Development of an Illumination Measurement Device for Color Distribution Based on a CIE 1931 XYZ Sensor
Development of an Illumination Measurement Device for Color Distribution Based on a CIE 1931 XYZ Sensor
Journal of the Optical Society of Korea. 2011. Mar, 15(1): 44-51
Copyright ©2011, Optical Society of Korea
  • Received : August 31, 2010
  • Accepted : January 12, 2011
  • Published : March 25, 2011
Export by style
Cited by
About the Authors
Do Ky, Son
Eun Byeol, Cho
Inkyu, Moon
Yousang, Park
Chung Ghiu, Lee

In this paper, an easy-to-use measurement device for illumination distribution is developed. The device consists of a sensor array module, a control module, and a PC interface. The sensor array module incorporates CIE 1931 color sensors and the ARM-based 96 MHz microcontroller in the control module for measurement and data processing. The sensor array module contains 64 color sensors arranged in a 16 × 4 array. The sensitivity of the sensor array module can be adjusted depending on the illumination level to be measured. The measurement data and control signals are exchanged via USB 2.0 standard. To demonstrate the performance of the device, the illumination distribution is measured for colors of red,green, and blue and is graphically shown. The device can be used for measurement of the illumination distribution, design and adjustment of LED illumination.
Nowadays, light-emitting diodes (LEDs) and laser diodes(LDs) for illumination are actively being developed and their basic optical and electrical characteristics are well described in [1 , 2] . Due to the commercial potential of LEDs with visible light emission, LED illumination draws a great deal of attention from LED manufacturers, LED driving IC manufacturers, LED backlight unit (BLU) manufacturers, illumination designers, and architects seeking new forms of illumination. LED illumination offers the user numerous advantages, including considerable power reduction, extreme durability, size reduction, a wide color gamut,improved degree of freedom for the illumination shape,and a high resistance to shock and vibration. Furthermore, LED illumination costs less to maintain due to its long lifetime and the fact that the price for the chips per unit of luminous flux is decreasing [3] . As a result, the LED with visible light emission is very useful not only for illumination and LED BLU, but also for the environment and for indoor decorations and advertisements. Therefore, colorful LEDs will be a versatile light source for all those applications. From the illumination point of view, the visible(red, green, blue) LEDs are characterized for illumination devices and colorful displays [4] . The driving current for each LED can be controlled quickly and independently with appropriate driving circuitry to maintain its brightness and color [5 , 6] . These two characteristics make a visible LED a prominent candidate for lighting instruments. In such a case, it is necessary to measure illuminance to ensure that an LED lamp provides an illumination level of 300 ? 1500 lx, based on the ISO standard for office work [7] . Since the lighting device based on LEDs is composed of individual LEDs, the illumination on a target surface is patterned, depending upon the density of the LEDs, the LED directionality, the shape of an LED array, etc. Therefore, the measurements of illumination distribution is significant for the design and characterization of LED illumination. Specifically, to analyze the irradiance performances from the LED arrays, the design expressions for illumination uniformity in a near-target plane from LED arrays have been derived [8] , and the far-field condition for an array of LEDs is analyzed by LED radiation pattern, array geometry, and the number of LEDs [9] . Moreover, to achieve uniform illumination, a design process using a surface-tailored lens has been proposed [10] and an efficient coupler design has been reported [11] .
Except for precise measurements in laboratory experiments or exact calibration processes, the LED is supposed to sufficiently ensure that human eyes perceive that the brightness and color are evenly distributed or that the chromaticity of certain measurement points is well distributed. A certain color measurement needs multi-point calibration with a calibrating procedure [12] , and a simultaneous color measurement and white balancing for RGB white LEDs were demonstrated by using a buried double p-n junction (BDJ) photodetector,which was fabricated by the same authors [13] . A chromatic property measurement system for LEDs was developed based on the spectroradiometric method using a photomultiplier [14] . These are not easy-to-use simple measurement devices for LED applications. Furthermore, a hand-held illuminance measurement system with versatile functions [15] is available. To measure multiple points simultaneously,the device needs to connect multiple remote detector heads. Therefore, easy-to-use and fast illumination measurement devices would be useful without a complex measurement process, such as in a precise measurement or an exact calibration process.
In this paper, we report a device for easy-to-use illumination measurement using a color sensor array. The color sensor is in an integrated circuit (IC) and is equipped with an XYZ tri-stimulus function, based on the CIE 1931 color matching functions [16] . Each sensor has a tolerance of nearly 1% variation of wavelength. The sensor array module with an appropriate control circuit makes it easy to measure and analyze the illumination and color distributions over a twodimensional surface at one time. Each sensor in the array module can measure illuminance and color coordinates, based on three independent CIE 1931 color matching functions: □, ȳ , and □ [17] . The analog signal from each sensor module is converted to a digital signal. The measurement device provides the illumination and color distributions over the surface.
The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 describes the configuration of the developed measurement device, including the component descriptions. Measurement and performance using the device are described in Section 3.Section 4 deals with discussions on future development. The paper is concluded with Section 5.
- 2.1. Device Organization
Fig. 1 shows the organization of the measurement device, which consists of three parts. The sensor array module includes a two-dimensional color sensor array, multiplexers, and an analog-to-digital converter (ADC). The control module consists of a microcontroller, a power supply, and various connectors. The other part provides the interface between the control module and the PC. The color sensor array is composed of 64 color sensors in a 16 × 4 array. Each sensor includes the standard XYZ (RGB) filters based on the CIE 1931 color matching functions [17] . The photocurrent from a color sensor is converted into the voltage inside the color sensor IC, which stands for a direct coordinate for the standard 1931 color space. The output voltage signals from the sensor array module are then multiplexed and converted into digital signals. Compact and portable, the sensor array module is suitable for hand-held applications. Using the two dimensional array of color sensors, fast and absolute color measurement over a surface is possible.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Block diagram of the measurement device.
The analog signals containing illumination and color information from 64 sensors are collected by multiplexers,and the ARM-based microcontroller in the control module processes digital signals and sends them to the PC through the USB 2.0 interface. The measurement data fed into the PC is processed to draw a two-dimensional figure for illumination and color distribution, which are described in Section 3. The LCD display in the control module shows the status of the measurement device and the basic parameters for measurement are set by using a keypad.
- 2.2. Color Sensor
The color sensor (MTCS-TIAM2, MAZeT) is a true color sensor IC (integrated circuit) and is equipped with an integrated transimpedance amplifier in a small plastic package on a PCB-carrier [16] . This color sensor includes the standard XYZ (RGB) filters based on the CIE 1931 color matching functions [17] . The in-depth descriptions on photometry and colorimetry are provided in [18] . After an offsetcorrection and calibration, the output voltages from the sensor become XYZ tristimulus values for the standard CIE 1931 color space [16] . Therefore, we can refer to the true color sensor as a CIE 1931 sensor. Each color sensor consists of 19 × 3 PIN silicon photodiodes with blue-enhancement integrated on a chip package. Since the color sensor can detect signals from a red light to a blue light by Si photodiodes in the array structure, it is simple to design the measurement device with the color sensors without additional optics. Therefore, this developed measurement device is suitable for measuring and analyzing illumination and color distributions for multiple points in a compact package.
- 2.3. Multiplexer and Analog-to-digital Conversion
A monolithic CMOS dual 16-channel analog multiplexer(ADG726, Analog Devices) switches one of 16 inputs, as determined by the 4-bit binary address lines A0, A1, A2,and A3. With this multiplexing capability, simultaneous measurement from 64 color sensors is possible. The multiplexer works well with a 1.8 V to 5.5 V single supply or a 2.5 V dual supply. It has only 4 Ω resistance and needs only 30 ns for switching. Therefore, it provides the number of address lines and sufficient switching time to ensure accuracy and speed for this development.
The analog-to-digital converter (ADS7824, Burr-Brown Company) is used to convert the analog signal from the sensor array module to a digital signal. The converted digital signal is a 12-bit data stream, which consumes only 50 mW at its maximum. Laser-trimmed scaling resistors provide the standard industrial ±10V input range and the channel-to-channel matching of ±0.1%.
Fig. 2 shows the block diagram for connectivity between the multiplexer and the ADC. The multiplexing of 64 sensors needs 192 color signal lines. However, we use only one ADC with four inputs by using the multiplexers to collect the signals from 64 sensors. The microcontroller controls the multiplexer and chooses which of the signal lines is to be connected to the ADC. The signal conversion processes from multiplexing to ADC are summarized into the following three steps: 1) choose a specific signal line using a 5 bits address, 2) convert the analog signal to a digital signal, and 3) obtain the digital values.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Block diagram for connectivity between multiplexingand analog-to-digital conversion. Analog signals aremultiplexed and converted into digital signals.
- 2.4. ARM-based Microcontroller
The microcontroller used for this development is an ARM-based microcontroller (STR912FAW46X6, ST Microelectronics). This microcontroller is a 32-bit ARM (advanced RISC machine) device. The general information on ARM processors can be found in [19] . The microcontroller is a 96 MHz ARM based microcontroller unit (MCU) with an ARM966E-S RISC core. It has Harvard architecture, a 5-stage pipeline, and tightly-coupled memories (SRAM and flash). The microcontroller also has dual burst flash memories, 32-bits wide with a 1 MB main flash memory, and a 128 KB secondary flash memory. Furthermore, it supports 10 communication interfaces, including 10/100 Ethernet MAC with DMA (direct memory access) and MII (medium independent interface) [20] , as well as a USB full-speed(12 Mbps) slave device [21] . By using the microcontroller with USB full-speed support, we can ensure the data transmission speed of the measurement device.
- 2.5. Printed Circuit Boards and Interfaces
The printed circuit boards (PCBs) are developed in a DXP 2004 Altium environment and are shown in Figs. 3 - 4 . We adopted 4-layer PCBs. Each PCB has a ground layer and its surface layers for wiring are covered with ground areas to reduce the noise from the outside of the PCB.
The device includes two modules: a control module and a sensor array module. Fig. 3 shows the control module with the microcontroller, the Ethernet connector, the USB connector, the power supply unit, the LCD connector, the push button, the sensor connector, and the JTAG connector.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Printed circuit board of the control module.
The front side and back side photos of the sensor array module are shown in Fig. 4 . This module includes the 16 × 4 sensor array and the ADC (ADS7824), with a 3.5 V onboard reference and the 4-input multiplexers (ADG704) with a 26-pin connector. The back side contains dual 16-input multiplexers (ADG726) and decoupling capacitors.
The USB driver was developed based on a virtual instrument standard architecture (VISA) tool in LabVIEW [22] . After setting up the developed driver and connecting the control module to the PC, the module becomes a USB device as shown in Fig. 5 .
Table 1 shows the frame format for the data packet between the PC and the control module. The frame packet from the PC to the control module begins with a 1 byte Device ID, a 1 byte Command ID, and 8 bytes data, successively, and is finished with a 1 byte checksum cyclic redundancy code (CRC). The frame packet from the control module to the PC begins with a 1 byte Sensor ID, then a 1 byte Color ID, and 32 bytes data, successively, and is finished with a 1 by checksum CRC.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Printed circuit board of the sensor array module; (a)front side and (b) back side.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Screenshot of USB driver initialization in the PCoperating system.
(a) Frame packet from PC to control module; (b)Frame packet from control module to PC
PPT Slide
Lager Image
(a) Frame packet from PC to control module; (b)Frame packet from control module to PC
- 3.1. Illumination Distribution
Fig. 6 shows three 3D surface plots that show the measured red (R), green (G), and blue (B) values of the 64 sensors from a single red, green, and blue LED, respectively. An LED is positioned to illuminate the center area of the sensor module. The distance from the LED to the sensor module is 25 cm. The highest optical intensity appears in the center area and the optical intensity decreases in the sensors near the border region. All sensors are set to the sensitivity level of 2. The color sensors convert the optical intensity (R, G, B) to voltage and the minimum measured voltage is 0 V when it is completely dark. The maximum measured voltage is 5 V when the received light is over the maximum received optical intensity. At that point, the 0 V is digitally encoded to 0, and 5 V is encoded to 255. The digital values are scaled from the received optical intensity. For the sensitivity level “zero”, the irradiance responsivities, for the red color at 600 nm, is S0 Red =0.067 mV/(μW/cm 2 ), for the green color, at 555 nm, the irradiance responsivities is S0 Green = 0.063 mV/(μW/cm 2 ),and for blue color, at 445 nm,, the irradiance responsivities is S0 Blue = 0.044 mV/(μW/cm 2 ). From these values, we can estimate the maximum received optical intensity to measure, using TIAM2: S0 Red,Max = 5V / S0 Red = 5000 /0.067 = 74.62 (mW/cm 2 ) for red, S0 Green,Max = 5V / S0 Green = 5000 / 0.063 = 79.37 (mW/cm 2 ) for green, and S0 Blue,Max = 5V / S0 Blue = 5000 / 0.044 = 113.64 (mW/cm 2 ) for blue.These values are shown in Fig. 6 . For the sensitivity level “seven”, the same calculation can be applied. The maximum received optical intensities for sensitivity level “seven” are 93.98 (μW/cm 2 ) for red, 99.8 (μW/cm 2 ) for green, and 143.27 (μW/cm 2 ) for blue.
The bottom surface means the geometrical measurement surface and the vertical axis means the scaled voltage, and, therefore, the relative measured intensity of each color can be set to absolute values for measured intensity or illuminance with an exact adjustment process.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Measured optical intensities for (a) red color (b)green color and (c) blue color.
Fig. 7 shows the 1931 CIE chromaticity diagrams with the ( x, y ) coordinates for multiple sensors for R, G, B, and white LEDs. The chromaticity coordinates ( x, y ) correspond to its color. A measure of spread of y , σy , can be calculated as
PPT Slide
Lager Image
where my is the mean of y , N is the number of y values from color sensors, and yi,j is the y value of the color sensor at ( i , j ) out of (16, 4). The uniformity of y is defined in terms of its average value, my , as
PPT Slide
Lager Image
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Measured 1931 CIE chromaticity diagrams for (a) ared LED (b) a green LED (c) a blue LED and (d) a whiteLED. The red rectangles connected with the solid lines definethe 1931 CIE chromaticity diagram. The blue overlappeddiamonds denote the chromaticity coordinates from all colorsensors.
The uniformity of y for an incandescent bulb is approximately 8.77% with the distance of 50 cm to the sensor array module. Next, the color coordinates for LEDs of different colors are measured. The color coordinates are evenly distributed for each sensor. The measured color coordinates for a specific LED coincide with the color of the corresponding LED. As an example, the color coordinates for the white LED ( Fig. 7 (d)) are compared with the datasheet from the manufacturer. The measured x values are distributed around 0.37, while the measured y values are distributed from 0.35 to 0.37. The datasheet provides the x values from 0.24 to 0.35, while the y values are distributed from 0.24 to 0.35. As can be seen from this comparison, the developed measurement device provides reliable color measurement for the sample white LED of the manufacturer. With precise adjustment in experimental conditions, the differences would be reduced.
- 3.2. Measurement Sensitivity
Fig. 8 shows the measured optical intensity for a red LED, with a different level of sensitivity, while maintaining the LED operating condition. It was tested with a single, commercial 1 W red-LED source at a distance of 20 cm. The sensitivity of the sensors is changed from the minimum value (Level 0) to the maximum value (Level 7). With Level 0, the sensor cannot detect the weak light. To detect the weak light, the sensitivity level must be increased. If the sensitivity is too high, the color is expressed as yellow, for sensitivity Level 6 and sensitivity Level 7. The sensitivity level is changed digitally by programmable adjustment of transimpedance of the color sensor IC [16] . For a simple adjustment, with the known source-detector standard, the sensitivity of the sensor module can be adjusted by using the sensitivity knob on the front panel of the graphical user interface (GUI) in the PC.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Optical intensity distribution for the increasedsensitivity level with a red LED.
The color sensor is a good candidate for a color measurement device because it includes the true color filters and an amplifier in a small package. Table 2 shows the electrical and optical characteristics of the color sensor [16] . From Table 2 , the appropriate sensitivity level suitable for a specific application can be chosen.
Fig. 9 shows the photograph of the measurement device for a measurement. The control module is connected to the sensor array module using a 26-pin connector and to a PC through a USB connector. The sensor sensitivity is in Level 4. The light source is a 1-W red color LED. A part of optical intensity figures such as Fig. 6 is shown on the PC screen. are shown on the PC screen. The measurement software is developed on the LabVIEW and we can stop the measurement procedure by clicking the stop button.
- 3.3. ADC Accuracy
We use a four channel, 12-bit sampling CMOS analogto-digital converter (ADS 7824). The input range of the ADC is from ?10V to +10V and provides a sufficient voltage range for converting the output of the color sensor. With this 12-bit ADC, the number of levels (NL) for each color is
PPT Slide
Lager Image
The PD Sensitivity of the Color Sensorthat wasused [11]
PPT Slide
Lager Image
The PD Sensitivity of the Color Sensorthat wasused [11]
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Setup using the developed measurement device. Thesensor array module and the control module are shown.
By generating the number of levels for three colors, we arrive at the number of color levels (NCL) as follows:
PPT Slide
Lager Image
We have 64 sensors with three colors (R, G, and B), and the number of total samples (NS) is
PPT Slide
Lager Image
The maximum sampling rate of ADS7824 is 40 kilo samples per second (ksps). Therefore, the minimum time required to convert the analog signal from the sensor module to the digital signal is
PPT Slide
Lager Image
The ARM-based microcontroller supports the USB 2.0 full speed interface. Therefore, we can transmit data to the PC at the maximum data rate of 12 Mbps. Since the 12-bit ADC is used, the total number of bits is
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Therefore, the minimum time required to transmit data from the control module to the PC is
PPT Slide
Lager Image
The minimum time required for conversion and transmission is
PPT Slide
Lager Image
- 3.4. Data Processing Speed
The ARM-based microcontroller (STR912FAW46X6), with a clock speed of 96 MHz, has enough processing speed to process and transmit data. In this development, we test the sensor array module, with the total time of TTOTAL = 65 ms. 64 ms is required to convert data from the 64 sensors(1 ms for each sensor), and 1 ms is required for the transmission of data through the USB (~ 2.3 Mbps).
The processing of measurement data is performed using the ARM-based microcontroller. The measurement device can be upgraded by adding more RAM, ROM, and external flash memory to form an embedded illumination measurement device that works without a PC.
The measurement device can be developed as an embedded system with its own data display. The ARM-based microcontroller, running on a tiny OS, can collect, process, transmit,save, and retrieve the measurement data.
The internet-connected remote measurement device can be used to measure the illumination and color distributions in real-time inside or outside a building, for example, on the highway, the subway, etc. Furthermore, the measurement device can communicate with a GPS module to record the measurement data and measurement position during measurement.
Although 12-bit data for each color in this device is in compliance with the 36-bit color standard, only the eight most significant bits (MSBs) are used for each color to follow the 24-bit true color standard, as it is sufficient to display the color data on a PC screen. If the 12-bit ADC is upgraded to a 16-bit ADC, we can have 48-bit color and the device can measure and show 281.5 trillion colors [23] .
We can use this device as a measurement device to characterize the indoor environment for developing an LED illumination system or an LED communication system. It will help illumination designers or interior designers to easily design an optimal illumination system by measuring the illumination at various positions.
The sensor that we used is a kind of true color sensor with true color filters. Therefore, it is possible to detect and analyze color contributions with appropriate transformation algorithms from an illumination system. With the independent sensitivity adjustment for each sensor, more precise distribution measurement would be possible.
An easy-to-use, portable measurement device for illumination distribution has been developed. The device was designed with the purpose of providing a measurement tool useful for developing an LED illumination system and measuring indoor illumination. The array of CIE 1931 XYZ sensors detects the illumination distribution and the CIE 1931 color coordinates. The measured data is transmitted to the PC through a USB interface and processed to draw graphs in the GUI.
The measurement of color coordinates from a white LED, using the measurement device, was tested by comparing the measured coordinates with the values in the data sheet from the manufacturer. The result shows a small difference.The development has provided a prototype measurement device for measuring the illumination distribution and the color coordinates.
This study was supported by research fund from Chosun University, 2007.
Schubert E. F , Chapter 8. 2003 Light-emitting Diodes Cambridge University Press Cambridge UK Chapter 8.
Ryu H.-Y , Kim D.-H 2010 High-brightness phosphor-conversion white light source using InGaN blue laser diode J. Opt.Soc. Korea 14 415 - 419    DOI : 10.3807/JOSK.2010.14.4.415
Zukauskas A , Chapter 7. , Shur M. S , Chapter 7. , Caska R , Chapter 7. 2002 Introduction to Solid-state Lighting John Wiley & Sons New York USA Chapter 7.
Ying S. P , Tang C.-W , Huang B.-J “Characterizing LEDs for mixture of colored LED light sources”
Muthu S , James G “Red green and blue LED-basedwhite light source: implementation challenges and controldesign” in Proc. Conference Record of the IAS AnnualMeeting (Salt Lake City USA Oct. 2003) 515 - 522
Carr J. J 1993 Sensors and Circuit Prentice Hall New JerseyUSA
Tanaka Y , Komine T , Haruyama S , Nakagawa M 2003 Indoor visible light data transmission system utilizing white LED lights IEICE Trans. on Commun. E86-B 2440 - 2454
Moreno I , Avedano-Alejo M , Tzonchev R. I 2006 Designing light-emitting diode arrays for uniform near-field irradiance Appl. Opt. 45 2265 - 2272    DOI : 10.1364/AO.45.002265
Moreno I , Sun C.-C , Ivanov R 2009 Far-field condition for light-emitting diode arrays Appl. Opt. 48 1190 - 1197    DOI : 10.1364/AO.48.001190
Whang A. J.-W , Chen Y.-Y , Teng Y.-T 2009 Designing uniform illumination systems by surface-tailored lens and configurations of LED arrays Journal of Display Technol. 5 94 - 103    DOI : 10.1109/JDT.2008.2001865
Lee J. H , Chang W , Choi D 2007 LED light coupler design for a ultra thin light guide J. Opt. Soc. Korea 11 113 - 117    DOI : 10.3807/JOSK.2007.11.3.113
Yang P. K , Chen J. C , Chuang Y. H 2007 Improvement on reflective color measurement using a tri-color LED by multi-point calibration Opt. Comm. 272 320 - 324    DOI : 10.1016/j.optcom.2006.11.051
Liang K , Li W , Ren H. R , Liu X. L , Wang W. J , Yang R , Han D. J 2009 Color measurement for RGB white LEDs in solid-state lighting using a BDJ photodetector Displays 30 107 - 113    DOI : 10.1016/j.displa.2009.03.002
Cheng J.-B , Jiang Q , Li J.-J 2005 Chromatic property measurement system for LED Proc. SPIE 5941 59411J -
Data Sheet of MTCS-TIAM2 2010 “Integral true color sensor IC”
DeCusatis C 1998 Handbook of Applied Photometry AIP Press New York USA
ARM Microcontroller;
USB http://
Travis J , Chapter 11 1996 LabVIEW for Everyone: Graphical Programming Made Even Easier Prentice-Hall Upper Saddle River USA Chapter 11
Color Depth