of calcareous cysts J. Phycol 33 122 - 131
Montresor M , Sgrosso S , Procaccini G , Kooistra W. H. C. F 2003 Intraspecific diversity inScrippsiella trochoidea(Dinophyceae): evidence for cryptic species Phycologia 42 56 - 70
Nézan E , Chomérat N 2011 Vulcanodinium rugosumgen. et sp. nov. (Dinophyceae) un nouveau dinoflagellé marin de la côte Méditerranéenne Française Cryptogam. Algol 32 3 - 18
R Development Core Team 2010 R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing Vienna Available from:
Rhodes L , Smith K , Selwood A , McNabb P , van Ginkel R , Holland P , Munday R 2010 Production of pinnatoxins by a peridinoid dinoflagellate isolated from NorthlandNew Zealand Harmful Algae 9 384 - 389
Rigby G. R , Hallegraeff G. M 1993 Shipping ballast water trials on the bulk carrier M/V Iron Whyalla. AQIS Ballast Water Research Series Report No. 2 Australian GovernmentPublishing Service Canberra 123 -
Ruiz G. M , Carlton J. T , Grosholz E. D , Hines A. H 1997 Global invasions of marine and estuarine habitats by non-indigenous species: mechanisms extent and consequences Am. Zool 37 621 - 632
Schiller J , Rabenhorst L 1937 Dinoflagellate (Peridineae) in monographischer Behandlung. 2. Teil Lieferung 4.In Kryptogamen-Flora von Deutschland Österreich und der Schweiz Akademische Verlagsgesllschaft Leipzig 1 - 589
Steidinger K , Landsberg J , Tomas C , Hallegraeff G. M , Blackburn S. I , Bolch C. J , Lewis R. J 2000 A report of the toxic microalgae in Florida waters Proc. 9th Int. Conf. Harmful Algal Blooms Paris 225 -
Steidinger K , Williams J Florida Department of Natural Resources Marine Research Laboratory 1970 Dinoflagellates: memoirs of the Hourglass cruises Florida Department of Natural Resources Marine Research Laboratory St. Petersburg FL 251 -
Strayer D. L , Levinton J. S , Waldman J. R 2006 Alien species in the Hudson River.In The Hudson River Estuary Cambridge University Press New York NY 296 - 310
Subba Rao D. V , Sprules W. G , Locke A , Carlton J. T 1994 Exotic phytoplankton from ships’ ballast waters: risk of potential spread to mariculture sites on Canada’s east coast Can. Data Rep. Fish. Aquat 937 1 - 51
Tomas C. R 1997 Identifying marine phytoplankton AcademicPress San Diego CA 858 -
Truby E. W 1997 Preparation of single-celled marine dinoflagellates for electron microscopy Microsc. Res. Tech 36 337 - 340
United States Environmental Protection Agency Gulf of Mexico Program 2004 Gulf of Mexico ballast water profile Available from:
Yoo J. -K , Song T. -Y , Hong H. -P , Jeong K. -M , Myung C. -S 2006 Marine plankton in ballast water of ship entering Korea Ocean Polar Res KOI : KISTI1.1003/JNL.JAKO200612242768860 28 57 - 65
Zhang F , Dickman M 1999 Mid-ocean exchange of container vessel ballast water. 1. Seasonal factors affecting the transport of harmful diatoms and dinoflagellates Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser 176 243 - 251
Zingone A , Siano R , D’Alelio D , Sarno D 2006 Potentially toxic and harmful microalgae from coastal waters of the Campania region (Tyrrhenian Sea Mediterranean Sea) Harmful Algae 5 321 - 337
Zonneveld K. A. F , Versteegh G. J. M , de Lange G. J 2001 Palaeoproductivity and post-depositional aerobic organic matter decay reflected by dinoflagellate cyst assemblages of the Eastern Mediterranean S1 sapropel Mar. Geol. 172 181 - 195