Graphene field-effect transistor for radio-frequency applications : review
Graphene field-effect transistor for radio-frequency applications : review
Carbon letters. 2012. Jan, 13(1): 17-22
Copyright ©2012, Korean Carbon Society
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License ( by-nc/3.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
  • Received : September 04, 2011
  • Accepted : December 12, 2011
  • Published : January 31, 2012
Export by style
Cited by
About the Authors
Jeong-Sun Moon

Currently, graphene is a topic of very active research in fields from science to potential applications. For various radio-frequency (RF) circuit applications including low-noise amplifiers, the unique ambipolar nature of graphene field-effect transistors can be utilized for highperformance frequency multipliers, mixers and high-speed radiometers. Potential integration of graphene on Silicon substrates with complementary metal-oxide-semiconductor compatibility would also benefit future RF systems. The future success of the RF circuit applications depends on vertical and lateral scaling of graphene metal-oxide-semiconductor field-effect transistors to minimize parasitics and improve gate modulation efficiency in the channel. In this paper, we highlight recent progress in graphene materials, devices, and circuits for RF applications. For passive RF applications, we show its transparent electromagnetic shielding in Ku-band and transparent antenna, where its success depends on quality of materials. We also attempt to discuss future applications and challenges of graphene.
1. Introduction
Graphene is an atomically thin but stable form of hexagonal carbon [1 , 2] and has attracted a lot of attention in the research community since the seminal papers published in 2004 [3 , 4] . Along with its unique electronic properties, graphene has shown interesting optical [5] , mechanical [6] and thermal [7] properties as summarized in Table 1 . Some of these unique properties have been considered for potential applications, such as transparent conductors for touch screens [8 , 9] , electromagnetic interference shielding [10] , antenna [11] , flexible electronics [12] , sensors [13] , nanoelectromechanical systems [14] , and interconnects [15] .
For radio-frequency (RF) electronic applications being considered, graphene exhibits the highest carrier mobility: >100 000 cm 2 V -1 s -1 at room temperature [16] . This is not only ~100 times greater than that of Si, but about 10 times greater than state-of-the-art semiconductors lattice-matched to InP, currently regarded the best high-speed materials. The saturation velocity (v sat ) of graphene has not been determined clearly yet, but it is estimated to be ~5 times greater than that for Si metal-oxide semiconductor field-effect transistor (MOSFETs) [17] . With expected large on-state current density and transconductance per gate capacitance compared to Si, graphene has the potential to offer excellent switching characteristics (capacitance/ on-state current) and short-circuit current gain cut-off frequency [18] . Although it is too early to predict, graphene-on-Si FETs [19] could potentially be further developed and processed in a manner compatible with Si complementary MOS (CMOS) with desirable integration density for system-on-chip applications.
While there are numerous challenges to be overcome for graphene to become a mature
A brief summary of properties of graphene
Lager Image
A brief summary of properties of graphene
technology, this material offers unique device and potential circuit applications ranging from conventional unipolar RF electronics, such as low-noise amplifiers (LNAs), to unique ambipolar RF electronics such as frequency multipliers, mixers and high-speed radiometers. With observed constant device transconductance over the gate voltages [20] , graphene FETs could potentially offer LNAs with higher dynamic range per given DC power, beyond the antimony-based low-bandgap devices. With graphene FETs biased near the ambipolar point, graphene FETs behave close to ideal “square-law” devices near the ambipolar point i.e., I(Vg) ∝ Vg 2 , where Vg is the gate voltage. It would greatly suppress odd-order harmonics and/or third-order intermodulation products and improve dynamic range in communications.
2. Status of Epitaxial Graphene-on-SiC Transistors
Graphene FETs are being developed on the wafer-scale utilizing graphene-on-Si [19 , 21] , graphene-on-SiC [20 , 22 - 24] , and graphene transferred to SiO2 substrates [25] . Several promising device parameters have been demonstrated. For example, epitaxial graphene RF FETs have been demonstrated in a top-gated layout with the highest ever on-state current density of 3 A/mm [24] . On the other hand, the current-voltage characteristics are quasi-linear with weak saturation behaviors, yielding low transconductance (gm) per capacitance (i.e., <140 mS/mm at 3.4 fF/ μm 2 ) and poor voltage gain (transconductance /output conductance). Also, the ratio of on-state current over off-state current, I on /I off , was ~4 with field-effect mobility below 200 cm 2 /Vs. While graphene field-effect mobility as high as 5400 cm 2 /Vs for electron has been demonstrated [22] , it was achieved using six to seven layers of epitaxial graphene on C-face SiC substrates,
Lager Image
(a) A schematic of the top-gated graphene field-effect transistor (FET). (b) A scanning electron microscopy photograph of 2f x 6 μm graphene FET. (c) A photograph of 75 mm graphene wafer.
resulting in an I on /I off ratio of <2. In the case of graphene FETs fabricated on the Si-face of SiC substrates, field-effect mobility has been limited to below 1200 cm 2 /Vs, but with an improved I on /I off ratio of ~10 [23] .
Top-gated graphene n-channel FETs (n-FET) and p-channel FETs (p-FETs) from epitaxial graphene layers were demonstrated with excellent I-V saturation behaviors [20] with a record peak extrinsic transconductance of 770 mS/mm. Also, the effective mobility and field-effect mobility versus E eff were characterized and compared with Hall mobility. The epitaxial graphene layers were grown on Si-face 6H-SiC substrates on 75-mm wafers via Si sublimation [26]. The sheet electron carrier density of the epitaxial graphene layer was typically 8.8 × 10 12 cm -2 at room temperature and had electron mobility of ~1192 cm 2 /Vs, characterized by non-contact Hall Lehighton 1600. The number of epitaxial graphene layers was found to be one layer on the SiC terraces and two layers on the step edges over the entire 75- mm wafer as characterized by Raman analysis and transmission electron microscopy analysis.
Figs. 1 a-c shows the graphene FET processed in a layout, where the gate metal is aligned with respect to the ohmic metals in an under lap layout with a gate-to-source/drain separation of <100 nm to minimize the access resistance over a source-drain spacing (L sd ) of 1 μm. The source access resistance was <0.2 Ω·mm via the standard end-point measurements on transmission line method structures. A graphene channel width of 6 μm was defined by O 2 plasma etching. The metal gates were processed with Ti/Pt/ Au metal deposition and lift-off process on top of a 35-nm-thick SiO 2 gate dielectric layer deposited by electron beam evaporation. The gate leakage current was in the range of ~nA/μm 2 or less, which is negligible in the device characterization presented here.
Figs. 2 a and b shows the measured room temperature and the common-source current-voltage characteristics of a two-gate finger 6-μm-wide n-channel graphene FET (denoted as 2f × 6 μm), in which excellent drain current saturation was observed. The source-to-drain voltage (Vds) increased to 3 V, where the gate-to-source (Vgs) voltage was stepped from 3 V (top-curve) in steps of -0.5 V. At Vds = 1 V, on-state current at Vgs = 3 V was 590 mA/mm. The I on /I off ratio was ~13. At Vds = 0.5 V, the I on /I off ratio increased to 20. At Vds = 3 V, the on-state current at Vgs = 3 V was measured as high as 1650 mA/mm. The onresistance was 1.6 Ω·mm. The peak extrinsic gm of 770 mS/ mm was measured at Vds = 3.05 V, which is the highest ever, amongst epitaxial graphene FETs.
Lager Image
(a) Measured common-source current-voltage characteristics of 1f x 6 μm graphene FET. (b) Both p-channel and n-channel graphene MOSFET operations. MOSFET: metal-oxide semiconductor field-effect transistor.
Lager Image
Measured effective carrier mobility and field-effect mobility of graphene n-FETs compared with those of Si n-MOSFET and strained Si on SGOI MOSFET. MOSFET: metal-oxide semiconductor field-effect transistor.
Fig. 3 shows extracted effective mobility (μ eff ) and field-effect mobility (μ FE ) of graphene n-FETs versus the effective electric field, E eff . In comparison, the universal and field-effect mobility of Si n-MOSFETs [27] and strained Si n-MOSFETs on SiGe-onoxide [28] are shown. While both the μ eff and μ FE of the graphene n-FETs depend on E eff , both values were higher than 1000 cm 2 /Vs over a wide range of the effective electric field up to 1.6 MV/cm. The peak field-effect mobility values ranged from 3200 cm 2 /Vs to 6000 cm 2 /Vs. A record field-effect mobility of 6000 cm 2 /Vs was obtained at an effective electric field of 0.27 MV/cm. The measured field-effect mobility of graphene n-FETs was at least seven times higher than that of Si n-MOSFETs in international technology roadmap for semiconductor and ~80 times higher than ultra-thin-body SOI n-MOSFETs. The peak field-effect mobility of graphene p-FETs was also determined to be 3200 cm 2 /Vs at an effective electric field of 0.2 MV/cm.
3. Graphene FET RF Performance
Regarding the graphene FET speed performance, in 2009 an extrinsic current-gain cutoff frequency (f t ) and maximum oscillation frequency (f max ) of 4.2 GHz and 14 GHz was reported with a 2 μm gate length [24] . The speed performance was not optimized due to the overlap capacitance between the gate and ohmic metal pads. In 2010, graphene FETs with a 240 μm gate length reported de-embedded f t /f max of 100 GHz/10 GHz, while there is no extrinsic f t /f max reported [29] . With graphene FETs processed with self-aligned nanowire gate with a gate length of 140 nm, de-embedded f t of 300 GHz was claimed while the extrinsic f t of 2.4 GHz was measured [30] .
As an example of graphene FET RF performance, Fig. 4 a shows the measured magnitude of H 21 (|H 21 |) and Mason’s unilateral gain (U) of the 2 × 12 μm graphene FETs with sourcedrain spacing (L ds ) of 1 μm. The S-parameters were measured at Vds = 5 V and Vgs = -2.5 V. An extrinsic f t of 4.1 GHz was extracted, yielding an extrinsic f t ·L g of 8.2 GHz·μm. The extrinsic gm was 195 mS/mm. A f max of 11.5 GHz was extracted from the unilateral gain with a slope of -20 dB/decade. Fig. 4 b shows a plot of extrinsic f t and f max measured from the graphene FETs. For graphene FET with L ds = 3 μm, the extrinsic gm improved to 148 mS/mm at Vds = 9 V, yielding the extrinsic f t and f max of 4.4 GHz and 6 GHz, respectively. For graphene FET with L ds = 1 μm, the f t and f max were 4.2 GHz and 14 GHz, respectively, at Vds = 7 V. With a source access resistance of 1.9 Ω·mm, the intrinsic gm becomes 205 mS/mm. This yields an intrinsic f t of 5 GHz with an intrinsic f t ·L g of 10 GHz·μm, which is slightly better than 8.9 GHz·μm from the bulk Si NMOS.
At present, the RF performance of graphene FETs is not close to what had been predicted by the intrinsic saturation velocity of the graphene channel, 4-5 × 10 7 cm/sec. The theoretical carrier transport velocity provides f t ·L g product >50 GHz·μm, which is far from the currently observed values of f t ·L g products. The f t ·L g product of graphene FETs is expected to improve as the quality of the epitaxial graphene film, gate dielectric layer, transconductance, and transistor fabrication processing improves with reduced parasitic charging delay [31] .
In most RF applications, f max is very important to provide amplifiers with gain. The weak I-V saturation leads to a smaller
Lager Image
(a) Measured |H21| and unilateral gain (U) are shown as a function of frequencies at Vds = 5 V and Vgs = -2.5 V of 2 x 12 μm graphene MOSFETs with Lds = 1 μm. (b) A plot of measured extrinsic fT and fmax of the graphene FETs is shown. The gate length is 2 m. The highest ft and fmax are 4.2 GHz and 14 GHz, respectively. MOSFET: metal-oxide semiconductor fieldeffect transistor.
output resistance (R ds ), transconductance, and higher C gd compared to other semiconductor FETs with a finite bandgap. In order to maintain high f max in short channel graphene FETs, channel engineering to reduce band-to-band tunneling will be desired as a mitigation method.
4. Graphene FET Ambipolar RF Applications
Unlike Si, SiGe, and III-IV semiconductor materials, graphene has a unique ambipolar characteristic, where excellent field-effect mobility for both electron and holes can be obtained. For instance, field-effect mobility of 6000 cm 2 /Vs for electrons and 3200 cm 2 /Vs for holes was obtained [20] . Several potential applications for these unique ambipolar graphene FETs have been under evaluation [32 - 34] . These include frequency multipliers, mixers, and oscillators. Frequency multiplication or mixing is based on the nonlinearity of graphene FETs near the ambipolar point.
Lager Image
(a) A schematic of frequency multiplication process is shown with RF output spectra consisting of even-order harmonic signals only. (b) Measured transfer curves of two 2f x25 μm graphene FETs at Vds = 1 V is shown with the ambipolar point at Vgs = -1.5 V. Output spectra of the graphene FETs driven under the 1f = 1 MHz, 0 dBm RF input signal are shown at the ambipolar point.
If graphene FETs behave as ideal “square-law” devices near the ambipolar point ie., I(V g ) ∝ V g 2 , it would greatly suppress odd-order harmonics and/or third-order intermodulation products and improve dynamic range in communications. A suppression of odd-order signals (f, 3f, 5f…) compared to the second harmonic (2f) was shown in the frequency multiplication experiments up to 200 kHz with ~10 dB suppression [32 , 33] , and above GHz [34] .
Fig. 5 a shows a schematic of the frequency multiplication process in the case of ambipolar transfer curve. Fig. 5 b shows an example of measured RF output spectra consisting of strong even-order harmonic signals with odd-order harmonics suppressed by >25 dB, supporting “square-law” device operation at the ambipolar point.
The phase noise measurement was reported with a carrier-tonoise degradation of 6 dB, which implies noiseless frequency multiplication without additional 1/f noise up-conversion during the nonlinear process [34] . Capitalizing on the ambipolar nature of graphene FETs, ambipolar mixers were demonstrated in the GHz range [35 , 36] . The conversion loss is typically in the order of 20-30 dB, which has to be solved in order to make ambipolar frequency doublers and mixers competitive technologies.
5. Conclusions
While it is early in the stage of development to clearly forecast its impact, graphene FETs could potentially offer performance benefits in RF systems including LNAs, frequency multipliers, mixers and high-speed radiometers. The future success of the RF circuit applications depends on high-quality material growth on large-wafer scale, vertical and lateral scaling of graphene MOSFETs to minimize parasitics and improved gate modulation efficiency in the channel, a bandgap engineering of graphene channels in the MOSFETs, and innovative circuit concepts.
This work was partially supported by the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) and monitored by Dr. John Albrecht at DARPA under SPAWAR contract #N66001- 08-C-2048. The views, opinions, and/or findings contained in this article/presentation are those of the author/presenter and should not be interpreted as representing the official views or policies, either expressed or implied, of the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency or the Department of Defense.
Geim AK , Novoselov KS (2007) The rise of graphene. Nature Mater 6 183 -    DOI : 10.1038/nmat1849
Auciello O , Avouris P , Berger C , Butler JE , Carpick RW , De Heer WA , First PN , Fuhrer MS , Hersam MC , Lau CN , Liu J , MacDonald AH , Martel R , Moon JS , Seyller T , Stroscio JA , Srinivasan S , Sumant AV (2010) Beyond silicon: carbon-based nanotechnology. MRS Bull 35 273 -
Novoselov KS , Geim AK , Morozov SV , Jiang D , Zhang Y , Dubonos SV , Grigorieva IV , Firsov AA (2004) Electric field in atomically thin carbon films. Science 306 666 -    DOI : 10.1126/science.1102896
Berger C , Song Z , Li T , Li X , Ogbazghi AY , Feng R , Dai Z , Alexei N , Conrad MEH , First PN , De Heer WA (2004) Ultrathin epitaxial graphite: 2D electron gas properties and a route toward graphene-based nanoelectronics. J Phys Chem B 108 19912 -    DOI : 10.1021/jp040650f
Nair RR , Blake P , Grigorenko AN , Novoselov KS , Booth TJ , Stauber T , Peres NMR , Geim AK (2008) Fine structure constant defines visual transparency of graphene. Science 320 1308 -    DOI : 10.1126/science.1156965
Lee C , Wei X , Kysar JW , Hone J (2008) Measurement of the elastic properties and intrinsic strength of monolayer graphene. Science 321 385 -    DOI : 10.1126/science.1157996
Balandin AA , Ghosh S , Bao W , Calizo I , Teweldebrhan D , Miao F , Lau CN (2008) Superior thermal conductivity of single-layer graphene. Nano Lett 8 902 -    DOI : 10.1021/nl0731872
Bae S , Kim H , Lee Y , Xu X , Park JS , Zheng Y , Balakrishnan J , Lei T , Ri Kim H , Song YI , Kim YJ , Kim KS , Ozyilmaz B , Ahn JH , Hong BH , Iijima S (2010) Roll-to-roll production of 30-inch graphene films for transparent electrodes. Nature Nanotechnol 5 574 -    DOI : 10.1038/nnano.2010.132
Kim KS , Zhao Y , Jang H , Lee SY , Kim JM , Ahn JH , Kim P , Choi JY , Hong BH (2009) Large-scale pattern growth of graphene films for stretchable transparent electrodes. Nature 457 706 -    DOI : 10.1038/nature07719
Moon JS , Gaskill DK (2011) Graphene: its fundamentals to future applications. IEEE Trans Microwave Theory Tech 59 2702 -    DOI : 10.1109/tmtt.2011.2164617
Jornet JM , Akyildiz IF (2010) Graphene-based nano-antennas for electromagnetic nanocommunications in the terahertz band. Proceedings of the 4th European Conference on Antennas and Propagation Barcelona, Spain
Eda G , Fanchini G , Chhowalla M (2008) Large-area ultrathin films of reduced graphene oxide as a transparent and flexible electronic material. Nature Nanotechnol 3 270 -    DOI : 10.1038/nnano.2008.83
Schedin F , Geim AK , Morozov SV , Hill EW , Blake P , Katsnelson MI , Novoselov KS (2007) Detection of individual gas molecules adsorbed on graphene. Nature Mater 6 652 -    DOI : 10.1038/nmat1967
Bunch JS , Van Der Zande AM , Verbridge SS , Frank IW , Tanenbaum DM , Parpia JM , Craighead HG , McEuen PL (2007) Electromechanical resonators from graphene sheets. Science 315 490 -    DOI : 10.1126/science.1136836
Murali R , Brenner K , Yang Y , Beck T , Meindl JD (2009) Resistivity of graphene nanoribbon interconnects. IEEE Electron Device Lett 30 611 -    DOI : 10.1109/led.2009.2020182
Morozov SV , Novoselov KS , Katsnelson MI , Schedin F , Elias DC , Jaszczak JA , Geim AK (2008) Giant intrinsic carrier mobilities in graphene and its bilayer. Phys Rev Lett 100 016602 -    DOI : 10.1103/PhysRevLett.100.016602
Akturk A , Goldsman N (2008) Electron transport and full-band electronphonon interactions in graphene. J Appl Phys 103 053702 -    DOI : 10.1063/1.2890147
Moon JS , Curtis D , Hu M , Wong D , Campbell P , Jernigan G , Tedesco JL (2009) Development toward wafer-scale graphene RF electronics. ECS Trans 19 35 -    DOI : 10.1149/1.3119525
Moon JS , Curtis D , Bui S , Marshall T , Wheeler D , Valles I , Kim S , Wang E , Weng X , Fanton M (2010) Top-gated graphene field-effect transistors using graphene on si (111) wafers. IEEE Electron Device Lett 31 1193 -    DOI : 10.1109/led.2010.2065792
Moon JS , Curtis D , Bui S , Hu M , Gaskill DK , Tedesco JL , Asbeck P , Jernigan GG , Vanmil BL , Myers-Ward RL , Eddy CR Jr , Campbell PM , Weng X (2010) Top-gated epitaxial graphene FETs on sifacesic wafers with a peak transconductance of 600 mS/mm. IEEE Electron Device Lett 31 260 -    DOI : 10.1109/led.2010.2040132.
Kang HC , Karasawa H , Miyamoto Y , Handa H , Fukidome H , Suemitsu T , Suemitsu M , Otsuji T (2009) Epitaxial graphene top-gateFETs on silicon substrates. International Semiconductor Device Research Symposium College Park, MD
Wu YQ , Ye PD , Capano MA , Xuan Y , Sui Y , Qi M , Cooper JA , Shen T , Pandey D , Prakash G , Reifenberger R (2008) Top-gated graphene field-effect-transistors formed by decomposition of SiC Appl Phys Lett 92 092102 -    DOI : 10.1063/1.2889959
Kedzierski J , Hsu PL , Healey P , Wyatt PW , Keast CL , Sprinkle M , Berger C , de Heer WA (2008) Epitaxial graphene transistors on SiCsubstrates IEEE Trans Electron Devices 55 2078 -    DOI : 10.1109/ted.2008.926593
Moon JS , Curtis D , Hu M , Wong D , McGuire C , Campbell PM , Jernigan G , Tedesco JL , VanMil B , Myers-Ward R , Eddy C Jr , Gaskill DK (2009) Epitaxial-graphene RF field-effect transistors on Si-face6H-SiC substrates. IEEE Electron Device Lett 30 650 -    DOI : 10.1109/led.2009.2020699
Kedzierski J , Hsu PL , Reina A , Kong J , Healey P , Wyatt P , Keast C (2009) Graphene-on-insulator transistors made using C on Ni chemical-vapor deposition. IEEE Electron Device Lett 30 745 -    DOI : 10.1109/led.2009.2020615
Gaskill DK , Jernigan G , Campbell P , Tedesco JL , Culbertson J , VanMil B , Myers-Ward RL , Eddy C Jr , Moon J , Curtis D , Hu M , Wong D , McGuire C , Robinson J , Fanton M , Stitt T , Snyder D , Wang X , Frantz E (2009) Epitaxial graphene growth on SiC wafers. ECS Trans 19 117 -    DOI : 10.1149/1.3119535.
Takagi SI , Toriumi A , Iwase M , Tango H (1994) On the universality ofinversion layer mobility in Si MOSFET's: Part I - effects of substrateimpurity concentration. IEEE Trans Electron Devices 41 2357 -    DOI : 10.1109/16.337449
Cheng ZY , Currie MT , Leitz CW , Taraschi G , Fitzgerald EA , Hoyt JL , Antoniadas DA (2001) Electron mobility enhancement in strained-Si n-MOSFETs fabricated on SiGe-on-insulator (SGOI) substrates. IEEE Electron Device Lett 22 321 -    DOI : 10.1109/55.930678
Lin YM , Dimitrakopoulos C , Jenkins KA , Farmer DB , Chiu HY , Grill A , Avouris P (2010) 100-GHz transistors from wafer-scale epitaxial graphene. Science 327 662 -    DOI : 10.1126/science.1184289
Liao L , Lin YC , Bao M , Cheng R , Bai J , Liu Y , Qu Y , Wang KL , Huang Y , Duan X (2010) High-speed graphene transistors with a selfalignednanowire gate. Nature 467 305 -    DOI : 10.1038/nature09405
Moon JS , Wong D , Hu M , Hashimoto P , Antcliffe M , McGuire C , Micovic M , Willadson P (2008) 55% PAE and high power Ka-bandGaN HEMTs with linearized transconductance via n+ GaN sourcecontact ledge. IEEE Electron Device Lett 29 834 -    DOI : 10.1109/led.2008.2000792
Wang H , Nezich D , Kong J , Palacios T (2009) Graphene frequency multipliers IEEE Electron Device Lett 30 547 -    DOI : 10.1109/led.2009.2016443
Wang Z , Zhang Z , Xu H , Ding L , Wang S , Peng LM (2010) A highperformancetop-gate graphene field-effect transistor based frequencydoubler. Appl Phys Lett 96 173104 -    DOI : 10.1063/1.3413959
Moon JS , Curtis D , Zehnder D , Kim S , Gaskill DK , Jernigan GG , Myers-Ward RL , Eddy CR Jr , Campbell PM , Lee KM (2011) AsbeckP. Low-phase-noise graphene FETs in ambipolar RF applications IEEE Electron Device Lett 32 270 -    DOI : 10.1109/led.2010.2100074
Wang H , Hsu A , Wu J , Kong J , Palacios T (2010) Graphene-based ambipolarRF mixers. IEEE Electron Device Lett 31 906 -    DOI : 10.1109/led.2010.2052017
Moon JS (2010) Graphene MOSFETs for RF applications. Proceedings of the 35th Annual GOMACTech Conference Reno, NV