Application of welding simulation to block joints in shipbuilding and assessment of welding-induced residual stresses and distortions

International Journal of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering.
2014.
Jun,
6(2):
459-470

This is an Open-Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

- Published : June 30, 2014

Download

PDF

e-PUB

PubReader

PPT

Export by style

Share

Article

Metrics

Cited by

TagCloud

Ship structure, Block joint, Welding-induced residual stress, Distortion
;
Numerical welding simulation

INTRODUCTION

The welding simulation is today a wide-spread method to predict the welding-induced distortions and residual stresses. Not the process is modelled here, but the heat-input into the weld.
First attempts to explain the effects of the weld process in a scientific way started with the development of heat conduction models. Already in 1941,
Rosenthal (1941)
published a set of formulae for the calculation of the temperature field due to a moving heat source. 1952 appeared one of the detailed books by
Rykalin (1952)
for the calculation of the temperature development during welding. In the 1980’s, these theories were further developed by
Lancaster (1986)
. Different partial phenomena such as the formation of the arc with plasma flux, the vaporization at the surface of the molten weld pool, the melting and dropping of the electrode as well as the forming of the weld bead surface were increasingly included in the investigations (
Karlsson and Lindgren, 1990
;
Lowke et al., 1992
;
Choo and Szekely, 1994
;
Hoffmeister, 1986
;
Ruyter, 1993
;
Böllinghaus, 1995
). Up to then the individual models were only partially combined to models for engineering purposes (
Haibach, 2002
;
Radaj, 2003
;
Rörup, 2003
;
Radaj et al., 2006
). The accuracy of the simulations was determined in the past mainly by the limited computer capacity. With the increasing development in this area, new possibilities exist to increase the accuracy of the models.
Generally, different levels of accuracy of such simulations exist, starting from the modelling, followed by the implementation of the temperature-dependent material data until the consideration of the phase transformation. The more parameters are considered in the computation, the larger will be the time required for the solution. For this reason, the considered geometry is far idealized in many cases, however, it has been seldom verified up to now if the original geometry behaves in the same way, i.e. the results are comparable and transferable. Therefore, the main objective of the investigation presented here is to develop a method which allows the computation of relatively large geometries. A block joint in the forward part of a RO/RO vessel is considered. Local regions, idealized with small models, are compared with the results of the original geometry (block joint) so that conclusions regarding the comparability and transferability of the results from small models can be drawn and the simplified models can be used during fatigue design. All computations were performed with the finite element program ANSYS.
PROCEDURE

In addition to the computing time mentioned above, another problem exists during the investigation of large structures: The validation of the results is frequently impossible. Therefore it is very important to verify the algorithm chosen. The application of the welding simulation to the block joint considered requires simplifications because otherwise computation times of several months would have to be expected. A stepwise reduction of the mesh density is performed, starting point for the calibration of the different mesh density is a reference model which was thoroughly investigated and validated in an extensive research project (
Zacke and Fricke, 2011
). As shown in
Fig. 1
, a comparison model is calibrated against this reference model, the former containing the necessary simplifications in order to transfer the process to the block joint (original geometry).
PPT Slide

Lager Image

REFERENCE MODEL

The reference model consists of a plate with a 250
PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

Heat input.

PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

COMPARISON MODEL

A great number of approaches exist to simplify the algorithm for calculating residual stresses. The objective of the calculation has to be taken into account and determines or limits admissible measures; therefore, these have to be defined at first: the residual stress state of the original geometry (block joint) shall be determined. It is not wanted to compute the exact residual stress distribution in the local weld region where very high temperature and stress gradients occur which would require a very fine mesh. This local area is restricted to about 2.5 times the weld seam width acc. to
Osawa et al. (2007)
.
Furthermore, it is assumed that phase transformation and the associated changes in material data do not have a significant effect on the development of residual stresses. The effects of phase transformation are, of course, known and can be considered in specialized simulation software, however, the welding simulations of the reference model (
Zacke and Fricke, 2011
) have shown that the distortions and the reaction forces can be well determined when neglecting phase transformation.
Apart from the knowledge of the input parameters, decisive is the necessary mesh fineness when performing a welding simulation. Normally, element lengths of a few millimetres are used which lead to an enormous number of nodal points. The requirement of small elements is due to the high temperature gradients. If these are not correctly reproduced, the resulting strains and stresses and also the reaction forces cannot correspond to reality. Therefore, the temperature field with its input parameters and mesh density are calibrated with measurements. The temperature distribution is created by a heat source which represents the welding nozzle respectively the feed wire at a definite instant of time. As the nozzle is moving continuously along the weld, the question has to be answered how the increments of the heat source are defined during the simulation.
Fig. 7
illustrates the situation.
From an engineering point of view, the essential problem is the correct heat input of the total energy and the formation of the three temperature gradients in space. As the focus is only on global residual stresses, it seems to be logical to calibrate the model on the basis of the measured reaction forces which result from the shrinking due to the thermal load. This has the advantage that a coarser mesh is possible as the final stage is compared and not the temperature field resulting from the first step of the analysis.
PPT Slide

Lager Image

- • Reduction of the multi-pass to a single-pass weld
- • Increase of the element length (and hence, the increment of the heat source)

PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

ORIGINAL GEOMETRY (BLOCK JOINT)

The original geometry is a block joint in the forebody of a 193
PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

VALIDATION OF THE SIMPLIFICATIONS

The procedure is validated by comparing the results of the original geometry (block joint) with those obtained for the comparison model containing the same simplifications and the reference model for which extensive measurements have been performed. These are the basis for the validation, see also
Fig. 1
.
As illustrated in
Fig. 14
, the reference model, which represents a section of the block joint due to its constraining conditions, corresponds to a section in the first plate field just above the inner bottom. The calculated residual stresses are compared with those in the reference model in the following.
PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

ASSESSMENT OF THE RESULTS

The welding simulation was performed as shown in
Fig. 12
in three sections. The computation time of clustered workstations was six days. The results presented in the following refer only to longitudinal membrane stresses in the components.
Fig. 18
shows these stresses in the shell after the weld in the third section has cooled down. The stresses represent the global stress state acting transverse to the weld line.
The first impression is that the welding of the block joint affects a large region when looking at the resulting residual stresses. The longitudinal stresses reach values between 11 and 33
PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS

The paper describes the application of the numerical welding simulation to a block joint in shipbuilding. The main objective is the determination of the residual stresses occurring due to the constraint by the surrounding structure. Its effect was at first studied by 250
Acknowledgements

The investigations were performed within the project “Strength of block joints welded with wide gaps in shipbuilding” which was funded with public means within the programme “Industrial Cooperative Research” by the German Federal Ministry of Economics and Technology via the AiF and was coordinated by the Center of Maritime Technologies (CMT) in Hamburg.

Böllinghaus T.
1995
Determination of crack-critical shrinkage restraints and hydrogen distribution in welded joints bynumerical simulation (in German). Dissertation
Universität der Bundeswehr
Hamburg

Choo R.T.
,
Szekely J.
1994
The possible role of turbulence in GTA weld pool behavior
Welding Journal Research Supplement
74
(2)
25s -
31s

Fricke W.
,
Zacke S.
2011
Application of welding simulation to block joints in shipbuilding and assessment ofwelding-induced residual stresses (in German). Jahrb. der Schiffbautechnischen Gesellschaft 105, ‘Hansa‘
Schiffahrts-Verlag
Hamburg

Goldak M.
,
Bibby A.
1984
A new finite element model for welding heat sources
Metallurgical Transaction B
15B
299 -
305

Haibach E.
2002
Betriebsfestigkeit - Verfahren und Daten zur Bauteilberechnung (Fatigue strength - procedures anddata for analysis of components)
Springer-Verlag
Berlin, Heidelberg

Hoffmeister H.
1986
Concept and procedure description of the IRC test for assessing hydrogen assisted weld cracking
Steel Research (AEW)
57
(7)
345 -
347

Huismann G.
,
Savu D.
2001
Welding of large gaps at butt joints of shipbuilding blocks (in German), Final Report ofBMBF Research Project 03SX133B/Teilprojekt P3.1
Universität der Bundeswehr
Hamburg

Karlsson L.
,
Lindgren L.E.
,
Rappaz M.
1990
Modeling of Casting, Welding and Advanced Solidification Processes V
Minerals, Metals & Materials Society
5th Internationalconference on modeling of casting and welding processes

Lancaster J.F.
1986
The physics of welding
2rd Ed.
Pergamon Press
Oxford

Lowke J.J.
,
Kovitya P.
,
Schmidt H.P.
1992
Theory of free-burning arc columns including the influence of thecathode
Journal of Physics D Applied Physics
25
(11)
1600 -
1606

Osawa N.
,
Hashimoto K.
,
Sawamura J.
,
Nakai T.
,
Suzuki S.
2007
Study on shell-solid coupling FE analysis for fatigueassessment of ship structure
Marine Structures
20
(3)
143 -
163
** DOI : 10.1016/j.marstruc.2007.04.002**

Radaj D.
2003
Welding residual stresses and distortion: calculation and measurement
DVS-Verlag
Düsseldorf

Radaj D.
,
Sonsino C.M.
,
Fricke W.
2006
Fatigue assessment of welded joints by local approaches
2nd Ed.
Woodhead Publishing
Cambridge

Rörup J.
2003
Influence of compressive mean stresses on the fatigue strength of welded ship structures (in German).Report 619, Schriftenreihe Schiffbau
TU Hamburg-Harburg
Hamburg

Rosenthal D.
1941
Mathematical theory of heat distribution during welding and cutting
Transactions ASME Supplement
20
(5)
220s -
234s

Ruyter E.
1993
Development and assessment of welding procedures for avoiding weld joint cracking in highly restrainedoffshore steel structures. Dissertation
Universität der Bundeswehr
Hamburg

Rykalin N.
1952
Die Wärmegrundlagen des Schweißvorganges (Thermal fundamentals of the welding process), Band 1
Verlag Technik
Berlin

2006
Production standard of the german shipbuilding industry
7rd Ed.
Verband für Schiffbau und Meerestechnik e.V
Hamburg

Wichers M.
2006
Welding under uniaxial cyclic loading - experimental and numerical investigations (in German). Dissertation
Universität Braunschweig, Braunschweig
Germany

Zacke S.
,
Fricke W.
,
Guedes Soares C.
,
Fricke W.
2011
Advances inMarine Structures
Taylor & Francis Group
London
Welding of large gaps of block joints in ships using different techniques

Citing 'Application of welding simulation to block joints in shipbuilding and assessment of welding-induced residual stresses and distortions
'

@article{ E1JSE6_2014_v6n2_459}
,title={Application of welding simulation to block joints in shipbuilding and assessment of welding-induced residual stresses and distortions}
,volume={2}
, url={http://dx.doi.org/10.2478/IJNAOE-2013-0192}, DOI={10.2478/IJNAOE-2013-0192}
, number= {2}
, journal={International Journal of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering}
, publisher={The Society of Naval Architects of Korea}
, author={Fricke, Wolfgang
and
Zacke, Sonja}
, year={2014}
, month={Jun}