We printed a one-dimensional array of metallic wires and a two-dimensional array of metallic split ring resonators on a photo-paper by using a high-dots-per-inch resolution printer and an ink with silver nano-particles. The printed sample sizes are 1.0 × 1.0 cm
2
. The transmission measured by a terahertz time domain spectroscopy system shows that the arrays of wires and split ring resonators could act as polarizers and band-stop filters, respectively, in a terahertz frequency region.
I. INTRODUCTION
Terahertz (THz) waves are electromagnetic radiation with frequencies generally in a range of 0.1 to 10 THz, between the microwaves and the far-infrared
[1]
. Owing to recent advancements in optical and electrical components, efficient THz sources, detectors, and passive devices have been developed
[2]
. THz time-domain spectroscopy (THz-TDS) and THz imaging systems still demand suitable THz components for improving their performance.
Artificial periodic structures have been demonstrated to be useful in manipulating electromagnetic waves. The representative example is a photonic crystal which is periodically composed of materials with different dielectric constant
[3]
. Photonic crystals can improve the performance of optical devices such as waveguides, filters, light emitting diodes, and semiconductor lasers. Metallic periodic structures are also useful in improving radiation efficiency and patterns of antennas in microwave and millimeter wave ranges
[4
,
5]
. Thus periodic structures are expected to be useful in manipulating THz waves and could act as functional devices in a THz frequency range
[6
-
10]
.
Usually, planar metallic structures on solid or flexible films have been fabricated by a photolithography technique including nine steps: making a photo-mask, cleaning the substrate, spin-coating the photo-resist, baking, exposure, development, post-baking, metal evaporation (etching) and resist removal. The processes demand a long task time and high cost.
Recently, printing techniques have been widely used in fabricating electronic components on polymer films. The printing method has only 3 steps: cleaning substrate, ink-jet printing, and heating. The last process lets silver nanoparticles be sintered together and thus a printed sample becomes metallic. The printing method reduces processing time and effort for fabrication of planar T
y
pe metallic structures on films. Walter et al., reported THz transmission of periodic arrays of split ring resonators (SRRs) printed on a polyimide substrate with ink including silver nanoparticles
[11]
. Hangyo et al., also reported fabrication of wire-grid structures and SRRs on high-resistiviT
y
Si substrates by using a super-fine ink-jet printer with silver paste ink
[12]
. The printed structures act a good polarizer and filter. Thus the printing method can be useful in fabricating periodic structures to work in a THz range. It is interesting to print the periodic structures on conventional photo-papers to have no absorption in a THz range. A photo-paper is also flexible as well as cheap. Moreover, surface treatments such as plasma or ultrasonic cleaning are not required, unlike Si-substrates and polymide substrates.
In this paper, we report fabrication of a one-dimensional arrays of metallic wires and two-dimensional arrays of metallic SRRs by using an ink-jet printer and a conductive ink with silver nanoparticles. The structures were printed on a conventional photo-paper. The THz spectral responses are measured by a home-made THz-TDS system. The measured spectra show that the metallic wire array can act as a THz polarizer and the SSR array can act as a THz band-stop filter in a certain THz range.
II. FABRICATION
A high-dpi (dots-per-inch) resolution drop-on-demand printer and a conductive ink were employed to fabricate metallic periodic arrays on a conventional photo-paper. We printed a one-dimensional array of wires on a general-purpose photo paper with an ink containing silver nano-particles (DGP-40LT-15C) by using an ink-jet printer (DMP-2831). The samples were placed on a hot plate at 130℃ during 30 minutes for the sintering of silver nano-particles.
Microscopic image of a printed one-dimensional array of wires with the period of 300 μm and the width of 140 μm (a) and a two-dimensional array of single split ring resonators (b). The one side length of a SSR is about 150 μm. The line width and the gap size are about 20 μm and 50 μm, respectively. The period of the array is about 230 μm.
The feature resolution of a printed structure depends on a nozzle to jet ink drops and compositions of ink. We have tried to find conditions to give a good feature resolution by varying both the weight percent of Ag in the ink and temperature and bias-voltage of a nozzle. After a lot of trial and error, we achieved 20 μm-feature resolution that is good for printing periodic arrays to work in a THz frequency range under the conditions that temperature and bias-voltage of a nozzle are about 30℃ and 16 V, respectively, and the weight percent of Ag is 32.0. However, printed arrays with 20 μm-feature resolution do not exhibit metallic properties because few Ag nano-particles are sintered in printed 20 μm-lines. To improve probabiliT
y
of sintering between Ag nano-particles, we iterated printing on the same place maintaining the 20 μm-feature resolution. We have found that four iteration printing is enough to make structures which exhibit metallic properties.
Fig. 1(a)
shows the printed one-dimensional array of wires with a period of 300 μm and width of 140 μm. A two-dimensional array of SRRs printed on the photo paper is shown in
Fig. 1(b)
. The one side length of a SSR is about 150 μm. The line width and the gap size are about 20 μm and 50 μm, respectively. The period of the array is about 230 μm. The printed sample sizes are about 1.0 × 1.0 cm
2
.
III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Fig. 1(a)
shows the printed one-dimensional array of wires with a period of 300 μm and width of 140 μm. A two-dimensional array of SRRs printed on the photo paper is shown in
Fig. 1(b)
. The one side length of a SSR is about 150 μm. The line width and the gap size are about 20 μm and 50 μm, respectively. The period of the array is about 230 μm. The printed sample sizes are about 1.0 × 1.0 cm
2
.
Schematic view of a home-made terahertz-time domain spectroscopy system employed in experiments.
Fig. 3
shows the transmission spectra of the one-dimensional wire array for THz pulses with polarizations perpendicular (
x
-polarized) and parallel (
y
-polarized) to the wire when THz pulses are normally incident on the sample. The transmission spectrum of the paper was presented as a reference spectrum. The transmittances of the sample were normalized to that of the paper. One can see that the planar onedimensional wire array prevents the
y
-polarized THz waves with frequencies below 0.35 THz from transmitting through the sample, while it does not affect the
x
-polarized THz waves. The
y
-polarized waves induce currents in the wires and thus the wire array structure acts effectively as a metal for the waves. However, for the x-polarized waves, the structure does not act as a metal but, in effect, as a lossy dielectric because currents are not induced by the x-polarized waves. In fact, due to the polarization dependent properT
y
, a one-dimensional metallic wire array has been used as a polarizer for waves with wavelengths much longer than the period of the array
[14
,
15]
.
To test the abiliT
y
of our sample as a THz polarizer, we calculated the ratio of transmittances of
x
- and
y
-polarized THz waves,
P
xy
=
T
x
/
T
y
, shown in
Fig. 4
.
P
xy
calculated from transmittance data is depicted in
Fig. 3
. The dashed line indicates
P
xy
= 3.
T
x
is larger than three times
T
y
in a frequency range between 0.1 and 0.4 THz. Thus the printed wire array could be a polarizer in that range.
Fig. 5
shows the transmission spectra of a two-dimensional array of SRRs for the
x
- and
y
-polarized THz waves. The dashed line presents the transmission spectrum of a paper used as a substrate. One can see that the SRR array exhibits a transmission dip around 0.325 THz, for the y-polarized wave. It has been demonstrated that the
y
-polarized wave induces a current circulating along a SRR, and a magnetic properT
y
with negative permeabiliT
y
. Thus, a SRR array strongly reflects an electromagnetic wave in a frequency range where permeabiliT
y
is negative. Our printed sample has negative permeabiliT
y
around 0.325 THz
[16]
.
Transmission spectra of the one-dimensional wire array for the x- and the y-polarized THz waves when THz waves are normally incident on the sample. The transmission spectrum of the paper was presented as a reference spectrum.
The SRR structure has been also modeled to be a
LC
resonant circuit because the metallic line of a SRR gives rise to an inductance and the gap of a SRR gives rise to a capacitance
[17]
. A
LC
resonant circuit exhibits high impedance at the resonant frequency and thus electromagnetic waves are highly reflected from the SRR array structure around the resonant frequency which corresponds to a frequency range with negative permeabiliT
y
. The resonant characteristic of a SRR could make the SRR array a THz band stop filter.
The ratio of transmittances of x- and y-polarized THz waves, Pxy = Tx /Ty, of the printed one-dimensional array of wires.
Transmission spectra of a two-dimensional array of SRRs for the x- and y-polarized THz waves. The dotted line presents the transmission spectrum of a substrate paper.
IV. CONCLUSION
A one-dimensional array of wires and a two-dimensional array of split ring resonators were printed on a photo-paper with an ink including silver nano-particles. The printed sample sizes are about 1.0 × 1.0 cm
2
. The transmission measured by a THs system shows that the arrays of wires and split ring resonators could act as a polarizer and a band-stop filter in a THz region, respectively. The printing method could be a tool to realize various structures for functional THz devices.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the National Research Foundation Grant funded by the Korea Government (2010- 0014291) and Photonics 2020 research project through a grant provided by GIST in 2010.
Dexheimer S
2007
Terahertz Spectroscopy: Principles and Applications
Taylor & Francis
London UK
Lee Y.S
2008
Principles of Terahertz Science and Technology
Springer
New York USA
Joannopoulos J
,
Johnson S
,
Meade R
,
Winn J
1995
Photonic Crystals: Molding the Flow of Light
Princeton University Press
Princeton NJ USA
Brown E.R
,
Parker C.D
,
Yablonovitch E
1993
Radiation properties of a planar antenna on a photonic crystal substrate
J Opt Soc Am B
10
404 -
407
DOI : 10.1364/JOSAB.100404
Gonzalo R
,
de Maagt P
,
Sorolla M
1999
Enhanced patch-antenna performance by suppressing surface waves using photonic-bandgap substrate
IEEE Trans Microw Theory Tech
47
2131 -
2138
DOI : 10.1109/22.798009
Zhao Y
,
Grischkowsky D
2006
Terahertz demonstrations of effectively two-dimensional photonic bandgap structures
Opt Lett
31
1534 -
1536
DOI : 10.1364/OL.311534
Prasad T
,
Colvin V.L
,
Jian Z
,
Mittleman D.M
2007
Superprism effect in a metal-clad terahertz photonic crystal slab
Opt Lett
32
683 -
685
DOI : 10.1364/OL.320683
Zhao Y
,
Grischkowsky D
2007
2-D terahertz metallic photonic crystals in parallel-plate waveguides
IEEE Trans Microw Theory Tech
55
656 -
663
DOI : 10.1109/TMTT.2007.892798
Han H
,
Park H
,
Cho M
,
Kim J
2002
Terahertz pulse propagation in a plastic photonic crystal fiber
Appl Phys Lett
80
2634 -
2636
DOI : 10.1063/1.1468897
Kim S
,
Kee C.S
,
Lee J
2007
Single-mode condition and dispersion of terahertz photonic crystal fiber
J Opt Soc Korea
11
97 -
100
DOI : 10.3807/JOSK.2007.11.3.097
Walther M
,
Ortner A
,
Meier H
,
Loffelmann U
,
Smith P.J
,
Korvink J.G
2009
Terahertz metamaterials fabricated by inkjet printing
Appl Phys Lett
95
251107 -
251107
DOI : 10.1063/1.3276544
Takano K
,
Kawabata T
,
Hsieh C.F
,
Akiyama K
,
Miyamaru F
,
Abe Y
,
Tokuda Y
,
Pan R.P
,
Pan C.L
,
Hangyo M
2010
Fabrication of terahertz planar metamaterials using a super-fine ink-jet printer
Appl Phys Exp
3
016701 -
016701
DOI : 10.1143/APEX.3.016701
Costley A.E
,
Hursey K.H
,
Neill G.F
,
Wald J.M
1977
Free-standing fine-wire grids: their manufacture performance and use at millimeter and submillimeter wavelengths
J Opt Soc Am
67
979 -
981
DOI : 10.1364/JOSA.670979
Mok C.L
,
Chambers W.G
,
Parker T.J
,
Costley A.E
1979
Far-infrared performance and application of freestanding grids wound from 5μm diameter tungsten wire
Infrared Phys
19
437 -
442
DOI : 10.1016/0020-0891(79)90055-1
Yen T.J
,
Padilla W.J
,
Fang N
,
Vier D.C
,
Smith D.R
,
Pendry J.B
,
Basov D.N
,
Zhang X
2004
Terahertz magnetic response from artificial materials
Science
303
1494 -
1496
DOI : 10.1126/science.1094025
Marques F
,
Mesa J
,
Martel F
,
Medina
2003
Comparative analysis of edge- and broadside- coupled split ring resonators for metamaterial design - theory and experiments
IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation
51
2572 -
2581
DOI : 10.1109/TAP.2003.817562