Advanced
Lightning Impulse Breakdown Characteristic of Dry-Air/Silicone Rubber Hybrid Insulation in Rod-Plane Electrode
Lightning Impulse Breakdown Characteristic of Dry-Air/Silicone Rubber Hybrid Insulation in Rod-Plane Electrode
Journal of Electrical Engineering and Technology. 2015. May, 10(3): 1181-1187
Copyright © 2015, The Korean Institute of Electrical Engineers
This is an Open-Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/)which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
  • Received : July 29, 2014
  • Accepted : November 29, 2014
  • Published : May 01, 2015
Download
PDF
e-PUB
PubReader
PPT
Export by style
Article
Author
Metrics
Cited by
TagCloud
About the Authors
Jung-Hun Kwon
Dept. of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Chungbuk National University, Korea (kjlimg@gmail.com)
Cheong-Won Seo
Dept. of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Chungbuk National University, Korea (kjlimg@gmail.com)
Yu-Min Kim
Dept. of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Chungbuk National University, Korea (kjlimg@gmail.com)
Kee-Joe Lim
Corresponding Author: Dept. of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Chungbuk National University, Korea (kjlimg@gmail.com)

Abstract
Sulfur hexafluoride (SF 6 ) gas is used widely in electric power equipment such as Gas Insulated Switchgear (GIS), Gas Insulation transmission Line (GIL), and Gas Circuit Breaker (GCB). But applications of SF 6 should be restricted because SF6 gas is one of the greenhouse effect gases. To reduce use of SF 6 gas, a study on eco-friendly alternative insulation medium is needed. In this paper, we investigated lightning impulse (LI) breakdown of dry-air which is attracting attention as an ecofriendly alternative gas and the LI breakdown of hybrid insulation combined with dry-air and solid insulation (Room-Temperature Vulcanizing Silicone Rubber-RTV SIR) and dry-air in inhomogeneous fields according to gap distance and pressure. The experiment results showed that the LI breakdown strength of hybrid insulation system was higher than that of dry-air insulation system. It was verified that the development of technology related to eco-friendly power apparatus compact such GIS, GCB and GIL can be used as basic research data.
Keywords
1. Introduction
SF 6 gas chemically is extremely stable and not only has excellent insulation performance compared with other gases but also outstanding current block and arc extinguishing capability [1] . So gas insulated high voltage equipment such as Gas Insulated Switchgear (GIS), Gas Insulation transmission Line (GIL), and Gas Circuit Breaker (GCB) in electric power applications have been mainly used in pressured SF 6 gas. SF 6 significantly contributed to reduce economic costs and size of the highvoltage equipment for a GIS, GCB and GIL. The emission of SF 6 gas into the atmosphere needs to be reduced drastically because SF 6 gas is one of the greenhouse gases [2 - 8] .
Accordingly, to reduce amount of SF 6 gas the researchers on an alternative insulated medium in a various ways are active situation over the world. Studies on mixed with N 2 , CO 2 and other gases have been proceeding to reduce amount of SF 6 gas [9] . SF 6 /N 2 mixture gas is known as a valid current breaking medium [10] . SF 6 /CO 2 mixture gas has been reported to have more excellent insulation characteristics than SF 6 /N 2 mixture gas [11 - 13] . Also in non-uniform electric field, SF 6 /air and SF 6 /CO 2 mixture gas showed a higher breakdown strength than breakdown strength of SF 6 gas and by addition of 1% CO 2 in 50% SF 6 / N 2 gas mixture, breakdown strength has been reported to be more increased than breakdown strength of SF 6 /N 2 and SF 6 respectively 1.31 and 1.15 times [14 - 15] . But in case of these mixture gases, there are problems that do not completely ban the use of SF 6 . Therefore, for the development of eco-friendly gas insulated component that does not use SF 6 gas at all, research on Solid Insulated Switchgear (SIS), Dry-Air Insulated Switchgear (DAIS), and Nitrogen Insulated Switchgear (NIS) is being actively conducted and distribution class power apparatus has already been commercialization. However, because such the insulating strength of an alternative insulating gas is considerably lower than dielectric strength of SF 6 gas, in order to obtain required dielectric strength it is necessary to maintain very high pressures of the gas. So comercialization is difficult over distribution class yet.
Studies on the dry-air, which is attracting attention as an eco-friendly alternative gas, have been mainly studied in the uniform and non-uniform electric field [16 - 18] . Although there are many non-uniform electric fields in actual high voltage equipment, these researches are not many. Also the field utilization factor is an important design criterion that is dependent on the shape of the components and inner structures [19 - 20] . Therefore, the insulation design has to the lowest field utilization. So in this paper field utilization factor is less than 0.5 and discharge characteristic process studied at extreme non-uniform field according to gap distance and pressure. Since the dielectric strength of the dry air is one third of the level of SF 6 gas and breakdown is mainly starts from weak point where the electric field is concentrated and it lead to whole breakdown of equipment. When such an electrical weak point is coated with a solid dielectric, it is possible to obtain the electric field relaxation effect [21 - 24] .
To obtain an eco-friendly alternative insulated methods of SF 6 , This paper examines lightning impulse breakdown characteristic of hybrid insulation combined with dry-air and solid insulation in inhomogeneous field having a field utilization factor of range 0.1 to 0.4.
2. Experiments
- 2.1 Experimental setup
All experiments were carried out in a laboratory gas chamber made of stainless steel having 200 mm diameter and 200 mm height. The gas chamber which connected to the high pressure dry-air cylinder was evacuated to residual pressure of 1×10 −6 Torr and then filled with dry-air. Gas pressure confirmed pressure gauge of gas chamber. The standard LI voltages (1.2/50 μs) with both polarities were applied using an IVG-600A rated up to 600 kV and has an efficiency of 80 %. Fig. 1 shows a schematic diagram of the test facility.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Impulse breakdown experimental set-up.
The standard lightning impulse voltages with positive / negative polarities were determined by an up-and-down method until twenty sets of raw data were obtained. With a 63.2% Cumulative Failure Probability (CFP) of a breakdown voltage, the raw data was obtained from the Weibull-distribution. Fig. 2 shows an example of Weibull distribution plot which indicate positive polarity LI breakdown of dry-air at 6 atm.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Weibull distribution plot
The electrode configuration in the chamber consisted of a hemispherical rod, a dielectric covered (roomtemperature vulcanizing silicone rubber-RTV SIR) hemispherical rod, and an earthed plane electrode. Table 1 and Fig. 3 show the experimental conditions and electrode systems, respectively.
The electrode system.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
The electrode system.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Bare and coated rod-plane electrode system.
3. Results and Discussions
- 3.1 Lightning impulse breakdown characteristics of dry-air
The lightning-impulse-breakdown voltage of dry-air increased with increasing pressure and gap distance by right region of Paschen’s law, when the pressure and the gap distance increases, the air density is increased and then collision ionization of electrons is decrease so breakdown voltage of dry-air increased as shown in Fig. 4 . Under all test conditions, the negative breakdown voltage was higher than the positive breakdown voltage. This polarity effect can be understood as follows: In rod-plane electrodes, such as a non-uniform electric field, the gas breakdown mechanism proceeds in the following order: corona generation, corona progress, and spark discharge. In the case of a rod electrode with an applied negative LI, the initial electron emission is easy and the space charge effect time is short because of field emission or Schottky emission from the rod electrode metal to the gas. In addition, the negative corona generation voltage was reported to be lower than the positive corona voltage. On the other hand, growth of corona is slower than the positive electron avalanche because growth direction of the electron avalanche begins from a high field toward a lower field region. As the case stands, the positive breakdown voltage is lower than the negative breakdown voltage. Fig. 5 shows the extension process of corona positive and negative polarity at a non-uniform field. As indicated in Fig. 5 in the case of a positive corona, the spark discharge can be progressed easily [18 , 25 - 26] .
PPT Slide
Lager Image
LI breakdown of dry-air in the rod to plane according to gap distance with various pressure at (a) Positive polarity and (b) Negative polarity.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Extension process of the corona: (a) Positive polarity; (b) Negative polarity.
The field utilization factor is an important design criterion that is dependent on the shape of the components and inner structures. Therefore, the insulation design is subject to the lowest field utilization. The field utilization factor (η) is defined as the ratio of the average electric field ( Emean ) and maximum electric field ( Emax ) [19 - 20] :
PPT Slide
Lager Image
PPT Slide
Lager Image
where Vd is the measured breakdown value and d is the gap distance between the rod to plane electrode. The maximum field of the rod to plane electrode is expressed in equation (3.3)
PPT Slide
Lager Image
where r is the radius of the rod electrode. Substituting equation (3.3) to equation (3.1), the field utilization between the rod and plane electrode is expressed as equation (3.3). The field utilization is expressed as a function of the electrode distance, as shown Table 2 .
Electric field utilization factor of the electrode system as a function of the gap distance.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Electric field utilization factor of the electrode system as a function of the gap distance.
As indicated in Fig. 6 , the breakdown strength decreases with decreasing the field utilization factor because the electric field was more concentrated at the tip of the rod electrode. Fig. 7 shows that the maximum electric field is increased with decreasing the field utilization factor.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Breakdown electric filed strength as a function of the electric field utilization factor in the case of (a) positive polarity and (b) negative polarity
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Maximum electric field at breakdown, Emax.BD according to the field utilization factor in case of (a) positive polarity and (b) negative polarity
- 3.2 Lightning impulse breakdown characteristic of Dry-Air/Silicone Rubber Hybrid Insulation
The LI breakdown properties of dry-air in the case of adopting electrodes with dielectric coating were examined. The experiments were carried out for rod to plane electrode systems with a 4.5 mm diameter. The coated length of the rod electrode and plane electrode was 12 and 70 mm, respectively. The hybrid insulation system was equivalent to that corresponding to the same conditions in the bare electrode system.
The principal idea of the hybrid insulation system is the intentional use of the surface charge density to re-distribute the electric field within the insulation system. The potential difference between the metal electrodes results in a charge density (±ρe) at the metal surfaces and polarization of the dielectric coating, which is represented by the equivalent polarization charge density (±ρ ρ ). Owing to the electric field, the free charge in the dry-air gap, which is available from ionization discharge or other natural origins, is attracted to the surface of the coating. Together with the charge arising from the bulk condition through the dielectric coating, a surface charge density (±ρs) is formed. As a result, an electric field component is directed in opposite to the original electric field, resulting in decreased electrical stress in the dry-air gap [22 - 25] . Fig. 8 shows the simple principle, and Fig. 9 is a photograph taken at the breakdown of the hybrid insulation system.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Basic concept hybrid insulation
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Photograph taken at the breakdown of the hybrid insulation system.
As shown Fig. 10 , the LI breakdown voltage of hybrid insulation shows an increase according to the pressure and gap distance and depends on the polarity. Table 3 shows an increasing rate between the measured breakdown voltage of the coated electrode and uncoated electrode. From these results, substantial increase in breakdown voltage can be seen, with the exception of some cases which were attributed to experimental error. After the breakdown, voids were observed inside the specimen. Because the electric field is concentrated in the void after partial discharge occurs, it appears to have lower dielectric strength [27 - 29] .
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Breakdown voltage of the hybrid insulation system: (a) Positive breakdown voltage; (b) Negative breakdown voltage.
Increasing rate between the measured breakdown voltage of the coated electrode and uncoated electrode.
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Increasing rate between the measured breakdown voltage of the coated electrode and uncoated electrode.
Under all test conditions, the positive breakdown voltage was higher than the negative breakdown voltage. This result is different from the bare electrode system. Previous studies reported that the discharge propagation of a covered rod to plane arrangement differs according to the polarity of the rod. At a positive polarity, flashover along the cover surface is followed by breakdown of the air gap. At negative polarity, breakdown of the air gap was followed by flashover along the cover surface, as shown Fig. 11 . This can be explained as follows. In the case of positive polarity, the accumulation of surface charge, i.e. electrons, is easy because the mobility of electrons is faster than that of a positive ion. Therefore, the field relaxation effect of air gap was larger than that of the negative polarity because the surface charge density was different between the positive and negative polarity [29 - 33] .
PPT Slide
Lager Image
Breakdown propagation: (a) positive polarity; (b) negative polarity
5. Conclusion
The study examined the breakdown characteristics of hybrid insulation in inhomogeneous fields under a lightning impulse voltage. The results can be summarized as follows:
  • 1) LI breakdown voltage of dry-air increased with increasing pressure and gap distance. The negative breakdown voltage was higher than the positive breakdown voltage. The field utilization factor confirmed the important design criteria.
  • 2) The LI breakdown voltage of hybrid insulation increased with increasing pressure and gap distance. The positive breakdown voltage was higher than the negative breakdown voltage. In most cases, the breakdown voltage of the hybrid insulation system increased substantially compared to that of the dry-air insulation system.
Therefore, the development of technology related to ecofriendly power apparatus compact such GIS, GCB and GIL can be used as basic research data.
BIO
J. H Kwon He received his B.S. and M.S. degree in 2011 and 2013 in electrical engineering from Chungbuk National University, Korea. Currently, he is a Ph.D. student at the Department of Electrical Engineering, Chungbuk National University, Korea.
C. W Seo He received a B.S degree in electrical engineering from Chungbuk National University, Korea. Currently he is a Master’s student at the Department of Electrical Engineering, Chungbuk National University, Korea.
Y. M KIM He received his B.S. and M.S. degree in electrical engineering from Chungbuk National University, Korea in 2011 and 2013, respectively. He research interests include high voltage and electrical insulation.
K. J. Lim He received B.S. M.S. and Ph.D. degrees from Han-Yang University, Seoul, Republic of Korea, in 1973, 1979 and 1986, respectively. He is currently a full professor at the Department of electrical engineering at Chungbuk National University, Korea. His research interests include electrical materials, high voltage techniques, piezoelectric ceramics, etc.
References
Christophorou L. G. , Olthoff J. K. , Van Brunt R. J. 1997 “Sulfur Hexafluoride and the Electric Power Industry” IEEE Electrical insulation Magazine 13 (5) 20 - 24
Wiegart W. 1969 “A Model for the Production of Initial Electron by Detachment of. Ions” IEEE Trans. PAS-88 (10)
Malik N. H. , Qureshi A. h. 1991 “Breakdown mechanisms in sulphur-hexafluoride” IEEE Trans. on Elect Ei-12 (3) 135 - 145
Yanabu S. , Murayama Y. , Matsmoto S. 1994 “SF6 Insulation and its Application to HV Equipment” IEEE Trans. Elect 26 (3) 358 - 366
Yamagata Y. “Development of UHV gas insulated switchgear” Hitachi Hyoron 76 21 - 26
Lee B. H. 1995 “Dielectric Characteristics of SF6 Gas under Fast Transient Overvoltages in A Non- Uniform Electric Field” Proc of Int. Conf. on Gas Discharge and Their Application 1 - 34-307
Hasegawa T. , Yamaji K. , Hatano M. , Endo F. , Rokunohe T. , Yamagiwa T. 1997 “Development of insulation structure and enhancement of insulation reliability of 500kV DC GIS” IEEE Trans Power Del. 12 (1) 194 - 202    DOI : 10.1109/61.568241
Yaegashi M. , Ishiguro T. , Ohkubo K. , Yaginuma N. , Kawamoto H. 2003 “Development of 362 kV 63 kA gas circuit breaker” Nat. Convention Rec., IEEJ (6-210) 358 - 359
Cookson A. H. , Pedersen B. O. 1978 “High voltage performance of mixtures of with, air and in compressed gas-insulated equipment” 1978 IEE Conf. on Gas Discharge, IEE Conf. Publ. No. 165 161 - 164
Yamada T , Ishida T , Hayakawa N , Okubo H “Partial discharge and breakdown mechanism in ultra-dilute SF6/N2 GAS MIXTURES” IEEE Trans DEI 8 (1) 137 - 142    DOI : 10.1109/94.910436
Cookson A. H. , Pedersen B. O. 1978 “High voltage performance of mixtures of with, air and in compressed gas-insulated equipment” 1978 IEE Conf. on Gas Discharge, IEE Conf. Publ. No. 165 161 - 164
Zheng D. , Zhang P. , Gong G. , Wen Z. 1998 “Study about the Electrical Behaviour of the Binary Gaseous Mixtures of” Proc. of 1998 Intern. Symp. on Elect. Insul. Master Toyohashi, Japan Sept. 27-30 437 - 440
Qiu Y. , Kuffel E. 1999 “Comparison of and Gas Mixtures as Alternatives to Gas” IEEE Trans. Dielec. Elec. Insul. 6 (6) 892 - 895    DOI : 10.1109/94.822033
Qiu X.Q. , Chalmers I.D. , Coventry P. 1999 “A studt of alternative insulating gases to” J.Phys.D: Appl. Phys. 32 2918 - 2922    DOI : 10.1088/0022-3727/32/22/314
Ohtsuka S. , Nagara S. , Miura K. , Nakamura M. , Hikita M. 2000 “Effect of Mixture of a Small Amount of in Mixed Gas on the Insulation Performance under Nonuniform Field” Conf, Record of the 2000 IEEE Intern. Symposium on Electrical Insulation Anaheim, CA USA April 2-5 288 - 291
Akyuz M. 2002 Positive Streamer discharges in air and along insulator surface: experiment and simulation University of Uppsala
Akyuz M. , Larsson A. , Cooray V. , Sandberg G. 2003 3D simulations of streamer branching in air Journal of Electrostatics (59) 115 - 141
Li Feng , Yoo Y-H , Kim D-K , lee B-K 2010 “Dielectric Characteristic of SF6 and Dry-Air Gases under Lightning Impulse Voltage” Journal of the Korean of Institute of illumination and Elec Insul Eng 142 - 149
Kuffel E. 1984 “High-voltage Engineering-Fundamentals
Nitta T. , Shibuya Y. , Fujiwara Y. 1975 “Voltage-time characteristics of Electrical Breakdown in SF6” IEEE Trans. PAS-94 (1) 108 - 115
2006 “Charge accumulation in rod-plane air gap with covered rod”, PhD Thesis Norwegian University of Science and Technology
Blennow H. J. M. , M L-A , Sjöberg M. “Electric Field Reduction Due to Charge Accumulation in a Dielectric-Covered Electrode System” IEEE Trans DEI 7 (3) 340 - 345    DOI : 10.1109/94.848912
Blennow H. J. M. , Leijon M., Å. S. , Gubanski S.M. 2002 “Active High Voltage Insulation” Journal of Electrostatics 55 (2) 159 - 172    DOI : 10.1016/S0304-3886(01)00189-9
Sjöberg M. 2003 Charge Accumulation in Hybrid High-Voltage Insulation, PhD Thesis Chalmers University of Technology
Kang H. K , Nah J B. , Chung Y. D. , Ahn M. C. , Bae D. K. , Ko T. K. 2010 “Study on the Breakdown Voltage Characterization of Insulation Gases for Developing a High Voltage Superconducting Apparatus” IEEE Trans on Applied superconductivity 20 (3) 1646 - 1649    DOI : 10.1109/TASC.2010.2041342
Karner Hermann 1985 “High Voltage Insulation Technology”
Mekala K. , Chandrasekar S. , Samson Ravindran R. 2015 “Investigations of Accelerated Aged Polymeric Insulators Using Partial Discharge Signal Measurement and Analysis” Journal of Electrical Engineering & Technology 10 (1) 299 - 307    DOI : 10.5370/JEET.2015.10.1.299
Jayaprakash Narayanan V. , Karthik B. , Chandrasekar S. 2014 “Flashover Prediction of Polymeric Insulators Using PD Signal Time-Frequency Analysis and BPA Neural Network Technique” Journal of Electrical Engineering & Technology 9 (4) 1375 - 1384    DOI : 10.5370/JEET.2014.9.4.1375
Wang Jian Lin Yan , Bao Lianwei 2014 “Space Charge Behavior of Oil-Impregnated Paper Insulation Aging at AC-DC Combined Voltages” Journal of Electrical Engineering & Technology 9 (2) 635 - 642    DOI : 10.5370/JEET.2014.9.2.635
Baldo G. , Pesaven G. 1987 “Impulse Performance of Air Gaps in Series with Thick Insulating Layers” Proc 5th Int. Symp. On HV Engineering Braunschweig, Germany paper no. 14. 25
Walfridsson L. 1986 Solid Insulation Covering of Conductors Improves Air Insulation System Int. Conference on Conduction and Breakdown in Solid Dielectric in Compresses Gases: A Review. IEEE Transaction on Electrical Insulation 21 (5)
Ming L. , Fromm U. , Leijon M. , Windmar D. , Walfridsson L , Vlastos A. , Darveniza M. , Kucera J. 1997 “Insulation Performance of Covered Rod/Plane Air Gap under Lightning Impulse Voltage” Proc. 10th Int. on HV Engineering Montreal, Canada paper no. 3236
Kreuger E. H. 1995 Industrial high dc voltage Delft University Press The Netherlands