Advanced
High Sensitive Fiber Optic Temperature Sensor Based on a Side-polished Single-mode Fiber Coupled to a Tapered Multimode Overlay Waveguide
High Sensitive Fiber Optic Temperature Sensor Based on a Side-polished Single-mode Fiber Coupled to a Tapered Multimode Overlay Waveguide
Journal of the Optical Society of Korea. 2010. Dec, 14(4): 337-341
Copyright ©2010, Optical Society of Korea
  • Received : August 08, 2010
  • Accepted : November 11, 2010
  • Published : December 25, 2010
Download
PDF
e-PUB
PubReader
PPT
Export by style
Share
Article
Author
Metrics
Cited by
TagCloud
About the Authors
Prerana
Physics Department, Indian Institute of Technology Delhi, New Delhi 110 016, India
Ravendra Kumar Varshney
Physics Department, Indian Institute of Technology Delhi, New Delhi 110 016, India
Bishnu Pada Pal
Physics Department, Indian Institute of Technology Delhi, New Delhi 110 016, India
bppal@physics.iitd.ernet.in
Bezwada Nagaraju
Sterlite Optical Technologies Limited, Aurangabad 431 136, Maharashtra, India
Abstract
A high sensitivity fiber optic temperature sensor based on a side-polished fiber (SPF) coupled to a tapered multimode overlay waveguide (MMOW) is proposed and studied. Both tapered and non-tapered MMOW were considered to study the effect of tapering of MMOW on the characteristics of the device and to investigate the criticality of the uniformity of the multimode overlay waveguide over the SPF.Present study shows that tapering of the MMOW can be used to tune the desired wavelength range without any loss in the sensitivity. Sensitivity up to 9 nm/℃ within the temperature range of 25 to 100℃ can be achieved with the proposed sensor, almost 6 times higher compared even to state-of-the-art high-sensitivity grating-based fiber optic temperature sensors.
Keywords
I. INTRODUCTION
Side-polished fibers (SPF) are the building blocks of many single-mode fiber components such as directional couplers, polarizers, modulators, switches and wavelength filters [1 - 5] due to the accessibility of a significant fraction of the evanescent field of the propagating mode close to the polished surface. The evanescent field coupling between a SPF and an appropriate multimode overlay waveguide(MMOW) has yielded an important platform to realize various fiber optic sensors such as refractive index, pH and temperature sensors [6 - 12] . Such a composite structure essentially functions as an asymmetric directional coupler with a band-stop characteristic attributable to the wavelengthdependent resonant coupling between the guided mode of the SPF and one or more modes of the MMOW. The throughput power of the SPF exhibits dip(s) at the phasematching(or resonant) wavelength(s) [5 , 6] . Since the refractive index ( n0 ) of the film of the MMOW depends on temperature, any change in n0 would modify the mode spectrum of the MMOW and hence the throughput power spectrum of the device, which shifts the resonance wavelength.This shift in resonance wavelength with temperature has been exploited to realize a highly sensitive fiber optic temperature sensor. Since the location of phase resonance wavelength, in turn, depends on the parameters of the MMOW in addition to the propagation characteristics of the SPF, sensitivity of the sensor depends on the MMOW parameters. So far all the reported SPF-MMOW-based sensors assume the MMOW to be uniform. However, in practice,the fabricated MMOW may not necessarily be uniform along its length unless special steps are ensured. Moreover it has been shown recently in a different context that a tapered MMOW is very useful for attaining tunability e.g.filtering characteristics of such devices [13 , 14] .
In this paper, we have studied tunability of the sensitivity of such a temperature sensor by tapering the overlay waveguide interacting with a SPF, and have examined importance of the criticality, if any, of the MMOW’s designed parameters. We have approximated the SPF by an equivalent planar waveguide [15] and pursued the normal mode analysis for the resultant composite structure through a matrix method [16] . Curvature of the single-mode fiber affixed on the polished block was approximated with a staircase profile. This technique has been successfully used to model a fiber-optic temperature sensor with linear response in the temperature range 25 ~ 100℃ having a wavelength sensitivity (in terms of shift in the resonance wavelength) of 6~9 nm/℃, which is much higher compared to even the reported high-sensitive temperature sensors based on in-fiber gratings [17 , 18] . We may mention that the temperature range measurable by this sensor is limited by the choice of the thermo-optic overlay material and can be increased further through suitable choice of a different MMOW. For completeness and standalone understanding of the concept, we describe below the functional principle of the model along the lines we described earlier in [12 , 13] .
II. MODELING OF THE SENSOR
A schematic of a SPF-MMOW-based temperature sensor is shown in Fig. 1 (a), in which a SPF having limited cladding on one side of the fiber core up to a desired extent is loaded on its top with an appropriate thermo-optic MMOW. In order to model this device, we have used a semi-numerical normal mode analysis [5 , 7] , which involves approximating the SPF by an equivalent planar guide (EPG) [15] and the composite structure can then be treated as a planar multi-layered structure as shown in Fig.1 (b). Modal characteristics of such a structure can be easily obtained by using the normal-mode formalism based
PPT Slide
Lager Image
(a) Schematic diagram of the sensing device. (b).Diagram depicting the staircase approximation for taking intoaccount curvature of the fiber and tapered nature of theoverlay waveguide.
on a well-known matrix method [16] . In reality, the remaining cladding thickness of SPF varies along the length of interaction due to the curved nature of the convex slot in which the fiber is fixed. Moreover, overlay waveguide is also typically non-uniform along the length of the block. The effect of both these non-uniformities has been taken into account through the staircase approximation.If the effective interaction length between the SPF and MMOW is Leff and the whole structure comprises of N equi-sized segments of width dz (<< Leff) along the direction of propagation z (see Fig. 1 (b)), then the cladding thickness varies as [4]
PPT Slide
Lager Image
where, Si is the waveguide separation in the ith segment, S0 is the minimum waveguide separation at the center of the block, and Rc is the radius of curvature of the fiber in the groove.
For modeling the tapered waveguide, we assume a linear variation of MMOW thickness along the z direction, whereas,in the case of a non-tapered waveguide the thickness of MMOW is assumed constant in each segment. To evaluate the throughput power of such a structure (shown in Fig.1 (b)), we evaluate the power exchange in terms of the normal modes of the planar multi-layer structure consisting of the EPG and MMOW. We assume that unit power is launched into the device through the SPF, and at the device input it would excite all possible normal modes corresponding to the first segment of the structure. If ψs(x) is the transverse field distribution of the EPG at the input( z=z0 ), it would excite a total field ψ1(x, z0) , which is a linear combination of the modal field [ ψj1 ] of all the normal guided ( M ) modes of the first segment of the structure and is given by
PPT Slide
Lager Image
where
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Since the refractive index distribution corresponding to each segment in the structure is known, the transverse field distributions of all the normal modes would also be calculated and hence the coefficient Aj1 can be easily evaluated. Each of these M modes, i.e. ψ11 , ψ21 ,… ψM1 , would propagate independently through the first segment and accumulate a phase βjidz (where βji is the propagation constant of the jth mode of the first segment). Thus after propagating through a length dz (i.e., at z=z1 ), the total field ψ1 in the first segment would be
PPT Slide
Lager Image
At the interface z=z1 , this would excite a field ψ2 in the second segment of the structure. In this manner, the excitation coefficients of each successive segment can be obtained in terms of those of the previous ones, and the overlap integrals of the modal fields. Finally, at the output of the device, the total field in the last segment N of the structure would excite the mode of the EPG with an excitation coefficient As
PPT Slide
Lager Image
where
PPT Slide
Lager Image
and the normalized throughput power PT (= Pout/Pin ) would be given by
PPT Slide
Lager Image
To study the effect of tapered MMOW on temperature sensing, we have analyzed both tapered and non tapered MMOW on a side-polished fiber. Through simulations, the parameters, S0 , Leff and Rc were found to be 1.9 ㎛, 0.8 mm and 27 cm, respectively. For simulating a tapered overlay, the thickness of MMOW was varied in accordance with the taper ratio, which we define as
PPT Slide
Lager Image
where t1 and tN are thicknesses of the 1st and last ( Nth )segment respectively, under the staircase approximation(see Fig 1 (b)).
Various thicknesses (20-40 ㎛) and ratios were considered in simulations for the tapered MMOW. The thickness of the MMOW on the fabricated sensor was estimated to be 28.5㎛. The SPF half-coupler block used in the device was fabricated in-house with a standard Corning fiber (SMF-28).The unjacketed portion of the fiber was fixed into a convex slot cut in a quartz block of length ~ 3 cm, with radius of curvature ~ 27 cm. Then the block was polished up to the desired extent through selective removal of the fiber cladding from one side. MMOW was realized by spin coating the SPF with an appropriate polymer.
III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Detailed numerical investigations were carried out for the optimization of the device parameters to achieve the desired throughput loss spectrum of the device having clearly identifiable wavelength resonance notches. To demonstrate the sensing ability of the device experimentally, light from a white light source was launched at the input end of the fabricated device. The output power was measured using an optical spectrum analyzer (OSA). Temperature of the device was controlled by using a heater having temperature control and was measured by using a digital thermometer. Figure 2 shows a block diagram of the experimental setup of the proposed sensor.
The variation of throughput power as a function of wavelength i.e. the throughput power spectra, obtained experimentally and theoretically at room temperature, are shown in Fig. 3 . The solid curve corresponds to theoretically estimated
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Schematic block diagram of the experimental setupused for characterization of the sensor.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Throughput power spectrum of the fabricated device;solid and dotted curves correspond to theoretical andexperimental results respectively.
spectrum whereas the dotted curve shows measured throughput spectrum. This figure clearly illustrates a good agreement between our model and the experimental results; whatever small disagreement there is could be attributed to lack of precise knowledge of some of the parameters of the fabricated device, like remaining cladding thickness of the SPF and the consequential length of interaction,..
Figure 4 shows the variation of throughput power as a function of wavelength for two different temperatures for a tapered overlay waveguide ( t1 =20 ㎛ and tN =20.5 ㎛).Three resonance wavelengths (λ r1 , λ r2 and λ r3 ), identifiable in the figure, could be seen to shift with the variation in temperature. Figure 5 illustrates the experimental response of the device in the temperature range of 26-70℃. The
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Spectral response of the throughput power of thedevice with tapered overlay at two different temperatures.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Shift in the resonance wavelength with temperatureas observed in the experiment; data points correspondto experimental values and solid curve is the linear fit.
variation is almost linear with temperature. It is worthwhile to mention that in the simulations similar linear trend was observed even up to ~ 100℃. The resonance wavelength shifts towards a shorter wavelength with increasing temperature,as evident in Fig. 4 . This is due to the fact that the polymer chosen as the overlay has a negative thermo-optic coefficient, i.e., as the temperature increases, the refractive index of the overlay decreases, which results in a blue shift of the resonance wavelengths.
Figure 6 compares the shift (change) in the resonance wavelengths (λ r1 , λ r2 and λ r3 ) with temperature for a tapered MMOW and for the corresponding uniform MMOW by considering the throughput power at 26℃ as the reference.The wavelength shift in both the cases is almost linear with temperature. As can be seen in the figure, the shift in resonance wavelength is nearly the same for both tapered and non-tapered MMOW, and hence both have almost the same sensitivity. However the sensitivity varies with the choice of the resonance wavelength. For example, using a resonance wavelength towards the longer end of the throughput power spectrum (e.g. λ r1 in Fig. 4 ), one can achieve higher sensitivity compared to the sensitivity attained at the lower end of the spectrum (e.g. λ r2 or λ r3 ).The sensitivity of the device as calculated from the slopes of these curves can be tuned by 6 ~ 9 nm/℃. Thus one could choose an operating wavelength based on sourcedetector availability and desired sensitivity. In a uniform MMOW, the spectrum is fixed and so are the positions of dips (resonance wavelength) in the throughput power spectrum while in a tapered MMOW, the resonance dips in the throughput power spectrum can be tuned through slightly translation of the upper quartz block relative to the MMOW underneath. From Fig. 6 , one can also infer that the non-uniformity of the MMOW is really not a matter of concern for attaining high sensitivity of the device as long as the tapering of the MMOW is not large. Moreover in practice, it is hard (almost impossible) to fabricate a device consisting of a MMOW on a side-polished fiber
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Shift in the resonance wavelengths λr1 λr2 and λr3 with temperature for both tapered and non-tapered MMOWwith resonance wavelengths at 26℃ as the reference.
block precisely with the parameters that were obtained at the design optimization stage. Thus our results could be gainfully exploited to tune the device response through slight tapering of the MMOW if desired. Since a small amount of longitudinal taper is usually invariably present in a fabricated MMOW structure, our results indicate extent of tolerance to such longitudinal tapering in MMOW besides explicit results showing utility of such a tapered MMOW, which can be gainfully exploited. Also, the sensitivity achieved in both tapered and non-tapered cases is much higher than the fiber optic temperature sensors that rely on LPG and FBG [17 , 18] .
IV. CONCLUSION
A highly sensitive fiber optic temperature sensor based on evanescent coupling of a side-polished fiber to a multimode overlay waveguide is designed and realized.Both tapered and non-tapered MMOW were studied for the temperature sensitivity. We can achieve sensitivity up to 9 nm/℃ in the temperature range of 25 to ~100℃. The sensitivity is more than 6 times higher compared to earlier reported high-sensitivity fiber optic temperature sensors based on e.g. in-fiber Bragg and long period gratings. Also our studies have indicated that a small tapering in the MMOW is tolerable and it does not affect the sensitivity of the proposed temperature sensor significantly while at the same time offering the advantage of certain amount of tunability in the choice of the operating wavelength/temperature range. Tapering also offers greater possibility of realization of the overall device closer to the parameters optimized at the simulation stage.
References
Varshney R. K , Guided Wave Optics Chapter 7. , Sharma A , Guided Wave Optics Chapter 7. 2005 Side-polished fiber coupler half block and devices Viva Books Pvt. Ltd New Delhi India Guided Wave Optics Chapter 7.
Johnstone W , Thursby G , Moodie D , Varshney R. K , Culshaw B 1992 Fiber optic wavelength channel selector with high resolution Electron. Lett. 28 1364 - 1365
Tseng S. M , Chen C. L 1992 Side polished fibers Appl.Opt. 31 3438 - 3447
Varshney R. K , Singh A , Pande K , Pal B. P 2007 Side polished fiber based gain flattening filter for erbium doped fiber amplifiers Opt. Comm. 271 441 - 444
Pal B. P , Raizada G , Varshney R. K 1996 Modelling a fiber half block with multimode overlay waveguide J.Opt. Comm. 17 179 - 183
Raizada G , Pal B. P 1996 Refractometers and tunable components based on side polished fibers with multimode overlay waveguides: role of the superstrate Opt. Lett. 21 399 - 401
Flannery D , James S. W , Tatamand R. P , Ashwell G. J 1997 pH sensors using Langmuir Blodgett overlay on polished optical fibers Opt. Lett. 15 567 - 569
Sohn K. R , Kim K. T , Kang S. W 2002 Optical fiber sensor for water detection using side polished fiber with a planar glass overlay waveguide Sens. Actuators A 101 137 - 142
Jung W. G , Kim S. W , Kim K. T , Kim E. S , Kang S. W 2001 High sensitivity temperature sensor using a side polished single mode fiber covered with the polymer planar waveguide IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 13 1209 - 1211
Tien C. L , Hwang C. C , Chen H. W , Liu W. F , Lin S.W 2006 Magnetic sensor based on side-polished fiber Bragg grating coated with iron film IEEE Trans. on Magnetics 42 3285 - 3287
Lin H. Y , Tsai W. H , Tsao Y. C , Sheu B. C 2007 Side-polished multimode fiber biosensor based on surface plasmon resonance with halogen light Appl. Opt. 46 800 - 806
Nagaraju B , Varshney R. K , Singh A , Pal B. P , Monnom G , Dussardier B 2008 Design and realization of a side-polished single-mode fiber optic high sensitive temperature sensor Proc. SPIE 7138 71381H-1 - 71381H-6
Varshney R. K , Nagaraju B , Singh A , Pal B. P , Kar A.K 2007 Design and realization of an all-fiber broadband tunable gain equalization filter for DWDM signals Opt.Express 15 13519 - 13530
Kim K. T , Hwangbo S , Mah J. P , Sohn K. R 2005 Widely tunable filter based on coupling between a side-polished fiber and a tapered planar waveguide IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett. 17 142 - 144
Sharma A , Kompella J , Mishra P. K 1990 Analysis of fiber directional coupler half blocks using a new simple model for single mode fiber 8 143 - 151
Ghatak A. K , Thyagarajan K , Shenoy M. R 1987 Numerical analysis of planar optical waveguides using matrix method IEEE J. Lightwave Technol. 5 660 - 667
Rao Y. J 1997 In-fiber grating sensors Meas. Sci. Technol. 8 355 -
Kersey A. D , Davis M. A , Patrick H. J , LeBlanc M , Koo K.P , Askins C. G , Putnam M. A , Friebele E. J 1997 Fiber grating sensors IEEE J. Lightwave Technol. 15 1442 - 1463