The Variation of Radiation Transmittance by the cw 1.07 μm Fiber Laser and Water Aerosol Interaction
The Variation of Radiation Transmittance by the cw 1.07 μm Fiber Laser and Water Aerosol Interaction
Journal of the Optical Society of Korea. 2012. Sep, 16(3): 191-195
Copyright ©2012, Optical Society of Korea
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available online.
  • Received : June 06, 2012
  • Accepted : July 07, 2012
  • Published : September 25, 2012
Export by style
Cited by
About the Authors
Hae Seog Koh
Future Technology Research Directorate, Defense Advanced R&D Center, Agency for Defense Development, Yuseong P.O. Box 35, Daejeon 305-600, Korea
Wan Soon Shin
Future Technology Research Directorate, Defense Advanced R&D Center, Agency for Defense Development, Yuseong P.O. Box 35, Daejeon 305-600, Korea
Min Yong Jeon
Department of Physics, Chungnam National University, Daejeon 305-764, Korea
Byung Suh Park
Future Technology Research Directorate, Defense Advanced R&D Center, Agency for Defense Development, Yuseong P.O. Box 35, Daejeon 305-600, Korea
Among the atmospheric effect of laser propagation, the variations of the radiation transmittance by water aerosol evaporation have quantitatively been investigated. When the aerosol was exposed by a 1.07 μm cw fiber laser, the increased amount of the transmittance variation was a maximum of 19.1% and the volume concentration variation of aerosol was observed as an increasing of laser intensity. Also, significant irregularity of refractive index was not found in the heated area during the continuous laser heating.
The laser interaction with water aerosols brings as a result the attenuation of laser energy by scattering and absorption. The absorbed energy consequently raises the temperature of water droplets when the aerosol is exposed by a high power laser. If the temperature increase is significant, the droplets will begin to evaporate. At the same time, the change in the droplet size further alters the radiation transmittance. The interaction of a high power laser with water droplets is an important topic in the study of atmospheric propagation [1 - 6] .
It has been reported by the previous papers that two evaporation extremes of heated aerosol by heating laser are known to occur. For a highly intense beam, it is the explosive vaporization regime, in which droplet deformation and shattering may occur. At the other extreme, droplet interaction with less intense beams falls into what may be termed as the slow evaporation regime, where the droplet evaporation occurs at its surface [7 - 11] .
In this paper the intensity and profile variation of the laser by aerosol evaporation are investigated and subsequent variation in the radiation transmittance is observed to understand the cw laser interaction with water aerosol.
By assuming spherical symmetry, the laser heating property is represented by the thermal diffusion equation (1),
Lager Image
where c is the specific heat at constant pressure, ρ is the fluid density, T is the temperature, K is the thermal conductivity, r is the radius,
Lager Image
is the heat production distribution, Re ( n ) and Im ( n ) are the real and imaginary parts of the refractive index of water, respectively, λ 0 is the wavelength of the incident laser, I is the input irradiance, and
Lager Image
is the normalized source function with the electric field
Lager Image
at a given point and the electric field
Lager Image
of the incident laser beam.
It is possible to estimate the critical irradiance Isf which divides the slow and fast heating using the two terms of the right hand side in equation (1). The terms represent the thermal diffusion and heating terms respectively [9] . Using these relations we can deduce the critical irradiance shown in equation (2), where Δ T is the temperature variation corresponding to the radial variation Δ R . It is shown that Isf depends upon the absorption coefficient and droplet radius variation as,
Lager Image
For the case of the interaction between water droplet of radius R 0 =6 μm and a 2.08 μm heating laser, the calculated Isf are approximately 10 3 W/cm 2 . For 1.07 μm wavelength, the fast heating may occur in laser intensity more than 10 8 W/cm 2 . The difference between the two cases is due to the absorptivity according to the wavelength.
In order to investigate the water aerosol evaporation effect in laser propagation, first it is necessary to identify the particle size and volume concentration, the volume of aerosol particles per unit volume, of water aerosol in the test chamber. A schematic of the experimental setup to measure particle size and volume concentration of water aerosol is shown in Fig. 1 . The chamber which is 34 mm width and 100 mm length is located within the particle sizer (System 2600 LC, Malvern Instruments). The particle sizer measures size and obscuration, the portion of aerosol area obscured, of aerosol generated by an aerosol generator (DRW-2000). At the same time, the transmittance was measured by the silicon detector (PD300, Ophir) and 543.5 nm wavelength cw green laser (dia. 0.8 mm, Melles Griot) is used as a probing laser.
The measured average particle size was 6 μm and particle volume concentration was obtained from the measured obscuration and particle size. The relationship between particle
Lager Image
Particle size and volume concentration measurement setup.
volume concentration and measured obscuration is shown in Fig. 2 . The measured transmittance as a function of the particle volume concentration and its polynomial fitting is shown in Fig. 3 . From those results, it is possible to estimate the variation of volume concentration in each test.
In order to investigate the water aerosol effect by highenergy laser heating, another experimental setup was constructed as shown in Fig. 4 . As a heating laser, a 1.07 μm wavelength single-mode cw fiber laser (IPG Photonics Inc) with a power of 1 kW and beam diameter of 5.85 cm was used. Maximum intensity of the heating laser is 7.5 × 10 3 W/cm 2 (This is the value of the middle area of the beam profile.). It is too low a value to investigate the effect of fast heating. Despite slight differences between these experimental conditions and prerequisites for calculation, it is of course considered that this experiment can be regarded as a slow heating regime. The 543.5 nm wavelength cw green laser is used as a probing laser to measure the variation in the transmittance of aerosol.
Because the probing laser has the same path as the heating laser in the chamber and its diameter is smaller than that of the heating laser beam, it will pass through the center of heated path exposed by the heating laser. The dichroic beam splitters (HR at 1.07 μm, AR at 543.5 nm, incident
Lager Image
Relationship between volume concentration and obscuration.
Lager Image
Measured transmittance as a function of the particle volume concentration.
Lager Image
Transmittance variation measurement setup by the heating laser.
Lager Image
Power variation of aerosol by the heating laser. (a) No aerosol, 6.0 kW/cm2 heating laser intensity, (b)~(f) 1.5 kW/cm2, 3.0 kW/cm2, 4.5 kW/cm2, 6.0 kW/cm2 and 7.5 kW/cm2 heating laser respectively.
angle 45°) are used to separate two beams and minimize the power which enters the power meter directly from the heating laser. The power disturbance due to the retro-reflection or scattering of the heating laser over the path is measured in the vacant chamber and the result is shown in Fig. 5 (a). It is estimated that the disturbance is as small as about 0.6% of measured power, so we make sure that the direct backward power from the heating laser is not large enough to affect the results. The power variation with heating laser intensity 1.5 kW/cm 2 , 3.0 kW/cm 2 , 4.5 kW/cm 2 , 6.0 kW/cm 2 and 7.5 kW/cm 2 are shown in Fig. 5 (b)~(f) respectively. While the heating laser irradiates a path through the aerosol chamber, the measured power of the probing beam is significantly increased in proportion to the heating laser intensity.
Aside from the above, it is observed that there are time delays of the power response about 0.5 seconds at most whenever the heating laser turns on and off as shown in Fig. 5 . The time delays are much longer than the time that is needed to evaporate the aerosol by laser heating [7 - 9] . So, it is believed that the time delay is due to the presence of aerosol movement in the chamber. The power difference between before and after laser heating is thought to be as a result of the aerosol evaporation by laser heating. When the high energy laser propagated through the chamber, aerosol exposed by the heating laser begins to be heated and evaporated in a short time. As a result, its density on the optical path is decreased and aerosol uniformity in the cell is altered. After turning off the heating laser, the density may not be recovered to its initial value as quickly. Therefore the power level after laser heating showed a tendency to increase as in Fig. 5 (d), (e) and (f).
The logarithmic scale of radiation transmittance with the heating laser intensity is shown in Fig. 6 . From the transmittance variation in Fig. 5 and the relation of radiation transmittance with the particle volume concentration in Fig. 3 , the volume concentration variation with the heating
Lager Image
Radiation transmittance as a function of the heating laser intensity.
Lager Image
Volume concentration reduction as a function of the heating laser intensity.
laser intensity is obtained. The logarithmic scale of volume concentration variation with the heating laser intensity is shown in Fig. 7 . It shows that the volume concentration decreases rapidly by water aerosol evaporation depending on the heating laser intensity.
The intensity profiles of probing laser when there is no aerosol, no heating and when heated by the 1 kW laser are shown in Fig. 8 (a), (b), and (c) respectively. Though there is a slight peak intensity and beam diameter variation, the intensity profiles do not show any noteworthy distorted distribution. This shows that any considerate irregularity of refractive index in heating area does not occur during the laser heating.
Lager Image
Transmitted probing laser intensity profile by the laserheating using profiler (SP503U Spiricon). (a) when there isno aerosol , (b) no heat, (c) heated by the 1 kW laser.
We observed the variation in the radiation transmittance generated by a cw laser interaction with water aerosol using a probing laser. The transmittance is significantly increased and the volume concentration of aerosol logarithmically increased with the intensity of the heating laser. Also, when the measured intensity profiles were investigated, there was no change in the relative refractive index at the heated area. Based on the results, when a high energy laser is propagated through the atmosphere with aerosol, we concluded that the energy will be able to be much more completely delivered than as predicted by a calculated value which does not consider the self-induced aerosol evaporation.
Amstrong R. L. (1984) “Aerosol heating and vaporization by pulsed light beams” Appl. Opt. 23 148 - 155
Chitanvis S. M. , Gerstl S. A. W. (1987) “Aerosol clearing model for a high-energy laser beam propagating through vaporizing media” J. Appl. Phys. 62 3091 - 3096
Kwok H. S. , Rossi T. M. , Lau W. S. , Shaw D. T. (1988) “Enhanced transmission in CO2-laser-aerosol interactions” Opt. Lett. 13 192 - 194
Zelensky S. E. (2003) “Self-induced attenuation of pulsed laser radiation in an aqueous suspension of submicron light-absorbing particles” J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 15 6647 - 6657
Chen X. , Wei H. (2010) “A combined atmospheric radiative transfer model (CART): a review and applications” J. Opt. Soc. Korea 14 190 - 198
Song I. , Kim Y. , Baik S.-H. , Park S.-K. , Cha H. , Choi S. , Chung C.-M. , Kim D. (2010) “Measurement of aerosol parameters with altitude by using two wavelength rotational raman signals” J. Opt. Soc. Korea 14 221 - 227
Davies S. C. , Brock J. R. (1987) “Laser evaporation of droplets” Appl. Opt. 26 786 - 793
Davies S. C. , Brock J. R. (1987) “Laser beam propagation in an evaporating polydisperse aerosol” Appl. Opt. 26 1806 - 18133
Park B. S. , Amstrong R. L. (1989) “Laser droplet heating : fast and slow heating regimes” Appl. Opt. 28 3671 - 3680
Caramana E. J. , Webster R. B. , Quigley G. P. , Morse R. L. (1991) “Theoretical and experimental studies of CO2laser evaporation of clouds” J. Appl. Phys. 70 4601 - 4616
Varghese S. K. , Gangamma S. (2007) “Evaporation of water droplets by radiation: effect of absorbing inclusions” Aerosol and Quality Research 7 95 - 105