The collapse of Langmuir monolayers of arachidic acid (AA) on water at various rates of molecular area compression has been investigated
by imaging ellipsometry (IE). The thickness of the collapsed AA molecules, which are inherently inhomogeneous, was determined by IE with a spatial resolution of a few microns. For the analysis, we determined the dielectric function of AA monolayers from 380 to 1690 nm by conventional spectroscopic ellipsometry. Compression rates ranged from 0.23 to 0.94 Å
/min. A change of multilayer domains was observed in the
IE images. Lower compression rates resulted in more uniform collapsed films. Our experimental results correspond with previous theoretical simulations.
Langmuir monolayers provide a unique means to study two-dimensional (2D) materials at asymmetric interfaces. Investigations of Langmuir monolayers have uncovered a rich variety of physical phenomena
. When a 2D film is compressed to its stability limit, it explores the third dimension by collapse. 2D monolayers of a large number of amphiphiles transform into overgrown 3D structures in a state of metastability and supersaturation
. The mode of collapse can be tuned by varying the mechanical properties of the film. Understanding this 2D-to-3D transition is of great importance, as it provides insight into the origin and nature of defects in thin films such as the biological films that protect our eyes
, and the inner surface of our lungs
The more common system of fatty-acid Langmuir monolayers forms very rigid films at high pressures, and one can imagine their behavior upon collapse would be different from that of monolayers of lung surfactant
. The microscopy and rheology of the collapse phenomenon in a single-component system of fatty acids is a simpler problem, one that has allowed the folding and collapse phenomena to be modeled
. The changes in structure of collapsed films of fatty acid molecules having different chain lengths under different compression rates, temperatures, and subphase conditions (pH and salt species) have also been investigated
isotherms and the structure of the collapsed films are strongly affected by these various experimental parameters.
In this work we focus on the effect of compression rate. We use imaging ellipsometry (IE)
to characterize monolayer collapse physically as a function of the rate of molecular area compression from 0.23 to 0.94 Å
/min per molecule. IE is a noninvasive,
technique, unlike electron microscopy or atomic force microscopy. However, in contrast to conventional ellipsometry, which measures the average property of the surface over the size of the probe beam, IE obtains local ellipsometric values of the size of an image with a spatial resolution of a few μm, depending on the optics used. These values can be converted to film thicknesses at the same resolution. Whereas fluorescence microscopy
or Brewster-angle microscopy can also provide 2D images of collapsed films, the ellipsometric method that we use in this study adds value by yielding information about the third dimension of the individual domains, specifically their thicknesses.
For numerous insoluble monolayers, π-
isotherms of amphiphiles are in a metastable state above the equilibrium surface pressure. Thus in our studies we used IE to determine the changes in structure of the collapsed films as a function of the rate of molecular area compression. As expected, the surface after collapse was found to be very inhomogeneous, with coexisting regions of monolayer and multilayer films.
Arachidic acid (CH
COOH, ≥99%, AA for short) is a saturated fatty acid with a carbon chain of 20 atoms. Our material was purchased from Sigma-Aldrich. AA was suspended and stored in a chloroform/methanol (HLPC grade, Sigma-Aldrich) 3:1 mixture in a freezer (−20℃) until use. It was spread onto organic-free deionized water of high resistivity (18.2 MΩ·cm, pH 5.7) in a custom-built Langmuir trough. Compression was begun about 15 minutes after spreading to ensure complete evaporation of the solvent. The Langmuir trough was put in the sample position of the IE and the surface was imaged
as the AA film progressed from a monolayer to multilayers. All IE measurements were carried out at room temperature (20℃). The rate of molecular area compression ranged from 0.23 to 0.94 Å
/min per molecule and was controlled by varying the speed of the barrier motor.
The IE used in this experiment was a rotating retarder type, manufactured by Beaglehole Instruments, Inc., New Zealand. The configuration is shown in
. The wavelength was 632.8 nm and the angle of incidence (AOI) was 53.18°, which is the Brewster angle of water. The measured image covered a sample area of 1.8 × 2.7 mm with 200 × 500 pixels. An objective lens with a large numerical aperture (NA) would collect the light from the sample over a wider angular range, but also would increase the uncertainty of the incidence and reflection angles and thus decrease the resolution in the vertical direction (see the IE image of
). To compromise between horizontal and vertical resolutions, the numerical aperture was kept at ~0.18. In this configuration each pixel corresponds to ~9 and ~5.4 μm for the vertical and the horizontal lengths respectively, for a wavelength of 632.8 nm. To avoid a large AOI error, we used a test beam a few mm in size in the vertical direction. The error bound of AOI is about ±0.6°. To minimize uncertainty, we averaged 11 chargecoupled device (CCD) images taken at analyzer angles of +45° and −45°. Typical exposure time was 100 ms for each CCD image. It takes 20 seconds to measure one frame of an IE image.
Schematic diagram of the IE configuration with a Langmuir trough.
III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
isotherms of an AA Langmuir monolayer on water, measured using the Wilhelmy plate method with compression rates from 0.23 to 0.94 Å
/min per molecule. The isotherms are in good agreement with those in previous reports
. Before collapse, the onset point of an area of about 25 Å
per molecule and tilted-untilted transition pressure (
) area of 20.5 Å
per molecule are similar to those in previous reports. After collapse, the isotherms exhibit higher values of surface pressure with increasing compression rate. A transition from a surface pressure “spike” to a “plateau” was induced by faster compression at maximum surface pressure (
. IE measurements were performed
after film collapse to obtain images on the monolayer scale of the film undergoing collapse.
π· A isotherm of arachidic acid on water.
For the analysis of the collapsed monolayers, the dielectric function of AA is required. We obtained this using conventional spectroscopic ellipsometry (SE)
. SE measures Ψ and Δ, which are determined from the ratio of the complex reflectances of
-polarized light and can be converted to the pseudodielectric function <
> = <
> given as
is the AOI and
indicate the complex reflectances for
-polarized light respectively. Using the Langmuir trough we made an AA monolayer of area 19 Å
/molecule, then acquired
SE data using a model RC2 SE instrument (J. A. Woollam Co., USA). The original data bear information about both the complex refractive index (
) and the film thickness. Here
. To obtain
and thickness of the AA film, we fitted the data using a multilayer calculation
with a three-phase model consisting of air, the AA monolayer, and water. We adjusted the fitting parameters to minimize the mean square error (MSE) which is defined as
where the number of measured Ψ and Δ pairs is
, the total number of real-valued fit parameters is
are the experimental errors of Ψ and Δ respectively. A Cauchy dispersion relation
was used to represent the dielectric function of the monolayer. With this procedure we obtained the dielectric function of AA from 380 to 1690 nm. The calculated AA monolayer thickness was 28.0 ± 1.5 Å, in good agreement with previous reports
. In previous work
data were obtained only at 632.8 nm, where a refractive index
= 1.4461 and extinction coefficient
= 0 were found. We emphasize that we observe not only a similar refractive index at 632.8 nm but also the entire dielectric function of AA over a much wider spectral range.
shows the refractive index
and real part of the dielectric function
of AA that we obtained.
The refractive index and dielectric function ( ε1 ) of an AA monolayer.
In IE we measured the same parameters introduced for conventional SE above, but a two-dimensional array of the pairs of ellipsometric parameters (Ψ, Δ) are obtained over the sample surface, which assess the properties of the sample at the scale of the resolution of the image. Thus IE is particularly suitable for probing the third dimension of the inhomogeneous layer
. For layers appreciably thinner than the wavelength of the probing light, Δ is sensitive to change in layer thickness, while the Ψ value is hardly affected
= 1.44 for AA and
= 1.33 for water at 632.8 nm, the connection between Δ and thickness is shown in
. To obtain the relationship, we calculated total reflectances of
with a threephase model (air/AA layer/water), varying the AA layer thickness using a multilayer calculation
, and therefore the Δ values for different thicknesses can be extracted from Eq. (1). Thus all our IE images are those of Δ. To better visualize the thicknesses of the collapsed regions, mono-, bi-, tri-, and multilayer regions are color-coded separately with the boundary values of Δ set at the respective midpoints: Δ = 56, 72, 82, and >82° for mono- (28 Å), bi- (50 Å), tri- (75 Å), and multilayers (>75 Å), as shown in
. The monolayer thickness was taken from our conventional SE result, while the thicknesses for bi- and trilayers are obtained from published x-ray and neutron reflectance measurements
. The monolayer thickness corresponds to the length of the all-trans AA molecule, while the thicknesses for bi- and trilayers are slightly smaller than twice and three times of the AA monolayer length.
Calculated layer thickness vs. Δ. The blue, green, red, and yellow colors correspond to mono-, bi-, tri-, and multilayer regions, respectively.
shows Δ images of 200×500 pixels of AA monolayers with several different values of molecular areas in condensed and after-collapse states for areas per molecule of 19.5, 18.6, and 17.5 Å2, respectively. The compression was performed in the vertical direction of the presented IE images. In
, the overall blue color of the images indicates that the surface is covered by a monolayer. As the molecular area decreases, a careful examination of
shows that small dots with Δ values appreciably higher than those of the monolayer begin to appear, indicating that the layer thickness is not uniform over our detection area of 1.8 × 2.7 mm. This can be understood as the coexistence of the condensed phase (blue regions) and the collapsed phase (dark green regions). We statistically analyzed the data for the distribution of the AA layer thickness in corresponding areas.
shows the pixel histograms of the corresponding image of
, which consists of 0.1 million CCD pixels. We counted the pixels of equal Δ values with equidistant intervals of 1°, because the Δ is the original experimental data. In
the histogram indicates the distribution of film thicknesses within the probed area. We label the
-axis with thicknesses for clarity, using the relation obtained in
. As shown in
, the center value of the histogram corresponds to the thickness of the monolayer dm, and the peak widths correspond to the thickness variation over the probed area. The uniform distribution indicates the credibility of the IE data.
Δ images for initially condensed states and those after collapse at different per-molecule compression rates. (a), (b), and (c) are at 0.23 Å2/min, (d), (e), and (f) are at 0.69 Å2/min, and (g), (h), and (i) are at 0.94 Å2/min. The per-molecule areas of (a), (d), (g) are 19.5 Å2, (b), (e), (h) are 18.6 Å2, and (c), (f), (i) are 17.5 Å2.
Histograms of the thicknesses corresponding to the image of Fig. 5(a).
presents a collection of Δ images in the collapsed phase (
), and (
), which correspond to per-molecule compression rates of 0.23, 0.69, and 0.94 Å
/min respectively. The area per molecule in
is 15.6 Å
, that in
is 13.4 Å
, and that in
is 11.5 Å
shows that some green regions with Δ values appreciably higher than that of the monolayer are present. The image of
/min per molecule compression rate) shows only a few small, collapsed dark green domains. Increasing the compression rate yields many more collapsed light green domains, appearing particularly in
/min) and (g) (0.94 Å
/min). Bilayer domains, appearing in green, increase as the film is further compressed. At the compression rate of 0.94 Å
/min some trilayer domains (red) become more numerous, as shown in
. Very large Δ values are associated with multilayers. Consequently, the green and red dots in
are assigned to the spontaneous formation of multilayers
Δ images after collapse at different per-molecule compression rates: (a), (b), and (c) are at 0.23 Å2/min, (d), (e), and (f) are at 0.69 Å2/min, and (g), (h), and (i) are at 0.94 Å2/min. The per-molecule area of (a), (d), (g) is 15.6 Å2, of (b), (e), (h) is 13.4 Å2, and of (c), (f), (i) is 11.5 Å2.
The molecular mechanism assumes that over compression leads to bilayer domains merging with monolayer parts, yielding trilayer domains
. Consistent with the simulation of Ref.
for AA on water, additional AA molecules move onto the AA monolayers, while at the same time head groups of AA molecules combine with each other due to hydrogen bonding. Upon further compression, more AA molecules are present and strong van der Waals forces cluster the hydrogen-bonded AA molecules into trilayers. According to Ref.
the combination of AA head groups yields bilayers, which form “towers”, thereby making trilayers on monolayers. Our experimental results correspond more closely to the theoretical simulations in Ref.
It is clear that compression rates strongly affect the formation of multilayers. As expected, molecules that are moved more slowly, i.e., at smaller compression rates, yield more stable multilayers. Moreover, the collapsed regions in
are similar in shape to the light-blue regions associated with water, indicating that molecules in nearby monolayer domains are a reservoir for forming multilayer domains, as shown in a previous report
shows the corresponding histograms for the images of
the thicknesses have a wider distribution than in
, which means that the monolayers have collapsed and been transformed to multilayers. The histograms exhibit increasing widths and larger thicknesses with decreasing surface area.
Histograms of the thicknesses corresponding to the maps of Fig. 7.
It is interesting to note that the tails of
differ significantly, as shown in
, where only the right-hand-side tail parts are compared carefully. In the case of a small compression rate of 0.23 Å
/min (red striped bar) the tail ends quickly, meaning that relatively uniform layers are formed. However, when the compression rate is high (white bar), the tail reaches the maximum thickness value, nearly 60 Å, showing the existence of thick multiple layers. This clearly suggests that AA monolayers spontaneously form multilayer domains more easily at higher compression rate.
Enlargement of the right-hand-side tails of the histograms in Fig. 8, panels (a) (red striped bars), (d) (blue bars), and (g) (white bars).
shows the fully collapsed morphology of films with surface areas reduced to 10.4 and 9.5 Å
/molecule. This molecular area is approximately half of the area of the intact monolayer and could not be reduced further, due to the limitations of the trough and the beam geometry of our IE configuration. The image shows that the film is indeed very inhomogeneous, being covered by spatially separated multilayer domains. The average collapsed layer thickness is more uniform for films compressed at a slower rate. Clearly the different compression rates affect both the underlying domain structure and the collapsed phase.
Δ images after collapse for different per-molecule compression rates. (a) and (b) are at 0.23 Å2/min; (c) and (d) are at 0.69 Å2/min; and (e) and (f) are at 0.94 Å2/min. The per-molecule area of (a), (c), (e) is 10.4 Å2 and of (b), (d), (f) is 9.5 Å2.
shows the corresponding histograms for the images of
. To analyze the thicknesses of these samples more quantitatively, the histograms were fitted with multipeak Gaussian functions. Initially we tried to use only three peaks with
values fixed at those corresponding to the thicknesses of mono-, bi-, and trilayers, but it immediately became clear that additional peaks at lower and higher
values were needed to achieve a reasonable fit, indicating that multilayer formation necessarily involves peaks of thicknesses different from those of collapsed monolayers and bilayers. We then allowed the
values to vary; the results are shown as the solid lines in
. The agreement is excellent. The AA layer thicknesses found by fitting are not integer multiples of the monolayer thickness, indicating that the molecules in the multilayers are not oriented parallel to the surface normal
. The fitting parameters yielding the Gaussian peak positions in
are listed in
. We note that small magnitudes of uncertainty in all the parameter values suggest the uniqueness of the fitting, supporting the current analysis. For the image in
the thicknesses for the lower compression rate are relatively uniform, while for the higher compression rates of
, the thicknesses are more random. It is clear that collapse is a kinetic process, and the compression history changes the structure of the films substantially.
Histograms of the thicknesses corresponding to the maps of Fig. 10. The fitting functions are Gaussians.
The fitting parameters of the Gaussian peak positionsd0and uncertainties inFigs. 11(b), (d), and (f)of the case of per-molecule area of 9.5 Å2
The fitting parameters of the Gaussian peak positions d0 and uncertainties in Figs. 11(b), (d), and (f) of the case of per-molecule area of 9.5 Å2
Using IE, we observed detailed images of the thicknesses of AA molecular films on water after collapse with per-molecule compression rates of 0.23, 0.69, and 0.94 Å
/min. To analyze the thicknesses of the AA Langmuir layers we obtained the refractive index of an AA monolayer by conventional SE. The images show that some regions of the monolayer undergo spontaneous collapse more readily at higher compression rates. As the film is further compressed, multilayer domains form and grow as the surface area available to the film decreases. The analysis of the image at the smallest nominal molecular area of 9.5 Å
/molecule indicates that the thickness of collapsed film is more uniform at slower compression rates. In other words, under faster compression rate the film has no time for relaxation to form multiple layers of high thickness. Therefore, this observation suggests the existence of some relaxation mechanism of the AA film, indicating that a further study of the effect of compression rate using IE is needed, to analyze the relaxation time of the film. We find that its imaging capability makes SE an excellent method for studying inhomogeneities in such a system. We expect that in the future SE will find many applications in examining a wide range of subjects such as nucleation, domain structure, and film collapse.
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available online.
This work was supported by the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) grant funded by the Korea government (MSIP) (2013-016297). We thank D. E. Aspnes for useful discussions.
McConnell H. M.
Structures and transitions in lipid monolayers at the air-water interface
Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem.
Knobler C. M.
Phase transitions in monolayers
Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem.
Surfactant layers at water surfaces
Rep. Prog. Phys.
Different adsorption behavior of rare earth and metallic ion complexes on Langmuir monolayers probed by sum-frequency generation spectroscopy
J. Opt. Soc. Korea
Nucleation in monolayers
Adv. Colloid Interface Sci.
Glasgow B. J.
Gasymov O. K.
Abduragimov A. R.
Yusifov T. N.
Knobler C. M.
Tear lipocalins: Potential lipid scavengers for the corneal surface
Investig. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci.
Greiner J. V.
Korb D. R.
Leahy C. D.
Phospholipids in Meibomian gland secretion
Surfactant in middle ear effusions
Otolaryngol. Head Neck Surg.
Hills B. A.
Hydrophobic lining of the Eustachian tube imparted by surfactant
The role of lipids in pulmonary surfactant
Biochim. Biophys. Acta
Lipid compositional analysis of pulmonary surfactant monolayers and monolayer-associated reservoirs
J. Lipid Res.
Biochim. Biophys. Acta
Lee K. Y. C.
Collapse mechanisms of Langmuir monolayers
Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem.
Knober C. M.
Collapse of a monolayer by three mechanisms
J. Phys. Chem. B
Knobler C. M.
Bruinsma R. F.
Folding Langmuir monolayers
Phys. Rev. Lett.
What is the characteristic time of measurement of π-A isotherms? Necessity of a constant strain rate of compression of insoluble monolayers for π-A measurements
The “time of observation” of π-A isotherms. 2. A possibility that so-called “solid films” in π-A isotherms of monolayers of longchain acids may not correspond to the two-dimensional solids but to the first-order phase transition regions from two-dimensional liquids to solids
The time of observation of π-A isotherms III Studies on the morphology of arachidic acid monolayers observed by transmission electron microscopy of replica samples of one-layer Langmuir-Blodgett films using plasma-polymerization
Thin Solid Films
Ionov R. J.
2D-3D transformations of amphiphilic monolayers influenced by intermolecular interactions: A Brewster angle microscopy study
J. Phys. Chem.
Satija S. K.
Ordering by collapse: Formation of bilayer and trilayer crystals by folding Langmuir monolayers
Kim T. J.
Hwang S. Y.
Kim Y. D.
Imaging of collapsed fatty acid films at air-water interfaces
Bae Y. M.
Oh B. K.
Lee W. H.
Choi J. W.
Immunosensor for detection of Yersinia enterocolitica based on imaging ellipsometry
Choi A. J.
Ghong T. H.
Kim Y. D.
Oh J. H.
Imaging ellipsometry study on the Ni-mediated crystallization of a-Si
J. Appl. Phys.
In situ fluorescence optical detection using a digital micromirror device (DMD) for 3D cell-based assays
J. Opt. Soc. Korea
Russev S. C.
Simultaneous thickness and refractive index determination of monolayers deposited on an aqueous subphase by null ellipsometry
Aspnes D. E.
Studna A. A.
High precision scanning Ellipsometer
Azzam R. M. A.
Bashara N. M.
Ellipsometry and Polarized Light, Chapter 4
Jenkins F. A.
White H. E.
Fundamentals of Optics
Helm C. A.
Synchrotron x-ray diffraction and reflection studies of arachidic acid monolayers at the airwater interface
J. Phys. Chem.
Howland M. C.
Szmodis A. W.
Parikh A. N.
Characterization of physical properties of supported phospholipid membranes using imaging ellipsometry at optical wavelengths
Ellipsometric microscopy Imaging monomolecular surfactant layers at the air-water interface
Lorenz C. D.
Atomistic simulations of Langmuir monolayer collapse
Ries Jr. H. E.
Electron microscope and pressure-area studies on a gramicidin and its binary mixtures with cerebronic acid cholesterol and valinomycin
Bilayer and trilayer crystalline formation by collapsing behenic acid monolayers at gas/ aqueous interfaces