This case report is to report the effect of Korean traditional treatment for idiopathic ninth, tenth, and twelfth cranial nerve palsy with ipsilateral headache.
The medical history and imaging and laboratory test of a 39-year-old man with cranial palsy were tested to identify the cause of disease. A 0.2-mL dosage of Hwangyeonhaedoktang pharmacopuncture was administered at CV23 and CV17, respectively. Acupuncture was applied at P06, Li05, TE05, and G37 on the right side of the body. Zhuapiandutongbang (左 偏頭痛方) was administered at 30 minutes to 1 hour after mealtime three times a day. The symptoms were investigated using Visual Analogue Scale (VAS).
The results of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), computed tomography (CT), and laboratory tests were normal. The medical history showed no trauma, other illnesses, family history of diseases, medications, smoking, drinking and so on. All symptoms disappeared at the 10th day of treatment.
Korean traditional treatment such as acupuncture, pharmcopuncture, and herbal medicine for the treatment of ninth, tenth, and twelfth cranial nerve palsy of unknown origin is suggested to be effective even though this conclusion is based on a single.
The glossopharyngeal nerve (CN IX) and the vagus nerve (CN V) are involved in taste, speech impediments, and swallowing and are often damaged together because they exit side by side at the brain stem (upper medulla), and have similar and overlapping anatomical and functional distributions in the periphery. Damage to CN IX & V results in loss of bitter and sour taste and impaired swallowing [
]. The hypoglossal nerve (CN XII), which originates from the hypoglossal nucleus near the midline in the dorsal aspect of the medulla, innervates the muscles of the tongue and is related to the control of voluntary movement of the tongue [
With damage of CN XII, the tongue has weakness, atrophy, fasciculations on the side of the involvement, and a deviation toward the affected side when the tongue is stuck out. The causes of twelfth-nerve palsy have been reported to be tumors (the first most common), trauma [
] (the second most common), strokes, hysteria, multiple sclerosis, surgery, autoimmune disease, Guillain-Barre’ neuropathy, internal carotid artery dissection [
], extracranial internal carotid artery aneurysms [
], idiopathy [
], and infections [
Hypoglossal nerve palsy is a rare disease, but has several cases of this disease have been reported [
]. On the other hand, CN IX & X palsy has very few reports except for cases caused by upper respiratory infection [
]. The cause of CN X & XII palsy, which was similar to the symptoms of our case, was internal carotid artery dissection [
Few reports on the cases of idiopathic CN IX, X, and XII palsy treated with Korean traditional treatment exist. Thus, this study reports a rare case in which a combination treatment of acupuncture, pharmacopuncture, and herbal medicine had an effect on a male patient with ninth, tenth, and twelfth cranial nerve palsy of unknown origin.
2. Case report
- 2.1. Characteristics of patient and medical history
A 39-year-old man visited our Korean Internal Medicine Department complaining of a severe headache over his left parietal region, left-sided tongue weakness, loss of taste and sensation on the left side of his inside tongue, a slight alteration in speech, vague swallowing difficulty, and indigestion for 5 days. There was no past history except Bell's palsy one year earlier and gastritis six months before. The medical history showed no trauma, other illnesses, family history of disease, medications, smoking, drinking, and so on. He had not caught a common cold, nor had be received any vaccination or specific treatment before his first visit.
On neurological examination, his tongue deviated to the left on protrusion but no atrophy or fasciculations were observed. Mild right-sided deviation of the uvula and a decreased gag reflex on the left side of the throat were observed. The other pathological reflexes were normal. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), with and without gadolinium, and computed tomography (CT), with and without enhancement, of the brain, brain stem, upper neck, and skull base were normal. Laboratory tests and electrocardiography were also normal. The syndrome differentiation of the patient was categorized as the syndrome of ascendant hyperactivity of liver yang with heart fire on the grounds that overwork and much stress had given a rise to a flushed face, bitter taste, thin dry tongue coating in the mouth, palpitation, and string-like pulse
- 2.2. Treatment
- 2.2.1. Pharmacopuncture
From among the types of eight principle pharmacopuncture (EPP) a 0.2-mL dosage of Hwangyeonhaedoktang pharmacopuncture was administered at CV23 and CV17, respectively, at a perpendicular angle and a 0.5-mm depth by using the tapping method [
- 2.2.2. Acupuncture
0.25 mm × 3.0 mm stainless needles (Dongbang Acupuncture Inc., Korea), was applied at P06, Li05, TE05, and G37 on the right side of the body at depths of 0.5~1 cm, a total of 4 needles, by using neutral supplementation and draining (平補平瀉) for 20 minutes.
- 2.2.3. Herb medicine
Zhuapiandutongbang(左偏頭痛方)was administered at 30 minutes to 1 hour after mealtime three times a day for 5 days. Herbal compounds, a twentyfold dosage of the total amount in Table
, were decocted in 6000 mL of water for two to three hours. The extracted liquid was packed in 15 pouches, 120 mL per pack. The composition of zhuapiandutongbang is shown in Table
The Prescription of zhuapiandutongbang
|Herbal name ||Botanical name ||dosage |
|Sukjihwang ||Rehmanniae Rhizoma ||5 g |
|Baekjakyak ||Paeoniae Lactiflorae Radix ||5 g |
|Danggwi ||Angelicae Gigantis Radix ||5 g |
|Cheongung ||Cnidii Rhizoma ||5 g |
|Banha ||Pinelliae Tuber ||8 g |
|Gulpi ||Citri Nobilis Pericarpium ||4 g |
|Jeokbonglyeong ||Poria ||4 g |
|Gamcho ||Glycyrrhizae Radix ||2 g |
|Hyeogae ||Schizonepetae Herba ||3 g |
|Bakha ||Menthae Herba ||3 g |
|Seosin ||Asari Radix ||3 g |
|Manhyeoja ||Viticis Fructus ||3 g |
|Siho ||Bupleuri Radix ||3 g |
|Jugeum ||Scutellariae Radix ||3 g |
|Total amount || ||56 g |
- 2.3. Progress of symptoms (Fig4)
The severity of headache was decreased 20% on the first day of treatment, 50% on the third day, 70% on the 4th day, and 100% on the 10th day. Herbal medicine was stopped on the 6th day of treatment because of cost problems. The left-sided deviation and the weakness of tongue were improved 30% on the 4th day and 100% on the 10 days of treatment (Figs
). The swallowing difficulty was recovered 10% on the 3rd day, 50% on the 4th day, and 100% on the 10th day of treatment. The mild dysarthria on the left side of throat was restored 30% on the 3rd day, 80% on the 4th day, and 100% on the 10th day of treatment. The taste and the sensation of the tongue were regained 20% on the 3rd day, 50% on the 4th day, and 100% on the 10th day of treatment.
The tongue’s deviation on protrusion on the first day of treatment
The left-sided deviation of the tongue was not improved on the first day of treatment.
The tongue’s deviation on protrusion on the third day of treatment
The left-sided deviation of the tongue was slightly improved on the third day of treatment
The tongue’s deviation on protrusion on the 10th day of treatment
The left-sided deviation of the tongue was improved 100% on the 10th day of treatment. Treatment was terminated.
The progress of the symptoms. The symptoms began to decrease from the third day of treatment and improved 100% on the 10th day of treatment
NRS: Numeric Rating Scale
Mild dysarthria on the left side of the throat and loss of taste and sensation on the left side of the inside tongue were caused by CN IX and X palsy, and the left-sided deviation of the tongue on protrusion and tongue weakness were caused by CN XII palsy. CN IX and X are more often damaged together because of their anatomical and functional similarity [
]. The cause of CN IX, X and XII palsy couldn't be identified despite the detailed medical history and all the studies, such as brain MRI, brain CT, and other examinations, so that this disease was diagnosed as idiopathic CN IX, X and XII palsy [
]. Acupoints CV23 to treat tongue palsy and CV17 to relieve heart fire and liver yang were selected with Hwangyeonhaedoktang pharmacopuncture among the types of EPP [
]. P06, the pericardium meridian's connecting point; Li05, the liver meridian's connecting point; TE05, the triple energizer meridian's connecting point; and GB37, the gallbladder meridian's connecting point were used for acupuncture after pharmacopuncture treatment. The left parietal region in the head is the course of the gallbladder meridian, and the same lesser yang meridian is the triple energizer meridian. The lesser yang exterior-interior meridian is the pericardium meridian and the liver meridian. The liver's five body constituents are tendons. The liver meridian was selected to treat dysphagia and the tongue's palsy and weakness. The gallbladder meridian and the liver meridian have an exterior-interior relationship. The connecting point of both the reverting yin meridian and the lesser yang meridian was selected because the connecting point could connect and enforce the exterior-interior relationship of the twelve meridians closely [
], is a prescription that combines Samultang (四物湯) with Leejintang (二陳湯), to which Schizonepetae Herba 3 g, Menthae Herba 3 g, Asari Radix 3 g, Viticis Fructus 3 g, Bupleuri Radix 3 g, and Scutellariae Radix 3 g are added. Based on literature [
], it was used to relieve left-sided headache. This herbal medicine was administrated for 5 days at first, and the severity of headache was markedly decreased although the medication was halted due to the cost. The acupuncture and pharmacopuncture treatment, however, continued until the symptoms disappeared on the 10th day.
Several reports on CN XII palsy with ipsilateral headache [
], CN IX and XII palsy [
], unilateral CN XII palsy [
], and CN X and CN XII palsy [
] exist in the literature. The causes of these diseases are diverse, such as internal carotid artery dissection, trauma, external and internal carotid artery aneurysms, idiopathy and so on. This case, in which CN IX & X palsy and CN XII palsy with severe ipsilateral headache occur together and are idiopathic, is thought to be a rare condition. In addition, no reports of Korean medicine treatment for CN IX, X and XII palsy seem to have been published to date even though many reports on different cranial nerve palsies, such as oculomotor nerve palsy [
], and facial nerve palsy [
], do exist.
Isolated idiopathic CN XII palsy cases similar to my case have been reported to have been treated with dexamethasone and prednisolone in Western medicine. However, the treatment duration of my case was shorter than that of the Western medicine treatment [
This study has limitations. Which of the three types of treatments were more effective could not be identified, and the results cannot be generalized based on one case report. Nevertheless, the results suggest that the rare and idiopathic CN IX, X, and XII palsy of unknown origin may be effectively treated by using Korean medicine.
Korean medicine treatment such as acupuncture, pharmacopuncture, and herbal medicine is suggested to be effective in treating idiopathic ninth, tenth, and twelfth cranial nerve palsy with ipsilateral headache.
This research was supported by the Sangji University Research Fund, 2011.
ShinHeung MedScience, Inc
Chapter 11, The cranial nerve nuclei and their central connections and distribution
Korean Neurological Association
Koonja Publishing Co
Chapter 03, Neurological examination
Delayed glossopharyngeal and vagus nerve paralysis following occipital condyle fracture. Case report
DOI : 10.3171/jns.1996.84.3.0522
Traumatic isolated unilateral hypoglossal nerve palsy--case report and review of the literature
Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg
DOI : 10.1016/0266-4356(95)90292-9
Isolated hypoglossal nerve palsy due to internal carotid artery dissection
J Laryngol Otol
DOI : 10.1258/0022215011908324
Extracranial internal carotid artery aneurysm presenting as symptomatic hypoglossal and glossopharyngeal nerve paralysis
J Laryngol Otol
DOI : 10.1258/002221504772784649
Transient unilateral hypoglossal nerve palsy: A case report
Clin Neurol Neurosurg
DOI : 10.1016/0303-8467(94)90050-7
Idiopathic isolated unilateral hypoglossal nerve palsy: a diagnosis of exclusion
Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod
DOI : 10.1016/j.tripleo.2008.02.024
Isolated unilateral hypoglossal nerve palsy: nine cases
[Dysphagia due to glossopharyngeal and vagus nerve palsy after upper respiratory infection]
Kor J Neurogastroenterol Motil
Tenth and twelfth nerve palsies in a patient with internal carotid artery dissection mistaken for cervical mass lesion
DOI : 10.1055/s-0030-1249246
Korean Pharmacopuncture Insitute
Pharmacopuncturology: principles and clinical application
Elsevier Korea LLC
Chapter 06, Instruction on the usage of pharmacopuncture; Chapter 08, Eight principle pharmacopuncture (EPP)
[A series of the study of acupoints]
Textbook committee of the Korean acupuncture & moxibustion society
[Acupuncture & moxibustion (II)]
Chapter 08, Fifteen collateral vessels
Two cases report of the patients with left migraine improved with zhuapiandutongbang
Korean J Oriental Physiology & Pathology
[Case report of three cases of idiopathic oculomotor nerve palsy treated with hominis placenta pharmacopuncture]
Journal of Pharmacopuncture
DOI : 10.3831/KPI.2009.12.1.091
[Comparison of the efficacy between method of regulating ascending kidney water and descending heart fire and sweet bee venom pharmacopuncture on peripheral facial paralysis]
The Journal of Korean Acupuncture & Moxibustion Society
[Effects of scalp acupuncture with usual acupuncture on peripheral facial palsy in comparison with usual acupuncture only]
The Journal of Korean Acupuncture & Moxibustion Society
[A case of idiopathic isolated hypoglossal nerve palsy]
Yeungnam Univ J of Med