Recently reported asynchronousopticalsampling terahertz (THz) timedomain spectroscopy enables highresolution spectroscopy due to a long timedelay window. However, a longlasting tail signal following the main pulse is often measured in a timedomain waveform, resulting in spectral fluctuation above a background noise level on a highresolution THz amplitude spectrum. Here, we adopt the wavelet power spectrum estimation technique (WPSET) to effectively remove the spectral fluctuation without sacrificing spectral features. Effectiveness of the WPSET is verified by investigating a transmission spectrum of water vapor.
I. INTRODUCTION
Over the past two decades, the field of terahertz (THz) waves has drawn much attention due to the development of THz science and technologies
[1]
. It is noteworthy that THz timedomain spectroscopy (THzTDS) has been pioneered as a basic measurement tool for characterizing optical and electrical properties of materials
[2
,
3]
. THzTDS also provides a potentially attractive method for probing fundamental physical interactions as well as practical applications
[4
,
5]
. However, conventional THzTDS using a single modelocked femtosecond laser and a mechanical delay line has an inherent tradeoff between frequency resolution and measurement time since the frequency resolution is inversely proportional to an overall time delay window. Translation stages can commonly offer a time delay window up to hundreds of picoseconds while they need a measurement time of several minutes. On the contrary, vibrating mirrors can give a scan rate of up to 100 Hz but the measured time delay window is limited to less than 100 ps. Different types of optical delay line have also been devised for rapid data acquisition or high spectral resolution
[5
,
6]
.
Asynchronous optical sampling (ASOPS) THzTDS has recently been demonstrated to overcome the tradeoff
[7

10]
. The ASOPS THzTDS can serve for highresolution spectroscopy as well as highspeed monitoring of dynamic processes
[11]
. It should be noted, however, that spectral fluctuation can significantly appear on highresolution THz spectra measured in ASOPS THzTDS. It is caused by a longlasting tail signal following a main THz pulse in timedomain waveforms. The tail signal is considered to be due to multiple reflections within and between optical components. Since the tail signal causes spectral fluctuation on the spectrum above the background noise level, signal processing techniques are needed to remove the fluctuations.
Signal processing based on wavelets is expected to enhance signal quality without losing information as compared to filtering or smoothing. Actually, there have been a few reports in which the wavelet denoising technique is applied to timedomain waveforms from THzTDS for gas sensing
[12]
, imaging
[13
,
14]
, and local tomography
[15]
. In this paper, we intend to directly apply the wavelet denoising technique to highresolution THz amplitude spectra to enhance the spectrum quality. Our ASOPS THzTDS setup with a frequency resolution of 100 MHz is described along with typical experimental results. Then, the wavelet power spectrum estimation technique (WPSET) is described for fluctuation reduction in highresolution THz amplitude spectra measured from ASOPS THzTDS. A transmission spectrum of water vapor is investigated to verify the performance of the WPSET.
II. EXPERIMENT
Our experimental setup for ASOPS THzTDS is illustrated in
Fig. 1
. We employ a laser system where two Ti:Sapphire femtosecond lasers are pumped by a diodepumped solid state laser at 532 nm wavelength. The whole laser system is placed on a temperaturecontrolled baseplate to reduce thermal fluctuation. Both the femtosecond lasers 1 and 2 have a center wavelength of 800 nm and their pulse durations are 10 and 20 fs, respectively. Two phaselocked loops are used to stabilize the repetition frequencies of the femtosecond lasers. The repetition frequencies of femtosecond lasers 1 (
f_{r1}
) and 2 (
f_{r2}
) are stabilized at 100 MHz and at a variable frequency, respectively, so that the difference frequency (Δ
f_{r}
=
f_{r1}

f_{r2}
) can be adjusted. By using doublebalanced mixers (DBM), the tenth harmonics of f
_{r1}
and f
_{r2}
are compared with the outputs of a 1 GHz dielectric resonator oscillator (DRO) and a signal generator, respectively. The DRO and signal generator share a 10 MHz reference oscillator to reduce the relative timing jitter between the optical pulses from the two femtosecond lasers. The phase error signal output from the DBM is amplified by a proportionalintegral amplifier and a highvoltage amplifier and is supplied to a piezoelectric transducer (PZT) to which a
Schematic diagram of the experimental setup for ASOPS THzTDS. PD: photodetector EM: THz emitter DT:THz detector PM: offaxis parabolic mirror Amp: variablegain current amplifier NOC: nonlinear optical crystal.
cavity mirror is attached. The repetition frequencies are stabilized by controlling the cavity lengths via the PZTs.
Two lowtemperaturegrown GaAs photoconductive antennas are used for THz emission and detection. The optical pulses from the femtosecond laser 1 are incident on the THz emitter to generate THz pulses, which are guided into the THz detector by using four offaxis parabolic mirrors. The optical pulses from the femtosecond laser 2 are used to optically sample the THz pulses incident upon the THz detector. The photocurrent output from the DT represents the magnitude of the electric field of the THz pulses temporally sampled. It is amplified by a variablegain current amplifier and then is input to a 24bit flexible resolution digitizer. The digitizer is triggered by a crosscorrelation signal generated from a nonlinear optical crystal (2mmthick BBO crystal) on which the optical pulses from the two femtosecond lasers are noncollinearly focused. The trigger signal has a repetition frequency equal to the difference frequency. The digitizer acquires timedomain data when triggered by the crosscorrelation signal, and we can average over consecutive traces to reduce the noise. The time axis is converted from a real time to a time delay by
A typical timedomain signal with a 10 ns time delay window measured from the ASOPS THzTDS is displayed in
Fig. 2
(a). It is acquired by averaging over 1,000 traces during 100 s at a difference frequency of 20 Hz. It can be seen that the tail signal following the main pulse lasts for several nanoseconds. The tail signal is considered to arise from multiple reflections within and between optical components.
Fig. 2
(b) shows a typical THz amplitude spectrum with a frequency resolution of 100 MHz given by the fast Fourier transform (FFT) of the timedomain waveform in
Fig. 2
(a). The longlasting tail signal leads to the spectral fluctuation on the spectrum above the background noise level. The fluctuation is not observed in the conventional THzTDS using an optical delay stage since it has a low spectral resolution due to a much shorter time delay window. The timedomain waveform around the main pulse is displayed on a time delay window of 100 ps in the inset of
Fig. 2
(a). Its spectrum with a frequency resolution of 10 GHz has almost no fluctuation, as shown in the inset of
Fig. 2
(b). Hence, a signal processing technique is needed to remove the fluctuation on highresolution THz amplitude spectra measured from the ASOPS THzTDS.
III. THEORETICAL DESCRIPTION OF WPSET
Wavelet based signal processing appears a natural choice for denoising THz pulses since wavelet analysis is good for capturing singularities both in the time and frequency
(a) Typical timedomain waveform on a 10 ns time delay window measured from ASOPS THzTDS at relative humidity of 28%. (b) THz amplitude spectrum obtained by FFT of the timedomain waveform in (a).
domains
[12]
. Signals can be analyzed by wavelet transform using a set of basis shifted and dilated from a mother wavelet
ψ
(
t
), defined as
where
j
and
n
mean the scale and location indices, respectively, and Z is the set of integers. A wavelet basis is an orthogonal basis of
L
^{2}
(R), where R is the set of real numbers and
L
^{2}
(R) corresponds to the Hilbert space for functions
f
(
t
) with finite energy such that
∫
'
f
(
t
) '
^{2}
dt
< +∞ . It is known that any signal f(t)∈
L
^{2}
(R) can be represented as
where
is the inner product. By introducing a scaling function
Φ
, we can also represent Eq.(3) as
where the scaling function
Φ
can be readily derived from a mother wavelet
ψ
and
J
is the maximum scale index for dilation
[16]
. Then, the approximation coefficients {
aj
[
n
]}
j,n
and detail coefficients {
dj
[
n
]}
j,n
are defined by
The approximation and detail coefficients of the discrete signal are processed using a shrinkage operator
P_{T}
(·) :
Many different types of shrinkage operator
P_{T}
(·) have been proposed depending on applications. For example, the hardthresholding defined as
is one of popular methods for denoising
[16]
. Note that an appropriate choice of wavelet is especially important in wavelet analysis. A mother wavelet is usually designed to have appropriate vanishing moments, support size, symmetry,regularity, etc. It is known that the Daubechies wavelet has the maximum vanishing moment for a given support size
[16]
.
A timedomain waveform from conventional THzTDS can be directly processed using a wavelet denoising algorithm. For example, Mittleman et al. demonstrated that the noises in THz timedomain signals can be effectively suppressed by appropriate choice of wavelets
[12]
. Ferguson et al.further demonstrated that Tray images are also greatly improved by wavelet denoising followed by Wiener deconvolution
[13]
. However, the timedomain wavelet denoising cannot effectively remove the fluctuation on a spectrum while retaining spectral information since the fluctuation does not come from noise, but rather from the longlasting signal of the timedomain waveform.
Fig. 3
shows results of the timedomain wavelet denoising where the Daubechies wavelet with 10 vanishing moments was used at the scale of 5. For a low threshold value, the spectral features remain unchanged but the fluctuation is hardly reduced, as shown in
Fig. 3
(a). On the contrary, a high threshold value results in distortion at the singularities as well as
THz amplitude spectra of waveletdenoisedtimedomain waveforms. The orange lines show the raw spectrum in Fig. 2(b) and the black lines the spectra of the timedomain waveforms that are denoised for a low (a) and high (b) threshold value respectively.
reduction of the fluctuation, as shown in
Fig. 3
(b).
Therefore, we employ a direct power spectrum estimation technique to denoise the spectrum
[17]
. Here, the estimation problem of the power spectrum of THzTDS data is regarded as a nonparametric statistical estimation problem of a stationary random process. More specifically, timedomain data
x
[
n
] is assumed to be a real widestationary Gaussian random process with zero mean and covariance
R_{x}
[
n
]=
E
[
x
[
m
]
x
[
m
+
n
] where the
E
[·] is the expectation of an inside parameter. The periodogram of
x
[
n
] is then described by
The periodogram is often used as an estimate of the power spectrum
S
(
v
) which is defined as
If
S
(·) is sufficiently smooth and
N
is large enough, the periodogram and power spectrum satisfy the following asymptotic relation
[17]
:
where
γ
? 0.5772 denotes the EulerMascheroni constant, and {
ε
(
k
):
k
=0, ··· ,
N
} are independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) with zero mean and variance of
π
^{2}
/6. It is known that the periodogram is asymptotically unbiased
[17]
. Hence, the periodogram is quite often used as an estimate of the power spectrum. In wavelet power spectrum estimation, the wavelet transform is directly applied to the log periodogram in Eq. (10). We can define the detailed coefficients for ln
S
(·) and
ε
(·):
Hence, Eq. (10) can be equivalently transformed into
If
max_{ν}
'
ψ
(
ν
) '=
M
< ∞, then the probability density function of
d_{j}^{ε}
[·] converges to the Gaussian probability density function as
N
grows. Since
N
is sufficiently large in highresolution THzTDS, the model Eq. (12) is accurate and the noise has an i.i.d. Gaussian distribution with zero mean
[17]
. Under this condition, the result of wavelet denoising is a nearly minimax optimal estimate of the underlying true log power spectrum
[18]
, and the estimate can be represented by
where the shrinkage operator
P_{T}
is given by Eq. (7).
IV. WAVELET POWER SPECTRUM ESTIMATION
We denoised the THz amplitude spectrum in
Fig. 2
(b) using the WPSET as described above. It is presented in
Fig. 4
that the WPSET can effectively remove the fluctuations above the background noise level on the THz amplitude spectrum without altering the water vapor absorption
THz amplitude spectrum denoised by using the WPSET. The orange and black lines display the raw and denoised spectra respectively.
Magnified views at around 1.16 THz of the raw spectrum (a) and the spectra denoised using the Haar waveletat the scale of 5 (b) the Daubechies wavelet with 10 vanishing moments at the scale of 4 (c) and the Daubechies wavelet with 10 vanishing moments at the scale of 5 (d) respectively.
lines. The Daubechies wavelet with 10 vanishing moments was used at the scale of 5.
To find optimal parameters for wavelet power spectrum estimation, we compared the spectra denoised with different choices of the wavelet and scale.
Fig. 5
shows magnified views around 1.16 THz of the raw spectrum and denoised spectra. The Haar wavelet overestimated the noise at 1.1645 GHz as a real singularity, as shown in
Fig. 5
(b). The Daubechies wavelet offers the minimum support for a given number of vanishing moments
[13]
, which means that it is an optimal wavelet for denoising and detecting singularities simultaneously. Figs. 5(c) and (d) show the spectra that were denoised using the Daubechies wavelet with 10 vanishing moments at the scale of 4 and 5, respectively. It is apparently shown that the spectrum is more effectively denoised at
THz transmission spectra of water vapor resulting from the raw (orange line) and denoised (black line) amplitude spectra. The inset is an enlarged view around 1.16 THz.
the scale of 5, compared to the scale of 4. We also observed that the scales over 6 caused distortion at singularities (not shown here). Therefore, we chose the Daubechies wavelet with 10 vanishing moments and the scale of 5 for the following studies.
To verify the performance of the WPSET, we investigated a THz transmission spectrum of water vapor. The THz transmission spectrum of water vapor was obtained from THz amplitude spectra measured at relative humidity of 28% and 2% and at 21.5℃.
Fig. 6
shows the transmission spectra of water vapor before and after applying the WPSET with the optimized parameters, which are indicated by the orange and black lines, respectively. It is clearly demonstrated that the WPSET can effectively remove the fluctuations without distortion in the water vapor absorption lines. We extracted the center frequencies, linewidths, and transmittances of the 10 strongest absorption lines from the raw and denoised transmission spectra over the frequency range up to 1.5 THz by fitting them to Lorentzian line shapes.
Table 1
lists these values along with the error values of the fitting results from the raw spectrum. The fitting results from the raw spectrum are in good agreement with those from the denoised spectrum within the error values.
V. CONCLUSION
We clearly demonstrated that the wavelet power spectrum estimation technique (WPSET) was successfully applied to highresolution THzTDS. Through the wavelet power spectrum estimation, the fluctuations on highresolution THz amplitude spectra were removed while maintaining original spectral information. By investigating a THz transmission spectrum of water vapor, the parameters of the spectral singularities were shown to remain unchanged after the processing.
Parameters of the absorption lines extracted from the raw and denoised transmission spectra of water vapor.
Parameters of the absorption lines extracted from the raw and denoised transmission spectra of water vapor.
This study shows that the WPSET is ideally suitable for highresolution THzTDS. The WPSET will make highresolution THzTDS more practical by enhancing the spectrum quality. Even if this work was performed in the THz frequency regime, the WPSET can also be applied to highresolution spectroscopy in other frequency regions.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported in part by the Industrial Strategic Technology Program of the Ministry of Knowledge Economy (KI001889) and in part by the Ministry of Education, Science, and Technology through project KRISS10011131.
Lee Y.S
2009
Principles of Terahertz Science and Technology Chapter 3
Springer
New York USA
van Exter M
,
Fattinger Ch
,
Grischkowsky D
1989
Terahertz timedomain spectroscopy of water vapor
Opt. Lett.
14
1128 
1130
Cole B. E
,
Williams J. B
,
King B. T
,
Sherwin M. S
,
Stanley C. R
2001
Coherent manipulation of semiconductor quantum bits with terahertz radiation
Nature
410
60 
63
Pickwell E
,
Wallace V. P
2006
Biomedical applications of terahertz technology
J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys.
39
R301 
R310
Hoshina H
,
Seta T
,
Iwamoto T
,
Hosako I
,
Otani C
,
Kasai Y
2008
Precise measurement of pressure broadening parameters for water vapor with a terahertz timedomain spectrometer
J. Quant. Spectrosc. Radiat. Transfer.
109
2303 
2314
Kim G. J
,
Jeon S. G
,
Kim J. I
,
Jin Y. S
2008
High speed scanning of terahertz pulse by a rotary optical delay line
Rev. Sci. Instrum.
79
1061021 
1061023
Janke C
,
Forst M
,
Nagel M
,
Kurz H
2005
Asynchronous optical sampling for highspeed characterization of integrated resonant terahertz sensors
Opt. Lett.
30
1405 
1407
Yasui T
,
Saneyoshi E
,
Araki T
2005
Asynchronous optical sampling terahertz timedomain spectroscopy for ultrahigh spectral resolution and rapid data acquisition
Appl. Phys. Lett.
87
0611011 
0611013
Bartels A
,
Thoma A
,
Janke C
,
Dekorsy T
,
Dreyhaupt A
,
Winnerl S
,
Helm M
2006
Highresolution THz spectrometer with kHz scan rates
Opt. Express
14
430 
437
Bartels A
,
Cerna R
,
Kistner C
,
Thoma A
,
Hudert F
,
Janke C
,
Dekorsy T
2007
Ultrafast timedomain spectroscopy based on highspeed asynchronous optical sampling
Rev. Sci. Instrum.
78
0351071 
0351078
Kistner C
,
Andre A
,
Fischer T
,
Thoma A
,
Janke C
,
Bartels A
,
Gisler T
,
Maret G
,
Dekorsy T
2007
Hydration dynamics of oriented DNA films investigated by timedomain terahertz spectroscopy
Appl. Phys. Lett.
90
2339081 
2339083
Mittleman D. M
,
Jacobsen R. H
,
Neelamani R
,
Baraniuk R. G
,
Nuss M. C
1998
Gas sensing using terahertz timedomain spectroscopy
Appl. Phys. B
67
379 
390
Ferguson B
,
Abbott D
2001
Denoising techniques for terahertz responses of biological samples
Microelectronics Journal
32
943 
953
Ferguson B
,
Abbott D
2001
Wavelet denoising of optical terahertz pulse imaging data
Fluctuation and Noise Letters
1
L65 
L69
Mittleman D. M
,
Gupta M
,
Neelamani R
,
Baraniuk R. G
,
Rudd J. V
,
Koch M
1999
Recent advances in terahertz imaging
Appl. Phys. B
68
1085 
1094
Mallat S. G
1999
A Wavelet Tour of Signal Processing Chapter 7 9 10
Elsevier Academic Press
Burlington MA USA
Moulin P
1994
Wavelet thresholding techniques for power spectrum estimation
IEEE Trans. Signal Processing
42
3126 
3136
Donoho D. L
,
Johnstone I. M
1994
Ideal spatial adaptation by wavelet shrinkage
Biometrika
81
425 
455