Correlation between Physical Defects and Performance in AlGaN/GaN High Electron Mobility Transistor Devices
Correlation between Physical Defects and Performance in AlGaN/GaN High Electron Mobility Transistor Devices
Transactions on Electrical and Electronic Materials. 2010. Apr, 11(2): 49-53
Copyright ©2010, The Korean Institute of Electrical and Electronic Material Engineers
  • Received : March 03, 2010
  • Published : April 25, 2010
Export by style
Cited by
About the Authors
Seong-Yong Park
Tae_Hun Lee
Moon-J. Kim
Microstructural origins of leakage current and physical degradation during operation in product-quality AlGaN/ GaN high electron mobility transistor (HEMT) devices were investigated using photon emission microscopy (PEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). AlGaN/GaN HEMTs were fabricated with metal organic chemical vapor deposition on semi-insulating SiC substrates. Photon emission irregularity, which is indicative of gate leakage current, was measured by PEM. Site specific TEM analysis assisted by a focused ion beam revealed the presence of threading dislocations in the channel below the gate at the position showing strong photon emissions. Observation of electrically degraded devices after life tests revealed crack/pit shaped defects next to the drain in the top AlGaN layer. The morphology of the defects was three-dimensionally investigated via electron tomography.
The AlGaN/GaN heterostructure exhibits advantageous materials properties such as wide band gap, superior carrier saturation velocity, thermal conductivity, and high breakdown field, which are required for high electron mobility transistor (HEMT). The AlGaN/GaN devices already show excellent performance in cell phone base stations and are promising candidates for power switching applications [1 -6] . Most research concerning HEMTs has focused on improving power output and power added efficiency. Improvements in materials design and process control make these devices the most commercially accepted.
Excellent performance of GaN devices can be obtained routinely. However, relatively large gate leakage current, which can degrade power efficiency and noise performance, in GaN based devices is one of many undesirable characteristics. Growth defects and the mesa edge that are in contact with gate metal have been regarded as leakage current sources [7 -10] . Photoluminescent emission is a useful technique in detecting photonic radiation from defect sites, primarily due to carrier recombination mechanisms. During device operation, defect sites emit light, which can be used identifying their locations.
Achieving acceptable device reliability and stability under continuous high performance operations is still required before commercialization. While several researchers have reported stable operation lives of more than 10 5 hours, these results are limited by relatively low frequencies and drain biases [5] . Reliability under high drain bias and high frequency conditions should be ensured before use in applications of high performance devices is considered. Although several mechanisms related to electrical degradation have been proposed, no clear explanation in terms of physical changes has yet been suggested.
In this study, in order to find the origin of gate leakage current, site specific transmission electron microscopy (TEM) analysis, in conjunction with photoemission microscopy (PEM) were used. We also report physical changes, using TEM and electron tomography, in AlGaN/GaN HEMTs after reliability tests. These results elucidate the correlation between device microstructure and its electrical properties.
The AlGaN/GaN heterostructure is epitaxially grown on a SiC substrate via metal organic chemical vapor deposition (MOCVD). The device structure consists of 3 nm GaN cap/16 nm Al 0.28 Ga 0.72 N/2 μm GaN buffer layer/1 nm AlN barrier. A Pt/ Au metal gate 0.25 μm in length was deposited via evaporation. Standard III-V commercial production processing technology of TriQuint Semiconductor Inc. was used to fabricate the devices. SiN x passivation was used to connect the source pads. Overall structure is illustrated in Fig. 1 . Standard structure of the device consists of four gate fingers with an air bridge connecting the sources (as shown in Fig. 4 ). Two-gated device without the air bridge was additionally fabricated for PEM tests in order to detect the emission from the gate (Fig. 2) .
Lager Image
Schematics of AlGaN/GaN high electron mobility transistor.
Photons with the infrared wave range of 1 to 3 μm were detected in PEM under bias conditions of V DS = 10 V, V GS = -5 V. The infrared images obtained via CCD camera were then overlaid with its corresponding optical images. Cross sectional TEM samples were prepared via the lift-out technique using a focused ion beam (FIB, FEI Nova200; FEI, Hillsboro, OR, USA) at positions corresponding to remarkable emission spots in PEM results. Bright field (BF) and high resolution TEM images were obtained with JEOL 2100F (JEOL Ltd., Tokyo, Japan).
For the accelerated DC life-tests, multi finger HEMT devices were subjected to stress under base-plate temperatures of 82, 112, and 142℃. A drain bias of 40 V and a time-zero drain current of 250 mA/mm were applied for 1,000 hours. Variations of drain current (I DQ ) and gate current (I GQ ) with time was recorded during tests. Device failure was defined as a drop in I Dma x of more than 10%. Cross sectional TEM samples, all from the center of gate fingers, were prepared from over 80 failed devices. To obtain more detailed data on defect morphology, three-dimensional electron tomography was applied by acquiring TEM images every one degree in tilt angle in a range from -70 o to 70 o .
- 3.1 Defect for leakage current
In devices manufactured via standard processes, few devices showed high gate leakage current which is not in the acceptable range. In order to find the origin of the high leakage current, site specific PEM and TEM analyses were conducted. Fig. 2(a) is a PEM image obtained from the device exhibiting high leakage current. Light emission mainly occurs at the gate in the drain side. The luminescence along the drain side can be explained by a potential drop at the gate edge due to a change in potential distribution between the gate and drain electrodes [8] . A strong localized emission was observed at spot A in the upper gate finger while a very weak or no emission was detected at spot B. The emission irregularities indicate that the distribution of the electric field is not uniform along the gate.
In order to discover the source of localized emissions, cross sectional TEM samples were prepared at spots A and B using FIB, as shown in Fig. 2(b) . BF TEM imaging was conducted along the <10-10>; crystal direction of GaN. Mixed type of dislocations with edge and screw components in the AlGaN/GaN layer were detected below the gate in the sample from spot A, as indicated by arrows in Fig. 3(a) . However, no dislocations were detected near the gate area in the sample from spot B, but dislocations were observed in the GaN layer near the interface with substrate (Figs. 3(b) and (c)) . After several measurements, we found that the spots exhibiting high photon emission levels always have dislocations below the gate area. Based on site specific TEM observation in conjunction with PEM, the dislocations near the channel area, especially below the gate, are the source of gate current leakage, which results in photon emission irregularity along the gate.
Lager Image
(a) PEM image showing light emission in the transistor channels; emission intensity increases toward red color as indicated color bar in the upper right corner. (b) Site specific sample preparation using focused ion beam at the positions indicated by arrows in (a).
Due to the 4% lattice mismatch between GaN and SiC substrate, high threading dislocation density is present in epitaxially grown GaN films, 10 7 -10 10 cm -2 [11 , 12] . These highly conductive dislocations are known to provide high leakage current pathway at room temperature [9] . Although the total density of threading dislocation has been reduced to within the range for acceptable device performance via improved processing technology, dislocation density is still higher than that of the other III-V compounds such as GaAs.
According to Bouya et al. [13] , the observed emission irregularity is due to surface defects between SiN passivation and semiconducting layers. They observed delamination of SiN layer in the gate-drain space using cross sectional SEM observations after FIB milling. Non uniform distribution of the electric field, due to surface defects, was identified as the cause of emission irregularity. However, in our study, delamination of the passivation layer was not detected during FIB sectioning and TEM observation, indicating that the delamination is not the origin of gate leakage current in our case.
Lager Image
(a) and (b) cross sectional bright field (BF) TEM images prepared at the spot A and B in the Fig. 2(a), respectively. Inset in the lower left of (a) is a selected area diffraction pattern from GaN. (c) Lower magnification BF image of (b) showing entire GaN layer.
- 3.2 Physical degradation after reliability test
For the reliability test, four fingers packaged HEMTs with a configuration of 400 μm total gate length and source air bridge were used as shown in Fig. 4 . Fig. 5 shows the typical degradation of electrical properties during the tests. The decrease in I Dmax was used as a barometer to delineate the degree of electrical degradation. TEM analyses were conducted at the middle of the center gate finger since the area has the geometrically lowest cooling efficiency, resulting in the highest joule heating temperature. The results revealed that electrically degraded devices always contain a pit/crack shaped defect at the gate edge in the top AlGaN layer, as shown in Fig. 6 . A vertical crack propagates through the interface between AlGaN and GaN layer. Degradation of the AlGaN crystal structure just below the gate is indicative of the damage to the AlGaN channel layer. In the cases where devices showed minimal degradation, a shallow pit is observed only in the drain side. In contrast, severely degraded devices always have a large pit/crack in the drain side. Previously we reported a strong correlation between the degree of physical damage and the drain current (I Dmax ) degradation in terms of 'disfiguration factor' [14] . The concentration of temperature increase, strain development, and carrier traps on the drain side [15 -17] is an indication of drain side, gate edge defect formation.
Lager Image
Top view SEM image of high electron mobility transistor devices used in the reliability test. Transmission electron microscopy sample was prepared at the middle of center finger as indicated by red dotted line.
Lager Image
Evolution of drain current (IDQ) during the reliability test under a 40 V drain bias and maximum drain current (IDmax) recorded every hour under a 5 V drain bias and 1 V gate bias.
Lager Image
Cross sectional high resolution electron microscope(HREM) image showing a defect formed in the channel under gate edge in drain side.Fig. 6. Cross sectional high resolution electron microscope(HREM) image showing a defect formed in the channel under gate edge in drain side.
A drawback of TEM analysis is that the two dimensional image may lead to an incorrect interpretation of overall sample geometry. Thus, the application of the three dimensional tomography provides more accurate and detailed information about defects observed in TEM images. TEM images acquired in every one degree in tilt angle from -70° to 70° were reconstructed into a single three dimensional feature. Figure 7 is a snapshot from the reconstructed video showing the three-dimensional morphology of the defect displayed in Fig. 6 . The crack that has formed in the channel extends for the entire thickness of the TEM lamella, as indicated by the arrow. The crack detected at the center of the gate finger was also observed in multiple sections along the gate finger, indicating that physical features of a sample are representative of the physical features of the whole device [18] . Furthermore, tomography shows a more unclear interface between the channel and gate metal than that between the AlGaN and passivation layer. Surface defects of channels are found only in devices with severe electrical property degradation.
Several mechanisms for HEMT device degradation during operation have been suggested. However, there is no mechanism that sufficiently explains all the observed physical damage. It is known that AlGaN layer grown on GaN has a tensile in-plane misfit strain [19] . The tensile strain may account for the greater crack width in the AlGaN layer than that of the GaN layer. In addition, applied voltage in the AlGaN/GaN HEMTs causes the greatest amount of inverse piezoelectric strain/stress near the gate edge on the device [17] . Based on our observations, we believe that accumulated in-plane stress, a combination of the misfit strain and the inverse piezoelectric effect in the channel, is responsible for physical degradation of HEMT devices. However, this mechanism cannot sufficiently account for the formation of round pits in minimally degraded devices.
Device lifetimes showed significant sample to sample variation. Even devices fabricated by identical processes on the same wafer showed extremely high variation in lifetimes [18] . Also, as described earlier, the irregular leakage current was observed by PEM. Threading dislocations in the channel area below the gate are suspected to be the main pathways for gate leakage current. Leakage current and degradation during operation are believed to be related with stress/strain developed in channel layer. However, we could not, as of yet, find a direct correlation between these phenomena. The irregular leakage current and lifetime in GaN HEMT devices need to be further investigated to improve their performance and reliability.
Lager Image
TEM tomography image showing three dimensional morphology of the defect observed in Fig. 6.
The origin of gate leakage current and electrical properties degradation during life test in production quality AlGaN/GaN HEMT devices were investigated by various microscopy techniques. Irregular light emission along the gate was detected in the devices by PEM, indicating high leakage current. Site specific TEM analyses revealed that threading dislocations in the channel area below the gate, resulting from lattice mismatch with the substrates, act as high leakage current pathways. After reliability tests of devices under a high drain bias of 40 V, physical defects, such as pits and cracks, under the drain next to the gate, were observed in the electrically degraded devices. There is a strong correlation between the degree of physical damage and the degradation of electrical properties. Leakage current and reliability of HEMTs involve mechanical stress in the channel area.
This work was supported in part by the U.S. Defense Advanced Research Project Agency and Army Research Laboratory, ARL contract no. W911QX-05-C-0087. The authors thank TriQuint Semiconductor Inc. for device fabrication and reliability tests.
Wu Y.F , Saxler A , Moore M , Smith R.P , Sheppard S , Chavarkar P.M , Wisleder T , Mishra U.K , Parikh P 2004 30-W/mm GaN HEMTs by field plate optimization Electron Device Letters IEEE 25 117 -
Delage S. L , Dua C 2003 Microelectron Reliab 43 1705 -
Meneghesso G , Verzellesi G , Danesin F , Rampazzo F , Zanon F , Tazzoli A , Meneghini M , Zanoni E 2008 IEEE Trans Dev Mat Rel 8 332 -
Shen U. K , Kazior L , Yi-Feng T. E , Li W , Chaudhari A , Hanson A. W , Therrien R , Johnson J. W , Nagy W , Marquart J , Rajagopal J , Roberts 2008 Proc IEEE 96 287 -
Singhal S , Li T , Chaudhari A , Hanson A. W , Therrien R , Johnson J. W , Nagy W , Marquart J , Rajagopal P , Roberts J. C , Piner E. L , Kizilyalli I. C , Linthicum K. J 2006 Microelectron Reliab 46 1247 -
Jung K. M , Lee Y. S , Kim S. J , Kim D. H , Kim J. M , Choi H. G , Hahn C.K , Kim T. G 2008 J KIEEME 21 885 -
Kim H , Lee J , Liu D , Lu W 2005 Appl Phys Lett 86 143505 -
Mizuno S , Ohno Y , Kishimoto S , Maezawa K , Mizutani T 2002 Jpn J Appl Phys 41 5125 -
Zhang H , Miller E. J , Yu E. T 2006 J Appl Phys 99 023703 -
Hsu J. W. P , Manfra M. J , Molnar R. J , Heying B , Speck J. S 2002 Appl Phys Lett 81 79 -
Faleev N , Temkin H , Ahmad I , Holtz M , Melnik Y 2005 J Appl Phys 98 123508 -
Weimann N. G , Eastman L. F , Doppalapudi D , Ng H. M , Moustakas T. D 1998 J Appl Phys 83 3656 -
Bouya M , Carisetti D , Malbert N , Labat N , Perdu P , Clement J. C , Bonnet M , Pataut G 2007 Microelectron Reliab 47 1630 -
Chowdhury U , Jimenez J. L , Lee C , Beam E , Saunier P , Balistreri T , Seong-Yong P , Taehun L , Wang J , Kim M. J , Jungwoo J , del Alamo J. A 2008 IEEE Electron Device Lett 29 1098 -
Koudymov A , Shur M. S , Simin G 2007 IEEE Electron Device Lett 28 332 -
McAlister S. P 2007 Solid-State Electron 51 142 -
Sarua A , Ji H , Kuball M , Uren M. J , Martin T , Nash K. J , Hilton K. P , Balmer R. S 2006 Appl Phys Lett 88 103502 -
Park Park , Floresca C , Chowdhury U , Jimenez J. L , Lee C , Beam E , Saunier P , Balistreri T , Kim M. J 2009 Microelectron Reliab 49 478 -
Lee S. R , Koleske D. D , Cross K. C , Floro J. A , Waldrip K. E , Wise A. T , Mahajan S 2004 Appl Phys Lett 85 6164 -