Design and Simulation of an 808 nm InAlAs/AlGaAs GRIN-SCH Quantum Dot Laser Diode
Design and Simulation of an 808 nm InAlAs/AlGaAs GRIN-SCH Quantum Dot Laser Diode
Journal of the Optical Society of Korea. 2011. Jun, 15(2): 124-127
Copyright ©2011, Optical Society of Korea
  • Received : March 03, 2011
  • Accepted : April 15, 2011
  • Published : June 25, 2011
Export by style
Cited by
About the Authors
Trevor Chan
Sung Hun Son
Kyoung Chan Kim
Tae Geun Kim

Quantum dots were designed within a GRIN-SCH(Graded index - Separate confinement Heterostructure)heterostructure to create a high power InAlAs/AlGaAs laser diode. 808 nm light emission was with a quantum dot composition of In0.665Al0.335As and wetting layer composition of Al0.2Ga0.8As by LASTIP simulation software. Typical characteristics of GRIN structures such as high confinement ratios and Gaussian beam profiles were shown to still apply when quantum dots are used as the active media. With a dot density of 1.0x1011 dots/cm2, two quantum dot layers were found to be good enough for low threshold, high-power laser applications.
Many optical technologies, including free-space optical communications, laser displays and laser surgery, become possible as the power capacity of optical sources increases [ 1 - 2 ]. This has maintained the demand for high powered lasers and their development. Laser diodes commonly find a place as pumping sources for high power solid state lasers.Our focus is on 808 nm laser diodes which are used to pump Nd:YAG crystals
The power of semiconductor laser diodes has been limited primarily by the heating effects which occur at high optical intensities. The actual limiting event can take one of a number of forms such as catastrophic optical damage [ 3 - 5 ] or spatial hole burning [ 6 - 8 ]. The general approach to raising these limits is to design a heterostructure which effectively confines high power in the lasing mode while maintaining low internal optical intensities. A graded index separate confinement heterostructure (GRIN-SCH), usually used for its low threshold currents, is one such structure.
In a GRIN-SCH laser diode, the active region is sandwiched between graded index layers such that there is no sharp change in the refractive index between layers. This structure has been shown to yield high efficiency due to the confinement of both the optical power [9] and carriers [10] ,thereby reducing the optical intensity required to achieve higher output powers. Martin et al. [11] have shown that in their InGaN MQW structure, the GRIN-SCH configuration has a larger confinement factor than the SCH when the cladding layer width becomes large (~1 ㎛), or when the number of active layers exceeds six.
Quantum dots have been a desirable active material for lasers due to the enhanced optical properties associated with the zeroth dimensionality [ 12 - 14 ], which include temperature insensitivity, lower threshold currents and decreased noise.With the concern of heating effects at high operating currents, it is easy to see how these properties offer advantages for high power operation. To the authors’ knowledge, quantum dots have not yet been integrated within a GRIN-SCH. In our work, we use LASTIP software created by Crosslight Software Inc. to simulate the performance of quantum dots used in a GRIN-SCH structure. This creates the opportunity for optimization and understanding of quantum dot lasers in high-power heterostructures without the high cost of fabrication and experiments.
GRIN heterostructure with a quantum dot active region
PPT Slide
Lager Image
GRIN heterostructure with a quantum dot active region
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Partial cross section of the quantum dot layers in theactive region. Each dot had a trapezoidal cross section andwas radially symmetric. Layers were separated by 3 nmAl0.35Ga0.65As layers.
The graded index in a GRIN-SCH effectively confines the optical power near the active region. This benefits highpower operation in a number of ways. First, it increases the proportion of power that is contained within the fundamental mode thus restricting the effects of spatial hole burning.Second, it maintains power in a Gaussian profile which is more effective for output coupling. Furthermore, GRIN-SCH acts to reduce undesired emissions [9] and lowers the density of states in the confining regions [9] , thereby increasing the quantum efficiency.
In our simulations, we used the structure described by Table 1 which used the layered quantum dot structure shown in Fig. 1 . The composition of the waveguide layers are linearly graded from x = 0.35 to x = 0.65. For comparison purposes, we used Al 0.35 Ga 0.65 As waveguides when we simulated the equivalent separate confinement hetero structure (SCH). The SCH configuration has a V number of 9.46 at 808 nm wavelength, meaning that 18 modes can exist in the waveguide as a result of the large optical cavity. This also means that the GRIN-SCH configuration will have multiple modes as well. The active region (shown in Fig. 1 ) contained multiple layers of quantum dots where each layer contained a 1.0x1011 dots/cm 2 dot distribution.The dot composition (x=0.665) and size (10 nm diameter,5 nm height) was selected so that the gain peaked near 808 nm. When multiple quantum dot layers were used, each layer was separated by 3 nm barrier layers of undoped Al 0.35 Ga 0.65 As. The total cavity length was 3 mm with a front and back reflectivity of 2% and 90%, respectively.These last two parameters were selected as they are typical for high power laser diodes.
Our structure was simulated using LASTIP [15] , a simulation program created by Crosslight Software Inc. This software operates by using a finite-element method which maps the hole density, electron density and electric potential within a given structure. From these, all other properties of interest can be extrapolated. The electronic properties are found from using Poisson’s equation and the current continuity equations, while the optical properties are calculated from the wave equation and the photon rate equation. The electronic and optical properties are connected by the stimulated emission rate equation.
Figures 2 and 3 show the lateral profile of the refractive index and wave intensity, respectively, of a SCH laser and a GRIN-SCH laser with the same 2 ㎛ waveguide width using 6 layers of quantum dots. We chose 6 layers arbitrarily as the intensity profile did not change did not depend on layer number. As expected, this follows the trend seen in quantum well lasers where the fundamental lateral mode is prominent for large (~㎛) graded waveguides while the appearance of higher order modes reduces the optical confinement in the SCH structures, as shown in Fig. 4 . Figure 4 also shows that the difference in confinement factors increases with the waveguide size. These two points support the idea that with quantum dots, the GRIN-SCH allows for larger optical cavities and therefore, larger output powers.
We also simulated our structure using 1 to 10 quantum dot layers to determine the effect of the layer number on
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Refractive index profiles of the SCH and GRIN-SCHwith 2 μm thick waveguide.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Lateral intensity profiles of the SCH and GRIN-SCHwith a 2 μm thick waveguides.
the lasing characteristics. The output power versus injection current (P-I) curves are shown in Fig. 5 . With one quantum dot layer, the slope efficiency is low, as expected. As layers are added, the slope efficiency increases to a plateau while, at the same time, the threshold current reaches a minimum value. The further addition of layers results in a steady increase in threshold current while the slope efficiency remains approximately the same.
The plateau in slope efficiency can be seen as the maximum stimulated emission efficiency for the injected carrier. At this maximum efficiency, the addition of more quantum dots (by the addition of layers or higher dot density) does not result in higher optical output power and can be deemed as superfluous. Therefore, with 1.0*10 11 dots/cm 2 dot density,two quantum dot layers may be the optimum arrangement as this produces the maximum slope efficiency for this structure. We note that this will not be the case in other
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Confinement factor versus waveguide width in theSCH and GRIN-SCH.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Output power versus injection current for a quantumdot GRIN-SCH laser diodes using 1 to 10 quantum dot layers.
laser structures as the output power is affected by many other variables such as the mirror reflectivity, internal loss and cavity length. For different structures, our simulations show a similar trend in layer dependence where two layers is not always the optimum case. Further studies should be performed to determine the roles of additional variables.
We used LASTIP to simulate the performance of quantum dots as the active layer in a GRIN-SCH laser diode. Our results showed that properties of higher confinement and maintenance of the Gaussian beam inherited by the GRIN structure still apply when quantum dots are used. In our given structure, we explored the output dependence on the number of quantum dot layers and found that two layers produced the most output power.
This work was supported by the Seoul R&BD Program(WR080951) as well as the Ministry of Knowledge Economy through the IT Industry Foundation Program (2M26270).
Lee S. H , Jung H. W , Kim K. H , Lee M. H 2010 All-optical flip-flop operation based on polarization bistability of conventional-type 1.55-μm wavelength single-mode VCSELs J. Opt. Soc. Korea 14 137 - 141    DOI : 10.3807/JOSK.2010.14.2.137
Kim S , Byun Y. T , Kim D.-G , Dagli N , Chung Y 2010 Widely tunable coupled-ring reflector laser diode consisting of square ring resonators J. Opt. Soc. Korea 14 38 - 41    DOI : 10.3807/JOSK.2010.14.1.038
Puchert R , Barwolff A , Menzel U , Lau A , Voss M , Elsaesser T 1996 Facet and bulk heating of GaAs/AlGaAshigh-power laser arrays studied in spatially resolved emissionand micro-Raman experiments J. Appl. Phys. 80 5559 - 5563    DOI : 10.1063/1.363606
Sanayeh M. B , Brick P , Schmid W , Mayer B , Muller M , Reufer M , Streubel K , Tomm J. W , Bacher G 2007 Temperature-power dependence of catastrophic opticaldamage in AlGaInP laser diodes Appl. Phys. Lett. 91 041115 - 041115-3    DOI : 10.1063/1.2760143
Hempel M , Tomm J. W , Ziegler M , Elsaesser T , Michel N , Krakowski M 2010 Catastrophic optical damage at frontand rear facets of diode lasers Appl. Phys. Lett. 97 231101 - 231101-3    DOI : 10.1063/1.3524235
Wilson G. C , Kuchta D. M , Walker J. D , Smith J. S 1994 Spatial hole burning and self-focusing in vertical-cavitysurface-emitting laser diodes Appl. Phys. Lett. 64 542 - 544    DOI : 10.1063/1.111097
Law S. Y , Agrawal G. P 1997 Effects of spatial hole burning on gain switching in vertical-cavity surface-emitting lasers IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 33 462 - 468    DOI : 10.1109/3.556016
Unold H. J , Golling M , Mederer F , Michalzik R , Supper D , Ebeling K. J 2001 Single mode output powerenhancement of InGaAs VCSELs by reduced spatial holeburning via surface etching Electron. Lett. 37 570 - 572    DOI : 10.1049/el:20010407
Tsang W. T 1982 Extermely low threshold (AlGa)As gradedindexwaveguide separate-confinement heterostructure lasersgrown by molecular beam epitaxy Appl. Phys. Lett. 40 217 - 219    DOI : 10.1063/1.93046
Nagle J , Hersee S , Krakowski M , Weil T , Weisbuch C 1986 Threshold current of single quantum well lasers:the role of the confining layers Appl. Phys. Lett. 49 1325 - 1327    DOI : 10.1063/1.97366
Martin J. A , Sanchez M 2005 Comparison between agraded and setp-index optical cavity in InGaN MQW laserdiodes Semicond. Sci. Technol. 20 290 - 295    DOI : 10.1088/0268-1242/20/3/006
Bimberg D , Grundmann M , Heinrichsdorff F , Ledentsov N. N , Ustinov V. M , Zhukov A. E , Kovsh A. R , Maximov M. V , Shernyakov Y. M , Volovik B. V , Tsatsul’ikov A. F , Kop’v P. S , Alferov Zh. I 2007 Quantumdot lasers: breakthrough in optoelectronics Thin Solid Films 367 235 - 249
Grundmann M , Christen J , Ledentsov N. N , Bohrer J , Bimberg D , Ruvimov S. S , Werner P , Richter U , Gosele U , Heydenreich J , Ustinov V. M , Egorov A. Y , Zhukov A. E , Kop’v P. S , Alferov Zh. I 1995 Ultra narrowluminescence lines from single quantum dots Phys. Rev. Lett. 74 4043 - 4046    DOI : 10.1103/PhysRevLett.74.4043
Kovsh A. R , Wang J. S , Hsiao R. S , Chen L. P , Livshits D. A , Lin G , Ustinov V. M , Chi J. Y 2003 High power (200 mW) single mode operation of GaAs basedInGaAsN/GaAs ridge waveguide lasers with wavelengtharound 1300 nm Electron. Lett. 39 1726 - 1728    DOI : 10.1049/el:20031085
Li Z.-M 1997 “Physical models and numberical simulation of modern semiconductor lasers” Proc. SPIE 2994 698 - 708