Negative Correlation between the Prevalence of Norovirus and High Bacterial Loads of Escherichia coli in Oysters Crassostrea gigas
Negative Correlation between the Prevalence of Norovirus and High Bacterial Loads of Escherichia coli in Oysters Crassostrea gigas
Fisheries and aquatic sciences. 2015. Sep, 18(3): 235-240
Copyright © 2015, The Korean Society of Fisheries and Aquatic Science
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial Licens (http://creativecommons. org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
  • Received : May 08, 2015
  • Accepted : July 13, 2015
  • Published : September 30, 2015
Export by style
Cited by
About the Authors
Eun-Gyoung, Oh
Southwest Sea Fisheries Institute, National Fisheries Research and Development Institute, Yeosu 59780, Korea
Ki Cheol, Song
West Sea Fisheries Institute, National Fisheries Research and Development Institute, Incheon 22383, Korea
Sukyung, Kim
West Sea Fisheries Institute, National Fisheries Research and Development Institute, Incheon 22383, Korea
Kunbawui, Park
Food Safety Division, National Fisheries Research and Development Institute, Busan 46083, Korea
Hongsik, Yu
West Sea Fisheries Institute, National Fisheries Research and Development Institute, Incheon 22383, Korea

Seasonal variation in the prevalence of norovirus in oysters Crassostrea gigas was investigated and compared to levels of Escherichia coli , a fecal indicator in oysters. Oysters were collected from Iwon-myeon, Taean-gun, Korea, a primary production area for European Union export of oysters between 2013 and 2014. We observed seasonality in the prevalence of norovirus in oysters, with a higher prevalence and viral load detected during winter months. Oysters taken from production areas that complied with the European Union standard for raw consumption (< 230 MPN/100 g of E. coli ) had 22.1% of the samples test positive for norovirus (15/68 samples). However, norovirus was not detected in any of the samples (0%, 0/4 samples) that were collected from production sites that exceeded the standard fecal contamination level for raw consumption (> 230 MPN/100 g of E. coli ). These results indicated that there is a negative correlation between the prevalence of norovirus and high levels of E. coli in oysters. Therefore, our results suggest that current food safety guidelines using only a bacterial fecal contamination indicator, E. coli , may not adequately assess shellfish production areas for viral and bacterial contamination.
Shellfish (bivalve molluscs) are a food consumed worldwide. However, areas of shellfish production are often located in estuaries or coastal waters, which are heavily influenced by human-mediated factors ( Carlos et al., 2013 ). Shellfish filter suspended particles and accumulate microorganisms from the surrounding waters. They are passive carriers of pathogens, making them vehicles in the transmission of several bacterial and viral enteric diseases. This is especially prevalent and of concern in areas that partake in raw consumption ( Bagordo and Grassi, 2013 ).
Indicator organisms including fecal coliform (U.S. National Shellfish Sanitation Program) and Escherichia coli (EC Regulation 854/2004) are microbial pathogens used to assess the safety of shellfish and the waters in which they inhabit ( Carlos et al., 2013 ). Several reports indicate that these bacterial standards do not adequately reflect the risk of viral transmission from shellfish, including viruses such as adenovirus, rotavirus, astrovirus, norovirus, enterovirus, and hepatitis A virus ( Lees, 2000 ; Jiang et al., 2001 ; Gerba et al., 2002 ; Fong and Lipp, 2005 ; Haramoto et al., 2006 ; Diez-Valcarce et al., 2012 ; Donia et al., 2012 ; Shin et al., 2012).
The purpose of this study was to investigate the seasonal prevalence of norovirus in shellfish and to compare it to the level of E. coli , a fecal indicator, in shellfish. Our results indicated that shellfish may be a vehicle for norovirus transmission even when E. coli levels are below the regulatory limits considered void of bacterial risk. Thus, we do not believe that the use of a single fecal indicator for classification of shellfish production areas is adequate to evaluate the public health risk of viral transmission from shellfish.
Materials and Methods
- Sample collection
In Iwon-myeon, Taean-gun, Korea, a primary area for European Union export, three selected beds were chosen from an oyster production area. These beds were closed off to any potential inland pollution. From each bed, one sample of 20 or more oysters Crassostrea gigas was collected per month between January 2013 and December 2014 ( Fig. 1 ). In total, 72 oysters were transported to the laboratory under temperaturecontrolled conditions and tested.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Sampling locations for detection of norovirus and Escherichia coli from oyster Crassostrea gigas in Iwon-myeon, Taean-gun, Korea.
- Preparation of sample homogenate for norovirus detection
Digestive glands from 20 shellfish were excised and finely chopped using a razor blade. A 2-g subsample of each chopped gland was transferred to a clean tube and 10 μL of feline calicivirus (FCV) tissue culture supernatant was added as an extraction process control for viral RNA. Homogenates were treated with 2 mL of 100-μg/mL proteinase K solution (30 U/mg; Promega) ( Dancer et al., 2010 ). Next, the sample was incubated at 37°C while shaking at 320 g for 1 h and subsequently incubated at 60°C for 15 min. Finally, the sample was centrifuged at 3,000 g for 5 min. The soluble portion was retained and stored at 4°C prior to further analysis ( Lowther et al., 2012 ).
- RNA extraction
Total RNA was extracted from 500 μL of shellfish homogenate using Qiagen-Viral RNA Mini Kits (Qiagen, Venlo, Germany) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Negative (water only) and positive (homogenate-derived from bioaccumulated oysters) controls were also prepared and tested in parallel with each set of samples. Eluted RNA was stored at -20°C until further analysis. The positive control was used as a within-batch RNA extraction and quantitative reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (qRT-PCR) control in addition to a FCV process control.
- Duplex quantitative reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (qRT-PCR)
For G1, primers COG1F/COG1R and probe RING1(a)-TP (Kageyama et al., 2003) were used. For G2, primers BPO-13/BPO-13N/BPO-14 and probe BPO-18 (KFDA, 2014) were used. We used FCV primers and probes as described previously ( Lee et al., 2009 ). For both norovirus genogroup-specific assays, three 5-μL aliquots of RNA from samples and the control were tested in a 25-μL total volume reaction mixture containing the following components: 12 μL (2X) RT-PCR buffer, 0.5 μL (25X) enzyme mix, 1.5 μL enhancer, 1 μL (10 pmol) of each primer, and 0.5 μL (10 pmol) of each probe. Amplification was performed using a Dice TP600 thermocycler (Takara, Japan) at the following cycling parameters: 45°C for 30 min, 95°C for 10 min, followed by 45 cycles of 95°C for 15 s and 56°C for 60 s. Wells containing nuclease-free H 2 O and the above Duplex qRT-PCR mixes were also included on each plate as negative controls.
- qRT-PCR quantification
All samples were assessed for extraction efficiency by comparing the sample cycle threshold (CT) values for FCV to a standard curve generated from the process control material, as described previously ( Lee et al., 2009 ). Quantification of viral load was determined by the methods outlined by the Joint CEN-ISO Coordinating Group ( Lees, 2010 ). For each qRTPCR replicate, the quantity (copies/μL) was calculated using the corresponding standard curve ( Lowther et al., 2012 ). Average quantities from three replicates were calculated and used as the representative quantity of virus per sample.
- Quantification ofEscherichia coli
Homogenates were prepared from the flesh and intravalvular fluid of shellfish and assayed according to the ISO/TS 16649-3 most probable number (MPN) technique using 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl-beta-D-glucuronide (International Organization for Standardization, 2005). Results were recorded as MPN/100 g of shellfish flesh and intravalvular fluid.
- Norovirus prevalence
In total, 15 samples (20.8%) tested positive for norovirus; three (20.0%) were positive for both genogroups, five (33.3%) were positive for G1 only, and seven (46.7%) were positive for G2 only. Norovirus prevalence had high seasonal variability, with 66.7% of the samples positive (10/15 samples) during winter months (Dec.-Feb.) and 0% positive (0/15) during summer months (Jun to Aug) from 2013 to 2014 ( Table 1 ).
Monthly levels of norovirus andEscherichia colilevel in oystersCrassostrea gigascollected from Iwon-myeon, Taean-gun, Korea from 2013 to 2014
PPT Slide
Lager Image
aQuantification limit.
Quantitative data indicated that levels of norovirus varied greatly among individual oysters. We observed 66 copies/g of norovirus G1 and 939 copies/g of G2. However, a large proportion of the positive results (40%) were below the method’s limit of detection (10 copies/g). Levels of norovirus G2 were on average higher than those observed for G1.
- Comparison withEscherichia coli
In total, 68 of the 72 samples contained bacterial fecal levels compliant with the standards required by the European Union Food Regulations for raw consumption of shellfish (< 230 MPN/100 g) (European Community, 2004). The highest level recorded was 3,500 MPN/100 g in July 2013 ( Table 1 ). There was seasonal variation of E. coli during the summer months of 2013 and 2014, especially during the period from June to July. All measured environmental parameters were examined. We observed that the amount of accumulated rainfall prior to sampling was a key factor associated with elevated levels of E. coli in oysters. In 2013, a copious rainfall occurred between June and July (131 mm), but in 2014 during these same months only 13.5 mm rainfall was recorded.
In samples with < 230 MPN/100 g of E. coli , 22.1% of the samples tested positive for norovirus (15/68 samples). In samples with E. coli levels > 230 MPN/100 g (too high for raw consumption) 0% of the samples were positive for norovirus (0/4 samples). Comparing the presence of norovirus and E. coli in individual oysters indicated a negative correlation between norovirus prevalence and high levels of E. coli contamination.
In total, 60 samples were collected from the oyster production area in Iwon-myeon, Korea with a category A classification status and 12 from a category B classification. We observed a difference in the average amount of norovirus contamination between oysters collected from categories A and B ( Table 2 ). For each classification, the percentage of samples positive for norovirus (G1 and/or G2) was different. Samples from category A, a status that indicates that oysters can be consumed raw without any post-harvest treatment under the relevant regulation of the European Union ( European Community, 2004 ), had 25.0% of the samples test positive for norovirus (15/60). However, norovirus was not detected in any of the samples taken from category B areas, areas in which shellfish can only be consumed after purification by relaying or depuration.
Norovirus positive and not-detected samples taken from shellfish production areas complied with EU classification category A and B
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Norovirus positive and not-detected samples taken from shellfish production areas complied with EU classification category A and B
- Comparison with water temperatures
In Fig. 2 , water temperatures during the study period are shown in conjunction with norovirus and E. coli levels in oyster at St. 1. These microorganisms had a strong inverse relationship relative to seasonality. Norovirus levels were highest during periods of low water temperatures. Alternatively, E. coli levels were highest during periods of high water temperatures. The maximum norovirus viral load detected in oysters was in January 2013, correlated with a low water temperature (4.0°C). The maximum E. coli bacterial load in oysters was observed in July 2013, correlated with a high water temperature (21.8°C). There was a negative correlation between water temperature and norovirus levels as well as between E. coli and norovirus loads ( Fig. 2 ).
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Comparison of within-site geometric mean levels of norovirus and Escherichia coli in oysters Crassostrea gigas with water temperatures at shellfish production area in Iwon-myeon, Taean-gun, Korea from 2013 to 2014.
Similar to previous studies ( Le Guyader et al., 2000 ; Formiga-Cruz et al., 2002 ; Lowther et al., 2008 ; Flannery et al., 2009 ), we observed norovirus seasonality in shellfish, with a higher prevalence and viral load detected during the winter months of the study period. Possible explanations include a greater persistence of the virus in low solar irradiation, low temperature, higher turbidity, and higher norovirus prevalence in the human population during winter months ( Blanton et al., 2006 ; Lowther et al., 2012 ; Allwood et al., 2005 ; Cannon et al., 2006 ). It is thought that oysters are more effective at viral purging during summer months due to heightened metabolism in warmer waters ( Doré et al., 1998 ; Hernroth and Allard, 2007), Furthermore, shellfish production areas are located in transitional and coastal waters which are influenced by many environmental factors that are present at the boundaries of land, freshwater, and seawater environments (Clements et al., 2015). These factors are more stressful on bacterial organisms including E. coli and other gastro-intestinal tract bacteria in warm-blooded animals ( Troussellier et al. 1998 ).
Routine bacterial monitoring of shellfish production areas using fecal indicators is a common global practice designed to prevent human consumption of contaminated shellfish (Clements et al., 2015). European Union food regulation 854/2004 ( European Community, 2004 ) also outlines microbiological criteria required for shellfish production areas in EU countries as well as third-world countries, including Korea, that participate in the international shellfish trade. Shellfish from category A production areas meet the requirements necessary to be consumed raw. Shellfish from these areas must contain < 230 E. coli per 100 g. Shellfish from category B production areas (< 4,600 E. coli per 100 g of flesh for 90% of samples and < 46,000 E. coli per 100 g of flesh for all samples) must be purified by relaying or depuration prior to consumption. Shellfish from category C classification production areas (all samples with < 46,000 E. coli per 100 g of flesh) must be subjected to long-term relaying (> 2 months) or appropriate heat treatment prior to consumption ( Lowther et al., 2012 ). Current monitoring procedures focus solely on fecal indicator quantification. However, several norovirus outbreaks occur from shellfish taken from areas that comply with the bacterial fecal indicator criteria required for raw consumption ( Chalmers and McMillan, 1995 ; Ang, 1998 ). As shown in this study, on an individual sample basis, E. coli was poorly predictive of norovirus risk.
This study supports the assumption that using bacterial parameters (fecal indicator) alone is not sufficient in identifying the presence of enteric viruses in shellfish ( Greening and McCoubrey, 2010 ). Previously, routine assessment of pathogenic viruses was difficult because of viral issues regarding small dimensions, variety of species, lack of replication in the environment, low concentrations, and our inability to cultivate these species ( Bagordo and Grassi, 2013 ). However, recently technological advances have overcome the difficulties associated with detecting viruses in the environment. Several methods are now available to evaluate viral contamination in shellfish ( Legeay et al. 2000 ; Manso and Romalde, 2013 ). For example, validated methods to detect norovirus and hepatitis A virus have been developed ( Greening and Hewitt, 2008 ; Lees, 2010 ).
Similar to other studies, this study observed the presence of norovirus in oysters that had levels of E. coli below the regulatory limits. These findings suggest the potential need to revise the safety criteria for shellfish production areas. The inclusion of a viral indicator could have important implications for both public health and economic prosperity of the shellfish industry.
This work was funded by a grant from the National Fisheries Research and Development Institute of Korea (RP-2015-FS-004)
Allwood PB , Malik YS , Maherchandani S , Hedberg CW , Goyal SM 2005 Effect of temperature on the survival of F-specific RNA coliphage, feline calicivirus, and Escherichia coli in chlorinated water Int J Environ Res Public Health 2 442 - 446    DOI : 10.3390/ijerph2005030008
Ang LH 1998 An outbreak of viral gastroenteritis associated with eating raw oysters Commun Dis Public Health 1 38 - 40
Bagordo F , Grassi T , Idolo A , Serio F , Gabutti G , Donno AD 2013 Rotavirus occurrence in shellfish with low levels of E. coli Food Environ Virol 5 169 - 175    DOI : 10.1007/s12560-013-9119-z
Blanton LH , Adams SM , Beard RS , Wei G , Bulens SN , Widdowson MA , Glass RI , Monroe SS 2006 Molecular and epidemiologic trends of caliciviruses associated with outbreaks of acute gastroenteritis in the United States, 2000–2004 J Infect Dis 193 413 - 421    DOI : 10.1086/499315
Cannon JL , Papafragkou E , Park GW , Osborne J , Jaykus LA , Vinje′ J 2006 Surrogates for the study of norovirus stability and inactivation in the environment: a comparison of murine norovirus and feline calicivirus J Food Prot 69 2761 - 2765
Carlos JA , Simon RK , Ron JL 2013 Environmental influences on faecal indicator organisms in coastal waters and their accumulation in bivalve shellfish estuaries and coasts Est Coast 36 834 - 853    DOI : 10.1007/s12237-013-9599-y
Chalmers JWT , McMillan JH 1995 An outbreak of viral gastroenteritis associated with adequately prepared oysters Epidemiol Infect 115 163 - 167    DOI : 10.1017/S0950268800058222
Clements K , Giménez L , Jones DL , Wilson J , Malham SK 2013 Epizoic barnacles act as pathogen reservoirs on shellfish beds J Shellfish Res 32 533 - 538    DOI : 10.2983/035.032.0233
Dancer D , Rangdale RE , Lowther JA , Lees DN 2010 Human norovirus RNA persists in seawater under simulated winter conditions but does not bioaccumulate efficiently in Pacific oysters (Crassostrea gigas) J Food Prot 73 2123 - 2127
Diez-Valcarce M , Kokkinos P , Söderberg K , Bouwknegt M , Willems K , de Roda-Husman AM , von Bonsdorff CH , Bellou M , Hernández M , Maunula L , Vantarakis A , Rodríguez-Lázaro D 2012 Occurrence of human enteric viruses in commercial mussels at retail level in three European countries Food Environ Virol 4 73 - 80    DOI : 10.1007/s12560-012-9078-9
Donia D , Dell’Amico MC , Petrinca AR , Martinucci I , Mazzei M , Tolari F , Diviziaa M 2012 Presence of hepatitis E RNA in mussels used as bio-monitors of viral marine pollution J Virol Methods 186 198 - 202    DOI : 10.1016/j.jviromet.2012.06.007
Doré WJ , Henshilwood K , Lees DN 1998 The development of management strategies for control of virological quality in oysters Water Sci Technol 38 29 - 35
2004 Regulation (EC) no 854/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 April 2004 laying down specific rules for the organisation of official controls on products of animal origin intended for human consumption. L226 Off J Eur Communities 83 - 127
Flannery J , Keaveney S , Doré WJ 2009 Use of FRNA bacteriophages to indicate the risk of norovirus contamination in Irish oysters J Food Prot 72 2358 - 2362
Fong TT , Lipp EK 2005 Enteric viruses of human and animals in aquatic environments: health risks, detection, and potential water quality assessment tools Microbiol Mol Biol Rev 69 357 - 371    DOI : 10.1128/MMBR.69.2.357-371.2005
Formiga-Cruz M , Tofino-Quesada G , Bofill-Mas S , Lees DN , Henshilwood K , Allard A K , Conden-Hansson AC , Hernroth BE , Vantarakis A , Tsibouxi A , Papapetropoulou M , Furones MD , Girones R 2002 Distribution of human virus contamination in shellfish from different growing areas in Greece, Spain, Sweden, and the United Kingdom Appl Environ Microbiol 68 5990 - 5998    DOI : 10.1128/AEM.68.12.5990-5998.2002
Gerba CP , Gramos DM , Nwachuku N 2002 Comparative inactivation of enterovirus and adenovirus 2 by UV light Appl Environ Microbiol 68 5167 - 5169    DOI : 10.1128/AEM.68.10.5167-5169.2002
Greening GE , Hewitt J 2008 Norovirus detection in shellfish using a rapid, sensitive virus recovery and real-time RT-PCR detection protocol Food Analytical Methods 1 109 - 118    DOI : 10.1007/s12161-008-9018-3
Greening GE , McCoubrey DJ 2010 Enteric viruses management of shellfish production in New Zealand Food Environ Virol 2 167 - 175    DOI : 10.1007/s12560-010-9041-6
Haramoto E , Katayama H , Oguma K , Yamashita H , Tajima A , Nakajima H , Ohgaki S 2006 Seasonal profiles of human noroviruses and indicator bacteria in a wastewater treatment plant in Tokyo, Japan Water Sci Technol 54 301 - 308    DOI : 10.2166/wst.2006.888
2005 Microbiology of food and animal feeding stuffs horizontal method for the enumeration of beta-glucuronidase-positive Escherichia coli. Part 3. Most probable number technique using 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl-beta-D-glucuronide. ISO/TS 16649-3 International Organization for Standardization Geneva, Switzerland
Jiang S , Noble R , Chu W 2001 Human adenoviruses and coliphages in urban runoff-impacted coastal waters of Southern California Appl Environ Microbiol 67 179 - 184    DOI : 10.1128/AEM.67.1.179-184.2001
Kageyama T , Kojima S , Shinohara M , Uchida K , Fukushi S , Hoshino FB , Takeda N , Katayama K 2003 Broadly reactive and highly sensitive assay for Norwalk-like viruses based on real-time quantitative reverse transcription-PCR J Clinic Microbiol 1548 - 1557
2014 Guideline for investigation on the cause of food poisoning Korea Food and Drug Administration Chungcheonbuk-do, Korea Chapter 5 182 - 201
Le Guyader F , Haugarreau L , Miossec L , Dubois E , Pommepuy M 2000 Three-year study to assess human enteric viruses in shellfish Appl Environ Microbiol 66 3241 - 3248    DOI : 10.1128/AEM.66.8.3241-3248.2000
Lee HJ , Oh EG , Yu HS , Shin SB , Son MJ , Jung JY , Kim YM , Yoon HD 2009 Recovery of norovirus surrogate in seawater using an electropositive and electronegative filter Korean J Fish Aquat Sci 42 238 - 242    DOI : 10.5657/kfas.2009.42.3.238
Lees DN 2000 Viruses in bivalve shellfish Int J Food Microbiol 59 81 - 116    DOI : 10.1016/S0168-1605(00)00248-8
Lees DN 2010 International standardisation of a method for detection of human pathogenic viruses in molluscan shellfish(CENWG6TAG4) Food Environ Virol 2 146 - 155    DOI : 10.1007/s12560-010-9042-5
Legeay O , Caudrelier Y , Cordevant C , Rigottier-Gois L , Lange M 2000 Simplified procedure for detection of enteric pathogenic viruses in shellfish by RT-PCR J Virol Methods 90 1 - 14    DOI : 10.1016/S0166-0934(00)00174-9
Lowther JA , Gustar NE , Powell AL , Hartnell RE , Lees DN 2012 Two-year systematic study to assess norovirus contamination in oysters from commercial harvesting areas in the United Kingdom Appl Environ Microbiol 78 5812 - 5817    DOI : 10.1128/AEM.01046-12
Lowther JA , Henshilwood K , Lees DN 2008 Determination of norovirus contamination in oysters from two commercial harvesting areas over an extended period, using semiquantitative real-time reverse transcription PCR J Food Prot 71 1427 - 1433
Manso CF , Romalde JL 2013 Detection of hepatitis A virus and norovirus from Galicia (NW Spain) Food Environ Virol 5 110 - 118    DOI : 10.1007/s12560-013-9108-2
Shin BS , Oh EG , Yu HS , Son KT , Lee HJ , Park JY , Kim JH 2013 Genetic Diversity of Noroviruses Detected in Oysters in Jinhae Bay Korea Food Sci Biotechnol 22 1453 - 1460
Troussellier M , Bonnefont JL , Courties C , Derrien A , Dupray E , Gauthier M , Gourmelon M , Koux F , Lebaron P , Martin Y , Pommepuy M 1998 Responses of enteric bacteria to environmental stresses in seawater Oceanologica Acta 21 965 - 981    DOI : 10.1016/S0399-1784(99)80019-X