On the effects of hull-girder vibration upon fatigue strength of a Post-Panamax container ship disaggregated by short-term sea state

International Journal of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering.
2014.
Jun,
6(2):
431-441

This is an Open-Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

- Published : June 30, 2014

Download

PDF

e-PUB

PubReader

PPT

Export by style

Article

Metrics

Cited by

TagCloud

Fatigue strength
;
Hull-girder vibration
;
Miner’s rule
;
Short-term sea state
;
Post-Panamax container ship

INTRODUCTION

According to the current trend of larger size container ship, the effect of hull-girder vibrations such as springing and whipping on the fatigue strength becomes the main concern of classification societies as well as ship structural designers. This is because the wave-induced hull-girder vibrations are likely to occur due to relative decrease of flexural rigidity of larger ships, and this fact has raised fears that the high frequency stress components of vibration increase the fatigue damages. In spite of the fear, however, serious damages attributed to such hull-girder vibrations were rarely reported in well-maintained properlyoperated ships up to now.
The fatigue strength of a ship is usually evaluated by using Miner’s rule. Miner’s rule is based on the linear cumulative law and the fatigue damage is considered to be proportional to the ratio of the number of applied stress cycle to that to cause failure at any stress range. This means that the small amplitude components are still effective on the fatigue damage, particularly in the case where the number of occurrence is large enough.
The fatigue strength has well been estimated by Miner’s rule in a practical sense so far. This is because the calibration of the method using accumulated experiences and past data was rightly done. However, the applicability of Miner’s rule to the case where the smaller amplitude higher frequency stress components are superposed on the larger amplitude lower frequency stress components is not clear at the moment. Actually, through fatigue tests and numerical simulations, it was shown recently that the smaller amplitude higher frequency stress component does not affect so much as is expected (
Matsuda et al., 2011
;
Gotoh et al., 2012
;
Kitamura et al., 2012
;
Sumi, 2012
).
In the present paper, the effects of hull-girder vibration upon fatigue strength of a Post-Panamax container ship are investtigated. Nonlinear time-domain simulations of ship response are performed in short-term sea states, and the obtained stress histories are processed by means of the rainflow counting method. The cumulative fatigue damage factors are then evaluated by using Miner’s rule disaggregated by short-term sea state. Through the calculated results, the characteristics of fatigue damage factor estimated by using Miner’s rule is discussed in the case where the smaller amplitude higher frequency stresses are superposed on the larger amplitude lower frequency stresses.
OCCURRENCE PROBABILITY OF SHORT-TERM SEA STATE

Assuming that the lifetime of a ship is 25 years and the mean duration of a short-term sea state is roughly 3 hours, the occurrence probability of a short-term sea state is given by (
Fukasawa et al., 2007
).
PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

Occurrence probability index of a short-term sea state,K, obtained from IACS North-Atlantic wave scatter diagram.

PPT Slide

Lager Image

HULL-GIRDER STRESS CALCULATIONS

The effect of hull-girder vibrations upon fatigue damage of a ship will be investigated in the present paper. A Post-Panamax type container ship is used in the study, of which particulars are
RAINFLOW COUNTING METHOD

A ship in service experiences complex load histories and the resulting stress amplitude is not constant, which bears little resemblance to the constant amplitude fatigue test. In order to apply Miner’s rule in the assessment of the fatigue life of a ship, the complex stress time history have to be broken down into recognizable stress cycles by using a ‘cycle counting method’. The cycle counting is a procedure which is carried out to convert a complex stress history into a sequence of identifiable stress cycles; the complex stresses are divided into blocks of constant amplitude, and the service stresses are expressed in terms of numbers of complete cycles at particular stress levels.
The rainflow counting method is the most popular counting technique in the analysis of fatigue data, where a stress spectrum is reduced into a set of simple stress reversals (
Matsuishi et al., 1968
). The rainflow algorithm can be explained by an analogy to the flow of rainwater over a series of rooftops. The water flows down from each turning point and continues until either it is interrupted by flow from above or it reaches a turning point which is larger than the one that started. By using the rainflow counting method, the stress range against number of cycles occurring at that range can be obtained.
The fatigue life of a structural member subjected to the stress sequence is then estimated by summing up the calculated fatigue damage arising from each block of cycles using a cumulative damage rule.
FATIGUE DAMAGE ANALYSIS ACCORDING TO MINER’S RULE

The damage rule which is most widely used nowadays is Palmgren-Miner linear cumulative damage rule, or simply called as Miner’s rule. This rule states that the fatigue damage from any particular stress range is proportional to the ratio of the number of cycles applied at that stress to the number of cycles which is required to cause failure. The cumulative fatigue damage factor
PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

SIMULATED RESULTS AND CONSIDERATIONS

The stress history of the ship in each short-term sea state was firstly calculated by means of nonlinear simulations of ship response. The calculated stress peaks were processed by the rainflow counting method, and the stress ranges against number of cycles occurring at that ranges were obtained. The fatigue damages were then estimated by applying Miner’s rule in each shortterm sea state.
- Hull-girder vibration in each short-term sea state

Firstly, the effect of the hull-girder vibrations to the fatigue damage factor is investigated in the disaggregated short-term sea state. For this purpose, the calculated results assuming the ship’s hull to be a rigid body are compared with the results assuming that to be a flexible body. The rigid ship is the rigid limit of the hull and there is no vibration expected.
Table 2
shows the rounded ratio of the fatigue damage factor in flexible body assumption to that in the rigid body assumption, where the ship is travelling in each short-term sea state for 3 hours. It can be seen from the table that the ratio is large around the sea state of
Ratio of fatigue damage factor in flexible body assumption to that in rigid body assumption in short-term sea state (Rounded to unit).

PPT Slide

Lager Image

- Fatigue damage factor disaggregated by short-term sea state

As was mentioned before, the total number of occurrence of short-term sea states in the lifetime of a ship can be considered to be the order of 10
Fatigue damage factor in each short-term sea state (Rigid body,Ntotal= 100,000).

PPT Slide

Lager Image

Fatigue damage factor in each short-term sea state (Flexible body,Ntotal= 100,000).

PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

- Effect of hull-girder vibration on fatigue damage factor

The fatigue damage factor is larger in the short-term sea state category of occurrence probability of 10
PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

- Consideration of cycle counting procedure based on the crack propagation behavior

The fatigue crack propagation behaviors under variable amplitude loading with different frequency components are investigated recently by means of fatigue testing and numerical simulations (
Matsuda et al., 2011
;
Gotoh et al., 2012
;
Kitamura et al., 2012
;
Sumi, 2012
). According to the results of such research works, the smaller amplitude component of higher frequency superposed on the larger amplitude component of lower frequency has not significant effect on the fatigue damage, but only the enlargement effect of the total amplitudes of the superposed stress is effective. This means that the smaller amplitude component of stress range does not affect the fatigue strength so much even if the number of cycles is large, but the enlargement effect in stress range by the smaller amplitude component of higher frequency is important in the fatigue strength. This effect can roughly be demonstrated by counting zero crossing peaks, rather than local peaks, in the rainflow counting method.
The fatigue damage factor in each short-term sea state obtained by using the zero crossing peak counting method is shown in
Table 5
, where the ship’s hull is assumed to be a flexible body. The largest fatigue damage factor is 0.094 to be exact in the sea state of
Fatigue damage factor in each short-term sea state (Zero crossing counting, flexible body,Ntotal= 100,000).

PPT Slide

Lager Image

Ratio of fatigue damage factors counted by local peak and that counted by zero crossing peak in short-term sea state (Flexible body).

PPT Slide

Lager Image

PPT Slide

Lager Image

CONCLUSIONS

The effect of hull-girder vibrations on the fatigue damage factor is investigated in the present paper for a Post-Panamax container ship by applying the rainflow counting method and Miner’s rule to the fatigue strength estimation. The conclusions obtained are as follows:
- (1) If the ship is assumed to encounter 100,000 sea states according to the occurrence probability of the short-term sea state given in the IACS North Atlantic wave scatter diagram, the total cumulative fatigue damage factor is almost unity in the case where the ship’s hull is assumed to be rigid. In this context, Miner’s rule can be considered to be reasonably applicable to the fatigue strength design of a ship.
- (2) However, if the ship’s hull is assumed to be flexible, the total cumulative fatigue damage factor becomes almost double as many as that in the case of rigid body ship.
- (3) In the above two cases, the short-term sea state of the occurrence probability of 10-2contributes largely to the fatigue damage factor among the categorized short-term sea states of the occurrence probability of 10-K.
- (4) The stress range around 100MPahas a significant effect on the fatigue damage in the present ship, and a peak can be seen in the fatigue damage factor around the stress range of 100MPa. It is important to confirm whether this phenomenon can be observed or not in the actual fatigue damage of a ship taking account of the nonlinearity in crack initiation/propagation behavior.
- (5) In the case where the smaller amplitude component of higher frequency vibration superposed on the larger amplitude component of lower frequency vibration, the enlargement effect of the total amplitudes of superposed stress is dominant in the fatigue damage factor, and the number of cycle of the small amplitude component has insignificant effect.
- (6) The fatigue damage factor is reasonably evaluated by the rainflow counting method even in the case where the smaller amplitude component of higher frequency vibration superposed on the larger amplitude component of lower frequency vibration.
- (7) The crack initiation and propagation behaviors are nonlinear phenomena and there may be some limitation in the application of Miner’s rule to estimate the fatigue damage precisely. Further investigation would be necessary to clarify the effect of hull-girder vibration upon the fatigue strength of a ship by taking account of stress histories which is effective in the crack initiation and propagation as well as the mean stress effect due to still water bending moment.

Derbanne Q.
,
Rezende F.
,
de Hauteclocque G.
,
Chen X.B.
2011
Evaluation of rule-based fatigue design loads associated at a new probability level
Proceedings 21st International Offshore and Polar Engineering Conference, ISOPE 2011
929 -
935

Fukasawa T.
2012
Some Considerations on the effect of wave-induced vibrations upon hull-girder fatigue strength of a Post-Panamax container ship
Hydroelasticity in Marine Technology, Hydroelasticity 2012
389 -
398

Fukasawa T.
,
Kawabe H.
,
Moan T.
2007
On extreme ship response in severe short-term sea state, Advancements in Marine Structures
1st Int. Conf. on Marine Structures, Advancement in Marine Structures, MARSTRUCT 2007
33 -
40

Gotoh K.
,
Matsuda K.
,
Kitamura O.
2012
Numerical simulation of fatigue crack propagation under superposed loading histories with two different frequencies
Hydroelasticity in Marine Technology, Hydroelasticity 2012
287 -
297

2003
Guidelines for container carrier structures
ClassNK
Chiba Japan

Kitamura O.
,
Sugimura T.
,
Nakayama S.
,
Hirota K.
2012
A study of the results of fatigue crack propagation tests under combination loads of high & low cycles -Consideration to the effect of whipping on the fatigue strength-, 2012SOS1-4
Conference Proceedings The Japan Society of Naval Architects and Ocean Engineers
13 -
16

Maddox S.J.
1991
Fatigue strength of welded structures
Abington Publishing
Cambridge, UK

Matsuda K.
,
Takahashi H.
,
Gotoh K.
2011
Numerical simulation of fatigue crack propagation under variable amplitude loading with different frequency components
25th Asian-Pacific Technical Exchange and Advisory Meeting on Marine Structures, TEAM 2011
736 -
742

Matsuishi M.
,
Endo T.
1968
Fatigue of metals subjected to varying stress
Proceedings Kyushu Branch, Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers
37 -
42

Sumi Y.
2012
The effect of slam-induced whipping stress for fatigue crack growth under random seaway loading, 2012SOS1-3
Conference Proceedings The Japan Society of Naval Architects and Ocean Engineers
9 -
12

Yamamoto Y.
,
Fujino M.
,
Fukasawa T.
1983
Longitudinal strength of ships in rough seas
Technical Bulletin of Nippon Kaiji Kyokai
1
1 -
12

Citing 'On the effects of hull-girder vibration upon fatigue strength of a Post-Panamax container ship disaggregated by short-term sea state
'

@article{ E1JSE6_2014_v6n2_431}
,title={On the effects of hull-girder vibration upon fatigue strength of a Post-Panamax container ship disaggregated by short-term sea state}
,volume={2}
, url={http://dx.doi.org/10.2478/IJNAOE-2013-0190}, DOI={10.2478/IJNAOE-2013-0190}
, number= {2}
, journal={International Journal of Naval Architecture and Ocean Engineering}
, publisher={The Society of Naval Architects of Korea}
, author={Fukasawa, Toichi
and
Mukai, Keiichi}
, year={2014}
, month={Jun}