A study is presented of improved road light design for drivers and pedestrians with the use of a ray- or reverse raytracing method. Many existing road lights are unsuitable for drivers and pedestrians because of serious problems such as glare effect or randomicity of illuminated areas. This situation has arisen because in customary design methods the emphasis has been on simple factors such as luminance or electrical power. However a high luminance or electrical power consumption, alone, do not guarantee bright and good road lighting. So we have applied a ray-tracing method to the design of a road light reflector with the goals of ensuring that illuminated objects on the road can be seen more clearly and that the illuminating light is more comfortable for the eyes of drivers and pedestrians. We have set design targets for factors such as the uniformity of lighting on the road area per road light, the shading angles and the continuous luminance uniformity on long lengths of road. For set heights of the eyes of drivers and pedestrians eyes we have calculated a design guideline for the achievement of the above design targets. Then we designed a road light reflector using the reverse ray-tracing approach. Also we have achieved the same luminance on the road with almost half the power consumption, through the reduction of lighty loss. In an ideal design optimum parameters are suggested to be a shading angle of 75 degrees and a luminance uniformity of 0.5 on the road area. This reflector performance is achievable with a 250 watt power consumption ceramic discharge metal light source.
Recently, energy saving in public facilities has become very important. Most of public electrical power consumption is expended on lighting for drivers or pedestrians on the road during night time. It is most important that drivers recognize objects on the road during night time for the prevention of traffic accidents.However vehicle head lamps by themselves often provide insufficient luminance. So in many of countries standard guides have been set for road light luminance. Therefore, it is not always true that brighter light produces safer road conditions. It is more important that the road light be well tuned for drivers and pedestrians.i.e. the light can be made more comfortable for their eyes. It is also important to achieve this result with minimum power consumption. Much road lighting is tuned for high power consumption because it has been seriously misunderstood that brighter road lighting means safer road conditions. Also the search for brighter road lighting has been focused on the development of high power consumption lamps and the required circuit systems. However it is more important that lamp reflector design is optimized to reduce power consumption and at the same time provided proper luminance conditions on the road.
We have investigated an optimized lamp reflector design using a ray-tracing method
. The design results in definite energy saving effects such as 250 W ceramic discharge metal (CDM) lamp is capable of replacing a 400 W sodium lamp. The standard half-bowl shaped reflector design has been improved. Also the curves of luminance at a 180 degrees viewing angle are presented together with a realistic simulation of luminance on a road.
Conventional lamp reflector design: (a) mainmapping design,(b) cutting images of design.
Brightness characteristics on the road surface: (a) brightnesscharacteristics on the road surface, (b) brightness curve on the roadsurface.
Optimized lamp reflector design: (a) mainmapping design, (b)cutting images of design.
Finally the lighting conditions on a road have been calculated including the uniformity of lighting. The calculations calculated road condition and uniformity of road that by using an optimized reflector, road brightness uniformity is improved
. We considered a set the several road lights, and then investigated the continuous road brightness uniformity conditions
2. EXPERIMENTS AND RESULTS
Using the ray-tracing method, we designed a conventional half-bowl shaped lamp reflector and calculated the brightness characteristics on the road.
shows a traditional reflector design such as bowl shaped basic reflector of road light.
shows the role of reflection on the reflector parts, and
(a) shows that the brightness on the right bottom part of the designed road light.
(b) shows the horizontal brightness curve on the illuminated road. It is clearly recognized from Fig.2(b), that the luminance of the central point is 17 Lux and the average brightness was 6.7 Lux. Based on
the most serious defect is the edge part of the opening side. This part (displayed in red) produces many reflections from the CDM lamp.
We have improved the above design in the edge parts by the introduction of a cone shaped edge which is good for directing light to the road surface.
shows the improved design.
shows its improved brightness characteristics on the road surface. In this optimized design the central luminance was 40 Lux and the average brightness was 8.7 Lux. This result shows that improvement of lamp reflector is the major factor in road light design.
Finally, we have investigated an actual installation simulation.
shows the brightness characteristics on the road surface.The road light was set to a height of 12 meter and with a 2 meter distance from the pole to the light. Also the road surface area was set at 35 meter × 35 meter.
shows the brightness uniformity of the road surface at several road lamps installed at 35 meter intervals. We studied the improved road light design using the ray-tracing method. First, we presented the improved lamp reflector shape design, particularly improvements in the edge shape of the reflector. It produced significant improvements such as a central brightness of 40 Lux in the traditional half-bowl shape reflector. At the same time the average brightness was improved.Finally we presented a simulation result of actual road lighting conditions and reviewed the uniformity of several road lights under installed conditions.
Brightness curves on the road surface: (a) brightness characteristicson the road surface, (b) brightness curve at horizontal direction,(c) brightness curve at perpendicular direction.
Brightness characteristics of road surface.
Brightness uniformity at 3 lamps installed 35 meter intervals.
As a result, using optical simulation such as a ray-tracing method is a very significant method of road light reflector design.The method can achieve a high efficiency reflector design which both reduces power consumption whilst improving the amount and uniformity of the luminance on a road. So, optimized road light design is a necessary element of energy saving and improvement of the road environment at night time.
This research was supported by the science and research supporting program of Seoil University.
Principles of Optics: Electromagnetic Theoryof Propagation, Interference and Diffraction of Light
Lee S. M.
Choi H. W.
Lee M. G.
Min J. H.
Choi J. S.
Kim J. H.
Kim S. I.
Choi Y. S.
SID Symposium Digest
DOI : 10.1889/1.1832538
Ministry of Construction and Transportation
Standard of Road Design
Proceeding of International Display Workshop (IDW)