Polyvinyl alcohol/alginate hydrogel beads containing Mg-Al layered double hydroxide (LDH-PVA/alginate beads) were synthesized for phosphate removal. Results showed that blending PVA with the LDH-alginate beads significantly improved their stability in a phosphate solution. The kinetic reaction in LDH-PVA/alginate beads reached equilibrium at 12 hr-post reaction with 99.2% removal. The amount of phosphate removed at equilibrium (
) was determined to be 0.389 mgP/g. The equilibrium data were described well by the Freundlich isotherm with the distribution coefficient (
, 0.638) and the constant (
, 0.396). Phosphate removal in LDH-PVA/alginate beads was not sensitive to solution pH. Also, the removal capacity of LDH-PVA/alginate beads (
, 1.543 mgP/g) was two orders of magnitude greater than that of PVA/alginate beads (
, 0.016 mgP/g) in column experiments. This study demonstrates that LDH-PVA/ alginate beads with a higher chemical stability against phosphate compared to LDH-alginate beads have the potential for phosphate removal as adsorptive media.
The eutrophication of lakes and seas by phosphorus is a widespread environmental problem, posing a great threat to aquatic environments. Recently, considerable attention has been paid to the use of layered double hydroxides (LDHs) for phosphate removal because of their high surface area and large anion exchange capacity
. LDHs are a class of nanostructured anionic clays. They have a general formula of [M1-x
O, where M
is the divalent cation, M
is the trivalent cation, x is the molar ratio of M
), and A is the interlayer anion of valence n. LDHs consist of positively charged brucite-like sheets which are balanced by the intercalation of anions in the hydrated interlayer regions
. Several researchers have examined the phosphate removal by various LDHs including Mg-Al LDHs
, Zn-Al LDHs
, Mg-Mn LDHs
, and iron-based LDHs
. They have demonstrated that LDHs could be applicable to phosphate removal.
Due to low hydraulic conductivity and large sludge production, however, a powder form of LDHs might not be suitable in wastewater treatment systems. Thus, the granular forms of LDHs have been synthesized by few researchers, including Mg-Al LDHcoated sand
, Mg-Al LDH aggregates
, Mg-Al LDH-coated zeolites
, and granular Mg-Al LDH
. The entrapment of functional materials into calcium alginate beads has been widely applied in regards to water treatment because it is a simple and cost effective technique
. Sodium alginate is composed of (1-4)-linked D-mannuronic and L-glucuronic acid repeat units. Calcium ions can chelate carboxylate groups, make crosslinks between chains, and form an insoluble hydrogel
. However, the mechanical strength and chemical stability of alginate hydrogel is poor. It is, therefore, necessary to improve its properties by blending it with polymers such as polyvinyl alcohol (PVA)
In this study, LDH-PVA/alginate beads were synthesized through immobilization of Mg-Al LDH into calcium alginate beads blending with PVA. The properties of LDH-PVA/alginate beads were analyzed using a field emission scanning electron microscopy (FESEM) combined with an energy dispersive X-ray spectrometer (EDS). The stability of LDH-PVA/alginate beads in a phosphate solution was compared with LDH-alginate beads. Also, the removal of phosphate in LDH-PVA/alginate beads was examined using batch and column experiments.
2. Materials and Methods
- 2.1. Synthesis of LDH-PVA/alginate Beads
All chemicals used for the experiments were purchased from Sigma Aldrich. A powdered form of LDH was prepared by coprecipitating mixtures of magnesium nitrate [Mg(NO
O] and aluminum nitrate [Al(NO
O] following the procedures described in
. The Mg-Al LDH was obtained via calcination at 573 K for 24 hr in an electric muffle furnace (C-FMA; Vision Lab, Seoul, Korea). LDH-PVA/alginate beads were prepared by entrapping a powdered form of Mg-Al LDH in a PVA and a calcium alginate blend gel. Twenty grams of PVA and two grams of sodium alginate were dissolved in 200 mL of distilled water and agitated on a magnetic stirrer at 70℃ for 5 hr. Then, 16 g of LDH was added to 200 mL PVA/alginate solution under intensive stirring to obtain the homogeneous suspension. The suspension contained in plastic syringe (outlet diameter, 2 mm) was allowed to drop into a stirred reservoir containing a 500 mL solution of 0.3 M calcium chloride (CaCl
) in order to form 4.20 ± 0.25 mm (number of beads, 90) spherical beads (LDH-PVA/alginate beads). The beads were allowed to cure in the same CaCl
solution for 24 hr under stirring and then rinsed with deionized water to remove excess Ca
. In addition, LDH-alginate beads were prepared by entrapping a powder form of Mg-Al LDH into a calcium alginate gel following the same procedures used for LDH-PVA/ alginate beads excluding PVA.
- 2.2. Characterization and Stability of LDH-PVA/alginate Beads
LDH-PVA/alginate beads were examined by X-ray microanalysis, as described in the literature
, briefly, specimens were mounted on metal stubs using carbon tape and sputtercoated with platinum (approximately 20 nm in thickness). Specimens were examined with a FESEM (Supra 55VP; Carl Zeiss, Oberkochen, Germany) at an accelerating voltage of 3 kV. In addition, the elemental composition was determined with EDS (XFlash 4000; Bruker AXS, Berlin, Germany), combined with an electron microscope at an accelerating voltage of 15 kV. X-rays were collected with a detector fixed at a take-off angle of 35°, and region analysis and mapping were performed on the specimens.
The stability of LDH-alginate beads and LDH-PVA/alginate beads in a phosphate solution was compared under various phosphate concentrations (50, 100, 150, 200 mgP/L). Both beads (numbers of beads, 51–53) were added to a 30 mL phosphate solution in 50 mL polypropylene conical tubes. The tubes were shaken at 25℃ and 40 rpm using a culture tube rotator (MG- 150D; Mega Science, Seoul, Korea). After 24 hr, solutions were poured into petri dishes, and then the numbers of beads with a distinct shape were counted.
- 2.3. Batch Experiments
All experiments were performed at the solution pH of 4.9 (excluding the pH effect tests). Kinetic batch experiments were performed with PVA/alginate beads and LDH-PVA/alginate beads at the initial phosphate concentration of 25 mgP/L. The desired phosphate solution was prepared by diluting the stock solution (1,000 mgP/L), which was made from potassium dihydrogen phosphate (KH
). Two grams of beads were added to a 30 mL phosphate solution in 50 mL polypropylene conical tubes. The tubes were shaken at 25℃ and 40 rpm using a culture tube rotator (MG-150D; Mega Science, Seoul, Korea). In the experiments, the samples were taken at 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 12, and 24 hr after the reaction and filtered through a 0.45 μm membrane filter. The phosphate was analyzed by the ascorbic acid method
. Phosphate concentration was measured at a wavelength of 880 nm using a UV-vis spectrophotometer (Helios; Thermo Scientific, Waltham, MA, USA).
Equilibrium batch experiments were conducted with LDHPVA/ alginate beads (2 g) at different initial phosphate concentrations. Samples were collected 12 hr post-reaction. Further batch experiments were performed to observe the effect of solution pH on phosphate removal in LDH-PVA/alginate beads. The experiments were conducted at an initial phosphate concentration of 25 mgP/L with 2 g of LDH-PVA/alginate beads. The initial solution pHs ranged from 4.9 to 8.9. The pH was measured with a pH probe (9107BN; Thermo Scientific). All experiments were performed in triplicate.
- 2.4. Column Experiments
Three column experiments were performed using a Plexiglas column (inner diameter, 2.5 cm; bed depth, 10 cm; bulk volume, 49.1 cm
) packed with PVA/alginate beads, LDH-PVA/alginate beads, and LDH-alginate beads. Prior to the experiments, the packed column was flushed upward using a HPLC pump (Series II pump; Scientific Systems Inc., State College, PA, USA) operating at a rate of 0.5 mL/min with 5 bed volumes (BV) of deionized water until a steady state flow condition was established. Then, a phosphate solution (10 mgP/L) was introduced downward to the packed column at the same flow rate. The empty bed contact time was determined to be 26.5 min. Portions of the effluent were collected using the auto collector (Retriever 500; Teledyne, Lincoln, NE, USA) at regular intervals, and phosphate was analyzed by the ascorbic acid method
3. Results and Discussion
- 3.1. Stability and Characteristics of LDH-PVA/alginate Beads
The deformation of LDH-alginate beads and LDH-PVA/alginate beads at various phosphate concentrations under batch condition are demonstrated in
. The deformation percentages (
) provided in
were calculated using the following equation:
Deformation of LDH-alginate beads and LDH-PVA/alginate beads under different phosphate solutionsLDH: layered double hydroxide, PVA: polyvinyl alcohol.
Deformation of LDH-alginate beads and LDH-PVA/alginate beads under different phosphate solutions LDH: layered double hydroxide, PVA: polyvinyl alcohol.
Deformation of layered double hydroxide (LDH)-alginate beads (LAB) and LDH- polyvinyl alcohol (PVA)/alginate beads (LPAB) at various phosphate concentrations (unit, mgP/L) under batch condition: (a) before reaction of LAB, (b-e) after reaction of LAB, (f) before reaction of LPAB, (g-j) after reaction of LPAB.
Field emission scanning electron micrographs (FESEM) of LDH-PVA/alginate beads: (a) cross-sectional view (bar, 200 μm), (b) FESEM image (bar, 2 μm), (c) X-ray spectrum. LDH: layered double hydroxide, PVA: polyvinyl alcohol.
are the numbers of beads with a distinct shape before and after the reaction, respectively. In LDH-alginate beads,
increased from 0% to 100% with increasing phosphate concentrations from 50 to 200 mgP/L. In LDH-PVA/alginate beads, however, zero deformation percentages were determined at 50, 100, and 150 mgP/L while 7.8% was calculated at 200 mgP/L. It was also observed that the LDH-PVA/alginate beads in
(g) were less swollen than the LDH-alginate beads in
(b) at 50 mgP/L even though zero deformation percentages were determined for both beads. PVA is a water-soluble synthetic polymer with high tensile strength and flexibility. The blending of alginate with PVA could improve the strength and durability of hydrogel beads
. Idris et al.
showed that the reusability of PVA/ alginate beads was much greater than that of alginate beads. They reported that PVA/alginate beads could be used for the removal of chromate for up to seven cycles while alginate beads could only be used for up to three cycles. Our results also indicated that blending PVA into the calcium alginate significantly improved the stability of the beads in a phosphate solution.
The FESEM image and EDS pattern for LDH-PVA/alginate beads are presented in
. It demonstrated that the crosssectional surface of LDH-PVA/alginate beads was heterogeneous in surface topography in
(a). The powders of LDH were intermingled with PVA/alginate polymers. The sheet-like polymer matrices were present on the cross-sectional surface of LDH-PVA/alginate beads in
(b). Calcium and chloride were evident at the peak positions of 3.69 and 2.62 keV as K-alpha Xray signals, respectively. In addition, magnesium and aluminum were found at 1.25 and 1.48 keV as K-alpha X-ray signals, respectively in
- 3.2. Phosphate Removal in Batch Condition
The kinetic data and model fit for phosphate removal in PVA/ alginate beads and LDH-PVA/alginate beads are presented in
. It revealed that the reaction reached equilibrium after 12 hr of reaction time. In PVA/alginate beads, the average removal percentage was 12.1% while it was 99.2% in LDH-PVA/alginate beads, indicating the sharp increase of phosphate removal in the presence of LDH. The kinetic data were analyzed by the pseudo second-order model
is the amount of phosphate removed at time
is the amount of phosphate removed at equilibrium (mgP/g), and
is the velocity constant (g/mgP/hr). In the pseudo-secondorder model, the value of
for PVA/alginate beads was 0.057 mgP/g. For LDH-PVA/alginate beads, it was 0.389 mgP/g, which was one-order of magnitude greater than that for PVA/alginate
Kinetic experimental data for PVA/alginate beads and LDHPVA/ alginate beads with pseudo-second-order model fit. LDH: layered double hydroxide, PVA: polyvinyl alcohol.
Equilibrium experimental data for LDH-PVA/alginate beads with Freundlich isotherm model fit. LDH: layered double hydroxide, PVA: polyvinyl alcohol.
Breakthrough curves for phosphate removal in columns packed with PVA/alginate beads, LDH-PVA/alginate beads, and LDH-alginate beads. LDH: layered double hydroxide, PVA: polyvinyl alcohol.
beads. The value of
for PVA/alginate beads was 0.066/hr while it was 6.787/hr for LDH-PVA/alginate beads, indicating that the reaction rate for LDH-PVA/alginate beads was faster than that for PVA/alginate beads. The correlation coefficients (
) of the pseudo second-order model for PVA/alginate beads and LDHPVA/ alginate beads were 0.856 and 0.998, respectively.
The equilibrium data and model fit for phosphate removal in LDH-PVA/alginate beads are given in
. The data were analyzed by the Freundlich isotherm model:
is the mass of phosphate adsorbed per unit mass of LDH-beads (mgP/g),
is the concentration of phosphate in the aqueous solution at equilibrium (mgP/L),
is the distribution coefficient, and
is the Freundlich constant. Values of
were determined by fitting the model to be 0.638 and 0.396, respectively. The correlation coefficient (
) of the Freundlich model was 0.984.
The influence of solution pH on phosphate removal in LDHPVA/ alginate beads is presented in
. The average removal percent was 99.21% at pH 4.9, decreasing slightly to 96.22% with the solution pH approaching 9.0. This indicated that phosphate removal in LDH-PVA/alginate beads was not sensitive to pH change for the given experimental conditions. Our result did not conform with the report of Das et al.
demonstrated that phosphate removal in the powder form of Mg-Al LDH sharply decreased from 91.7% to 39.0% with increasing pH from 5.0 to 10.0.
- 3.3. Phosphate Removal in Flow-Through Column Condition
The phosphate breakthrough curves (BTC) in PVA/alginate beads, LDH-PVA/alginate beads, and LDH-alginate beads are presented in
. The breakthrough data was presented in terms of phosphate concentration versus BV. At the given flow conditions, the BTC for PVA/alginate beads increased sharply, reaching 95% of the initial phosphate concentration (9.5 mgP/L) around 25 BV. For the same conditions, the BTCs for LDH-PVA/ alginate beads and LDH-alginate beads were distinctively delayed relative to that for PVA/alginate beads. In LDH-PVA/alginate beads, the BTC increased slowly, reaching to
= 1 mgP/L around 44 BV. Thereafter, the BTC increased continuously, arriving at
= 9.5 mgP/L around 1,150 BV. In LDH-alginate beads, the BTC also increased slowly, reaching to
= 1 mgP/L around 28 BV. Thereafter, the BTC increased continuously, arriving at
= 8.6 mgP/L around 620 BV.
The column capacity for phosphate removal (
, mgP) at a given flow rate and influent phosphate concentration was quan-
Phosphate removal in LDH-PVA/alginate beads under different solution pH (initial phosphate concentration, 25 mgP/L)LDH: layered double hydroxide, PVA: polyvinyl alcohol.
Phosphate removal in LDH-PVA/alginate beads under different solution pH (initial phosphate concentration, 25 mgP/L) LDH: layered double hydroxide, PVA: polyvinyl alcohol.
tified using the following equation
is the influent concentration of phosphate (mgP/L),
is the effluent concentration of phosphate (mgP/L). In PVA/alginate beads, the value of
was 0.7 mgP while it was 62.2 mgP in LDH-PVA/alginate beads, which was approximately 90 times higher than that of PVA-alginate beads. In addition, the value of
in LDH-alginate beads was 39.1 mgP. The mass of phosphate removed per unit mass of LDH-PVA/alginate beads in the column (
, mgP/g) was determined as follows
is the mass of the beads in the column (g). The value of
was 0.016 mgP/g in PVA/alginate beads while it was 1.543 mgP/g in LDH-PVA/alginate beads, which was two orders of magnitude larger than that of PVA/alginate beads. In LDH-alginate beads, the value of
was 0.977 mgP/g. In our previous experiments
, the phosphate sorption capacity of powdered form of Mg-Al LDH was determined to be 37.4 mgP/g. This value was in the range of the phosphate sorption capacity of Mg-Al LDH (7.3?81.6 mgP/g) reported in the literature
It should be noted that the column experiment in LDH-alginate beads was discontinued around 620 BV due to the bead deformation observed at the top of the column. After the column experiments, the beads were taken out from the column and then observed for the effect of phosphate solution on their stability. As shown in
, the deformation of LDH-alginate beads
(a-c) was notable, especially on top of the column. However, the deformation of LDH-PVA/alginate beads
(d-f) was not eminent throughout the column. It indicated that blending PVA with calcium alginate beads considerably improves the stability of the beads during phosphate removal.
In flow-through column experiments, phosphate ions could move through the paths formed among the beads and diffuse into the beads through the pores in the beads. Then, the phosphate could come in contact with the entrapped LDH particles and subsequently be removed from the solution via three different mechanisms. First, the negatively-charged phosphate could adsorb to the positively-charged brucite-like layer in surface adsorption. Second, the phosphate could replace the charge balancing anion (carbonate) in the interlayer region in the anion exchange process. Third, the phosphate could intercalate into the interlayer due to the reformation effect of the calcined LDH in the aqueous phase
In this study, LDH-PVA/alginate beads were synthesized and used for phosphate removal. Results showed that blending PVA with the LDH-alginate beads significantly improved their stability in the phosphate solution. The results also indicated that the phosphate removal reaction in LDH-PVA/alginate beads reached equilibrium at 12 hr-post reaction with a high removal percentage. The equilibrium batch data were well described by the Freundlich isotherm model. In addition, phosphate removal in LDH-PVA/alginate beads was not sensitive to solution pH. Furthermore, results also showed that the removal capacity of
Deformation of LDH-alginate beads (LAB, a?c) and LDHPVA/ alginate beads (LPAB, d-f ) in column experiments: (a) LAB on top, (b) LAB on middle, (c) LAB on bottom, (d) LAPB on top, (e) LAPB on middle, (f ) LAPB on bottom (column length, 10 cm). LDH: layered double hydroxide, PVA: polyvinyl alcohol.
LDH-PVA/alginate beads in the column experiments was two orders of magnitude greater than that of PVA/alginate beads. This study demonstrates that LDH-PVA/alginate beads possess higher chemical stability against phosphate than LDH-alginate beads and have the potential for phosphate removal as adsorptive media.
This research was supported by the National Research Foundation of Korea, funded by the Ministry of Education, Science and Technology, Republic of Korea (grant no. 2012-0001296).
Application of layered double hydroxides for removal of oxyanions: a review.
Preparation and phosphate ion-exchange properties of a hydrotalcite-like compound.
Phosphorus removal by hydrotalcite-like compounds (HTLcs).
Water Sci. Technol.
de Roy A
Ion exchange of different phosphate ions into the zincaluminium- chloride layered double hydroxide.
Phosphate adsorption from sewage sludge filtrate using zincaluminum layered double hydroxides.
J. Hazard. Mater.
Phosphate uptake behavior of ZnAlZr ternary layered double hydroxides through surface precipitation.
J. Colloid Interface Sci.
Adsorption of phosphate from seawater on calcined MgMn-layered double hydroxides.
J. Colloid Interface Sci.
Removal of phosphate by layered double hydroxides containing iron.
Sorption of MS2 bacteriophage to layered double hydroxides: effects of reaction time, pH, and competing anions.
J. Environ. Qual.
A simple technology for arsenic removal from drinking water using hydrotalcite.
Sci. Total Environ.
Mg-Al hydrotalcite coating on zeolites for improved carbon dioxide adsorption.
Chem. Eng. Sci.
Phosphate removal and recovery with a synthetic hydrotalcite as an adsorbent.
Sorptive removal of trivalent and hexavalent chromium from binary aqueous solutions by composite alginate-goethite beads.
Removal of organic compounds by alginate gel beads with entrapped activated carbon.
J. Hazard. Mater.
Van Beinum W
van Riemsdijk WH.
Competitive sorption and diffusion of chromate and sulphate in a flow system with goethite in gel beads.
J. Contam. Hydrol.
Arsenic removal by a waste metal (hydr)oxide entrapped into calcium alginate beads.
J. Hazard. Mater.
Entrapment of iron nanoparticles in calcium alginate beads for groundwater remediation applications.
J. Hazard. Mater.
Removable colored coatings based on calcium alginate hydrogels.
Adsorption of phosphate by layered double hydroxides in aqueous solutions.
Appl. Clay Sci.
Anatomical descriptions of silicified woods from Madagascar and Indonesia by scanning electron microscopy.
Standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater.
American Public Health Association;
Esterification in organic solvents by lipase immobilized in polymer of PVA-alginate-boric acid.
Mohd Zain NA
Immobilization of Baker’s yeast invertase in PVA-alginate matrix using innovative immobilization technique.
Modified PVAalginate encapsulated photocatalyst ferro photo gels for Cr(VI) reduction.
J. Hazard. Mater.
Adsorption of cadmium from aqueous solutions by vermiculite.
Sep. Sci. Technol.
Humic acid removal from water by iron-coated sand: a column experiment.
Environ. Eng. Res.
Entrapment of Mg-Al layered double hydroxide in calcium alginate beads for phosphate removal from aqueous solution.
Desalination Water Treat.