Stress Analysis Using Finite Element Modeling of a Novel RF Microelectromechanical System Shunt Switch Designed on Quartz Substrate for Low-voltage Applications
Stress Analysis Using Finite Element Modeling of a Novel RF Microelectromechanical System Shunt Switch Designed on Quartz Substrate for Low-voltage Applications
Transactions on Electrical and Electronic Materials. 2013. Oct, 14(5): 225-230
Copyright ©2013, The Korean Institute of Electrical and Electronic Material Engineers
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-CommercialLicense ( which permits unrestricted noncommercial use,distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
  • Received : June 06, 2013
  • Accepted : June 06, 2013
  • Published : October 25, 2013
Export by style
Cited by
About the Authors
Tejinder Singh
Navjot K. Khaira
Jitendra S. Sengar
This paper presents a novel shunt radio frequency microelectromechanical system switch on a quartz substrate with stiff ribs around the membrane. The buckling effects in the switch membrane and stiction problem are the primary concerns with RF MEMS switches. These effects can be reduced by the proposed design approach due to the stiffness of the ribs around the membrane. A lower mass of the beam and a reduction in the squeeze film damping is achieved due to the slots and holes in the membrane, which further aid in attaining high switching speeds. The proposed switch is optimized to operate in the k-band, which results in a high isolation of -40 dB and low insertion loss of -0.047 dB at 21 GHz, with a low actuation voltage of only 14.6 V needed for the operation the switch. The membrane does not bend with this membrane design approach. Finite element modeling is used to analyze the stress and pull-in voltage.
Microelectromechanical Systems (MEMS) switches [1] optimized to work at Radio Frequencies (RF) have been a primary focus of intensive research over the past few years in both academia and industrial organizations. RF MEMS switches have grown at very fast pace, and have entered into many applications in wireless communication [2] and space systems. RF MEMS switches have replaced the conventional GaAs FET and p-i-n diode switches in RF and microwave systems, because of their negligible power consumption of a few μ-watts, low insertion loss, high isolation, much lower intermodulation distortion, small footprints, low cost, and light weight [3] . Due to the enormous advantages of MEMS switches, these are widely used at RF to millimeter-wave frequencies.
Typically MEMS switches are fabricated using surface micromachining processes, and have a suspended thin metal membrane called the “bridge,” which can be a fixed-fixed, cantilever, or torsion beam). The bridge allows or blocks the electronic transmission through mechanical movement of the membrane above the electrode [3] . MEMS switches can be actuated by various methods, such as electrostatic [4 - 6] , electromagnetic [7] , piezoelectric [8] , and thermal [9] actuation. Due to the near-zero power consumption and linearity, electrostatic actuation is most widely used, in which electrostatic force is generated between a fixed electrode and a movable membrane for switching operation. Several disadvantages include slow switching speeds, high actuation voltage, and hot switching in high-power RF applications [10] .
This paper presents a novel design for a RF MEMS capacitive switch on quartz substrate, which results in excellent RF performance in the k-band with high isolation and low insertion loss. With the inclusion of ribs around the membrane, the bucking effect and stiction problem can be eliminated. The effect of this novel membrane design can be seen in stress analysis. The membrane can withstand several switching cycles. The spring constant, required voltage, and stress is analyzed using multiphysics environment.
- 2.1 Structure and principle of operation
The proposed RF MEMS switch has a coplanar waveguide (CPW) line for RF signal transmission on a 100-μm-thick quartz substrate. A dielectric layer of hafnium dioxide (HfO 2 ) is used due to its very high dielectric constant over the substrate. The working principle of the switch is shown in Fig. 1 . The CPW consists of a 70-μm-wide signal line with a gap of 90 μm. The same dielectric material is used on top of the signal line. The characteristics of the switch are mainly governed by the design of the membrane.
To lower the pull-down voltage, meanders are included on the sides of the membrane, which helps to lower the spring constant of the membrane. The membrane is thin on the inside and thick at its boundary. Four anchors 4-μm thick are attached to the ground plane, and meanders are present on the top end to give the membrane a proper space for movement above the RF line. A gap height g 0 of 3 μm is maintained between the membrane and pull-down electrode, as it is needed to optimize the pull-down voltage and gap. Otherwise, the membrane may become prone to self-biasing and external vibrations, and then it would not be possible to recover the membrane’s position due to elastic recovery forces. A 3D view of the proposed switch is shown in Fig. 2 , and a tilted view of the switch membrane is shown in Fig. 3 , showing the varying height of membrane.
The proposed switch is actuated by electrostatic force. When a voltage is applied to the pull-down electrode, the membrane connected to the grounds of the CPW line snaps down onto the signal line. As the dielectric layer is applied to the signal line, it reduces the gap g 0 , and the down-state capacitance value is increased. When the membrane is in the up-state, the capacitance value becomes low, thus giving a good capacitance ratio. The design is optimized after the analysis of the von Mises stress and spring constant constraints.
- 2.2 Design of membrane
The inclusion of holes of 5-μm diameter and slots in the membrane help to reduce the biaxial residual stress, and thus reduce the buckling effect of the membrane after the removal of the sacrificial layer during fabrication. The membrane is reliable in terms of switching life due to the flatbed internal structure. Hence, the membrane does not bend when pulled in towards the signal line. The bending only occurs at the meanders. The holes also help in reducing the principle strain on the membrane at the pull down electrode area. The diameter of the holes in the membrane should be less than 2g 0 , so as not to affect the capacitance value. In MEMS switches, if the spring constant k is very low and the membrane gap is less than 3 μm, then during switching, the membrane sometimes is not restored to its original rest position due to stiction at the electrode. The top view of the membrane is shown in Fig. 4 . The thin internal membrane helps in reducing the overall mass and squeeze-film damping of the membrane. The meanders help to restore the membrane. Overall, the switching speed is increased due to the holes and slots. The dimensions of the meanders are shown in Fig. 4 .
Lager Image
Operation principle of proposed switch in up and down states.
Lager Image
3D view of designed switch.
Lager Image
Tilted view of membrane on co-planar waveguides.
Lager Image
Top view of membrane and dimensions of meanders.
- 2.3 Switch specifications
The proposed shunt switch is designed in Ansoft HFSS v13, which was also used to measure the RF performance. A combined multiphysics environment, COMSOL Multiphysics 4.3b, is used to compute stress, the required actuation voltage, and the spring constant. The specifications, dimensions, and materials used to design the switch are presented in Table 1 .
- 2.4 Selection of materials
A flat and smooth substrate surface is preferred to fabricate the switch, as the substrate is the base over which the switch operates. It should have uniform electrical properties and
Switch specifications.
Lager Image
Switch specifications.
chemical resistance (as required during fabrication) [11 , 16] . These requirements make quartz a good candidate, as it fulfills all these requirements. Quartz has a high melting point compared to silicon, so a switch designed with a quartz substrate can withstand higher temperatures than one made with a silicon substrate [3] .
Hafnium dioxide (HfO 2 ) of 0.5-μm thickness is used over the substrate beneath a CPW line made of Gold (Au). HfO 2 has a dielectric constant of k~25. It is always preferable to use materials that have high k [12] . Most of the conventionally designed MEMS switches have used silicon dioxide (SiO 2 ) or silicon nitride (Si 3 N 4 ) as dielectric materials, with k~3.9 and k~7.5, respectively. As the research evolved, more advanced materials came into existence. We compared these materials with the one actually used in the switch, and the results indicate that HfO 2 provides higher isolation compared to other dielectric materials.
- 2.5 Switch characteristics
- 2.5.1 Actuation mechanics and power handling capabilities
Due to the approach used to design the membrane, the load on the membrane is shifted toward the ends, and it has meanders to lower the overall spring constant k . The load is distributed because of the ribs around the edges of the membrane. The residual stress component can be neglected during calculation due to the stiffness of the membrane.
The actuation voltage V p of a MEMS switch with a spring constant k is given by:
Lager Image
where ε 0 is the permittivity of free space, g 0 is the gap between the membrane and the electrode, and A is the area of the membrane actually covering the dielectric on the signal line.
The analytical value of the actuation voltage is 14.6 V for the dimensions of the switch given in Table 1 . The permittivity ε 0 and spring constant k are fixed, so the value of the actuation voltage completely depends upon the gap height between the membrane and the signal line [15] .
The power handling capability is augmented in comparison to various designs due to the use of a single electrode. The switch relies on the elastic recovery force of the meanders instead of the force of the membrane to pull it upwards, because the membrane is stiff around edges.
- 2.6 Electromagnetic circuit modeling
A lumped CLR model [13 , 14] of the membrane and two sections of the transmission line are used to model the capacitive switch with a capacitance having the down-state/up-state values. Figure 5 shows the equivalent circuit model of the switch. The sections of the transmission line are of length l +( w /2), where l = 15 μm is the distance from the reference plane to the edge of the membrane. For the k-band switch, the calculated value of the capacitance is 2.47 pF / 16.41 fF with an inductance of 5-6 pH and series resistance of 0.15 Ω.
The shunt impedance of the switch is given by:
Lager Image
with C = C up or C down depending on the position of the switch. The LC resonant frequency of the switch is given by:
Lager Image
The CLR model behaves purely as a capacitor for frequencies below the LC series resonant frequency, and as an inductor at higher frequency. At resonance, the CLR model behaves as series resistance of the membrane. For C down / C up = 2.47 pF / 16.41 fF and L = 5 pH, the resonance occurs at f 0 = 45.28 GHz at the down-state position, and 555 GHz at the up-state position of the switch. The impedance is approximated by:
Lager Image
When the resonant frequency is 555 GHz, the inductance of the membrane plays absolutely no role in the up-state for f < 100 GHz, but plays a significant role in the down-state position of the switch. The cut-off frequency of the switch is stated as fc = 1/2π C up R s and f c = 64.65 THz for C up = 16.41 fF and R s = 0.15 Ω.
It is preferred to use the down-state resonant frequency ( f 0 or 2 f 0 ), because the switch results in isolation up to twice the resonant frequency f 0 in the down-state position [5] . The switch inductance limits the down-state performance at a much lower frequency than cut-off frequency f c .
Silicon is used for the membrane, as it is robust and has a low initial stress for bending compared to Au or Al membranes. Hence, it has no residual stress component, which results in locally different bending of the membrane, and a constant gap is maintained between the membrane and transmission line. The various parameters of the silicon material used in the membrane design are given in Table 2 .
- 2.6.1 Up-state capacitance
The parallel plate capacitance of a shunt switch is given calculated as:
Lager Image
The dielectric constant k of HfO 2 is 25, and a dielectric layer of
Lager Image
Magnified top view of stiff membrane with meanders and holes.
0.5-μm thickness is used with a gap height g 0 of 3 μm. The fringing field capacitance of switch C f is a substantial portion of the total switch capacitance. The calculation is done by solving the total capacitance using a 3D electrostatic simulation tool called Maxwell 3D by Ansoft, and then subtracting the analytically derived capacitance. As the diameter of holes in the membrane is 5 μm, the fringing field does not affect the capacitance.
- 2.6.2 Down-state capacitance
The down-state capacitance of the switch is calculated for when the membrane is in the down position. The calculated value of the down-state capacitance is 2.47 pF. In the down position, the thickness of the dielectric layer is so small that the fringing capacitance can be neglected. The down-state capacitance can be calculated by:
Lager Image
- 2.6.3 Capacitance ratio
The preferred value of the capacitance ratio should be greater than 100:1 [3] . In the calculation of the capacitance ratio, the result is 150:1 with an up-state capacitance of C up = 16.41 fF and down-state capacitance of C down = 2.47 pF. The down-state and up-state capacitance ratio is given by:
Lager Image
By varying the thickness of the dielectric layer to improve the capacitance ratio, the optimized thickness of the dielectric is used, as we cannot go beyond one particular value. The RF MEMS switch needs an actuation voltage, and if the dielectric layer is very thin, it can cause dielectric breakdown.
- 2.6.4 Series resistance and inductance
The main factors for the calculation of series resistance are R sl and R s , which are due to the transmission line loss and to the membrane of the switch, respectively. The series resistance is given by:
Lager Image
To model the inductance in the down-state position of the switch, it is assumed that the capacitance is large enough for it to act as a short circuit. The short circuit model can be analyzed numerically or by using an electromagnetic tool like Ansoft HFSS. The inductance in the down-state is given as:
Lager Image
- 3.1 RF performance analysis
The isolation loss, return loss, and insertion loss of the proposed switch are measured using Ansoft HFSS v13. The RF performance of the switch is observed between frequencies of 1 GHz and 40 GHz. From Fig. 6 , it is clear that the switch gives an excellent isolation S 12 of -40 dB at 21 GHz in the down-state.
Table 2 manifests the switch performance for the k-band.For the up-state position, the insertion loss S 12 is analyzed, and the results in Fig. 7 show a low insertion loss of -0.047 dB in the upstate. The return loss S 11 is calculated, and Fig. 8 presents a plot of the return loss. The results show that the switch has excellent performance in the k-band.
- 3.2 Stress analysis
The von Mises Stress is analyzed to check the deflection of the membrane due to stress for the desired height. The membrane is made of gold, which has a maximum stress of 25 MPa. This value is good enough to handle higher switching under the given maximum stress. Figure 9 shows the deflection of the membrane under stress.
- 3.3 Spring constant
The spring constant k is given as the deflection of the membrane per unit meter under applied force. The plot is obtained by setting a parametric sweep of the force applied. Figure 10 shows the spring constant plot. The plotted value, 1.32 (N/m), is quite close to the analytical calculations.
- 3.4 Pull-In voltage vs. gap
The pull-in voltage or the electrostatic actuation voltage required to pull the membrane down to change the state of the switch can be calculated by eq. (1). The pull-in voltage is plotted vs. the gap in between the membrane and the signal line in Fig. 11 . The graph is plotted for the spring constants k = 1, 2, and 1.32 (N/m). It is clear from the plot that as the gap and spring constant increase, higher pull-in voltages are required for switching actions. Hence, the design is optimized to work at 14.6 V for a 3-μm gap height with low k .
The proposed design utilizes a novel approach of membrane design, as the membrane is a hybrid in terms of thickness, and it
Lager Image
Isolation performance S12 for frequency range 1 - 40 GHz.
Lager Image
Insertion loss S12 for frequency range 1 - 40 GHz.
Lager Image
Return loss S11 for frequency range 1 - 40 GHz.
is designed to reduce the buckling effect and to reduce the overall spring constant. From the numerical calculations and simulations, it is clear that the switch shows excellent isolation and insertion loss in the k-band. The meanders and ribs are designed so that the stiction problem in the switch can be reduced, and holes and slots in the membrane reduce the fringing fields and air resistance under the membrane, allowing the switching speed to be increased. The reliability of the switch can be approximated
Lager Image
von Mises stress showing deflection of 3 μm for applied force.
Lager Image
Spring constant k calculations for different membrane heights.
Lager Image
Pull-in voltage vs. gap g0 for different spring constant k.
by the von Mises stress analysis.
The switch operates at lower actuation voltage than other capacitive switches. This results in excellent RF response, which allows the switch to be used in applications where low power and low loss are a primary concerns, such as in wireless communication and space systems.
Performance analysis.
Lager Image
Performance analysis.
Peterson K. E. (1979) IBM J. Res. Develop. 23 376 -
Nguyen C. T. 1998 Center for Integrated Sensors & Circuits, Michigan Univ. The 11th Annual International Workshop on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems (Heidelberg) Ann Arbor, MI, USA Jan 25 - 29 1 -
Rebeiz G. M. 2003 RF MEMS Theory, Design and Technology John Wiley & Sons USA
Muldavin J. B. , Rebeiz G. M. (2000) IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Techn. 48 1053 -
Yao Z. J. , Chen S. , Eshelman E. , Denniston D. , Goldsmith C. L. (1999) IEEE J. Microelectromech. Systems 8 129 -
Pacheco S. P. , Katehi L. P. B. , Nguyen C. T. 2000 Radiat. Lab., Michigan Univ. Microwave Symposium Digest. 2000 IEEE MTT-S International (USA) Ann Arbor, MI, USA Jun 11-16 165 -
Ruan M. , Shen J. , Wheeler C. B. 2001 Micro Electro MechanicalSystems, 2001. MEMS 2011. Dept. of Electr. Eng., Arizona State Univ. The 14th IEEE International Conference on (USA) Tempe, AZ, USA Jan 21-25 224 -
Lee H. C. , Park J. H. , Park J. Y. , Nam H. J. , Bu J. U. (2005) Journal of Micromechanics and Microengineering 15 2098 -
Daneshmand M. , Fauladi S. , Mansour R. R. , Lisi M. , Stajcer T. 2009 Microwave to Millimeter-wave Lab., Univ. of Alberta Microwave Symposium Digest, 2009. MTT-S International (USA) Edmonton, AB, Canada Jun 07-12 1217 -
Spenger W. M. V. , Puers R. , Wolf I. D. (2003) J. Adhesion Sci. Technol. 17 563 -
Rocha L. A. , Cretu E. , Wolffenbuttel R. F. (2004) Nano Science and Tech. Inst. Tech. Proc. of the 2004 NSTI Nanotech. Conference and Trade Show (USA) Boston, MA 2004 Vol. 2 203 -
Badia M. F. , Butrado E. , Ionescu A. M. (2012) IEEE J. Microelectromech. Systems 21 1229 -
Muldavin J. B. , Rebeiz G. M. (2000) IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Techn. 48 1045 -
Zhang L. X. , Zhao Y. P. (2003) Microsys. Technol. 9 420 -
Goldsmith C. L. , Forehand D. I. (2005) IEEE Microw. Wireless Compon. Lett. 15 718 -
Wang G. , Ph.D. Dissertation 2006 RF MEMS switches with novel materials nd micromachiningtechniques for SOC/SOP RF front ends Georgia Institute of Technology Atlanta, GA Ph.D. Dissertation [1853/14112]